Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not be fobbed off with "data protection" as an excuse?

244 replies

KER90 · 15/11/2022 15:58

Have name changed for this just in case it's identifiable.

DS is 6 years old and in Year 1. Last week he was attacked by another child, who is in year 2. He was left with marks around his neck and a mark and lump on his head. DS doesn't know the other child's name, he's not in his class (mixed y1 & y2) and he's not even sure if he is in the other mixed class or the year 2 only class.

DH has been to speak briefly to the head today as he wants to know what the school have done about it as all we were told on the day of the incident was that the other child had "been dealt with". She tried to fob him off with "data protection" as an excuse for not being able to tell us what they have done. Just that it had been "severely dealt with".

Now, I think this is just a vague response in order to avoid admitting they've done sweet FA. Hoping that we go oh okay no worries and just forget about it. It's not giving out personal or identifiable information and as above, we don't even know who the child is. Surely when it comes to safeguarding, they should be able to tell parents what measures they are putting in place to protect their children? The way in which DS was assaulted, is, in my opinion, not the kind of thing you do as a first time offence, it is serious and if I had done that to another adult, I would be arrested and probably jailed. Just because they are under the age of criminal responsibility, it doesn't mean they should do nothing about it. If it's not dealt with now, who knows what that child will go on to do in the future.

"Severely dealt with" is also surely a matter of opinion? They may think it's a severe punishment, but I might not, and vice versa. For example has the child been "told off" or "lost certain privileges" or has he been suspended? Bit of a difference.

We are going back in on Friday for a more formal chat and DH has told the head that he wants answers to his questions and we are not going to let it go until we are satisfied with the response. She seemed very flustered and didn't quite know what to say, which tells me that she knows she can't bullshit her way out of this situation with her usual tactics.

Thankfully, DH is, shall we say, very assertive, but does anyone with inside knowledge of this type of thing have any advice?

OP posts:
ReluctantCourier · 15/11/2022 17:07

They’ll have someone nominated to look after data, you could write to the office and request which aspect of GDPR would be infringed by you being told the punishment.

I would suspect they’d respond it’s not necessary to disclose this, one of the key principles is that you only use the data that’s absolute necessary to the business needs.

You could submit a freedom of information request to the school or trust if the office can’t answer as they might be more likely to have a Data Protection Officer who will give you the details of how this would infringe on the other childs’ GDPR protections.

As pps have said though, forget that kid’s experience, it’s the wrong q to be asking. What support do you want your kid to get: ask for that.

Getoff · 15/11/2022 17:06

I agree that it is an unsatisfactory non-answer though. If an adult had been convicted for an equivalent assault, the courts wouldn't be citing data protection while refusing to tell anyone what the sentence was. Presumably there is a specific exemption that allows the information to be public, when it's an actual criminal case.

Hankunamatata · 15/11/2022 17:05

No they will not tell you how its been dealt with as that's information about the other child. You can ask measures about keeping your child safe. I'd also be careful about your husband crossing boundary from assertive to threatening or bullying which may be why head became flustered.

IhearyouClemFandango · 15/11/2022 17:03

I’d want to know, for sure. But I would also understand why they couldn’t tell me the details of something that is happening to another child.

Getoff · 15/11/2022 17:02

Actually I think data protection does apply. I was reading up on it because of another thread recently, and if the information they give you could be combined with information obtained from elsewhere that identifies the child, then it would be a breach. So, to take an example, today they tell you the perpetrator received punishment X, tomorrow your child sees the person again, asks someone his name, and relays it to you, you know know the identity of a child who received punishment X.

FlippityFlippityFlop · 15/11/2022 17:01

Honestly if another child attacked my child to the point that they were left with marks around their neck I would report it to the police. To hell with leaving it up to the school to deal with. They have already failed massively in their safeguarding responsibility.

KER90 · 15/11/2022 16:57

fairycakes1234 · 15/11/2022 16:46

Of course, you'd want to know what punishment was given, he harmed her child?

Thank you!! I'm sitting here in disbelief that so many people would be fine with just being told it's been dealt with and nothing more?

OP posts:
FacebookPhotos · 15/11/2022 16:57

Safeguarding is separate to punishment.

What you actually need to know in order to determine if they can keep you child safe is what led to this happening (lack of supervision, for example) and what steps they are taking to rectify the problem.

If your DH was being "assertive" to the head, don't be surprised if there are two or three staff in your meeting rather than just the head. All saying the same thing. You do not have any right to know what punishment another child has received.

KER90 · 15/11/2022 16:56

sunshineandstrawberryjam · 15/11/2022 16:48

Thankfully, DH is, shall we say, very assertive

By that do you mean 'aggressive and bullying'?

No, I mean, he won't back down and be fobbed off with non answers, especially when it comes to our children.

OP posts:
MultiTulip · 15/11/2022 16:56

Why do you care what’s happened to the other child as a consequence? That’s not your problem. Your problem is what the school are doing to keep your child safe and that’s the only thing that they’ll tell you about. It’s not up to you what an appropriate response for the other child is because you know nothing about them or their situation.

KER90 · 15/11/2022 16:55

Fuuuuuckit · 15/11/2022 16:48

There's absolutely no chance that you will be told explicitly what sanctions were given to the other child. Zero. Black, white or rainbow coloured, data protection is the reason why, and is to protect every child in school. Even if it was your dc's best friend who did it, you wouldn't be told by the school.

You can expect an answer to the questions 'was behaviour policy followed' and 'what measures are in place to prevent a repeat and to keep my child safe'.

Strong-arming the head is not going to change her mind.

Ok but what information would they be giving me that is covered by data protection? Punishment is not personal information. Personal information is name, dob, address, phone number, up address etc. Something you can use to identify that person. Say just for example, that the child had to miss a school trip as a punishment, how would I be able to identify the child from that information?

OP posts:
KER90 · 15/11/2022 16:51

BritishDesiGirl · 15/11/2022 16:41

Unfortunately, you being a black and white person with no grey areas means nothing to the school either OP.

And yes, the child could potentially be outed, other children talk to their parents and parents talk amongst each other. You could identify the child from something like that.

But it's a none answer. It's a complete and utter cop out. Are you telling me that if someone doesn't explain something properly to you or you don't understand something, that you just accept that? You don't ask more questions to fully understand the situation? They're telling me they've dealt with it, I want to know what that means, because to me, it means absolutely nothing.

I would know who the child was if DS could actually remember his name. It's just unfortunate that he doesn't as he's a year 2 and in one of the other classes. So the fact that I could find out from someone else is neither here nor there.

OP posts:
Justthisonce12 · 15/11/2022 16:50

The world has changed so much from when my children were at school. I actually got a written letter of an apology from the parents of the child that attacked mine and the school handed out the email address in order for them to send it. I mean it was all taken in the spirit of which it was intended but yeah it was quite a surprise when it dropped into my email inbox.

sunshineandstrawberryjam · 15/11/2022 16:48

Thankfully, DH is, shall we say, very assertive

By that do you mean 'aggressive and bullying'?

Fuuuuuckit · 15/11/2022 16:48

There's absolutely no chance that you will be told explicitly what sanctions were given to the other child. Zero. Black, white or rainbow coloured, data protection is the reason why, and is to protect every child in school. Even if it was your dc's best friend who did it, you wouldn't be told by the school.

You can expect an answer to the questions 'was behaviour policy followed' and 'what measures are in place to prevent a repeat and to keep my child safe'.

Strong-arming the head is not going to change her mind.

fairycakes1234 · 15/11/2022 16:46

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Of course, you'd want to know what punishment was given, he harmed her child?

CousinKrispy · 15/11/2022 16:41

OP I totally get where you are coming from, it must be so upsetting that your child was attacked in this way.

But I do think at some point you have to trust the school. Let's say they spell out what consequences were given to the other child. Do you then trust that they actually carried out the punishment? What if they're just telling you about a punishment in order to fob you off, but didn't actually do it? What if they dealt out a punishment but didn't do it as thoroughly as you think appropriate?

Do you see what I'm getting at? At some point, unless the school just hands the power over to you and allows you to enact vigilante justice on the other child, you have to trust that they are making the right judgment and doing the right thing.

BritishDesiGirl · 15/11/2022 16:41

KER90 · 15/11/2022 16:21

I think the punishment/action take is relevant to how they're keeping my child safe. Her telling me it's been "severely dealt with" means absolutely nothing to me. I'm a very black and white person, I don't do grey areas. She's given a very grey answer.

Personal information is something you can use to identify that person. How is being told what punishment has been given going to allow me to identify the child?

Unfortunately, you being a black and white person with no grey areas means nothing to the school either OP.

And yes, the child could potentially be outed, other children talk to their parents and parents talk amongst each other. You could identify the child from something like that.

IhearyouClemFandango · 15/11/2022 16:39

I understand why you want to know, because it helps understand how seriously they have taken it, and therefore how put off the other little boy (remember the other child is not much older than yours) is likely to be.

But realistically, they don’t have to tell you and I don’t really know many schools that would…you have no rights in that respect. So getting your “assertive” husband to try to strong arm the head is unlikely to work, and her being ‘flustered’ in his eyes is probably more to do with his attempt to throw his weight around and less that she was “bullshitting”.

MrsSchrute · 15/11/2022 16:36

KER90 · 15/11/2022 16:33

But how can I know to trust them in the future, when I don't even know what they do in these types of situations?

Well you can see their behaviour policy, which outlines how they would deal with situations like this. So you either trust them to follow it, or you don't.
If you believe they haven't followed their policy, then complain.

Bingobangodrinkacanoftango · 15/11/2022 16:35

Also comparing this to an adult altercation isn’t the same thing. They are children.

KER90 · 15/11/2022 16:35

AntlerRose · 15/11/2022 16:32

They should have a behaviour policy.
This should outline what should happen in an instance like this.

All you can really ask is whether the behaviour policy has been followed.

Thank you, that is helpful, I will look into this!

OP posts:
Bingobangodrinkacanoftango · 15/11/2022 16:34

I agree with others that you seem to want to know purely to check it was “punitive” enough in your eyes. Really, they can’t go into the specifics or details about how it was handled sometimes without divulging further information regarding another child, that may concern SEN or something else of a nature that is a privacy issue. I absolutely agree they should be able to give you information about how they will keep your child safe going ahead and also how they are supporting your child with any of their concerns/worries that may have resulted from the attack.

I have empathy, I totally appreciate this must have been horrible for your DC and that you want to keep your child protected but I think your motivations here are coming from being (understandably) angry. These things do happen in school settings and from what you’ve said the school have dealt with it. The way you talk about your husband makes it sound a little like he may be intimidating and/or rude which may be why the staff member felt flustered in the circumstances. If you don’t feel it’s resolved, obviously speak to the school and ask for further clarification on what measures the school are taking to keep your child protected as that’s the most important thing here.

KER90 · 15/11/2022 16:33

MrsSchrute · 15/11/2022 16:31

Well you either trust the school to deal with this, or you don't. If you don't then follow their complaints policy.
You have no right to know anything about how the school has dealt with another child.

But how can I know to trust them in the future, when I don't even know what they do in these types of situations?

OP posts:
AntlerRose · 15/11/2022 16:32

They should have a behaviour policy.
This should outline what should happen in an instance like this.

All you can really ask is whether the behaviour policy has been followed.