Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I change my sons name to please my MIL?

459 replies

97DS · 15/11/2022 04:57

Ever since we found out baby was going to be a boy DH and I have had his name chosen. MIL has made subtle digs throughout pregnancy at how she’s not a fan of the name, and if we’ve considered anything else. I just dodge the question and ignore it because I don’t have the energy to argue with her. She can be very opinionated and very stubborn.
baby is now a week old, and not officially registered yet but we have announced his full name to friends/family/social media.
MIL has gone out of her way at every opportunity to make a comment on his name. Even after a traumatic birth which landed me in theatre with major haemorrhaging, her first text to DH was asking what baby’s name is going to be.

She’s been talking to family behind our back saying how disappointed she is, as well as pulling DH aside to privately ask if we would change the name. MIL is purposely avoiding saying his name, and has opted to calling him Jnr instead… That’s just the issue with his 1st name. Keep reading…

she also has a massive issue with his middle name too. DH has 2 middle names (X & Y) and when we chose baby’s name, we decided to use middle name Y so it followed the family tree as a tribute to the dads (Y runs quite far back in the male side of the family tree) and also, Y is my fathers middle name too so it seemed very sentimental to us all.
We’ve had a lot of compliments on his name from DH’s side of the family because we chose middle name Y. But MIL has kicked off BIG TIME. Pulling out crocodile tears and directly asking DH to change the middle name to something that tributes MIL’s family instead.
However, there’s only 2 male names to pick from if we were to consider it, and both names are awful, I genuinely don’t like them, and they don’t even go with baby boys 1st name, and would make the surname seem like a mouthful if you were to say it out loud.
My argument is, it’s not her baby so it’s not her business what his name is. She had the opportunity 30 years ago to tribute her family and that’s why DH’s middle name is X. But baby’s name isn’t meant to be a tribute to her family, it’s a tribute to DH’s family, as well as my own.

Yes we could just keep the peace and add a 2nd middle name that she wants, but I don’t want that. As his mother, I should be the one who has final say and I don’t want him to have 2 middle names, and I certainly don’t want to change his name under the pressure and influence of MIL. DH has agreed with me throughout pregnancy what his name is, but now MIL is getting into his head and playing a guilt card, DH is now having 2nd thoughts because he doesn’t like to upset MIL. I know it’s not what he wants either but his MIL is so good at minipulating everything to get her own way. She puts words into DH’s mouth and convinces him they’re his own. So now DH and I argue over this.
what’s your thoughts? AIBU to stick my guns and keep my sons name how it is, or should I reason with MIL, and change the name just to keep her happy?

OP posts:
wednesday32 · 15/11/2022 13:08

the woman sounds unhinged. Your H needs to have a firm word with her and state that the child's name is confirmed, deal with it. What a pathetic thing to moan about. Your MIL had her own children, she could have named them in tribute to her family with their names, but didn't so that doesn't mean this now falls on your head. Do not change your child's name because this will not please her, it will just mean she'll move onto something else she doesn't like ie the colour of the nursery, the place you get his first pair of shoes from, what school they go to. Nip this in the bud now. I would also make it clear if she names the child incorrectly, refer to her by an incorrect name.

Blueeyedgirl21 · 15/11/2022 13:06

I hate when men put their mothers needs over their partners. If you choose to have a child with someone you should act like an adult not a child and prioritise the person who’s given birth to your child

radho · 15/11/2022 13:04

Definitely don't change the name. All this fuss about the name is just a manifestation of her personal issues. She had the chance to name her own children. And you can't honour every side of the family tree without ending up with an overly long and silly-sounding name.

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 15/11/2022 12:57

chill it is a name, not life or death decision

Lol, pmsl. I think it's the MIL that needs to be told this, she is the one acting like it's a life or death decision and she is so obsessed she won't stop and is happy to turn her son against his own wife.

hesbeingabitofadick · 15/11/2022 12:57

Chooksnroses · 15/11/2022 09:18

I'm a Grandmother and Great Grandmother and have 14 Grandchildren and 3 Great Grandchildren. When those children were named I wasn't always very keen initially. But then it wasn't my place to give an opinion. I'd had my chance to name babies when mine were born. Now I love every name, because I associate each one with a much loved child or young person.
Your Mother in Law doesn't have the right to insist you change your child's name. She should have swallowed her disappointment, and said, as I always did, "What a lovely name".

Thank you @Chooksnroses for giving a grandmothers view and letting the love grow. Smile I'm sure each and every child knows they are cherished.

@97DS You have one chance to name your child...why would you let someone else do it for you?

If you'd bought a puppy and decided to call it "Timmy" and MIL had a hissy fit, would you change your pups name?

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 15/11/2022 12:56

mikulkin · 15/11/2022 12:52

So quick to make a judgement. Did it ever occur to you that the situation could have been different? Just imagine for a second the situation below.
DH was choosing names with OP and didn't think about his mother, he liked the idea about honouring two families in one middle name. Then he talks to his mother, and she tells him that she is upset that the baby has Welsh name, his father's surname and the middle name from his father's side, it feels like he has chosen his dad over her given that they are divorced. He considers it and thinks it is important to include heritage from his mother's side into the name too. He is not doing it to keep peace but genially wants to honour her side too. Is he not entitled to change his opinion specially before the baby is officially named in all certificates?
You are talking like he changed his opinion 15 years down the line.
People, chill it is a name, not life or death decision

Your post doesn't add anything. They already chose the names. Initially the husband agreed with his wife, even after hearing his mum out. But she has used wider family pressure and kept on and on and on at him and manipulated him until he broke. He doesn't want to change the names. He is only doing it to 'keep the peace' and in the process, upsetting his wife and being turned against her. Did it ever occur to you to read the OP's posts and understand what she is saying, instead of being so gullible you think her husband just..... willingly changed his mind out of the blue? Come on!

mikulkin · 15/11/2022 12:52

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 15/11/2022 12:41

He ONLY wants to include his mummy's family to keep the peace. That's all. He and OP chose the names, yet her husband wants to go back on this and disrespect his wife by letting his manipulative bitch of a mother run roughshod over his and OP's choices. If he makes OP back down now, MIL will always get her way from now on.

So quick to make a judgement. Did it ever occur to you that the situation could have been different? Just imagine for a second the situation below.
DH was choosing names with OP and didn't think about his mother, he liked the idea about honouring two families in one middle name. Then he talks to his mother, and she tells him that she is upset that the baby has Welsh name, his father's surname and the middle name from his father's side, it feels like he has chosen his dad over her given that they are divorced. He considers it and thinks it is important to include heritage from his mother's side into the name too. He is not doing it to keep peace but genially wants to honour her side too. Is he not entitled to change his opinion specially before the baby is officially named in all certificates?
You are talking like he changed his opinion 15 years down the line.
People, chill it is a name, not life or death decision

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 15/11/2022 12:41

mikulkin · 15/11/2022 12:38

MIL doesn't but DH does and he wants now to include his mother's family somehow.

He ONLY wants to include his mummy's family to keep the peace. That's all. He and OP chose the names, yet her husband wants to go back on this and disrespect his wife by letting his manipulative bitch of a mother run roughshod over his and OP's choices. If he makes OP back down now, MIL will always get her way from now on.

SleeplessInEngland · 15/11/2022 12:40

I think you absolutely should change your baby's name just to appease your MIL.

(I don't actually believe this, but ask a silly question get a silly answer.)

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 15/11/2022 12:38

mikulkin · 15/11/2022 12:35

I am suggesting it because her DH now feels guilty and argues with her. The OP clearly said this is not something she wants to do but she is not the only parent to the child. DC has two parents and his father now does feel something needs to be done.
OP is not creating dynasty but she explained her reasoning for middle name and it is about honouring family. MIL doesn't have rights but DH does and he now feels he needs to honour both sides of his family.
I am really surprised that everyone talks about MIL and nobody actually mentions that DH now thinks differently. He is not a puppet, he is a grown up man and he is entitled to change his opinion after considering the situation.

He is not a puppet, he is a grown up man

All evidence to the contrary! He is MIL's puppet and allows himself to be turned against his own wife.
He and OP have a one week old, and have already chosen the names. He shouldn't be going back on that and moving the goal posts because he is too much of a ball-less gutless wonder to tell his mummy to shut up.

mikulkin · 15/11/2022 12:38

Pipsquiggle · 15/11/2022 12:00

Eh?

The baby has names that reflects both his mother's and father's families - that's lovely.

Why the hell should the MIL get a say?

MIL doesn't but DH does and he wants now to include his mother's family somehow.

mikulkin · 15/11/2022 12:35

KettrickenSmiled · 15/11/2022 12:07

Why are you suggesting another middle name, when OP has very clearly said that this is NOT something she wants to do?

MiL has no rights to have her name "honoured".
OP isn't birthing future kings or establishing a dynasty ...

I am suggesting it because her DH now feels guilty and argues with her. The OP clearly said this is not something she wants to do but she is not the only parent to the child. DC has two parents and his father now does feel something needs to be done.
OP is not creating dynasty but she explained her reasoning for middle name and it is about honouring family. MIL doesn't have rights but DH does and he now feels he needs to honour both sides of his family.
I am really surprised that everyone talks about MIL and nobody actually mentions that DH now thinks differently. He is not a puppet, he is a grown up man and he is entitled to change his opinion after considering the situation.

Pompomsfantastix · 15/11/2022 12:28

STAY STRONG!!!! If she gets her own way after acting like this, it will be her MO for ever. Sounds like she’s spoilt the name for you but It’s absolutely fuck-all to do with her. My MIL still makes digs about my first child’s name. Just don’t tell her till it’s too late next time. She sounds insufferable!

GatoradeMeBitch · 15/11/2022 12:10

If you have a second child, keep the name a secret until after the birth. In my experience people are a lot more accepting when just presented with a little human being and their name.

I can see why MIL might have some hurt feelings, but ultimately what counts is that both you and your DH like the names you've chosen. If MIL wants to call him Junior for the next 30 years, that's up to her.

Sennelier1 · 15/11/2022 12:08

Don't change the name. A name is a most precious gift, your baby should know you chose it especially for him, not because his gran wanted it. .

Luredbyapomegranate · 15/11/2022 12:07

Don’t give in.

This woman needs boundaries, if you give in to this you will never have peace

KettrickenSmiled · 15/11/2022 12:07

mikulkin · 15/11/2022 11:50

Her reasoning on the first name is ridiculous and you obviously shouldn't change it.
Having said that I would go a bit against grain here and say add another middle name. I do understand all your reasoning, but given your MIL and FIL are divorced it looks like there is honouring to FIL side but not MIL one. I know that was not the intention, you explained it but to MIL it looks this way. I think that's why your DH is feeling guilty now and that's why he argues with you. He feels he honoured his dad but not his mum.

Why are you suggesting another middle name, when OP has very clearly said that this is NOT something she wants to do?

MiL has no rights to have her name "honoured".
OP isn't birthing future kings or establishing a dynasty ...

Folklore9074 · 15/11/2022 12:04

No. You give in on this and kiss goodbye to your authority over your son and family. This is one to kick off about and not meekly avoid the subject when she brings it up. Get angry. She is taking the absolute piss out of you.

Shinyandnew1 · 15/11/2022 12:03

Having read all your updates I can kind of see where she's coming from. Her grandchild has her husband's surname and a middle name from him, as well as a name from his country, so it's all about his side of the family and I can understand how she may feel pushed out.

In that case, shouldn’t it be the OP who is pushed out?!

Fenella123 · 15/11/2022 12:02

She sounds a delight!
Would it shut her up though if your baby got an additional middle name which is one of the surnames from her line - perhaps MiL's mother's maiden name? (You'd want to avoid any security-question names!!).

Pipsquiggle · 15/11/2022 12:00

TheBeesKnee · 15/11/2022 11:56

Having read all your updates I can kind of see where she's coming from. Her grandchild has her husband's surname and a middle name from him, as well as a name from his country, so it's all about his side of the family and I can understand how she may feel pushed out.

I would say don't give in on this occasion but if you're going down the sentimental middle name tradition then maybe the next child could have a MIL side of the family name tribute? Don't tell her this until the next one's here though Smile

Eh?

The baby has names that reflects both his mother's and father's families - that's lovely.

Why the hell should the MIL get a say?

TheBeesKnee · 15/11/2022 11:56

Having read all your updates I can kind of see where she's coming from. Her grandchild has her husband's surname and a middle name from him, as well as a name from his country, so it's all about his side of the family and I can understand how she may feel pushed out.

I would say don't give in on this occasion but if you're going down the sentimental middle name tradition then maybe the next child could have a MIL side of the family name tribute? Don't tell her this until the next one's here though Smile

CambsAlways · 15/11/2022 11:55

You have a MIL problem and also a husband problem, and I would be spitting feathers! Your husband is a big boy now and should be putting his wife before his mother

WinterLobelia · 15/11/2022 11:53

Do Not Be Bullied.

A family member said they did not like DS2's name and that they would instead call him by his middle name.

I laughed in his face and said he would not be doing so.

Everybody else also told him he was being a wanker.

he does not talk to me now which is a bit of a win tbh. Could not stand being stood up to.

You choose your son's name. You and DH. No-one has the right to behave in the way your MIL is behaving.

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 15/11/2022 11:50

That you are even considering this, considering how nasty MIL is and how she is manipulating your husband and brainwashing him to agree with her, shows you're being a doormat. Of COURSE you should not even consider it for a split second. Why reward her for being a nasty and manipulative bitch? That's how CFs and nasty bullies win. When people give in to them just for peace. Put your big girl pants on and tell her if she doesn't stop the bad-mouthing, the gossiping and the manipulating, she won't see her GC at all. You have the cards here to pull her into line. Use them.