Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not be fobbed off with "data protection" as an excuse?

244 replies

KER90 · 15/11/2022 15:58

Have name changed for this just in case it's identifiable.

DS is 6 years old and in Year 1. Last week he was attacked by another child, who is in year 2. He was left with marks around his neck and a mark and lump on his head. DS doesn't know the other child's name, he's not in his class (mixed y1 & y2) and he's not even sure if he is in the other mixed class or the year 2 only class.

DH has been to speak briefly to the head today as he wants to know what the school have done about it as all we were told on the day of the incident was that the other child had "been dealt with". She tried to fob him off with "data protection" as an excuse for not being able to tell us what they have done. Just that it had been "severely dealt with".

Now, I think this is just a vague response in order to avoid admitting they've done sweet FA. Hoping that we go oh okay no worries and just forget about it. It's not giving out personal or identifiable information and as above, we don't even know who the child is. Surely when it comes to safeguarding, they should be able to tell parents what measures they are putting in place to protect their children? The way in which DS was assaulted, is, in my opinion, not the kind of thing you do as a first time offence, it is serious and if I had done that to another adult, I would be arrested and probably jailed. Just because they are under the age of criminal responsibility, it doesn't mean they should do nothing about it. If it's not dealt with now, who knows what that child will go on to do in the future.

"Severely dealt with" is also surely a matter of opinion? They may think it's a severe punishment, but I might not, and vice versa. For example has the child been "told off" or "lost certain privileges" or has he been suspended? Bit of a difference.

We are going back in on Friday for a more formal chat and DH has told the head that he wants answers to his questions and we are not going to let it go until we are satisfied with the response. She seemed very flustered and didn't quite know what to say, which tells me that she knows she can't bullshit her way out of this situation with her usual tactics.

Thankfully, DH is, shall we say, very assertive, but does anyone with inside knowledge of this type of thing have any advice?

OP posts:
Beadpark · 15/11/2022 18:59

It's a shame, reading the tone of your post, you and your DH are going in ready for a fight and kind of enjoying the head being flustered.
You can't know any personal information about the other child. You can ask how your child will be kept safe in the future. You can ask the head to drop you a line after the meeting to confirm that information.
Complaints - why anticipate complaining? Wait and see what the head says. If you think that they aren't safeguarding your child enough then suggest that to them. If you decide you need to raise a complaint then just download the complaints procedure from the website (statutory requirement that it's there) and follow it. The first formal stage will always be to the headteacher, giving them a chance to consider and respond in writing.

KER90 · 15/11/2022 18:56

Has anyone actually read the posts where I've said I accept why I can't be told the punishment?? Hmm

OP posts:
fjäl · 15/11/2022 18:55

Actually OP you are being ridiculous. I'm sorry your child got hurt but it's not fucking rocket science, it does not take a genuine, to know or understand why a school will not reveal punishments given out to other children.

PositiveCoffee · 15/11/2022 18:55

KER90 · 15/11/2022 16:21

I think the punishment/action take is relevant to how they're keeping my child safe. Her telling me it's been "severely dealt with" means absolutely nothing to me. I'm a very black and white person, I don't do grey areas. She's given a very grey answer.

Personal information is something you can use to identify that person. How is being told what punishment has been given going to allow me to identify the child?

Data Protection professional here - the definition of personal data is “information that RELATES to an identified or identifiable individual “. It is not not only information that can identify someone like name etc.

Any punishment relates to that child and therefore constitutes their personal data. As such the school cannot disclose this to you. As a fellow mum, I understand your frustrations but this really is a black and white matter in terms of what is permissable to be disclosed under GDPR.

The school can and should let you know what measures are being put in place to safeguard your child in future, but knowing the specifics of the punishment doesn’t form a part of this.

KER90 · 15/11/2022 18:54

bellac11 · 15/11/2022 18:46

Well thats where we disagree, I couldnt have been more specific, you seem to have a habit of not viewing people's answers to you as sufficient, no doubt I am also giving a wishy washy answer, fobbing you off and bullshitting

I also disagree with you that you are reasonable (that is the question you were asking AIBU..) for wanting to know how something was dealt with and that you have a right to complain if it isnt to your liking. You're not being reasonable

You've been told that over and over again and you continue to argue about it and to top it right off are now lying about what others on the thread have said.

As I said, keep painting that picture.

Specific where? All I see is wishy-washy none answers to a direct question.

What picture am i painting of myself?

OP posts:
KER90 · 15/11/2022 18:53

fjäl · 15/11/2022 18:49

And what if you were told and didn't deem this punishment enough? Would you carry on sending your 'assertive' husband in to the school to harass and bully the teachers, to try to dish out some corporal punishment? A town flogging? Water torture? A beheading maybe?

Oh yes of course Hmm what an utter ridiculous comment.

No one has harassed or bullied anyone other than the boy who attacked my child.

OP posts:
Callipygion · 15/11/2022 18:51

Ghostsapply · 15/11/2022 18:47

Please ensure that you have full understanding of the policies. Just because a parent doesn't like something, it doesn't mean they have a right to complain. Absolutely do so if they are breaching their own policies.

Yes, well that’s the whole point, if they have the policies to read prior to the meeting with the Head the understanding can be addressed and questions asked.

Beadpark · 15/11/2022 18:50

ReluctantCourier · 15/11/2022 17:12

@KER90 if you want a say on appropriate punishments you need to get on the governers’ board. Obv they’re not gonna take a steer from parents on an incident by incident basis it’d be chaos

"Appropriate punishments" are part of the school behaviour policy and the Headteacher is responsible for that, not the governors. DfE guidance puts it firmly in the remit of the Headteacher, who can delegate responsibility if they wish. Approval interval is set by the head, but the governing board have an input into that.
They can't reveal details of disciplinary measures taken with a child, no more than they can a member of staff. It is a confidentiality and GDPR issue. That is because it would be very easy for you to find out the identity of the child involved.

bellac11 · 15/11/2022 18:49

LolaSmiles · 15/11/2022 18:47

What you said was:

Thankfully, DH is, shall we say, very assertive,

That "shall we say.." is what makes us think that he is a bit more than 'very assertive'.

Totally agree with you. I've seen enough men like that in my career, as well as their partners who seem to think we're all going to cower in a corner and roll over when their amazing husband comes to be shall we say... Assertive .

Particularly when followed by the clear enjoyment that the head was 'flustered'.

Perhaps she was intimidated, not so funny now.

fjäl · 15/11/2022 18:49

And what if you were told and didn't deem this punishment enough? Would you carry on sending your 'assertive' husband in to the school to harass and bully the teachers, to try to dish out some corporal punishment? A town flogging? Water torture? A beheading maybe?

Ghostsapply · 15/11/2022 18:47

Callipygion · 15/11/2022 18:45

Yes, ask for a copy of their Behaviour Policy and the Bullying Policy - I think Ofsted require that they should be available on their website. After your talk with the Headteacher if you are still not satisfied then You should put your complaint in writing to the Chair of Governors. Following all that you could also contact Ofsted to complain if you don’t think they’ve followed their own policies - and tell them that you’ll be doing that if you feel they're fobbing you off, it might make them think again.

Please ensure that you have full understanding of the policies. Just because a parent doesn't like something, it doesn't mean they have a right to complain. Absolutely do so if they are breaching their own policies.

LolaSmiles · 15/11/2022 18:47

What you said was:

Thankfully, DH is, shall we say, very assertive,

That "shall we say.." is what makes us think that he is a bit more than 'very assertive'.

Totally agree with you. I've seen enough men like that in my career, as well as their partners who seem to think we're all going to cower in a corner and roll over when their amazing husband comes to be shall we say... Assertive .

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 15/11/2022 18:47

OP, say you ask to see the behaviour policy, and ask whether it has been followed- which are totally reasonable questions, by the way, but you're unhappy with the behaviour policy? What's the next step?

I get that you're understandably upset and I'm sure some of this post is an emotional reaction.

But I will just say that schools get parental complaints all the time, and it is very, very rare that a complaint will result in any change of policy.

It sounds like you have concerns about the school in general? And really, the only way to address these is to look for a new school, or to consider home schooling.

bellac11 · 15/11/2022 18:46

KER90 · 15/11/2022 18:40

What picture have I painted of myself? You haven't answered my question.

I said we won't be be fobbed off by wishy washy bullshit answers. The avoidance by the school to tell us had me under the impression that it meant they'd done nothing and were trying to get out of admitting that.

I think it's reasonable to want to know how and that something was dealt with accordingly and to complain if it isn't. Especially when it comes to my children. Obviously the school and the law don't agree with that but in any other circumstances I don't think people would be so quick to accept that.

Well thats where we disagree, I couldnt have been more specific, you seem to have a habit of not viewing people's answers to you as sufficient, no doubt I am also giving a wishy washy answer, fobbing you off and bullshitting

I also disagree with you that you are reasonable (that is the question you were asking AIBU..) for wanting to know how something was dealt with and that you have a right to complain if it isnt to your liking. You're not being reasonable

You've been told that over and over again and you continue to argue about it and to top it right off are now lying about what others on the thread have said.

As I said, keep painting that picture.

Ghostsapply · 15/11/2022 18:46

KER90 · 15/11/2022 18:29

Oh I don't know, what about well they might have SEN, or they might have a violent home life? So that makes it ok to take this out on my child does it?

Of course it doesn't but let's say the punishment reflects that the child has significant SEN and/or a horrific homelife but they can't provide you those details so in your eyes the punishment is not enough. What then? As is the consistent theme of the thread, focus on the safety of your child and ensure that they keep them safe.

Callipygion · 15/11/2022 18:45

Yes, ask for a copy of their Behaviour Policy and the Bullying Policy - I think Ofsted require that they should be available on their website. After your talk with the Headteacher if you are still not satisfied then You should put your complaint in writing to the Chair of Governors. Following all that you could also contact Ofsted to complain if you don’t think they’ve followed their own policies - and tell them that you’ll be doing that if you feel they're fobbing you off, it might make them think again.

Jayneisagirlsname · 15/11/2022 18:44

You do realise that nobody at the school will have wanted this to happen to your child? That the staff will have been extremely concerned and most likely spent hours thinking about how it happened, why it happened and how to prevent it in the future?

This is not a cover up that you and your DH need to blow wide open - assertively or not. Demanding answers about 'punishments' doesn't make you a better or more protective parent. Requiring answers about your child's safety and the measures to protect them however, does.

saraclara · 15/11/2022 18:42

KER90 · 15/11/2022 17:32

So you've managed to come to conclusion that my husband is an arse and a bully, because I said he's assertive and won't back down or be fobbed off with none answers? How does that make him an arse?

What you said was:

Thankfully, DH is, shall we say, very assertive,

That "shall we say.." is what makes us think that he is a bit more than 'very assertive'.

LolaSmiles · 15/11/2022 18:42

Oh I don't know, what about well they might have SEN, or they might have a violent home life? So that makes it ok to take this out on my child does it?
All those things may well be very relevant in how the school follows up and sanctions the behaviour and informs future preventative measures.

Identifying features that affect the perpetrators in order to respond appropriately is 100% the school's job. I've written risk assessments for children who are high risk for violence towards staff and students. The children's history matters.

It would be very wrong if a school were to dismiss violent behaviour and do nothing, but identifying complex issues around a child who is behaving violently is entirely appropriate and in no way means anyone is saying it's ok for other children to be harmed by another child behaving violently.

Winterthoughts · 15/11/2022 18:40

WeepingSomnambulist · 15/11/2022 17:40

@Winterthoughts

Here. I hope that answers some of your question about why they cant discuss the response to behaviour like this.

Of course, there could be none of the additional intervention going on but telling that would be setting a precedent to disclose responses and sanctions. They cant do that.

If your child had any of these additional interventions due to their behaviour, would you want the other parents being told?

All you need to know is how your child will be kept safe and also what they were told and how they were treated after the incident to ensure they felt secure and not blamed etc.

I do sincerely appreciate the information,and it makes sense,and I understand the reasons for it.
At the same time,I can absolutely understand the parents of the victim,which they are, needing a lot of reassuring:if you are just told "we've dealt with it",without acknowledging that the safe guarding policies didn't catch this potential behaviour before, and explaining how it will be stopped going forward,then I think some distrust, or wanting reassuring they can't have about the original event, is a natural reaction.

KER90 · 15/11/2022 18:40

bellac11 · 15/11/2022 18:35

Your focus has been solely on the punishment and you say yourself you wont take no for an answer. You have said yourself you want to know if its 'appropriate' or not and if not you want to take it further.

That is all people need to know about you, you've painted the picture of yourself all by yourself, dont come the naive 'oh I dont know how people have got this view of me'.

What picture have I painted of myself? You haven't answered my question.

I said we won't be be fobbed off by wishy washy bullshit answers. The avoidance by the school to tell us had me under the impression that it meant they'd done nothing and were trying to get out of admitting that.

I think it's reasonable to want to know how and that something was dealt with accordingly and to complain if it isn't. Especially when it comes to my children. Obviously the school and the law don't agree with that but in any other circumstances I don't think people would be so quick to accept that.

OP posts:
jonnyjannoo · 15/11/2022 18:40

ghasovreiksteen · 15/11/2022 18:23

You are all minimising it though. The OP just wants to know that her kid isn't going to get their head kicked in again.

So being reassured that the child is being severely dealt with and then a meeting about how her child will be kept safe is exactly what is needed and what has been offered. But apparently that wasn't brought for the OP as they, so some reason, don't believe that severely dealt with actually means severely dealt with, but is just the school fobbing her off. I suspect the OP was hoping that the majority of posters would back her up with tales of being told what sanctions / punishments other kids have been given in similar circumstances, and lots of validation that the head clearly was just "bullshitting" her. Unfortunately she's been told the exact opposite. It's never nice to be wrong, is it?

PicaNewName · 15/11/2022 18:36

Justthisonce12 · 15/11/2022 16:50

The world has changed so much from when my children were at school. I actually got a written letter of an apology from the parents of the child that attacked mine and the school handed out the email address in order for them to send it. I mean it was all taken in the spirit of which it was intended but yeah it was quite a surprise when it dropped into my email inbox.

You do not know the circumstances. I can think of a lot of reasons and this attack doesn't sound like a normal 'lashing out' anyway. OP has no right for more information other than how the school will ensure protective measures have been taken.

WeepingSomnambulist · 15/11/2022 18:35

KER90 · 15/11/2022 18:29

Oh I don't know, what about well they might have SEN, or they might have a violent home life? So that makes it ok to take this out on my child does it?

Can you share the post which says that SEN or a violent home life makes this behaviour ok? I cant find it.

What you've been told is that these things might be in play and you have no right to know about them. They cannot explain the actions being taken without explaining these things and you cannot know these things.

No one had minimised it. No one has said the behaviour is ok. We have told you that you have no right to know about this other child.

bellac11 · 15/11/2022 18:35

KER90 · 15/11/2022 18:28

What does it say? You've drawn all these conclusions of me off of very little written information and have yet to respond when I ask you to elaborate??

Your focus has been solely on the punishment and you say yourself you wont take no for an answer. You have said yourself you want to know if its 'appropriate' or not and if not you want to take it further.

That is all people need to know about you, you've painted the picture of yourself all by yourself, dont come the naive 'oh I dont know how people have got this view of me'.