Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I change my sons name to please my MIL?

459 replies

97DS · 15/11/2022 04:57

Ever since we found out baby was going to be a boy DH and I have had his name chosen. MIL has made subtle digs throughout pregnancy at how she’s not a fan of the name, and if we’ve considered anything else. I just dodge the question and ignore it because I don’t have the energy to argue with her. She can be very opinionated and very stubborn.
baby is now a week old, and not officially registered yet but we have announced his full name to friends/family/social media.
MIL has gone out of her way at every opportunity to make a comment on his name. Even after a traumatic birth which landed me in theatre with major haemorrhaging, her first text to DH was asking what baby’s name is going to be.

She’s been talking to family behind our back saying how disappointed she is, as well as pulling DH aside to privately ask if we would change the name. MIL is purposely avoiding saying his name, and has opted to calling him Jnr instead… That’s just the issue with his 1st name. Keep reading…

she also has a massive issue with his middle name too. DH has 2 middle names (X & Y) and when we chose baby’s name, we decided to use middle name Y so it followed the family tree as a tribute to the dads (Y runs quite far back in the male side of the family tree) and also, Y is my fathers middle name too so it seemed very sentimental to us all.
We’ve had a lot of compliments on his name from DH’s side of the family because we chose middle name Y. But MIL has kicked off BIG TIME. Pulling out crocodile tears and directly asking DH to change the middle name to something that tributes MIL’s family instead.
However, there’s only 2 male names to pick from if we were to consider it, and both names are awful, I genuinely don’t like them, and they don’t even go with baby boys 1st name, and would make the surname seem like a mouthful if you were to say it out loud.
My argument is, it’s not her baby so it’s not her business what his name is. She had the opportunity 30 years ago to tribute her family and that’s why DH’s middle name is X. But baby’s name isn’t meant to be a tribute to her family, it’s a tribute to DH’s family, as well as my own.

Yes we could just keep the peace and add a 2nd middle name that she wants, but I don’t want that. As his mother, I should be the one who has final say and I don’t want him to have 2 middle names, and I certainly don’t want to change his name under the pressure and influence of MIL. DH has agreed with me throughout pregnancy what his name is, but now MIL is getting into his head and playing a guilt card, DH is now having 2nd thoughts because he doesn’t like to upset MIL. I know it’s not what he wants either but his MIL is so good at minipulating everything to get her own way. She puts words into DH’s mouth and convinces him they’re his own. So now DH and I argue over this.
what’s your thoughts? AIBU to stick my guns and keep my sons name how it is, or should I reason with MIL, and change the name just to keep her happy?

OP posts:
mikulkin · 15/11/2022 11:50

Her reasoning on the first name is ridiculous and you obviously shouldn't change it.
Having said that I would go a bit against grain here and say add another middle name. I do understand all your reasoning, but given your MIL and FIL are divorced it looks like there is honouring to FIL side but not MIL one. I know that was not the intention, you explained it but to MIL it looks this way. I think that's why your DH is feeling guilty now and that's why he argues with you. He feels he honoured his dad but not his mum.

CambsAlways · 15/11/2022 11:49

Sorry but you are joking! You actually are considering changing your babies name cos your MIL doesn’t like it 🤣🤣🤣🤣 bloody hell, whose baby is it, I’ve never heard anything like it! So you were in theatre due to a traumatic birth and as you say the first thing she asked, was not how you and the baby are, she wanted to know if you had changed it’s name! She has some issues going on massive controller, what’s your Dh doing about this he could shut her down straight away, even reading about how you are being treated makes me so sad for you

AryaStarkWolf · 15/11/2022 11:48

Absolutely do NOT give in to her, how childish and rude of her. This is your baby, you call him what you want

Herejustforthisone · 15/11/2022 11:47

TheEponymousGrub · 15/11/2022 11:41

I agree with PPS that you, and especially your DH, need to recognise clearly that this level of interference from MIL is not acceptable. I also agree that standing up to her now, together, will be an investment for your happy future. That said, in order to have your husband clearly on your side now, I think it's a great idea to add MIL's choice of name as an additional given name. OK, you didn't want to, and I agree that you shouldn't have to, but it could help your DH to stand with you in refusing other changes - and it won't affect your child at all. It needn't appear on the school register, even; it can be effectively dropped quietly, as soon as you like. There's no true reason to want not to do it except that it is irksome to feel pushed. I think it would be worth that cost, if it enabled your DH to stand with you.

Have you lost your mind?

KettrickenSmiled · 15/11/2022 11:47

CONSTANT carping & interference.

KettrickenSmiled · 15/11/2022 11:46

TheEponymousGrub · 15/11/2022 11:41

I agree with PPS that you, and especially your DH, need to recognise clearly that this level of interference from MIL is not acceptable. I also agree that standing up to her now, together, will be an investment for your happy future. That said, in order to have your husband clearly on your side now, I think it's a great idea to add MIL's choice of name as an additional given name. OK, you didn't want to, and I agree that you shouldn't have to, but it could help your DH to stand with you in refusing other changes - and it won't affect your child at all. It needn't appear on the school register, even; it can be effectively dropped quietly, as soon as you like. There's no true reason to want not to do it except that it is irksome to feel pushed. I think it would be worth that cost, if it enabled your DH to stand with you.

Eh?

So OP has to teach her husband how to stand up to his mother by ... agreeing to kowtow to his mother?

This is not something they should be making a concession over. Right now, they need to demonstrate that they are on the same page & MiL's input is not welcome. I can only hope that the DH has the balls to stand his ground. If he doesn't, he'll have opened the floodgates to contact carping & interference.

Webbedlife · 15/11/2022 11:42

It's not about her. She should stop being so controlling.

TheEponymousGrub · 15/11/2022 11:41

I agree with PPS that you, and especially your DH, need to recognise clearly that this level of interference from MIL is not acceptable. I also agree that standing up to her now, together, will be an investment for your happy future. That said, in order to have your husband clearly on your side now, I think it's a great idea to add MIL's choice of name as an additional given name. OK, you didn't want to, and I agree that you shouldn't have to, but it could help your DH to stand with you in refusing other changes - and it won't affect your child at all. It needn't appear on the school register, even; it can be effectively dropped quietly, as soon as you like. There's no true reason to want not to do it except that it is irksome to feel pushed. I think it would be worth that cost, if it enabled your DH to stand with you.

RedToothBrush · 15/11/2022 11:40

HELL NO.

If she gets away with bullying you to comply with this over your son, what will she demand next?

Its not all about her.

Stick to your guns and tell her its tough.

FictionalCharacter · 15/11/2022 11:40

"My argument is, it’s not her baby so it’s not her business what his name is."
This is all you need, and your DH needs to stop allowing himself to be bullied by her.
If you allow her to override this parenting decision, it paves the way for her to throw her weight around over everything else you do.
If she carries on being petulant enough to call him Junior when he's older, and he knows it's because she doesn't like his name, it will just make him dislike her. So she'll have shot herself in the foot.

Dogtooth · 15/11/2022 11:32

It's your baby, not hers.

Give in on this and you will find yourself faced with an endless series of battles about everything to do with your child. Feeding, sleep routines, schooling, clothing, etc etc etc. You make the decisions because it's your baby.

If she acts this badly she's not going to have much involvement with her grandchild, and she needs to know that.

CrackingcheeseWallace · 15/11/2022 11:31

DH and I had names for both male/female for our 2nd before she was born as we didn't know the sex during the pregnancy. Chatted in general to MIL about the names and she didn't like either; made it quite vocal how/why she didn't like them 🙄DH at the time, told her 'tough'. So DD arrived and we called her by the name we wanted, with a middle name...that MIL didn't like either when she found out! FIL, every time they saw DD as a baby said 'I absolutely adore her names; well done on such fine choices' with MIL chuntering away in the background.

Please don't give in to your MIL and don't let your DH beat you down either! You chose the names already; tough if people don't like them. MIL had her chance to name her children as she saw fit. Naming YOUR baby is nothing to do with her. Interfering old bat.

Goldpaw · 15/11/2022 11:29

Register the name you and your husband chose at the first possible opportunity.

Otherwise you will have a lifetime of her knowing if she goes on enough you'll do as she wants.

And she'll take full advantage of this.

HotWashCycle · 15/11/2022 11:28

Congratulations on your lovely baby. You absolutely cannot let her have an influence on whatever you do with your DS. This would set a precedent forever. How unreasonable, selfish and entitled can anyone be - your MIL is unbelievable. Please don't think of giving in over your preferred name. It is nothing to do with her, and none of her business.
My worry for you is that she may have got inside your DH's head as you said. If he goes to register the birth, can you trust him? Can you go and do it together?

diddl · 15/11/2022 11:24

She puts words into DH’s mouth and convinces him they’re his own.

So your husband can't remember what he actually said??

CoastalWave · 15/11/2022 11:23

Your MIL named her own children.

It's got sod all to do with her. If she wants to name something tell her to get a dog.

Cryalot2 · 15/11/2022 11:21

Congratulations on the birth of your baby.
No one has the right to tell anyone what to call their child. She had her choice and now you do the same. Don't even consider changing.
If she gets away with that what next? She would be trying to influence other aspects.
Tell her the name you like is registered and if she can't call him that well she isn't going to see him.

RinklyRomaine · 15/11/2022 11:17

For gods sakes say no. If you change it to please her you will have the same utter shit over every parenting decision from now til the old bat is gone. I speak from experience. Just give a laugh and say, goodness, imagine trying to dictate someone else's baby name!

My ExMiL did this with my ExDPs older kids. Dictated first and middle name. Mum didn't get a look in, with two kids. All named for her side. 15 years later she is still the dominant presence, despite her son having divorced their mum when they were toddlers. Controls everything. Their dad has ended up giving over most of his contact time to her.

Loathed and detested me for saying no to name, boarding school, bottle feeding...the list is endless. I am happy with her loathing.

Yousee · 15/11/2022 11:13

This happened to the woman in the bed beside me when I had DS earlier this year. Baby girl in NICU, mum in a terrible state post section, MIL causing merry hell because the woman and her DH had decided to give the baby a middle name in honour of both their grandmothers and apparently the MIL hated her MIL so wanted it changed.
It was awful to see the woman in floods of tears over it, she felt that her MIL was showing she could not care less about the baby as she wasn't asking how she was doing, just if they had changed the name yet.
As PP said, this is the hill to die on. The first major decision for you and DH as parents should be made by you and DH or you are setting a nightmarish precedent.
Congratulations on the birth of your baby 💐

KettrickenSmiled · 15/11/2022 11:12

97DS · 15/11/2022 09:34

At 4am my brain didn’t work so I don’t think it came across how I wanted.
Basically the 2 male names from MIL side of the family are both men who are deceased, who DH never met/too young to remember, or ever heard of before until now.
MIL had close relationships with these people, but they are not DH’s family (he doesn’t know who they are) I was implying they were MIL’s family because DH has never met or heard of them. So why name a baby after someone in MIL’s family that we have no association with. whereas when I refer to DH’s family, it’s directly family who he grew up with, had a close bond with and who’s death was very difficult to deal with, heartbreaking

OP - you don't need to explain or justify your name choices to anyone here!
No more than you need to justify them to MiL.

She is being so batshit rude that I think you need to read up about avoiding justification - because every time to try to justify your own side of an entirely reasonable argument, you are lending the argument legitimacy.
And MiL's argument is not legitimate.
outofthefog.website/what-not-to-do-1/2015/12/3/jade-dont-justify-argue-defend-explain

Coincidentally, PP mentioned your DH being trapped in the FOG, & the link above is from the Out of the Fog website. DH & you might benefit from exploring the site - outofthefog.website/toolbox-intro

Because your problem doesn't need to be MiL's batshittery about names - you can Grey Rock & not-JADE her quite easily about that.
www.e-counseling.com/articles/what-is-the-grey-rock-method/
But you can feel DH wavering & he NEEDS to understand that PP are correct - if you give an inch on this naming business, MiL will continue to take a mile out of every parenting decision she feels like sticking her nose into.

Fivebeanchilli · 15/11/2022 11:11

Don't change it.
My mil hated my son's name too (maybe still does 🤷) but it's tough. We love it. Naming one's children is a time you compromise with one other person only - the other parent.
I am generally a peaceable kind person and like to make other people happy - but this is a situation where I would not budge!

ohfourfoxache · 15/11/2022 11:09

Don’t even think about giving in

He’s your baby, not hers. She has fuck all say in it

Go ahead and register him and ignore the manipulative boot

97DS · 15/11/2022 11:02

Knowing her she would ask to see the certificate 😂

OP posts:
SunshineLoving · 15/11/2022 11:01

Definitely do not change his name. What you name your child is up to you and your DH. You have chosen a name you love. Done.

I haven't always loved the names my family have chosen and for my close family, I have given my opinion but then accepted that it's their choice. Your MIL has made it clear she doesn't like the name, you went ahead with the name, now she needs to accept it, not bully you into doing something you don't want to do.

ProcrastinatorsAnonymous · 15/11/2022 10:58

Just to echo the very sensible advice you've already had - 100% do not move on this. If you do, you will be setting a very bad precedent and she will think she can make a fuss and be the main decision maker in your child's life. That is not her job. Don't budge an inch on any of the names.

Also, I'm really sorry you are having to give any mental energy to this when your baby is just a week old. Take a big sniff of his head, look at his gorgeous crinkly ears and try to forget about MIL!

Swipe left for the next trending thread