Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not be fobbed off with "data protection" as an excuse?

244 replies

KER90 · 15/11/2022 15:58

Have name changed for this just in case it's identifiable.

DS is 6 years old and in Year 1. Last week he was attacked by another child, who is in year 2. He was left with marks around his neck and a mark and lump on his head. DS doesn't know the other child's name, he's not in his class (mixed y1 & y2) and he's not even sure if he is in the other mixed class or the year 2 only class.

DH has been to speak briefly to the head today as he wants to know what the school have done about it as all we were told on the day of the incident was that the other child had "been dealt with". She tried to fob him off with "data protection" as an excuse for not being able to tell us what they have done. Just that it had been "severely dealt with".

Now, I think this is just a vague response in order to avoid admitting they've done sweet FA. Hoping that we go oh okay no worries and just forget about it. It's not giving out personal or identifiable information and as above, we don't even know who the child is. Surely when it comes to safeguarding, they should be able to tell parents what measures they are putting in place to protect their children? The way in which DS was assaulted, is, in my opinion, not the kind of thing you do as a first time offence, it is serious and if I had done that to another adult, I would be arrested and probably jailed. Just because they are under the age of criminal responsibility, it doesn't mean they should do nothing about it. If it's not dealt with now, who knows what that child will go on to do in the future.

"Severely dealt with" is also surely a matter of opinion? They may think it's a severe punishment, but I might not, and vice versa. For example has the child been "told off" or "lost certain privileges" or has he been suspended? Bit of a difference.

We are going back in on Friday for a more formal chat and DH has told the head that he wants answers to his questions and we are not going to let it go until we are satisfied with the response. She seemed very flustered and didn't quite know what to say, which tells me that she knows she can't bullshit her way out of this situation with her usual tactics.

Thankfully, DH is, shall we say, very assertive, but does anyone with inside knowledge of this type of thing have any advice?

OP posts:
WeepingSomnambulist · 15/11/2022 17:46

KER90 · 15/11/2022 17:41

I understand that if there is SEN, poor home situation etc then they won't be giving me that sort of information.

I think you're all just running away with certain aspects of what I have said and being a bit rude now.

We absolutely can express and complain if we don't feel the schools actions are sufficient. We are not going to be demanding that they do X, Y or Z. Like I said, a slight telling off and told not to do it again doesn't cut it in my opinion (in normal circs).

We are not happy with the response that it's has been "dealt with" and want to know more. You have all made it QUITE CLEAR that we will not be told the exact punishment but I am not being robbed off with none answers and vague bullshit.

So what answer would you want?

Let's say the child has witnessed violence and is now being violent so the achool have contacted social services and a psychologist will be involved with the child. In addition, the child will spend some time in the nurture room rather than in the full playground with the other kids.

If they told you "the child will be in the nurture room for a while" would that be enough for you? Because it doesn't seem enough out of context, but they cannot give you the context.

You've had this explained over and over. So what is it you actually want them to tell you? What would be enough?

Why dont you believe that the achool know what they are doing and it has been handled?

jonnyjannoo · 15/11/2022 17:46

I hope your understanding has improved now OP and that it can help you when you have the meeting next week. You also need to explain everything you've learnt on here to your DH so that he isn't "assertive" in the wrong way, if you see what I mean...
You mention safeguarding in your OP. That's your question. How is your child being kept safe?
I really don't know how you've decided that being "severely dealt with" is actually just some wishy washy naughty step thing. You really need to reframe how you see this.
It will be the same throughout your DCs time at school so you'd better get used to it.

cansu · 15/11/2022 17:45

You were informed on the day it happened and told then that the other child had been identified and dealt with.

Your dh went back to speak to the head on another day as he was unhappy and asked for more information on the punishment. He was told he was not entitled to that information. Many people on here have tried to explain why it is inappropriate for you and your dh to judge whether the punishment is right.
He then disliked this answer so told her he was coming back for another conversation where 'he wanted answers to his questions'. Sounds quite bullying to me. He might not like her answer but he was given one.

You are being unpleasant and are not hearing what has been said to you.
You are not entitled to judge whether this was a suitable punishment or not. You are entitled to ask how they will keep this child away from your son. You are also entitled to try another school. You should however realise that kids do sometimes hurt others both verbally and physically. This will happen in any school your child attends. Schools do what they can to prevent incidents and to educate the children in how to interact and behave with others. Not all kids have the same social and emotional skills as others.

MrsSchrute · 15/11/2022 17:44

KER90 · 15/11/2022 17:41

I understand that if there is SEN, poor home situation etc then they won't be giving me that sort of information.

I think you're all just running away with certain aspects of what I have said and being a bit rude now.

We absolutely can express and complain if we don't feel the schools actions are sufficient. We are not going to be demanding that they do X, Y or Z. Like I said, a slight telling off and told not to do it again doesn't cut it in my opinion (in normal circs).

We are not happy with the response that it's has been "dealt with" and want to know more. You have all made it QUITE CLEAR that we will not be told the exact punishment but I am not being robbed off with none answers and vague bullshit.

So you accept that they won't tell you, so what information do you want? What counts as a valid answer and not 'vague bullshit'?
Of course you can complain if you want to, the schools complaints policy should be on their website, I'd follow it to the letter.

KER90 · 15/11/2022 17:41

I understand that if there is SEN, poor home situation etc then they won't be giving me that sort of information.

I think you're all just running away with certain aspects of what I have said and being a bit rude now.

We absolutely can express and complain if we don't feel the schools actions are sufficient. We are not going to be demanding that they do X, Y or Z. Like I said, a slight telling off and told not to do it again doesn't cut it in my opinion (in normal circs).

We are not happy with the response that it's has been "dealt with" and want to know more. You have all made it QUITE CLEAR that we will not be told the exact punishment but I am not being robbed off with none answers and vague bullshit.

OP posts:
WeepingSomnambulist · 15/11/2022 17:40

WeepingSomnambulist · 15/11/2022 17:29

@KER90

You need to reframe this in your head. It isnt about just sanctions. Sanctions are very often linked to ongoing situations.

A child may have additional needs and have access to a nurture room or a support staff member. Part of the strategy for handling the violence may include moving them to the nurture room during lessons which they find the most frustrating. It may include bringing their support staff into the classroom to sit quietly just in case.

A child may come from a bad background and the behaviour is linked, so part of the response is involving outside agencies to support the parents and help the child outside of school.

Part of the response may include bringing in the educational psychologist to work with the child.

It isnt all "the child lost their break time and no school trips and sits on the naughty chair."

"Sanctions" are not just punishments. They go much deeper than that if necessary. To tell you about what they're doing, if any of those further internvetions are being used, would be to reveal very private information about a child. And you do not need to know if that child will have social services involvement or educational psychologist involvement or a support staff member following them around or anything else.

If they have any of that in place, it is not your business. Any punishment they can tell you wouldnt seem enough because they cannot tell you the additional support.

You need to realise that things dont happen in a vacuum. There may be lots going on. They will be handling it. But you dont need to know.

@Winterthoughts

Here. I hope that answers some of your question about why they cant discuss the response to behaviour like this.

Of course, there could be none of the additional intervention going on but telling that would be setting a precedent to disclose responses and sanctions. They cant do that.

If your child had any of these additional interventions due to their behaviour, would you want the other parents being told?

All you need to know is how your child will be kept safe and also what they were told and how they were treated after the incident to ensure they felt secure and not blamed etc.

WheresTheCakeThen · 15/11/2022 17:39

As a PP said, the correct 'severity' of punishment really does depend on the child and their background. If the child is autistic for example, the consequences for him might not look like a punishment to you. For example, maybe the adults around him weren't supervising him closely enough to notice he was becoming overwhelmed in a busy environment, so he might be given extra support in dealing with emotions, being kind, appropriate responses when angry and what to do if he is struggling etc. He might be asked to apologise to your DC. It really depends on what his EHCP says his behaviour needs are, which you are not entitled to know about. All you would be told in this situation would be along the lines of "extra supervision will be provided where appropriate and the staff will try to ensure the pupils involved are kept separate at breaktimes. The child has been spoken to and is being supported with behaviour management". I work with autistic children and this is often how they have to be managed in situations like this. You have no right to know the medical background of the other child and its effect on how his behaviour is managed. A punishment which seems appopriately severe to you may actually have the effect of confusing and angering the child whose brain physically cannot cope with it, making their behaviour worse in the longer term.

Likewise, if the child is NT but lashed out because he has witnessed domestic violence at home, he might have what you see as a too mild punishment, combined with counselling etc, which again you would not be entitled to know other than "your child will be kept safe by there being more /better supervision on the playground and the children as a group being taught about being good friends etc in class"

Fuuuuuckit · 15/11/2022 17:37

KER90 · 15/11/2022 16:55

Ok but what information would they be giving me that is covered by data protection? Punishment is not personal information. Personal information is name, dob, address, phone number, up address etc. Something you can use to identify that person. Say just for example, that the child had to miss a school trip as a punishment, how would I be able to identify the child from that information?

Unless EVERY child had the trip (to use your example) cancelled, then if you were told that the boy who hurt yours was the only one not allowed on the trip, that makes them identifiable. Data protection doesn't just cover name and address, in schools almost every piece of recordable data, including behaviour sanctions, are included.

OP you will not be told what punishment was given. Please focus on asking what measures are in place to protect your child.

Winterthoughts · 15/11/2022 17:36

ReluctantCourier · 15/11/2022 17:33

OP how would you feel if you were getting divorced and your son struggled with it and was aggressive.

You later find out the parents of the child he hurt were told the behaviour policy wasn’t followed in this instance due to the child being distressed by ‘events at home’ and the school are working with the parents to help your son adjust. This information is then verbally passed around a few of the parents who draw their own conclusions- but the school never named your son or said what the issues were!

So ok to hurt others if you're upset: yep,I'd want to know they were teaching my child their boundaries dint count if others are having a bad time

Winterthoughts · 15/11/2022 17:34

Hi op,I would also want to know the way this has been dealt with: if my child,god forbid,was attacked and had marks around their neck and a lump on their head,this is not a small thing. I'd want to know safeguarding going forward,but absolutely understand wanting to know the child who had done. this had been dealt with so mine or another child was unlikely to be significantly assaulted at school. I don't see how outlining the punishment for this type of incident breaks data protection. Interesting to know what others said about the behaviour policy,so would go that route.

GrimDamnFanjo · 15/11/2022 17:34

ReluctantCourier · 15/11/2022 17:21

@GrimDamnFanjo agree RE exclusions but on reflection not super relevant to OP as I’m sure if an exclusion related to an incident involving a board member’s child that member would need to recuse themselves… so no, you really are unlikely to ever get to express your views on the punishment.

My comment was concerned with the extent governors are involved with these matters - that they don't decide "punishments" and are only involved on a different level. Of course no governor would serve on a panel they had a personal involvement with.
I even avoid panels with kids from my village or in the same year group as DS just in case...

ReluctantCourier · 15/11/2022 17:33

OP how would you feel if you were getting divorced and your son struggled with it and was aggressive.

You later find out the parents of the child he hurt were told the behaviour policy wasn’t followed in this instance due to the child being distressed by ‘events at home’ and the school are working with the parents to help your son adjust. This information is then verbally passed around a few of the parents who draw their own conclusions- but the school never named your son or said what the issues were!

KER90 · 15/11/2022 17:33

cansu · 15/11/2022 17:30

Your suggestion that you want to check it is in your view proportionate is ridiculous. You do not make the rules or run the school. You do not know the child or his / her abilities or level of understanding. You do not know the child's family circumstances or what is going on in that child's life. All these are relevant factors. I think you should maybe move school because you and your dh are embarrassing yourselves at the moment.

Embarrassing ourselves because we've had 1 brief conversation with the head about what happened, asked a few questions that we're not happy with the answers, and arranged a formal chat later in the week? How is that embarrassing? Hmm

OP posts:
Ducksurprise · 15/11/2022 17:33

I am not a weak or unconcerned parent for understanding that I can not know about the outcomes of another parents child.
There is a massive difference between assertive and aggressive, refusing to back down because the answer doesn't not suit your requirements is aggressive.

It doesn't matter what you want. Please listen to the posters that have been there, you need to find out and be reassured that this will not happen again to your child or someone else's. If you do not trust the school then home education or another school is the only option.

bellac11 · 15/11/2022 17:32

KER90 · 15/11/2022 17:14

Since when does being assertive mean bully and aggressive Hmm

Being assertive means asking the question clearly and understanding the remit or context of what the other person can deliver.

You have argued all through this thread against what people are telling you, and you still fail to understand what the school can and cant disclose to you

You mentioned your husband 'not taking no for an answer', that turns him into someone who is agressive. The answer isnt going to be any different to what has been said here. Its none of your business what sanctions or punishment was given to the child your business is only that of what safeguards are in place to protect your child from the other child.

Someone else made a very good point, carry on if you want a failed relationship with the school with the two of you looking like bullies who cant work professionally with staff.

KER90 · 15/11/2022 17:32

cansu · 15/11/2022 17:27

I would imagine she can say she dealt with it in line with the school's behaviour policy. The school will deal with the child according to their age and level of functioning. I would imagine they would have been told off for their behaviour and their parents would have been informed. It will have been explained that they hurt someone. I would imagine staff will be keeping a close eye on the child at playtimes. What else are you expecting? Public flogging? Twenty days isolation? This is at most a year 2 child. Ranting on about what would happen to an adult is irrelevant. This child is not criminally responsible. Your dh doesn't sound assertive, he sounds like an arse and possibly a bully. I hope the head tells him this in a polite 'assertive' way.

So you've managed to come to conclusion that my husband is an arse and a bully, because I said he's assertive and won't back down or be fobbed off with none answers? How does that make him an arse?

OP posts:
CandyLeBonBon · 15/11/2022 17:31

I imagine one of the reasons for non disclosure is so that the child and/or parents can't pursue the matter outside of school.

If you find out what sanctions have been applied, you could tell your child. That then gets gossiped about at school, word gets around, other parent find out, takes offence etc etc.

It's keeping things contained and handled to avoid escalation.

Strictly1 · 15/11/2022 17:31

What are you going to do then if it doesn’t meet your expectations? Demand they are punished again? Will you be able to make a fully informed decision when you don’t know all of the details?
Your child was hurt which is awful but that doesn’t give you the right to check you agree with the punishment. The behaviour policy will have been followed. That is all you need to know and that going forward, your child will be safe.

cansu · 15/11/2022 17:30

Your suggestion that you want to check it is in your view proportionate is ridiculous. You do not make the rules or run the school. You do not know the child or his / her abilities or level of understanding. You do not know the child's family circumstances or what is going on in that child's life. All these are relevant factors. I think you should maybe move school because you and your dh are embarrassing yourselves at the moment.

WeepingSomnambulist · 15/11/2022 17:29

@KER90

You need to reframe this in your head. It isnt about just sanctions. Sanctions are very often linked to ongoing situations.

A child may have additional needs and have access to a nurture room or a support staff member. Part of the strategy for handling the violence may include moving them to the nurture room during lessons which they find the most frustrating. It may include bringing their support staff into the classroom to sit quietly just in case.

A child may come from a bad background and the behaviour is linked, so part of the response is involving outside agencies to support the parents and help the child outside of school.

Part of the response may include bringing in the educational psychologist to work with the child.

It isnt all "the child lost their break time and no school trips and sits on the naughty chair."

"Sanctions" are not just punishments. They go much deeper than that if necessary. To tell you about what they're doing, if any of those further internvetions are being used, would be to reveal very private information about a child. And you do not need to know if that child will have social services involvement or educational psychologist involvement or a support staff member following them around or anything else.

If they have any of that in place, it is not your business. Any punishment they can tell you wouldnt seem enough because they cannot tell you the additional support.

You need to realise that things dont happen in a vacuum. There may be lots going on. They will be handling it. But you dont need to know.

Chimna · 15/11/2022 17:28

As PPs have said there may be sen or other factors. It's not the schools problem that you are incapable of understanding grey areas or that your husband is overly assertive/aggressive. You ask for a copy of the behaviour policy and ask if it is being followed. You ask how they are keeping your child safe. If your not happy look into moving schools but no school is going to give you this info. It's not up to you to decide if a punishment was acceptable and from what you've said you wouldn't be capable of doing so.

cansu · 15/11/2022 17:27

I would imagine she can say she dealt with it in line with the school's behaviour policy. The school will deal with the child according to their age and level of functioning. I would imagine they would have been told off for their behaviour and their parents would have been informed. It will have been explained that they hurt someone. I would imagine staff will be keeping a close eye on the child at playtimes. What else are you expecting? Public flogging? Twenty days isolation? This is at most a year 2 child. Ranting on about what would happen to an adult is irrelevant. This child is not criminally responsible. Your dh doesn't sound assertive, he sounds like an arse and possibly a bully. I hope the head tells him this in a polite 'assertive' way.

TellMeWhere · 15/11/2022 17:26

I understand your desire for information, but what difference does it actually make?

How they've dealt with it will depend on the circumstances of said child, any additional needs and/or background info that you aren't privy to.

Whether they've had a stern word, excluded the child for a few days, put them in isolation or contacted social services, what difference will that make to you? The child may have additional needs, have suffered a bereavement, have an abusive or chaotic home life... In some cases a heavy handed punishment might not be appropriate. Maybe this is the catalyst school needs to escalate existing concerns further. Whatever it is, they don't need to discuss this with you.

Your priority is how they safeguard your child to ensure it doesn't happened again. Will there be extra supervision at break times for example?

Goldenbear · 15/11/2022 17:24

It is literally my job to advise on these kind of issues and you seem to be ignoring my posts. It is not that parents 'don't care', it is that the school would be breaking the law by doing this. You talk of criminal law, which as others have pointed out won't apply due to their ages but there are other laws you can break, including data protection!

Soapboxqueen · 15/11/2022 17:24

There's a chance that knowing the nature of the punishment could indicate private information about the other child which you do not have a right to know about.

Hence why it won't be shared. Nor is it any of your business.

What exactly do you expect will happen if they tell you and you don't agree with the punishment?

They won't up the punishment to appease you nor should they. The education and care children receive while in school should not be subject to the opinions of unconnected adults.

You can ask for an account of what happened.

You can ask how they will keep your child safe.

That's it.

Or you can move schools but the same will apply there too.