Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Partner wants a new dog, I don't: end of the relationship?

262 replies

nomorequinoa · 15/11/2022 15:19

We've been together for 22 years. I'm 61, my DP's soon to be 60 and will be retiring in March 2023. I've freelanced from home for many years. DP works in IT as a contractor and has often worked abroad.

18 years ago we rescued our first dog, a young terrier. Soon after that DP took a 12-month contract in the Netherlands and I ended up looking after the dog for at least five days a week, with all the stress of training and caring for a young dog with behavioural issues. He'd come home for a couple of weekends each month and enjoy taking her on long walks, then be off again. Five years after that we mutually agreed to take on another rescue. I continued doing the lion's share of looking after them during the week. I loved them very much, but they were both quite challenging and they too often felt like a tie. Finding a reliable dog-sitter was always a challenge: I lost out on opportunities to go places and do things. The first dog died at 15 in 2017 and the younger one is about to turn 14 is just starting to look a bit stiff and doddery.

A week ago a friend of DP's asked if there was a chance of us rehoming a gorgeous terrier cross. The owners are divorcing and neither is in a position to take the dog. My DP went to see it without consulting me. It's clearly a sweet, much-loved pet and DP has as good as told them we will take it. Apparently he told them he'll just need to talk me round.

I don't want another dog once our current lovely old lad goes. I want us to be able to do all the things we've talked about doing in retirement without the stress of having to look after a dog. I want us to be able to take that three-month trip to South America we've talked about without the worry of dog care. I want to be able to take a last-minute trip away and do spontaneous things without having to factor in a dog. I don't want to have to continue putting on my boots and waterproofs and walking four miles in the cold and rain because the dog needs me to exercise him, as I've done for the last 18 years. I want a break from dog-care routine. DP says I'm making a mountain out of a molehill. He says the dog will be his, he'll walk it twice a day and take responsibility for it. I ask how he'll look after the dog when he's away on his sailing and cycling breaks with his brother and friends. He says he'll put it in kennels. We both know he'll expect me to look after the dog when he's away. He's working on the basis that I'll soften and give in, but I'm not going to. This is a hard, hard no from me.

I'd hoped he'd hear me and agree that once our current lovely boy has gone, we should be able to have at least a five-year break without a dog. Instead he's doubled down. We've never argued much, but in the last few days we've had some really hurtful rows that have made me see him in a new light. We've managed to work our way through things before, but this seems different.

AIBU? Has anyone else been through anything similar? I'd never imagined that it would be a dog that would end our relationship, but I think it might.

OP posts:
Chomolungma · 18/11/2022 20:16

Well done OP - that sounds like a really good conversation. Hopefully he now realises that you're serious about this.

skinnyminnie21 · 18/11/2022 20:13

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

RandomMess · 18/11/2022 20:12
Confused

He isn't considering your needs and wants is he?

Blind and deaf to what you are saying!

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 18/11/2022 20:08

Wow, I'm glad you held your ground.

He sounds amazingly oblivious to your wants, needs and preferences.

nomorequinoa · 18/11/2022 20:07

We managed to talk about it again yesterday evening, less heatedly. I said what I've said here. That I want freedom from routine. It's clear he wants what he's got now — a dog, a domestic routine and me to cover when he can't be here — in retirement. It's made me realise I don't want that, at least for the first few years. Even if I'm not away travelling or studying or visiting friends for six months of the year, I don't want the expectation that I'll be doing all the domestic duties while I'm here. He seems to think I'll be gardening and decorating and helping him build summer houses etc. These are things I did in the early days when we didn't have much money and we had to do it ourselves, but I'm not planning to be spending my retirement up a ladder with a paint roller unless I feel the desire to do so.

He seems genuinely perplexed that I might not be automatically on the same wavelength as him. He asked if I was serious about leaving if he got the dog and I said yes, I still feel absolutely adamant that I won't be trapped. He said it would be a sad and lonely life I'd leave and I said no, it would be a wonderful life where I could eat what I wanted, get up and go to bed when I wanted and above all not be dictated to by anyone else's needs — his or the dog. He said he couldn't think of anything worse than being on his own. I pointed out that he'd lived on his own for long periods when he was working abroad and he didn't seem to have minded that which pulled him up short. He is still talking about the dog and trying to persuade me that it would be different but I'm not even having to resist. It's just NO. Done that, over it.

OP posts:
Bonheurdupasse · 18/11/2022 17:56

How are things OP? Hope you managed to get through to him...

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 17/11/2022 17:46

Mirabai · 17/11/2022 16:50

I would say that life with a dog is no life - it’s just dog sitting permanently.

Agreed. And as a cat lover I think it would be less of a life without a cat than a dog. Dogs are far too much work and inconvenience, too noisy, stinky etc and from my experience, the reward isn't worth it with dogs.

Mirabai · 17/11/2022 16:50

aquashiv · 16/11/2022 23:51

Life without a dog is no life. So don't ask me.
However if your husband wants a dog it's his dog and stick to your guns

I would say that life with a dog is no life - it’s just dog sitting permanently.

longtompot · 17/11/2022 16:03

nomorequinoa · 16/11/2022 21:33

That’s what he’s not caring about. You want to be able to go to a friends if he goes sailing. You want to be able to go away.

I was away for 10 days last month on my own with friends. DP looked after the dog. I've said this upthread. DP has been home, pretty much, since Covid. I've had plenty of days and weeks off to do my own thing. What I want is the relief of knowing that, once this lovely old boy has gone, I won't have to think about factoring in dog care ever again.

I think the pp means that if he gets the dog, and he is away sailing or cycling, then that means you can't make a spontaneous decision to go away. You being away for 10 days recently was only possible because he was at home to look after your dog.

Your partner is being really unfair in thinking he can just talk you round to get this dog, and getting annoyed with you because you haven't just said oh ok then.

aquashiv · 16/11/2022 23:51

Life without a dog is no life. So don't ask me.
However if your husband wants a dog it's his dog and stick to your guns

Wombat27A · 16/11/2022 23:23

He sees a dog in his retirement as he doesn't carry the mental load for it currently.

My DH wants us to cut our pet count down & that's fair enough. I will say, 3 years post him retiring, it's only now he's really understanding how much work there is at home. He was away a lot. It's been a shock. It sounds to me like you really want your freedom.

Crumpleton · 16/11/2022 22:14

Your DP knows that it's been a dream of yours to travel, some of the journeys with him to.
So by him getting another dog it kind of prevents that from happening in the way you'd like it to.

rookiemere · 16/11/2022 21:55

Oh OP it's like he has thrown a grenade into that lovely list of plans you both have.

It seems he doesn't appreciate that with a dog, if he chooses to go sailing then either you look after the dog or someone has to source and pay for care for it, or if you both go away together, yet again someone has to source and pay for care for the dog.

I don't know what the answer is, but you must not capitulate as you feel this strongly about it. Who knows in a couple of years you may actually want another dog once you've done your travelling, but now is not the right time.

Chomolungma · 16/11/2022 21:43

Stand firm OP. You know your own mind and he's going to have to accept it.

Santagiveyoursackawash · 16/11/2022 21:42

We have 4 ddogs. It's tough-but neither of us have regrets! But...dh has (kindly) asked that when that number declines we won't be topping it back up
...
I have had my great times with 4. I will be as happy with less and a happy dh!

Marmiteontoastyum · 16/11/2022 21:35

This is really tough. I think you guys really need to talk. Don’t be too hasty. Things can get out of hand in heated discussions. Maybe suggest couples counselling. You don’t always need lots of sessions. We had two sessions at a make or break moment in our relationship about ten years ago and they ended up being a complete eye opener for both of us. We became stronger than ever after them, I think largely because we both realised we were 100% committed to making it work and compromising whereas before we were at a stalemate. Would he go to counselling with you?

nomorequinoa · 16/11/2022 21:33

That’s what he’s not caring about. You want to be able to go to a friends if he goes sailing. You want to be able to go away.

I was away for 10 days last month on my own with friends. DP looked after the dog. I've said this upthread. DP has been home, pretty much, since Covid. I've had plenty of days and weeks off to do my own thing. What I want is the relief of knowing that, once this lovely old boy has gone, I won't have to think about factoring in dog care ever again.

OP posts:
RandomMess · 16/11/2022 21:25

So he has all these plans for his first year that would leave you caring for his dog???

Can he not be bothered to see how that would inconvenience you Confused

nomorequinoa · 16/11/2022 21:22

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime · 16/11/2022 20:08

I suppose this is bigger than the dog really and there are intricacies of the dynamics of a such a long relationship that we can’t possibly understand as anonymous names on the internet.
Is there more to this? You seem quite ready to jump ship. If he said no to the dog would you otherwise be happy or would there be other things that make you want to start this new chapter of your life independently?

DP's latest contract comes to an end in March next year and it seemed the ideal moment to finish the working stage of our lives.

We've talked for the last few years about the things we'd like to do, mindful of the fact that we have an elderly dog to factor in. DP wants to redesign our poorly-planned garden and rebuild the garage. He also wants to cycle from Land's End to John O'Groats and have cycling and sailing holidays abroad in his first work-free year. I want to start an MA at the local university, go to Botswana to see an old friend who runs a game reserve there and take myself off for a few days every couple of months to visit galleries and museums as part of my specialist interest. That's not DP's idea of fun and I prefer to do it alone. We're not your typical wherever-one-goes-the-other-goes -too couple.

We've semi-planned longer trips, the main one being at least three months in South America, going from Mexico to Patagonia. I have family in Australia and New Zealand. We may, if we can find the right person to look after the dog, do a month-long trip to Oz next summer to see family in Queensland and the Northern Territories. Longer trips, are for when the dog has gone to the great beanbag in the sky.

These are things that are really important to me. They're what I've worked for over the years. It's me time. I'm astonished by my own strength of feeling, but as others have said, this is the equivalent of DP deciding unilaterally to have another child. If he won't hear me (and today he's taken the 'I don't know what's wrong with you, it's just a dog' line with me) then that's it. It may seem crazy; perhaps I am.

OP posts:
deeperthanallroses · 16/11/2022 20:47

nomorequinoa · 16/11/2022 20:20

It isn't all falling on me. DP fed and walked the old boy this morning and took him out this afternoon and did some shopping for supper on the way home. We share dog-care when he's here, which he is much of the time these days. We share chores. We both cook, we both clean, we both look after the dog. Tomorrow I'll do the morning walk and he'll do the evening one again because I'm out doing pursuing one of my hobbies.

That’s not quite the point though. How kind of him to support when it’s convenient - the point is you’ve looked after the dog when it’s not convenient for many years while he’s been able to work away, go sailing and generally do what he wants it sounds like. That’s what he’s not caring about. You want to be able to go to a friends if he goes sailing. You want to be able to go away. I would be doing that solo for now to remind him you’re a person and you matter and a dog means someone has to stay and look after it. ‘I’ve booked x, just me as you’ll need to look after the dog. I’ve been wanting to go for years. Byeeee’

nomorequinoa · 16/11/2022 20:20

MadKittenWoman · 16/11/2022 18:10

Apologies. Didn’t mean to offend. Not implying you should be married. You don’t want another dog. End of. But why is the care of this existing dog falling on you? Especially if you’re completely self-sufficient and independent? Tell him to pull his weight with the existing dog and that you won’t be looking after another. [Flowers]

It isn't all falling on me. DP fed and walked the old boy this morning and took him out this afternoon and did some shopping for supper on the way home. We share dog-care when he's here, which he is much of the time these days. We share chores. We both cook, we both clean, we both look after the dog. Tomorrow I'll do the morning walk and he'll do the evening one again because I'm out doing pursuing one of my hobbies.

OP posts:
speakout · 16/11/2022 20:17

SignOnTheWindow · 16/11/2022 19:02

Children are more portable, though, and they get more and more self sufficient as they get older! Plus they (hopefully) don't shit on the carpet if you leave them in the house too long...

I agree.
Dogs can cause more restrictions than children.
A day out with dogs cut options.
You can't just decide to go for lunch, explore some shops or visit a cafe with dogs- unless you find a dog friendly cafe (rare), tie them outside ( unsafe), leave them in the car ( never a good option even in winter cars heat up very quickly) or leave one family member outside caring for a dog.
A day out with children is far easier- you can take children into shops, cafes, restaurants, decide on the spur to go to the cinema or some attraction.

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime · 16/11/2022 20:08

nomorequinoa · 16/11/2022 20:02

Yes, I could. But that's not really the point, is it? Because we all know that if he gets the dog there will be times when I'm put in the position where I'll have to look after it, even if it's just in an emergency. For me retirement is about being free of routine, free to be spontaneous. DP won't be able to be spontaneous with me if he has a dog to look after.

I suppose this is bigger than the dog really and there are intricacies of the dynamics of a such a long relationship that we can’t possibly understand as anonymous names on the internet.
Is there more to this? You seem quite ready to jump ship. If he said no to the dog would you otherwise be happy or would there be other things that make you want to start this new chapter of your life independently?

nomorequinoa · 16/11/2022 20:02

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime · 16/11/2022 17:56

Can’t you just got to South America alone and leave him with the dog?
If you’re contemplating leaving him, three months on your own surely isn’t a big deal.

Yes, I could. But that's not really the point, is it? Because we all know that if he gets the dog there will be times when I'm put in the position where I'll have to look after it, even if it's just in an emergency. For me retirement is about being free of routine, free to be spontaneous. DP won't be able to be spontaneous with me if he has a dog to look after.

OP posts:
ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 16/11/2022 19:55

TortugaRumCakeQueen · 16/11/2022 16:56

These aren't your only options though.

I do home boarding for dogs. I look after them in my own home, where they are treated as if they are my own. I've been doing it for almost 10 years and I know all of my doggie guests really well, and they are all super comfortable here.

I charge the same as a kennel (£25 for 24 hours). My customers have been all over the globe this year, knowing that their dogs are comfy in my home. I'm licenced by the Council and fully insured.

I take dogs for as little as 4 hours (enabling people to go to the cinema/shopping/a meal), and my longest booking was for 2 months when the owners toured around Australia. And everything in between!

You should try to find something like this for your old boy, it will give you the freedom you desire.

With all of that said....in your shoes I would 100% refuse to get another dog! They are extremely tying. Even if you could find a home boarder like me, that will cost you ££££ every time you want to do something, especially as you talk about going away for 3 months at a time (I would charge you £2250 for that length of stay).

Our own dog died 4 years ago, and for all of the reasons you describe, we have not got another one. We are a bit younger than you, at 53 & 50, but given that dogs can live for 18 years, we knew that a dogs life could extend into what we'd like to be our retirement zone, so we haven't done it.

That sounds amazing, Tortuga.

I've been lucky enough to have a young woman (friend of friend) live in the past 10 years any time I wanted to travel, but it is an extra hassle to get the house, esp guest room, bathroom and kitchen, ready for a guest as I'm trying to head off on holiday.

Earlier this year I found a couple nearby, youngish academics, who love dogs and do pet sitting in THEIR home. I did a test run and my normally shy chihuahua was fine, so they watched him for a week over summer and will do again next month. It's a godsend. He was happy after the week, even energized. But it's still a big consideration when I want to go anywhere, making sure he is cared for. A dog is a huge responsibility.

Good luck, OP. Keep us posted.