Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Petty to see how long it takes son to call me?

176 replies

Bilbo1237 · 15/11/2022 07:50

I'm probably just venting...
My son lives the other end of the country
We text but only if I start the conversation or he might text first if he wants something.
I'm not overbearing and leave him to do his own thing.
He's 19 I ask if he will call me once a week for a catch up but quite often I have to text after about 9/10 days asking if he's going to call this week.
If I call him he always tells me he's busy so I leave the time and day to him.
He does come and visit a couple of times a year but it feels like it's never to see me, his dad or his brothers, it's like we are a pit stop/ b and b if he comes it's because something else is on in our area and we are cheaper than a hotel.

It's beginning to really annoy me.
It's been 11 days now since we last spoke.
I know boys will be boys I have 3 but he's the only one who makes me feel like this

OP posts:
Blanketpolicy · 15/11/2022 09:22

My mum used to play these silly emotional games and it drove me nuts.

When adults leave home, especially when they are young they have so much going on in their lives - work, relationships, friends, socialising, interests, gym, their own kids etc etc - the days pass quickly and before they know it they haven't spoken to mum for a little longer than expected.

Conversely, parents that have focussed so much of their life on their dc are left with an empty nest and so much spare time they don't know what to do with themselves so have more focus on the time that has passed between contact.

My mum used to call and say "just checking you weren't dead" 🙄

I hope when he leaves home I am able to appreciate my ds is out living his best life and knows I am here when he needs me. But I will probably be waiting for that call too!!

TakeYourFinalPosition · 15/11/2022 09:22

I'm not overbearing and leave him to do his own thing.

You say this, and that you don’t expect much from him, but then you say you expect a call a week and prompt him if he forgets. And it’s going to be a matter of perception, and personal opinion, but that feels pretty overbearing to me. I hate phone calls at the best of times, but scheduled ones for no real reason are the worst.

He might feel the same, but not want to tell you incase it hurts your feelings? Or he might just be busy, being in the army and having a girlfriend and friends. It’s not a judgement on you. I’d really try not to take it as one.

Chomolungma · 15/11/2022 09:25

At 19 I was at uni so still home for the long holidays, but when I was in my early 20s and had moved out I didn't phone home often - less than once a week. I adore my parents but it's a time when you're seeking independence.

October2020 · 15/11/2022 09:26

I find this so sad. My mum's like this with my brother too and it's damaged their relationship. You're the parent. You wiped his bum for him when he was a baby without resentment, presumably? This phase of adulthood is about reaching out to connect, so that he has roots even when he's off doing big new things. Your children are not your friends - they do not need to reciprocate a relationship in the way that you'd expect from a friend. You are the grown up. If you keep connection at this point, without guilt trips and game playing, then when he's finished maturing you may find he then reaches back.

BackOnTheBandWagon · 15/11/2022 09:26

Yeah, I spoke to my parents on average once a fortnight when I was at uni, and that was when they called me. Just teenagers being teenagers. Nothing to do with being a boy. Also it's not about you, so take your ego out of it.

BellePeppa · 15/11/2022 09:28

Bilbo1237 · 15/11/2022 09:04

Thank you all for your comments it's given me a lot to think about. he left to go in the army at 16 so I've had this for 2 years now.
It's just me been sensitive I think.

Yes you are and I speak as a highly anxious mother with a son the same age. For me the thing that makes me happiest is seeing him live life to the full. As long as I know he is safe I am happy and a text is sufficient for that.

CellarBellaatemycoal · 15/11/2022 09:30

I just take the bull by the horns with stuff like this , occasionally texting something like ‘hey stranger, did you forget you have a mother ? Everything good ?’
And when the reply is ‘hi mum I’m fine ,how are you’ I congratulate myself on raising an independent human and remind myself that I wasn’t much better at 19 and brains aren’t suitably fully developed at this age to be entirely responsible and empathetic.
Try to let go of resentment about it, and honestly it could be worse. Ime plenty of 19 year olds are still dossing round the house , expecting to be fully funded by despairing parents, partying each night and not engaging properly with education/ work. There will be people reading wishing their 19 yo would have the get up and go to move out and get a full time job and an active social life . Yours is probably an alright one, even if he’s a pain in the arse when it comes to communication.

Dixiechickonhols · 15/11/2022 09:31

I’d focus on fact he’s happy, working, gf and living his life. Young ones often prefer message to phone call.
I’d rather they messaged as a when rather than it’s 7pm Sunday I must ring my mum.
I’ve fallen in trap of set times with my elderly mum and it’s often weary. You are busy, can’t think of stuff to say at that moment. If I’m out she opens with a oh I rang and you weren’t in tone which gets my back up. You may have similar tone without realising - nice to hear from you at last. DH rarely rings mil as she always wants something, doesn’t listen to him and he copes by avoiding her.

Arucanafeather · 15/11/2022 09:32

BellePeppa · 15/11/2022 09:19

Seriously? I’m thrilled my son has built a great life for himself at Uni and has a girlfriend. If he wants to dump his washing at mine then spend time with his gf I couldn’t be happier.

That’s reminded me of the first weekend I came home from uni. Friday night out with my friends, Saturday night out with my friends. Sunday night I thought I had better stay in and see my parents. My Dad walked into the lounge and saw me sitting on sofa and said something along the lines of: where are you out to tonight? Do you need a lift? When I replied saying I wasn’t going out, he checked I hadn’t had a fallout with my friends and then said he’ll drop me off. My parents were so willing to let us fly as older teens that my sister and I would happily go to the pub or out for a meal with them and when we left home, married and had kids, my sister and I and our husbands loved going on holiday with them. Their parents had guilt ridden them so they were determined to never do it to us. They weren’t perfect parents of course but they 100% nailed this.

Our eldest barely talks to us now he’s in his early teens except for when he wants to do. I’m sure that will continue when he’s moves out. I do feel a pang when I think of the future and that I might only seen him once or twice a year if I’m lucky. I’m hoping he has other things to come back to when he’s left so he’ll use us as a base. I’m planning to sit on my hands and take my parents approach but I do think I’ll feel a little pang too. Our other 2 kids are currently more home birds but my DH and I have our future planned based on all three of them flying far away, so if any of them stay closer it will be a lovely addition.

CleopatrasBeautifulNose · 15/11/2022 09:35

I buggered off to oz for a year and got in touch once a month at that age. I was finding out about the world and me in it, and making sure my parents got enough contact based on frequency of calls would have been awful. I trusted they knew I loved them and they did. Thank goodness they didn't nudge and prompt and explain. Not saying they wouldn't have liked more, but 19 is not a parent focused time. Now I'm in my 40's I call and chat often, when the mood takes me and vice versa. Its all free and relaxed. Which is not how you sound.

LadyMarmaladeAtkins · 15/11/2022 09:38

A generation ago you'd be lucky to hear from a 19 year old who was away for months on end, or you might get a letter or if very advanced, an email! Is he at uni? Weekly calls home would be considered very attentive so 11 days isn't that bad. When I was at uni we had a few communal phone boxes. How did we cope? How did our parents?

Leave him be or he'll come to resent you. He's spreading his wings and it is as it should be.

ClaireEclair · 15/11/2022 09:45

On the other side of the coin, my mother never phones me to ask about me. She only phones if she wants something or wants me to do something or is someone has upset her/annoyed her. I frequently phone her to ask how she’s doing. Sometimes her messages start “would you…”. No “hi how are you?”. She didn’t even phone me on my 40th and 41st birthday. I can’t remember if she phoned me on any other birthdays now I think about it.

LadyMarmaladeAtkins · 15/11/2022 09:45

Of course by 25 I was calling them every day.

Oh goodness me too much! Unless there is an illness or other reasons that mean it really needs to be this much that is just suffocating.

I say this as the mother of adults and thinking back to my own 20s. It'd be suffocating for me now and them.

shiningstar2 · 15/11/2022 09:49

He's in the Army? And has been since he was 16? You must be so proud of him. Seriously military life is really full on and finding quiet times to ring home isn't always easy. Plus he is 19. Finding himself. Just keep to texts op. Try to keep them light hearted and newsy. No pressure. He sounds like he is doing well, he loves you but when home, at 19 it will be the girlfriend first. Be patient. He will engage more in a couple of years. 💐

SleepingisanArt · 15/11/2022 09:49

He's in the army - his friends probably give him grief about your calls.

We have daughters - one married who lives within an hour of our home who messages or calls every now and then. She's busy, has her own business and works extremely hard. The other is living and working in Asia at the moment. Sometimes we message every day (stuff going on or she sees things which would be of interest to me) and sometimes we go a few weeks with nothing.

I have done my job. I have raised 2 adults who are out in the world living their lives but who know that no matter what I am here if the need me.

xogossipgirlxo · 15/11/2022 09:49

I'm like your son, except I'm not a guy. I was always quite independent, I dreamt about moving out of my parent's house. Not everyone exists by missing family, hometown, meals cooked by mum etc. For me, ringing my mum once a week is very often. Fortnightly is more than enough for me. I get how you feel, but on the other hand I get what your son must be thinking- I bet he loves his new life. Btw. my mum always waits for me to call. Why can't she call first? It's not like I'll reject her. Are you the same perhaps?

RedToothBrush · 15/11/2022 09:50

I'm guessing he's your youngest?

He has gone into a career which teaches and encourages self sufficiency.

Realistically, given his occupation I don't think its necessarily helpful for either of you to be constantly feeling 'i need to be in touch with son/mum'.

You do perhaps need to have a chat about contact being important, but don't put a time frame on it.

If he is deployed somewhere, he may have limited ability to call regularly and I think you need to wrap your head around this but perhaps stress the need to be in contact at important times where possible and less treating the place like a hotel when in town because its important to you to have quality time with him too.

You don't want to be overbearing as that will trigger the opposite response.

He has to adjust himself and very genuinely its good he isn't needing you right now as that's the very best thing for him in terms of career. He just needs to know you are there if he needs you.

GelatoQueen · 15/11/2022 09:51

Hi OP - I was like this with my mum when I went to uni 30 years ago. There were no mobiles then so I couldn't text and life was just so busy / exciting and it wasn't always easy to get to a pay phone. I didn't realise how worried mum was when she didn't hear from me because it wouldn't have crossed my mind that she had anything to worry about.

In your shoes I would just text your son occasionally to say 'hi hope everything is OK with you? We are fine' and that's it or if there's something specific you need to arrange / talk to him about a quick ' Hi DS, could you give me a call this week / or specify days as I need a quick chat with you about x'

Temporary311022 · 15/11/2022 09:51

OP you sound ghoulish. Maybe he might find a foreign woman in the future and live abroad.

TortugaRumCakeQueen · 15/11/2022 09:54

I get you Op, I have a 25 y/o, who is similar. I was going to start a thread actually. He went off to USA for a holiday recently, travelling alone and meeting up in various locations to meet friends from Uni. I said that he should let someone know his travel plans, just in case something happened, and he accused me of treating him like he's 9. I just thought that was sensible!

When my Mum was alive she would always ask which hotel we were going to, and she would check in on our return date, to make sure we landed safely. As mobile phones came on the scene, I would just text my Mum "Landed".

I haven't replied to his last sarcastic text, because I don't know what to say to that.

In fairness, I probably think about the "what if's" more than most : my DH is a Police Officer and deals with missing people cases every day. It's amazing how many people don't know where their loved ones are. Can you imagine the conversation?

Parent : My child went on a trip but hasn't returned home
Police : Where did they go?
Parent : USA somewhere
Police : Whereabouts?
Parent : I don't know
Police : Who were they visiting?
Parent : I don't know
Police : What flight were they meant to be on?
Parent : I don't know

xogossipgirlxo · 15/11/2022 09:54

Btw. my sister, when she left for uni, she visited my parents twice a month. Sitting on the bus for 4 hours just to see them for the weekend. She was crying when she had to leave on Sunday evening etc. Trust me, it's much, much worse, because you worry your child is unhappy. It's better the way your son is.

dustofneptune · 15/11/2022 09:54

I contacted my parents around once a month, if that, when I was that age. I was at uni, then in my 20s figuring out my place in the world, then living overseas for months at a time.

I still remember when I was about 18, I was staying at a boyfriend's place often, but I loved coming back home to grab lunch, do washing, and just be at home and feel like it was my home. My mom went absolutely mental and said I was treating the place like a hotel. I remember feeling punched in the gut. It really hurt me, because I thought I was safe to have a home base but be happy and spread my wings. Apparently not.

This continued through uni and my 20s. She would secretly test me to see how long it took me to call, then resent and punish me for it with barbed comments and guilt trips. It fractured our relationship massively.

I'm now in my late 30s and see/speak to my mom a few times a year. When we do, it's warm, loving, easygoing, and relaxed. I would rather us have a nice time when we do connect even if it's infrequent, than force weekly/monthly calls to talk about the same thing every time. It feels so surfacey, and I resent the notion that I'm supposed to tick boxes to meet her expectations just because she chose to have a child. I don't have to think of my mom as my best friend in the world to love and respect her.

My dad is now the one pressuring me to call every week, guilt tripping me, and trying to force visits - and it's because he has nothing going on. This just pushes us further apart. I hate sitting on the phone for ages and would rather leave voice notes here and there. But he refuses, because he wants phone calls.

I guess my point in sharing this is to try to give you perspective from the other side?

Relationship quality is more important than quantity. Would you rather have an authentic relationship where your son feels loved and accepted and free? Or a forced relationship where he resents having to call and see you?

Don't "test" him. Just let him breathe. Even tell him, with love, that you're sorry for pressuring him to call you weekly, and that you were just scared you'd lose sight of each other / lose contact with him if you don't talk. Tell him that you love him and are always there for him if he needs anything. And then just let it be.

If he keeps asking for help, then you decide what help you want to give. It's manipulative to expect him to pay you back or earn your help with attention and phone calls. If you don't want to help, then don't. If you do, then do. Don't make it a transaction.

FetchezLaVache · 15/11/2022 09:55

Oh goodness, please don't end up like my auntie, whose adult children get grief if they don't check in at least every other day and all who live within striking distance must go for Sunday lunch every week unless they have a watertight excuse, and even then they get guilt-tripped!

MavisChunch29 · 15/11/2022 10:00

I would try and arrange a good time to catch up with him once a week, say, if he's amenable to that. Or if not just leave him be. You have to let them fly and hopefully they'll come back once in a while.

Newmum0322 · 15/11/2022 10:03

Ahh I mean, I kind of feel for you, but mostly I want to say you need to back off a little! (lot).

I love my MIL, I think she’s fab and I have a great relationship with her. Her sons… not so much. She’s a little passive aggressive with them and says ‘hello stranger’ or ‘who’s this’ if they dare not call for several days. She’s always been a SAHM and her boys are EVERYTHING to her (4 sons) I’ve tried to explain that to DP but he just ignores her now. Only calls out of obligation which is really sad!

Id say let him do his thing, let him WANT to call. There really is no joy in it if he’s only doing it to appease you!