Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to have done two weeks back in school and think oh hell no, nope, no

137 replies

OhHolyFuckNo · 15/11/2022 17:16

Name change for this, long term poster.

I worked in schools historically, but moved into education policy/ancillary stuff around 8 years ago, and recently have been at home with very young kids. I still have a lot of friends in local schools, and honestly, wondered if a few years back in the classroom might be the flexible work I need for family reasons and am struggling to find elsewhere. I dipped a toe back in with a temporary cover role.

I'm just so taken aback by how understaffed the schools are. Half of the people in on any day so far have been cover. Hardly any work is set, and the kids seem bored and justifiably fed up, but the contempt with which the older kids talk to the staff is not justifiable. The stronger staff are on permanent corridor duty maintaining discipline, so not in the classroom either.

Deliberately not putting this on the teaching board because I'm hoping for a range of responses. Is this how it is now? Do parents know? Is it covid as everyone seems to think? How bad is it when hardly anyone knows me but pretty much everyone I spoke to offered me a permanent job?

I would love to think it gets better and I am finding my feet again, but don't know if this is just completely naive and I don't want my own kids to pay the price if it is.

OP posts:
MrsHamlet · 15/11/2022 21:18

I love my job, but I am broken. I paste on a smile every day because that's what we do. But it's all becoming impossible.

PupInAPram · 15/11/2022 21:14

*worked in schools

PupInAPram · 15/11/2022 21:13

I've in schools for 26 years and never known it to be so bad. I rang 6 supply agencies for staff this morning and literally couldn't find a single cover supervisor or teacher. I'm doing 2 people's jobs. I long to leave.

FarewellNoel · 15/11/2022 20:59

It's a mental health crisis in secondary. Half our kids meet the criteria to be called vulnerable, such is the number of serious cases some who've recently lost parents don't even make the list if they look like they're coping. Kids coming in hungry and cold. Many ask me to turn the heating up as they want to make the most of it in school.

Staff are on their knees covering for sick colleagues/permanent vacancies. Sometimes 150 kids being 'taught' by two staff in the hall as there's literally no one to cover. TAs being asked to run whole courses. Secretaries and reception staff covering forms.

It's the worst I've seen it in 20 years and we're a nice school in leafy suburbia.

UWhatNow · 15/11/2022 20:25

It’s a perfect storm in education at the moment. School budgets are shot so the support staff (the most unappreciated and poorly paid) are given the heave-ho but all the actual support, that typically no-one values until it’s gone, impacts on the leadership and teaching staff who are dealing with increasingly challenging needs, no resources and increasing numbers of entitled, useless and lazy parents. And even reasonable, supportive parents have their own challenges with the cost of living and worrying about their kid’s education. Teachers also work crazy hours and weekends to keep up with the professional requirements.

I admire anyone sustaining a positive career in the state-sector education right now.

MunchyBunchy · 15/11/2022 20:20

My DC’s primary school has had a continuous stream of unfilled vacancies since September 2021. Some classes had short term supplies for the majority of last year - a not insignificant number of parents have moved their children elsewhere looking for more stability. I really feel for the staff who’ve been there throughout this period. They all look exhausted. The strain is clear for all to see.

I’m a teacher myself and have never known it to be this bad. I’ve been teaching for well over 15 years and I think this will probably be my last year. Things are stretched so thinly that something has to give.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 15/11/2022 19:52

Or are they actually long term supply, rather than having contracts with the school?

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 15/11/2022 19:52

Irritatedmum · 15/11/2022 19:48

As a parent, I can tell it’s happening. Turnover at the school is horrendous, experienced staff are leaving constantly - including giving up teaching. New teachers don’t last more than a year. And this week it’s been announced that teachers are leaving this week, not even waiting until end of term. The school can’t hide it.

Teachers leaving this week is pretty unusual- are they new to the school so likely to still be in their probationary period? Otherwise, I'd say that teachers effectively breaking their contract to leave early is a sign that something major is wrong.

Irritatedmum · 15/11/2022 19:48

As a parent, I can tell it’s happening. Turnover at the school is horrendous, experienced staff are leaving constantly - including giving up teaching. New teachers don’t last more than a year. And this week it’s been announced that teachers are leaving this week, not even waiting until end of term. The school can’t hide it.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 15/11/2022 19:37

Appuskidu · 15/11/2022 19:22

There are lots of jobs currently being advertised in my county- including primary, for January or "as soon as possible" starts. This isn't usual.

Yes! I’ve just looked on our LA job search page-I have never seen so many vacancies! Heads, deputies, senco, class teachers, SEN TAs. Very few class TA roles being advertised though actually-other schools may be doing as we are and just not replacing them when they leave.

According to the DfE teaching jobs search, there are 44 jobs available in schools in my LA right now- 29 of them are teaching jobs in some way, 22 looking for January or immediate starts (the others are looking for September 2023 starts, which in some ways speaks to broader recruitment problems, I assume they're trying to snap up ECTs from a limited pool early?).

The majority of the jobs advertised are science, maths and MFL- based on what I know of local schools, I think some of these will be vacancies the schools couldn't fill for this September.

Last year, the impression I got was that the science/maths trainees in the county all had jobs by February half term.

For those who aren't involved in education, it's worth bearing in mind normally this is the sort of time when very few jobs are advertised. It's normally seen as too early to advertise for next September. And nobody in a job can give notice for Christmas, now. So really, many of these jobs just won't be filled this academic year.

Appuskidu · 15/11/2022 19:22

There are lots of jobs currently being advertised in my county- including primary, for January or "as soon as possible" starts. This isn't usual.

Yes! I’ve just looked on our LA job search page-I have never seen so many vacancies! Heads, deputies, senco, class teachers, SEN TAs. Very few class TA roles being advertised though actually-other schools may be doing as we are and just not replacing them when they leave.

MarigoldPetals · 15/11/2022 19:18

Desperately understaffed, and those that are left are really struggling and demoralised.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 15/11/2022 19:15

I do think some schools are better than others- it might be worth trying another school/setting before giving up on the idea of teaching completely? I moved schools this September, because things were getting untenable in my last job for a lot of reasons (some of them outside the school's control to be fair). That school had a range of unfilled vacancies in September, and there are staff leaving at Christmas. I'll be amazed if they are able to recruit replacements (again, it's not entirely their fault- expensive rural town, crap public transport etc means it's not an especially viable school for ECTs, for example).

In response to your questions:

Is this how it is now? Yes and no- as I say, I think some schools/areas have it worse than others. Some subject areas have it worse than others, and depending on the school you can have departments that really struggle and departments that are fine.

But there is a national teacher shortage and school budget crisis, so...

Do parents know? Parents know when it affects them specifically. Last year I'd speak to lots of parents in my tutor group who had concerns about the amount of supply. By the end of the year, parents were aware of how many teachers were leaving and did seem to have significant concerns. But a lot of parents didn't have a viable alternative, and so they want to believe the head when they say it's a temporary rough patch and things will get better.

But equally some kids are lucky and they happened to not have as many supply teachers, or their teachers weren't leaving etc. And their parents would be shocked when I'd say things like "oh there's no available maths intervention" or "we aren't running DofE this year due to staffing issues". So I assume some don't know.

Is it covid as everyone seems to think? I don't think it's solely covid- I think covid hasn't helped, and last year on top of everything pushed a lot of people to breaking point. But I think the CoL crises, the pressures on school budgets, and the teacher shortage which has really been brewing/happening for a long time have all come to a head. I don't think things are really going to get better without major changes that have nothing to do with covid.

How bad is it when hardly anyone knows me but pretty much everyone I spoke to offered me a permanent job? Well, it depends- my friend has just left a school (left teaching, actually) where he was the last teacher who could teach A-level Physics. I think they'd bite your hand off if you could teach physics at any level!

Equally, as I said, previous school had real issues recruiting. Couldn't get maternity cover in certain subjects for love nor money- we had non specialists covering effectively for a full school year. We had maths teachers leave at Christmas who couldn't be replaced. We had a few teachers leave at Easter, who couldn't be replaced, either- and when I say not replaced, I mean their posts haven't been filled by permanent staff still (according to friends who are still at the school).

There are lots of jobs currently being advertised in my county- including primary, for January or "as soon as possible" starts. This isn't usual.

Appuskidu · 15/11/2022 18:55

honestly, wondered if a few years back in the classroom might be the flexible work I need for family reasons

I’ve not ever found teaching particularly flexible during term time, tbh.

Things are the worst I’ve known them to be in schools in 25 years-I’m not sure how aware people are really?

Mistletoewench · 15/11/2022 18:50

thenewaveragebear1983 · 15/11/2022 17:25

Yep, school office staff here (attendance officer) - the assistant left so I was stuck doing 2 full time jobs (all the registers etc for 1000 kids and , y’know, my actual full time job) and being paid as a bottom grade receptionist. I left 3 weeks ago. It’s honestly horrible in schools right now, there’s no support staff.

Pretty much in the same boat. I’m in a school office and leaving soon, same with my colleague. Shame as I don’t mind the job, but pay in appalling.
dont get me started on TAs either, it’s a national disgrace. We are in the midst of a recruitment crisis and I don’t think the government have quite woken up to it yet.

OhHolyFuckNo · 15/11/2022 18:47

Thank you to everyone who has commented so far and for your candour. As someone from a teaching family and lots of teacher friends I'm troubled that I read the news and have my own children in school while not having realised quite how bad it had got.

I'm embarrassed to say that I am going to read and run a bit, but I am on my way to bed at 6.30pm, wiped out.

Thank you @ThrallsWife , @noblegiraffe and others, and @RuleWithAWoodenFoot for expressing it so well on covid. Some of the classes I am doing are covid catch up, and it's the social impact of the time out that is talked about in reference particularly to Y10 behaviour. I really feel for the kids who are so visibly clearly desperate to be learning and engaging, because there is a layer of what feels like complete alienation.

@TripleFret Thank you particularly for your post. I will remember it when making decisions around whether this is right for my family. Thanks to you all, I feel quite sad to think not.

I can't imagine how making that decision feels with all of the loyalties of a life in school, but wish everyone leaving the very best for their future. Our schools will be poorer without you.

Maybe it has to be worse for them to finally start trying to make it better. What a sad cost though.

Thank you also @OldWeegie, for reasons ;-)

OP posts:
catinboots123 · 15/11/2022 18:32

*contrast

catinboots123 · 15/11/2022 18:31

DS2 is year 8 in a good local school. He rarely gets homework and if he does, it's never marked. Complete contract to when DS1 (now 23) was the same age.

I don't blame the teachers or support staff.

noblegiraffe · 15/11/2022 18:30

eveoha · 15/11/2022 18:29

Deliberate distraction re dire situation in schools in form of Ukraine Immigrants and cost of living - a perverse form of ‘bread and circuses’

Jeremy Hunt went on TV and said the biggest concern facing schools right now was energy bills.

It's not, it's the unfunded pay rise for teachers and support staff, that his government imposed on schools and said had to come out of existing budgets.

Jeremy didn't even mention this.

eveoha · 15/11/2022 18:29

Deliberate distraction re dire situation in schools in form of Ukraine Immigrants and cost of living - a perverse form of ‘bread and circuses’

Alloftheboys · 15/11/2022 18:27

The school I work in is utter shit. Scrabbling around everyday trying to ensure everyone is safe. No idea what’s happening from one day to the next.
I’m glad my kids have left.

CallmeAngelina · 15/11/2022 18:26

"Is this how it is now?"
"Yep."
"Do parents know?"
Well, Noble has done her best on MN to point out what's going on but just gets abused and accused of scare-mongering and trying to close schools.

RuleWithAWoodenFoot · 15/11/2022 18:24

It's not covid illness absence, it's lack of funding to deal with thr levels of challenge currently in mainstream education. Some of these challenges are to do with the impact of covid. I'm not sure that parents understand the impact of covid on children - I'm not talking about school closures in that either really, I'm talking about much bigger societal issues related to covid. Adults showed real weakness and anxiety, and children don't know how to process that (nor do the adults).

We had a pay rise which had to come out of existing budgets, this equals fewer staff. We can't recruit, even though we're trying.

Schools are not attractive places to work for support staff. Not enough money for the level of hassle, and it's an employees market right now.

I've just resigned too after 14 years. Schools are not thriving and are barely surviving. Roll on a la our government.

noblegiraffe · 15/11/2022 18:21

Inasec24 · 15/11/2022 18:09

My school isn't like this. Maybe you should try a different school.

The Covid cover has died right down - you still get the tight cover days every now and then but nowhere close to how you describe.

Most schools are facing an unprecedented crisis, not just the OP's.

www.theguardian.com/education/2022/oct/22/exclusive-90-of-uk-schools-will-go-bust-next-year-heads-warn

moonlight1705 · 15/11/2022 18:16

My DH is a teacher and was told by his head that the school has enough money for one more year. Any staff that are leaving will not be replaced.