Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to have done two weeks back in school and think oh hell no, nope, no

137 replies

OhHolyFuckNo · 15/11/2022 17:16

Name change for this, long term poster.

I worked in schools historically, but moved into education policy/ancillary stuff around 8 years ago, and recently have been at home with very young kids. I still have a lot of friends in local schools, and honestly, wondered if a few years back in the classroom might be the flexible work I need for family reasons and am struggling to find elsewhere. I dipped a toe back in with a temporary cover role.

I'm just so taken aback by how understaffed the schools are. Half of the people in on any day so far have been cover. Hardly any work is set, and the kids seem bored and justifiably fed up, but the contempt with which the older kids talk to the staff is not justifiable. The stronger staff are on permanent corridor duty maintaining discipline, so not in the classroom either.

Deliberately not putting this on the teaching board because I'm hoping for a range of responses. Is this how it is now? Do parents know? Is it covid as everyone seems to think? How bad is it when hardly anyone knows me but pretty much everyone I spoke to offered me a permanent job?

I would love to think it gets better and I am finding my feet again, but don't know if this is just completely naive and I don't want my own kids to pay the price if it is.

OP posts:
Aleaiactaest · 17/11/2022 09:15

“Schools are struggling to support SEND students as their budgets are stretched. When send students aren’t properly supported then behaviours can escalate.”
It is the same story in the NHS isn’t it. With not enough social care, you get bed blocking. People deserve to die with dignity and live their last few lives in a supported way.
Young people with special needs and special educational needs need early intervention and support to become valued members of society. Cutting mental health and support is the worst thing the government can do.

My youngest is still in state primary. It works really well in our school because staff are valued and parents are supportive. Staff can use the excellent wrap around care and the admissions policy was changed so their DC can attend. Most of the TAs are former parents too. Part time working parents make time to go in and read with the children, cook etc, support in whatever they can. So there are still schools like that at primary level.

celticprincess · 17/11/2022 09:00

Covid might be in part to play. But a lot of staff are off with stress and anxiety. Recruitment isn’t great in some areas - think rural and towns with bad transport links. Schools are struggling to support SEND students as their budgets are stretched. When send students aren’t properly supported then behaviours can escalate. This can lead to staff not wanting to go into work due to areas and anxiety etc.

School based work is not a family friendly option in reality. It can be costly for before and after school care and there’s no flexibility with this on many schools. Or some schools employ staff on a 10-2 type contract so they can work around childcare but this drops pay a lot and also leaves classes without support. It only really works for TAs and not teachers who tend to get to school anytime from 7:30 onwards and who can still be in school at 5:30. Teachers with children are reliant on wrap around care that often doesn’t open early enough or stay open late enough. Yes school staff get the 13 weeks school holidays - they aren’t paid for 13 weeks though. Only the statutory time is paid and contracts are 1265 hours for teaching staff and ‘term time’ contracts for TA/cleaning staff etc. I’ve know a lot of parents get TA roles thinking it will be all great for holidays and childcare then in reality their pay packet means they can’t actually afford to stay at the job. There’s no ‘overtime’ if you work full time. But many work longer than their actual hours - taking work home at weekends and on evenings.

Staff turnover in some schools is fast. This also leads to more staff leaving as well as staff get more work put on them and a vicious recruitment cycle.

Aleaiactaest · 17/11/2022 08:14

It is like that in state schools. Meanwhile in some top private schools you have a staff to student ratio of 8:1. So many good graduates go straight to private schools because life is more enjoyable for them there. The same happens in the NHS. The consultants work privately too, increasingly more hours. Dentists too etc
Most of my friends who taught state are now in private schools. The work load is also big but they are not as battered by regulations, generally freer, better behaved kids etc. I do not know what the solution is.
At the end of the day, teachers are educated people who deserve to be paid well and treated well. If they are not, then they will either retrain, move to another job or work in the private sector.

DarkKarmaIlama · 17/11/2022 08:07

Apologies that didn’t even make sense at the end.

DarkKarmaIlama · 17/11/2022 08:06

@Postapocalypticcowgirl

Yes. Heading for that for sure. I’ve always wanted to be a teacher but I’m not sure there’s any point putting myself through a PGCE now. All the cheap unqualified staff hold the power now and they’re not scrutinised as much as the expensive teachers. They know they’re safe from mostly from their wrath.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 17/11/2022 07:24

The vast majority of people don't think online education or mass education in a hall is right for their child though. Just other people's.

I think before we see anything like that we'll see a move to deprofessionalise teaching - so instead of having a post grad qualified subject specialist as the norm in secondary, you'll unqualified cover supervisors delivering video lessons from a provider like oak academy. Which, to be honest, is already happening in some schools and some subjects.

But again, it's not good quality education and doesn't teach important practical skills etc.

I teach biology at a level, and my school has a largish sixth form, lots of students from other, smaller schools without sixth forms come to us to do a levels etc. Some of them have very poor practical skills - I know this is partly covid, but we are talking never used a microscope, never built a circuit, never used a Bunsen burner etc. That suggests a long term lack of practical teaching even prior to covid.

To succeed on a science based degree, as well as a good knowledge of theory, you need decent practical skills. And a lot of (important, valuable) jobs use these skills. If they aren't being taught at secondary level then it does have negative implications for the country and the economy.

And I'd say that's the same across a lot of practical subjects.

Dancingqueenwannabe · 17/11/2022 07:10

geraniumsandsunshine · 16/11/2022 21:27

I predict education in the future will be 100 kids in a room sitting in individual booths with headphones on listening to a 'teacher' who may or may not be present but can't hear the responses of students. Low paid tech people will be in 'E learning rooms' and boot out anyone messing around. Those who participate and do well will be awarded tokens to use in extra curricular clubs. Not sure about those who don't because there really isn't a lot of discipline options

Sadly this would be cheered on by some. I was listening to a radio debate about teaching and teachers striking last week and some members of the public seem to think covid proved that we don't need teachers in a classroom. That children received a good enough education with the one size fits all videos that were available online.

Now if only they came to teach my class one day with my 4 way differentiation of activities which then need to be differentiated further in the group work 😕.

I fear the teachers strike is the only strike action members of the public will not support. 2 years ago all we heard was open the schools, we can't teach at home and there was a new found respect for teaching and the challenges of being a teacher. That is long forgotten by some now and with the government showing such disregard for education I'm not surprised.

DarkKarmaIlama · 16/11/2022 22:39

Slow recruitment my ends. Schools can’t afford support staff so that’s the reason I think.

geraniumsandsunshine · 16/11/2022 21:27

I predict education in the future will be 100 kids in a room sitting in individual booths with headphones on listening to a 'teacher' who may or may not be present but can't hear the responses of students. Low paid tech people will be in 'E learning rooms' and boot out anyone messing around. Those who participate and do well will be awarded tokens to use in extra curricular clubs. Not sure about those who don't because there really isn't a lot of discipline options

geraniumsandsunshine · 16/11/2022 21:22

Chilena2022 · 15/11/2022 22:33

my son is in reception and has special needs, at the moment he is not allowed to go to
school ( only for one hour and I need to be his TA), until I can get his ECPH that I could take more than 20 weeks.

Legal?

geraniumsandsunshine · 16/11/2022 21:21

roarfeckingroarr · 15/11/2022 21:59

As a parent, is there any answer except going private if you can?

Private is the plan for my daughter, if we can afford it. If not, I'm going to keep her at home from 13 and enrol her in an online School and hire tutors. Not sending her into a state school

geraniumsandsunshine · 16/11/2022 21:13

I'm also fed up with the school system. Children are not all the same and conprehensives don't work. Have music schools, science schools, more practical skills schools and academic schools. Bring back middles schools and select the best school post 14 for each child forgetting catchments

geraniumsandsunshine · 16/11/2022 21:09

Justthisonce12 · 15/11/2022 18:12

The enclosed photograph is what my 12-year-old was served for lunch apparently due to Covid measures which are still in place which means the kitchen can’t be operated. Is it actually any wonder the behaviour standards are plummeting if that’s what kids are being given along with a bottle of water for £2.50 a day ? Never mind the poor souls that will only receive that as their only meal for the day.

And in a polystyrene box. How depressing. Gone are the days when staff would sit with pupils and converse, modelling good behaviour.

MunchyBunchy · 16/11/2022 20:59

Lovesacake · 16/11/2022 20:39

Hope all the eligible teachers will be using their ballot papers to express their discontent….if there was ever a time for national action it’s now

I have. My heart was heavy completing the ballot, but on we go.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 16/11/2022 20:47

Lovesacake · 16/11/2022 20:39

Hope all the eligible teachers will be using their ballot papers to express their discontent….if there was ever a time for national action it’s now

I have, and the impression I've got is that feeling is quite strong. But lots of teachers do find it very difficult to strike.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 16/11/2022 20:46

I realised that I really had no idea. Teachers would still be meeting me at reception and meetings happening. I had no idea how much it is now costing them to be available.

Tbf though, I can't imagine the circumstance where I was in school and would say no to a parent meeting or meeting with external agencies. I went to a meeting about a child in my tutor group last year when every other member of the department I was in was off isolating due to covid. And then afterwards I was in school until 6.30, and back in at 7 the next day, sorting out the cover.

But what else do you do? The child was really struggling with their mental health, but apparently didn't meet the threshold for intervention via CAMHS, so we met with their family, and tried to make suggestions and other referrals to help.

Obviously there may be times when staff aren't available to meet, or when a member of staff is absent, but schools will usually try to find someone to sit down with parents, because in general parents don't ask to meet with secondary schools at least for completely spurious reasons.

I mean, equally I did have to tell parents that we weren't providing maths intervention for non exam year groups, or that yes, their child didn't have a permanent teacher for geography right now. And in one case I had a really difficult conversation of a parent of a child with autism who wasn't coping with having so many supply teachers each day.

I do think it's something parents and external agencies should be conscious of, though, at the moment.

Lovesacake · 16/11/2022 20:39

Hope all the eligible teachers will be using their ballot papers to express their discontent….if there was ever a time for national action it’s now

MichaelFabricantWig · 16/11/2022 20:15

Sounds horrendous. I’m glad mine only have a few years of school to go.

OhHolyFuckNo · 16/11/2022 20:11

2greenroses · 16/11/2022 07:27

Why am I not surprised that someone who has been working in "educational policy" had no idea what so ever what was going on in schools

There are no teachers. Even before covid, we were merging classes and teaching children by the hundred sitting at exam desks in the sports hall.

Since then, the situation has deteriorated

I understand this response and perhaps I should have given more detail. I've been working in SEN and safeguarding law as a family representative contracted by a charity. In recent years it has been policy because we have switch to endlessly re-establishing and re-clarifying what local authority and government duties are. Through 2020 my work was particularly around care proceedings, and then I had a year in serious safeguarding case review.

So genuinely, I thought I knew how it is. Part of wanting to explore being back in the classroom was knowing local schools are struggling and part of it just needing something positive alongside the safeguarding work.

I realised that I really had no idea. Teachers would still be meeting me at reception and meetings happening. I had no idea how much it is now costing them to be available.

I am very glad I have done it and do now know, and have also learnt so much from this thread. I have had some great lessons and moments, but I'm going to tell the school next week that I don't think I can go into the new year. I'm teaching the hardest groups day in and day out - the ones who have hardly had the same teacher for a full week all year. There is never any work prepared and I'm making it up as I go along from no prep but a post-it stuck between the pages of a text-book. I can't cover subjects that aren't my subjects when I'm reading it five minutes before the kids if I'm lucky.

Anyway, thanks all. You've made me feel it's ok not to be able to stay long-term, or at least, that it isn't really a choice.

OP posts:
Shoreditchintheafternoon · 16/11/2022 19:04

Private isn't as bad but is still getting worse. SEND is increasing massively, pastoral issues rising. Several long standing members of staff have retired recently. Recruitment is harder - lucky to get a few applicants. Even for support staff roles we struggle to hire. Trainee teachers are absolutely awful (in most cases, not all). More and more non-specialists are being used to teach, even at A level. Cost of pensions, energy bills, resources, staff pay etc going up but they can't pass all of that onto parent fees because they are struggling too.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 16/11/2022 19:03

Meadowbreeze · 16/11/2022 18:25

@Postapocalypticcowgirl is there a reason they've made this cut? Doesn't make much sense.

There are some articles here which might explain a bit about what's happened: www.tes.com/magazine/news/general/itt-shake-universities-could-launch-legal-action-against-dfe

www.tes.com/magazine/news/general/itt-almost-two-thirds-providers-not-accredited-first-wave

Basically, for whatever reason, I assume ideological, the DfE went through a re accreditation process for ITT providers recently. And a lot of providers lost their accreditation- including really well respected providers. It's a real concern in my local area because we have lost 2 (out of 4) local providers.

I don't fully understand the process, but my understanding is that for some providers the sticking point was their placement schools. The DfE wanted teachers trained to teach in a certain way, but if placement schools use other methods, this isn't always possible.

I think this is a really poor explanation of what's happened because I don't fully understand it- I just understand we are losing ITT places from 2024, when we desperately need more.

Meadowbreeze · 16/11/2022 18:25

@Postapocalypticcowgirl is there a reason they've made this cut? Doesn't make much sense.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 16/11/2022 18:20

@Meadowbreeze There is going to be a serious shortage of trainees coming through in the next few years too- trainee numbers are down this year, and from next year (or possibly 2024) the DfE has cut the number of accredited teacher training providers. This will reduce the number of teachers further across the country- so more than ever teachers will be able to have their pick of schools, and there are downsides to some private schools (e.g. expectations of Saturday or evening working).

@lonelyinyournightmare totally agree with all of that- I've been teaching for much less time, but I've really seen how a change in leadership can tip a school from "managing" to being over the edge. And I do think some heads are really quite naive about it as well.

@SpentDandelion I think lockdown showed us that approach simply doesn't work for the majority of students, and it also ignores subjects with a practical element that need specialist facilities such as science, art, DT, performing arts, PE etc. It would definitely reduce the need for so many teachers, though, and I do wonder if this is the way the government would like to go long term.

@TigerMummy1 Interesting to see the perspective from private. I do agree in terms of maternity cover. In the past I think some people would have done it to "get a foot in the door" with a school they view as desirable, but now people can't really afford to give up a permanent contract for anything but another permanent contract. And I agree as you say the grass isn't always greener, as it were.

Appuskidu · 16/11/2022 17:57

IMO EHCPs aren’t worth the paper they’re written on. The only good thing is that they often come with some sort of support officer from the LA who backs up the parents a bit

Some EHC Plans are good. I would say any input from the LA is usually the least helpful part of it! The ‘support’ they offer is often unhelpful, late or just downright wrong. The only good thing is that EHCPs come with some (nearly never enough, though) funding.

Noodledoodledoo · 16/11/2022 15:22

The whole system is letting all parts of it down.

  • Students with additional needs let down as no one applies for LSA/TA jobs so unable to provide required provision due to lack of staff - yes they may need a 1-1 but if we don't have the bodies we don't have them.
  • Students with no additional needs being taught in unsupported classes so teacher is stretched too thin trying to be all things to all people
  • Teachers who are trying their hardest, jumping through hoops, trying to support all students to the best of their ability, covering lessons, planning for other teachers who are off, planning for classes with no permenant teacher.
  • SLT trying to balance the books, trying to staff the school, dealing with behviour issues which are a lot worse since we have come back from Covid, we can all complain about them, but I don't envy them their job currently.
  • Parents - vast majority of which are just wanting the best for their kids and are supportive but are rightly concerned by things that happen in school. (I am both a teacher and a parent)

The government really need to reassess the whole situation, I don't have the magic answers but something needs to be done before we walk into a disaster.