Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

General election tomorrow - who do you vote for?

534 replies

IaminRome · 15/11/2022 19:12

I'm so sick of this government and reading a lot of the posts on here, it feels like on the one hand, so are lots of people, but there are also lots of other people who are very sceptical about labour or lib dem or greens. Added to which, there are so many issues at the moment, I know there's a lot of GC and what makes a woman, that is particularly important at the moment, and cost of living, private rentals, the environment, etc etc

So knowing what you know about the parties, if there was a general election tomorrow, who would you vote for..

YABU - Tories
YANBU - Labour
Comment for a third option

I used to be green, but I'm so not sure any more. So I think I'd vote labour, to stand best chance of keeping Tories out. (What I'd really like to vote for is a more representative government)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
8
TinyTopknot · 31/05/2023 12:25

MargotBamborough · 31/05/2023 07:10

I think this discussion about Stella Creasy has helped to clarify in my mind what the issue is with the Labour Party.

It's controlled by nutters.

There are many decent, sensible, intelligent left wing politicians in the Labour Party who go into politics genuinely wanting to build a better and more fair society.

But then they get elected and they quickly realise that if you actually want to progress in the party you have to pander to the loonies.

There are really only three directions you can go in.

One, the least trodden path, is to stand up to the loonies and keep your integrity, as Rosie Duffield has done. And look where that gets you.

The most common path is to try and be a fence sitter, repeating just enough mantras not to upset the loonies without going full on cray cray yourself. This is what Anneliese Dodds does. And that arse full of splinters is clearly causing her a lot of discomfort.

Or you sell your soul to the loonies and go full nutbag, as Stella Creasy has done. Shadow cabinet, and maybe one day cabinet positions await. And you no doubt get a lovely warm glow from all the people in your echo chamber saying how wonderful you are, how you're the future of the party. But it comes at the cost of your credibility and integrity in the eyes of the non insane contingent of the population.

That's about the size of it. And also why I left the party.

MargotBamborough · 31/05/2023 07:10

I think this discussion about Stella Creasy has helped to clarify in my mind what the issue is with the Labour Party.

It's controlled by nutters.

There are many decent, sensible, intelligent left wing politicians in the Labour Party who go into politics genuinely wanting to build a better and more fair society.

But then they get elected and they quickly realise that if you actually want to progress in the party you have to pander to the loonies.

There are really only three directions you can go in.

One, the least trodden path, is to stand up to the loonies and keep your integrity, as Rosie Duffield has done. And look where that gets you.

The most common path is to try and be a fence sitter, repeating just enough mantras not to upset the loonies without going full on cray cray yourself. This is what Anneliese Dodds does. And that arse full of splinters is clearly causing her a lot of discomfort.

Or you sell your soul to the loonies and go full nutbag, as Stella Creasy has done. Shadow cabinet, and maybe one day cabinet positions await. And you no doubt get a lovely warm glow from all the people in your echo chamber saying how wonderful you are, how you're the future of the party. But it comes at the cost of your credibility and integrity in the eyes of the non insane contingent of the population.

MargotBamborough · 31/05/2023 07:02

Blossomtoes · 30/05/2023 22:40

You answered your own question (despite poopooing me when I said exactly the same thing)

For what it's worth, I do think it is entirely possible that some people voted against purely because it was Stella Creasy who proposed it.

Yoy could substitute any opposition politician’s name there and it would still be the answer.

No, I said that was a possibility.

I would still like to know what opposing arguments were made before making assumptions.

And no, you couldn't substitute any opposition politician's name. The issue with Stella Creasy is that, despite her obvious genuine interest in women's issues, she's leaned right in to this "women can have penises" nonsense and is therefore no longer credible. She's just not a serious person and I would rather women's issues were being raised by someone who isn't so easily dismissed as totally batshit.

TinyTopknot · 30/05/2023 23:31

MargotBamborough · 30/05/2023 21:54

I used to really rate Stella Creasy.

But I'm pretty sure my jaw wasn't the only one that hit the floor when I saw that interview with her in the Telegraph with the headline, "JK Rowling is wrong, a woman can have a penis", and in which she confidently proclaimed that trans women are female.

Like...you care so much about pregnancy and childbirth and abortion but you don't think it is necessary to have a word for the class of people who may experience those things? What?

She was also dreadfully rude to posters on here when she participated in the web chat along with Caroline Nokes, and then had a three day meltdown on Twitter afterwards which was just a sight to behold.

She was a really promising politician. What happened? Does she not realise that these comments will follow her around forever, long after the general public are all in agreement that the transgender emperor has definitely not got a stitch on she/her?

Such a waste.

Oh lord I remember that meltdown! She just could not stop, it was actually astonishing in its awfulness.

verdantverdure · 30/05/2023 22:50

Nothing says "The party of protecting women's rights" than abstaining from voting for,

speaking against voting for, and voting against protecting women's rights.

Especially when it's such senior members of the Cabinet and even the Prime Minister.

Blossomtoes · 30/05/2023 22:40

MargotBamborough · 30/05/2023 21:43

But we are talking about the Commons debate on the subject so I would like to understand why, if it is such a no brainer, the buffer zone argument didn't win.

You answered your own question (despite poopooing me when I said exactly the same thing)

For what it's worth, I do think it is entirely possible that some people voted against purely because it was Stella Creasy who proposed it.

Yoy could substitute any opposition politician’s name there and it would still be the answer.

MargotBamborough · 30/05/2023 21:54

pointythings · 30/05/2023 21:47

So I've just read that section from Hansard, which is where my two point summary comes from.

I don't think it adds much to the debate - you'd have to ask MPs who voted against for their reasons, and they'd lie.

I seem to recall someone on here pointed out that marriage equality came about under a Tory government, therefore the Tories aren't all bad. Which means I have to point out that although it was a Tory idea, it would not have passed without substantive support from Labour and the Lib Dems.

Your opinion on Stella Creasy is just that - an opinion. Tory politicians can think what they want, but they're choosing to serve the Tory party, so that massively undermines their credibility in my eyes - because the trans issue is only a small piece of the whole.

I used to really rate Stella Creasy.

But I'm pretty sure my jaw wasn't the only one that hit the floor when I saw that interview with her in the Telegraph with the headline, "JK Rowling is wrong, a woman can have a penis", and in which she confidently proclaimed that trans women are female.

Like...you care so much about pregnancy and childbirth and abortion but you don't think it is necessary to have a word for the class of people who may experience those things? What?

She was also dreadfully rude to posters on here when she participated in the web chat along with Caroline Nokes, and then had a three day meltdown on Twitter afterwards which was just a sight to behold.

She was a really promising politician. What happened? Does she not realise that these comments will follow her around forever, long after the general public are all in agreement that the transgender emperor has definitely not got a stitch on she/her?

Such a waste.

pointythings · 30/05/2023 21:47

So I've just read that section from Hansard, which is where my two point summary comes from.

I don't think it adds much to the debate - you'd have to ask MPs who voted against for their reasons, and they'd lie.

I seem to recall someone on here pointed out that marriage equality came about under a Tory government, therefore the Tories aren't all bad. Which means I have to point out that although it was a Tory idea, it would not have passed without substantive support from Labour and the Lib Dems.

Your opinion on Stella Creasy is just that - an opinion. Tory politicians can think what they want, but they're choosing to serve the Tory party, so that massively undermines their credibility in my eyes - because the trans issue is only a small piece of the whole.

verdantverdure · 30/05/2023 21:45

Honestly I think all the Tories who spoke said some variation of "free speech, freedom of assembly, we already have laws for that,"

I can't recall any other argument being put across.

MargotBamborough · 30/05/2023 21:43

Blossomtoes · 30/05/2023 21:36

None. Nor are the various public bodies named above who were consulted for their expertise, which the government proceeded to ignore.

But we are talking about the Commons debate on the subject so I would like to understand why, if it is such a no brainer, the buffer zone argument didn't win.

verdantverdure · 30/05/2023 21:42

Tory MP Natalie Elphicks said that Pro Life groups praying outside an abortion clinic isn't a protest and isn't intimidation so buffer zones are not needed. Only not as succinctly.

MargotBamborough · 30/05/2023 21:42

pointythings · 30/05/2023 21:24

@MargotBamborough why don't you read up on the debate in Hansard and tell us all about it?

Maybe I will.

I wouldn't want to draw automatic conclusions about why people had voted or abstained in the way they had without having at least attempted to follow the debate though.

I certainly think it is very unwise to draw such conclusions without having followed the debate and then use them to scaremonger about the Tories wanting to restrict our abortion rights, when that wasn't even the subject of the debate in question.

For what it's worth, I do think it is entirely possible that some people voted against purely because it was Stella Creasy who proposed it. And that in itself is problematic.

Stella is actually quite unhelpful to women's rights at the moment. Ordinarily it would be wonderful that there is a young female MP who is so passionate about matters affecting the female sex, and who is constantly banging the drum and raising awareness about abortion rights, maternity leave and other forms of sex discrimination. But unfortunately, that person is getting a reputation for being a loony.

Because although she clearly does care about those issues, and although she is making very good and valid points, she also cares deeply about her own career in the Labour Party. She knows what a woman is and she knows what female means. She knows that trans women are neither. But she also knows that if she is to have any future in the Labour Party, she must do a marvellous impression of someone who truly believes that women can have penises. So she's embraced it. She isn't even doing a half-hearted, slightly embarrassed, "it's complicated" and "sex is not the same as gender" like Anneliese Dodds, who looks like she wants the earth to swallow her up every time she is asked this question. No, Stella is leaning right into it and saying, "Of course a woman can have a penis! Trans women are female!"

And that completely undermines her credibility. It means that when she stands up in Parliament to talk about maternity leave or buffer zones around abortion clinics, instead of listening to her, Tory MPs are going to nudge each other and snigger "Here comes Stella the loony! She thinks women can have penises! Hahahaha!" and switch off.

It's deeply unhelpful. We want these issues to be raised and debated by serious, credible politicians, not cowardly lightweights like Stella who are too afraid to state the fucking obvious in case it gets them cancelled on Twitter.

pointythings · 30/05/2023 21:41

So the arguments are basically

  1. the protesters are offering help (but they could do this without shouting and showing graphic images)
  2. freedom to protest (oh the irony, looking back to 2017 from the year 2023). If the protest is against the legality of abortion, then outside a clinic is not the place for it because clinics do not make policy.
Blossomtoes · 30/05/2023 21:36

MargotBamborough · 30/05/2023 21:17

How many of them are MPs?

None. Nor are the various public bodies named above who were consulted for their expertise, which the government proceeded to ignore.

verdantverdure · 30/05/2023 21:30

I think Claire Fox spoke against abortion clinic buffer zones.

pointythings · 30/05/2023 21:24

@MargotBamborough why don't you read up on the debate in Hansard and tell us all about it?

MargotBamborough · 30/05/2023 21:17

Blossomtoes · 30/05/2023 21:04

The only opposition I can find online is from Right to Life whose objection was that it would criminalise its members. 🙄

How many of them are MPs?

MargotBamborough · 30/05/2023 21:16

verdantverdure · 30/05/2023 20:58

From what I remember the British Medical Association, the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists, the Royal College of Midwives, the End Violence Against Women Coalition and Women’s Aid were in favour of abortion clinic buffer zones but Sajid Javid said buffer zones were not a proportionate response because legislation already existed to deal with protestors who caused any harm.

Have you managed to remember whether you watched the debate yet?

Blossomtoes · 30/05/2023 21:04

The only opposition I can find online is from Right to Life whose objection was that it would criminalise its members. 🙄

pointythings · 30/05/2023 20:59

verdantverdure · 30/05/2023 20:58

From what I remember the British Medical Association, the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists, the Royal College of Midwives, the End Violence Against Women Coalition and Women’s Aid were in favour of abortion clinic buffer zones but Sajid Javid said buffer zones were not a proportionate response because legislation already existed to deal with protestors who caused any harm.

Well, those are all clearly people who have zero interest in protecting women Hmm.

verdantverdure · 30/05/2023 20:58

From what I remember the British Medical Association, the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists, the Royal College of Midwives, the End Violence Against Women Coalition and Women’s Aid were in favour of abortion clinic buffer zones but Sajid Javid said buffer zones were not a proportionate response because legislation already existed to deal with protestors who caused any harm.

MargotBamborough · 30/05/2023 20:37

Blossomtoes · 30/05/2023 20:34

It’s not difficult to research what was proposed - and strongly supported by the Lords. I suspect the reason it failed in the Commons, despite being presented in the Lords by a Tory peer, was because it was put forward by Stella Creasey.

https://www.womenshealthmag.com/uk/health/female-health/a42722555/house-of-lords-buffer-zones-abortion/

But it appears nobody here watched the debate, and so we do not know what arguments were made against it.

If I were an MP I would have attended the debate, listened, and made my decision based on the evidence presented to me, not on the basis of who had put forward the proposal.

Even if that person believes in the female penis and is therefore quite difficult to take seriously.

Blossomtoes · 30/05/2023 20:34

MargotBamborough · 30/05/2023 20:26

Given that this legislation doesn't exist, you seem remarkably well informed about its contents.

It’s not difficult to research what was proposed - and strongly supported by the Lords. I suspect the reason it failed in the Commons, despite being presented in the Lords by a Tory peer, was because it was put forward by Stella Creasey.

https://www.womenshealthmag.com/uk/health/female-health/a42722555/house-of-lords-buffer-zones-abortion/

House of Lords backs buffer zones for abortion clinics in England and Wales

The proposal now has one last step to go through before becoming law

https://www.womenshealthmag.com/uk/health/female-health/a42722555/house-of-lords-buffer-zones-abortion/

MargotBamborough · 30/05/2023 20:26

pointythings · 30/05/2023 20:13

What is the difference between national buffer zone legislation which you don't have to enforce and having the ability to impose a buffer zone locally if you wish to?

The difference would be that if there were to be a local issue with protestors and the council wilfully (or because they were in sympathy) did nothing, they would be forced to enforce a buffer zone because there was a law requiring them to do so.

Given that this legislation doesn't exist, you seem remarkably well informed about its contents.

Swipe left for the next trending thread