Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to have done two weeks back in school and think oh hell no, nope, no

137 replies

OhHolyFuckNo · 15/11/2022 17:16

Name change for this, long term poster.

I worked in schools historically, but moved into education policy/ancillary stuff around 8 years ago, and recently have been at home with very young kids. I still have a lot of friends in local schools, and honestly, wondered if a few years back in the classroom might be the flexible work I need for family reasons and am struggling to find elsewhere. I dipped a toe back in with a temporary cover role.

I'm just so taken aback by how understaffed the schools are. Half of the people in on any day so far have been cover. Hardly any work is set, and the kids seem bored and justifiably fed up, but the contempt with which the older kids talk to the staff is not justifiable. The stronger staff are on permanent corridor duty maintaining discipline, so not in the classroom either.

Deliberately not putting this on the teaching board because I'm hoping for a range of responses. Is this how it is now? Do parents know? Is it covid as everyone seems to think? How bad is it when hardly anyone knows me but pretty much everyone I spoke to offered me a permanent job?

I would love to think it gets better and I am finding my feet again, but don't know if this is just completely naive and I don't want my own kids to pay the price if it is.

OP posts:
noblegiraffe · 16/11/2022 13:37

While I’m sure that some academies are top heavy in terms of leadership positions it’s worth remembering that when a school becomes an academy and then a MAT, it now has to perform tasks that would have been performed by the LA. LAs had all sorts of managers and consultants working for them. As MATs get bigger, they need those positions too but they are more visible because they are in-house so it can look like a school becomes an academy then immediately creates a load of well paid jobs for mates of the HT.

No idea about paying for helicopters, maybe the school has a really well-off PTA.

PatchworkElmer · 16/11/2022 12:54

I feel that things in my son’s school are bad, but the school are covering it so that we don’t see much of it. I know that they’ve lost their afternoon TA, who has been redeployed to Reception due to the high number of disruptive/ violent SEN children. The issue is that I’d say 2/3rds of DS’s class have behaviour issues and I know of at least 4 with significant SEN. I just don’t see how the teacher can cope with it all.

Thatsnotmycar · 16/11/2022 12:52

IMO EHCPs aren’t worth the paper they’re written on.

Only when they are vague and woolly, which many are, but if written correctly and detailed, specified and quantified they are worth it.

Beachbabe1 · 16/11/2022 12:33

Pinkflipflop85 · 15/11/2022 17:44

It's pretty dire.
I have 12 children on the send register in my class (ks1) before you even begin to consider anyone else's needs. My send number is due to increase as a few more have now had referrals.

I have no TA.

My day to day situation is currently just surviving with nobody getting hurt or doing a runner. Not sure how much longer I can sustain it.

This is awful! 12 in one class with no TA! Take care of yourself

Itsmadnessthisyear · 16/11/2022 12:27

I am a teacher and work in a school. Name changed as this is outing. I hear all these things about schools struggling and no money for staff or resources etc.
Maybe its the fact we are an academy but it seems they are creating more and more SLT jobs (with obviously very high wages) but yet not replacing the teachers/TAs/admin/lunch time staff that leave which we need.
We hear that the school has little money etc but the school i work in has several attendance events for the students each year. Think food vans, sweet stalls, food, fair ground rides, inflatables. This can't be cheap to run. Last year there was a helicopter, an actual helicopter that the school hired to give the students flights around the area for the day!
There are lots of regular competitions in school for students to win tvs, ipads, headphones, all the gadets which costs money too.
So is it that schools have no money and the situation is dire or that the money is misplaced is other areas?

Meadowbreeze · 16/11/2022 12:10

I'm actually really shocked about the private schools. I thought the state sector would just go down to private. Makes sense they're under stress too. Most people don't go to top rate academic ones. A lot of people are forking out for private just for better support and more opportunities in activities.

LadyMarmaladeAtkins · 16/11/2022 11:50

I have a school survey to fill out and I just don't know how to reply to it. If I'm brutally honest, its unfair on the staff but if I'm not I don't reflect where the situation is.

Be brutally honest - politely - but write at the top that you understand it is not the fault of {whoever it isn't}.

noblegiraffe · 16/11/2022 11:23

Pupil behaviour has been declining for years, but it is now at crisis point. No-one seems to have the first idea how to manage it, so in order to find quick, cheap solutions there are 'experts' out there peddling behaviour management techniques that place all of the blame and responsibilty onto the classroom teachers - not the children, not their parents, and certainly on on senior management

Paul fucking Dix. Thankfully many schools are now abandoning his shite methods and adopting more effective policies.

Behaviour at my school has vastly improved since ditching him and using much stricter rules. Unfortunately the more effective behaviour policies are the sort of thing you see parents kicking off on here about as ‘over the top’. Sweating the small stuff. Removing kids from class who are disruptive. Centralised detentions. It works and reduces teacher workload.

noblegiraffe · 16/11/2022 11:19

There's no need or value for older students studying at school, they are bored stiff, it can all be done at home online

Because that worked so well during covid Hmm

Redtoothbrush please fill your survey out honestly. Nothing is being solved by trying to brush over problems. Schools also need to know their attempts to prop up a failing system are inadequate - we can’t keep pretending things are fine.

RedToothBrush · 16/11/2022 10:53

I think something needs to be done about how additional needs and SEND is handled. Kids are being failed so badly and not just the ones with SEND, it’s the others around them who miss out to

Last year DS ignore. Teacher this year has openly said he was allowed to 'coast'. The moment we've said yes to exploring SEN and signed the paperwork, all the issues which have been ignored and we've said to the school suddenly coming back as issues to be resolved.

It has actually pissed me off, the degree to which he was left to rot and suddenly its being noticed.

I am hoping it will make a difference to DS but it concerns me in terms of the other kids and how much has been left to slip.

It seems you have to be labelled a priority to get any attention. I hate it. I hate we've actually had to speak to the teachers about some of the stuff going on (safeguarding level stuff so not optional).

We are realistic that the school has limitations too. It's obvious staff are burnt out.

Mamansparkles · 16/11/2022 10:49

@RedToothBrush unless you can afford one of the top tier public schools or you have a top academic independent day school in mind for your DS, in which case do it, I'd say it's better than state (for the kids, not necessarily the staff!) at the moment but it isnt a magic bullet in terms of having enough teachers and that is getting visibly worse each year. Much better in terms of behaviour though.
Posters who think their kids are protected from the recruitment and retention crisis in education by being in private should think again. It's just delayed by a few years.
I hope when MPs kids start being affected something might change but private schools will do all they can to cover it up from the parents (by running existing staff into the ground).

Blueeyedgirl21 · 16/11/2022 10:45

The last school I worked in had about half the amount of TA’s than needed. Kids with an EHCP that specified certain amounts of hours or one to one had a TA about fifteen minutes a day in total. The TA’s spent a lot of time helping kids who were undiagnosed and supposedly NT/ no learning needs but who obviously needed way more help than they were getting.

IMO EHCPs aren’t worth the paper they’re written on. The only good thing is that they often come with some sort of support officer from the LA who backs up the parents a bit.

I think something needs to be done about how additional needs and SEND is handled. Kids are being failed so badly and not just the ones with SEND, it’s the others around them who miss out to

RedToothBrush · 16/11/2022 10:39

TigerMummy1 · 16/11/2022 10:24

Private schools are also suffering from lack of teachers. Very few can offer to pay over the odds and most the pay is similar to state, often without the good pension. Hours are longer (especially in boarding) with no limit on contact time (even theoretically) so demands from management are extreme. Parents expect us to be on call for them 24/7. Our budgets are stretched and we are buying our own board pens. Staff are leaving in droves every year.
This year we had a few teachers join us to fill most of our our staffing gaps from the state sector. A couple of them lasted less than half a term. The others are struggling. It's obvious that they were hoping private would be better but have discovered it isnt, it has different challenges. At this rate, the state teachers will switch to private, try it for a year, realise it's just as bad in slightly different ways and leave the profession altogether within a couple of years.
The very top private schools will be fine. Most are cracking but Heads are desperate to cover that up to parents to prevent them pulling their kids out.
Behaviour is much, much better but staff are just as worn down from the understanding and workload and leaving the profession exhausted.
My friend is on maternity leave and her private school havent been able to get cover. Her classes, including GCSE, have got a cover teacher and a textbook for the whole year.
So, in conclusion, the private sector will be a couple of years behind state in falling apart completely with the exception of the very top tier schools which will be fine.

We are at a point where we are considering moving DS to a private school but we are really torn about it.

I certainly remain unconvinced its in his best interests and it will be a magic bullet. Because what I'm seeing is a lot of kids with problems trying to get into private schools so the issues aren't being contained in state schools.

I suspect it's better in some respects, but it's not necessarily in others. Stuff like the travelling and extra pressure also needs factoring in.

I really am in despair over it.

DS is being utterly failed. The teacher has practically admitted it.

I have a school survey to fill out and I just don't know how to reply to it. If I'm brutally honest, its unfair on the staff but if I'm not I don't reflect where the situation is.

TigerMummy1 · 16/11/2022 10:24

Private schools are also suffering from lack of teachers. Very few can offer to pay over the odds and most the pay is similar to state, often without the good pension. Hours are longer (especially in boarding) with no limit on contact time (even theoretically) so demands from management are extreme. Parents expect us to be on call for them 24/7. Our budgets are stretched and we are buying our own board pens. Staff are leaving in droves every year.
This year we had a few teachers join us to fill most of our our staffing gaps from the state sector. A couple of them lasted less than half a term. The others are struggling. It's obvious that they were hoping private would be better but have discovered it isnt, it has different challenges. At this rate, the state teachers will switch to private, try it for a year, realise it's just as bad in slightly different ways and leave the profession altogether within a couple of years.
The very top private schools will be fine. Most are cracking but Heads are desperate to cover that up to parents to prevent them pulling their kids out.
Behaviour is much, much better but staff are just as worn down from the understanding and workload and leaving the profession exhausted.
My friend is on maternity leave and her private school havent been able to get cover. Her classes, including GCSE, have got a cover teacher and a textbook for the whole year.
So, in conclusion, the private sector will be a couple of years behind state in falling apart completely with the exception of the very top tier schools which will be fine.

HerMajestysRoyalCoven · 16/11/2022 09:57

YANBU OP. It really is dire.

I’m not in teaching but I have friends and family who are and I’m trying to convince them all to leave before they have breakdowns. There’s not one of them who isn’t experiencing violence in the classroom (whether targeted at them or generic like throwing chairs), as well as constant verbal abuse. The parents either blame the school or accuse the teacher of lying. The main common factors are poverty (too many kids at home) and SEN.

The majority of them now have up to half their pupils with SEN (either diagnosed or being assessed for) and no additional support is provided. They work long hours and weekends and just seem to be constantly numb to anything other than the job.

To me, no job is worth being assaulted over. I feel desperately sorry for them and for the kids in their classes who just want to learn something educational, and all they’re learning is that an adult can be hit and nothing will be done, it’s acceptable and normal.

I don’t know what the answer is. The government has failed us all, and some parents want locking up for how they’ve dragged up their children (not the kids with SEN, obviously).

Get out while you can. God knows what it’ll be like by the next General Election.

SpentDandelion · 16/11/2022 08:47

The school system is failing teachers and students alike. It's on its knees and needs a complete overhaul. The current system as it stands it not preparing students for the world we live in today. There's no need or value for older students studying at school, they are bored stiff, it can all be done at home online, it will teach self discipline and independance, valuable life skills.A lot of jobs are WFH these days.

RedToothBrush · 16/11/2022 08:34

Teachers and TA are regularly being hurt. My friend is TA at my sons school and she's been hurt numerous times this term.

My son and his best friend have also been on the receiving end.

It just feels like the situation is so bad that the school hasn't got the ability to protection staff or kids from children who have exceptional needs that just aren't able to be met.

I don't believe it's a lack of will by the school. It's just they have run out of options.

Its an outstanding school in a nice area. It's always had a good reputation.

My suspicion is that if it had an ofsted inspection tomorrow it would be deemed failing. And parents would be up in arms.

Yet I also think the head is taking it seriously and is between a rock and a hard place.

lonelyinyournightmare · 16/11/2022 08:02

I quit after 30 years. This will have a serious impact on my pension, but on balance I thought that trying to save what was left of my sanity was more important.

What finally did for me was a change in management. There is a serious, and I mean very serious, shortage of good, decent Headteachers out there. Schools are appointing from the pool that they have - and frankly, many of them should not be in management.

Pupil behaviour has been declining for years, but it is now at crisis point. No-one seems to have the first idea how to manage it, so in order to find quick, cheap solutions there are 'experts' out there peddling behaviour management techniques that place all of the blame and responsibilty onto the classroom teachers - not the children, not their parents, and certainly on on senior management. The students are well aware of this and play the system. As a teacher it is exhausting and utterly demoralising. I went from being a well thought of, successful teacher to a shadow of my former self. I had classes that I was literally shaking at the dread and fear of having to stand in front of them. I got next to no support because the behaviour was so poor from so many children there was either no one to support, or because managment were busy saving themselves by keeping well away.

One thing that would have made a massive difference would have been to reduce my workload in other areas. Instead the opposite happened. Ridiculously complex and pointless marking schemes and constant assessment and data collection that took hours and hours before and after school, at the weekend and in the holidays. All of this utterly draining. Constant scrutiny of books, lessons and data - all under the guise of improving teaching and learning. All of it totally pointless.

I am so glad to be out of it.

Meadowbreeze · 16/11/2022 07:42

There are so many vacancies in my borough. I have never seen this at this time of year. This is normally the recruitment levels you see pre summer holidays for the new term. And almost all say starting immediately/Jan, even for SLT posts.

@Postapocalypticcowgirl I think you're right, it'll impact them more in future but mostly the ones in expensive areas. I think London is suffering with a deluge of teaching professionals that no longer afford it and are moving to cheaper areas. I imagine it's the same story with affluent suburban and rural areas. If they're not there, even the privates won't be able to recruit.

noblegiraffe · 16/11/2022 07:39

Private schools are also seeing increased costs in terms of energy, stationery, food, teacher pay, and yet if they put their fees up by the amount needed to cover this, parents would be unable to afford the rise and be taking their kids out (parents with kids in private are also feeling the cost of living increases).

So I assume that their provision is also being reduced (although from a much higher starting point!). We know that private schools in recent years have seen quite a lot of strike action around taking their teaching staff out of the teachers' pension scheme because they can't afford the employer contributions - this would also affect recruitment.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 16/11/2022 07:33

Halloweenshock · 15/11/2022 22:20

Is private suffering in the same way? Do they have high staff turnover too?

I don't have personal experience but what I would say is that private schools in some cases can pay over the odds if they want to recruit someone. For example I have a friend who teaches Astronomy GCSE in a private school, it's not a common skill set and they offered him quite a bit of money to come and teach for them.

I do have friends who've moved to private and most of them prefer it, but it does depend on both the school and the person.

From the outside I would say they don't have the same issues but long term the issues will impact them, because the experienced teachers many private schools like to recruit won't exist, or they'll be paying more and may have to pass that on to parents in some way. I do think they sometimes have similar issues recruiting eg maternity cover etc in shortage subjects, though. But again depends on the school.

I'd say it's only in the last few years these issues have started to impact the majority of state schools. And as teachers leave state teaching it can help private schools recruit. But I think if things continue as they are you will see some impact in private schools over the next 5 years or so.

2greenroses · 16/11/2022 07:27

Why am I not surprised that someone who has been working in "educational policy" had no idea what so ever what was going on in schools

There are no teachers. Even before covid, we were merging classes and teaching children by the hundred sitting at exam desks in the sports hall.

Since then, the situation has deteriorated

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 16/11/2022 07:20

roarfeckingroarr · 15/11/2022 21:59

As a parent, is there any answer except going private if you can?

I do still think some schools have it better than others, but it depends what options you have locally. If things are bad at your school it is worth looking around locally to see if there is an option where things are better, particularly before GCSEs.

You can use the DfE website to keep an eye on the schools you're considering and see if lots of vacancies are coming up mid year etc.

But obviously that depends on where you live and if other schools have spaces too. If you have concerns about your school, I would jump early if you can find somewhere better - otherwise other local schools may get filled up.

Alternatively, supplementing with tutoring is a lot cheaper than going private.

I'm saying either of these are morally right, btw, but if it was my child I'd definitely consider both.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 16/11/2022 07:16

Lanneederniere · 15/11/2022 21:28

What I would like to know is whether the schools with unsustainable and top-heavy management structures will be reducing senior leaders' pay in order to stop class sizes becoming any more unmanageable, and to pay TAs a reasonable living wage?

Yy to paying TAs better, but you can't recruit staff who don't exist to reduce class sizes.

Appuskidu · 16/11/2022 07:00

I’m nodding my way through these threads-it seems to be the same in most schools.

What’s sad is that you’d still get some posters saying that it’s probably good that those teachers who are leaving do something else as the children deserve better, more enthusiastic teachers.

Thus missing the point totally really.