Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I change my sons name to please my MIL?

459 replies

97DS · 15/11/2022 04:57

Ever since we found out baby was going to be a boy DH and I have had his name chosen. MIL has made subtle digs throughout pregnancy at how she’s not a fan of the name, and if we’ve considered anything else. I just dodge the question and ignore it because I don’t have the energy to argue with her. She can be very opinionated and very stubborn.
baby is now a week old, and not officially registered yet but we have announced his full name to friends/family/social media.
MIL has gone out of her way at every opportunity to make a comment on his name. Even after a traumatic birth which landed me in theatre with major haemorrhaging, her first text to DH was asking what baby’s name is going to be.

She’s been talking to family behind our back saying how disappointed she is, as well as pulling DH aside to privately ask if we would change the name. MIL is purposely avoiding saying his name, and has opted to calling him Jnr instead… That’s just the issue with his 1st name. Keep reading…

she also has a massive issue with his middle name too. DH has 2 middle names (X & Y) and when we chose baby’s name, we decided to use middle name Y so it followed the family tree as a tribute to the dads (Y runs quite far back in the male side of the family tree) and also, Y is my fathers middle name too so it seemed very sentimental to us all.
We’ve had a lot of compliments on his name from DH’s side of the family because we chose middle name Y. But MIL has kicked off BIG TIME. Pulling out crocodile tears and directly asking DH to change the middle name to something that tributes MIL’s family instead.
However, there’s only 2 male names to pick from if we were to consider it, and both names are awful, I genuinely don’t like them, and they don’t even go with baby boys 1st name, and would make the surname seem like a mouthful if you were to say it out loud.
My argument is, it’s not her baby so it’s not her business what his name is. She had the opportunity 30 years ago to tribute her family and that’s why DH’s middle name is X. But baby’s name isn’t meant to be a tribute to her family, it’s a tribute to DH’s family, as well as my own.

Yes we could just keep the peace and add a 2nd middle name that she wants, but I don’t want that. As his mother, I should be the one who has final say and I don’t want him to have 2 middle names, and I certainly don’t want to change his name under the pressure and influence of MIL. DH has agreed with me throughout pregnancy what his name is, but now MIL is getting into his head and playing a guilt card, DH is now having 2nd thoughts because he doesn’t like to upset MIL. I know it’s not what he wants either but his MIL is so good at minipulating everything to get her own way. She puts words into DH’s mouth and convinces him they’re his own. So now DH and I argue over this.
what’s your thoughts? AIBU to stick my guns and keep my sons name how it is, or should I reason with MIL, and change the name just to keep her happy?

OP posts:
Vonniee7 · 15/11/2022 18:21

At this point you need to stop being polite. She's had her say, you disagree so she needs to just shut up or lose contact with her lovely new grandson. Congratulations

JoJo2306 · 15/11/2022 18:16

My mil was exactly the same. We were discussing potential names as not even given birth and she was not shy about commenting!

its your baby, not hers, your decision not hers. Please choose the name you want as you may regret it.

Foodylicious · 15/11/2022 18:02

Tell her to get to the far side of F#^*

Do not give an inch here.
It will never end.

Your baby, your family unit.

AlbertaWildRose · 15/11/2022 16:46

I am on my lunch break at work and don't have time to read the whole thread, so I apologize if I am repeating what other posters have said. Please don't change your child's name to please your MIL. As you said, she had her turn, this is your child. I also believe that if you let her win with this, she will stick her nose in on everything in the future. Take this opportunity to establish your boundaries as the mother. She has no right to think she should have a claim on what you name your own child!

Quarique · 15/11/2022 16:25

I'd be registering his name asap before MIL talks your DH into something he will later regret! Grin

RoseAdagio · 15/11/2022 15:44

Also, sorry to hear that you had a difficult and traumatic birth. Hope you are recovered now and enjoying the first few weeks of parenthood, which can be a total shock to the system anyway even without all this unnecessary naming drama!

ZeilanBlueSky · 15/11/2022 15:34

MIL had her chance to name her children. Don't give into her demands, your baby's name is between you and your DH.

hesbeingabitofadick · 15/11/2022 15:28

strawberry2017 · 15/11/2022 15:15

She named her own children she doesn't get to name yours as well.

^This. again and again and again.

strawberry2017 · 15/11/2022 15:15

She named her own children she doesn't get to name yours as well.

Spellcheck · 15/11/2022 14:50

You are not being unreasonable! Stick to your guns - if you and DH like the name, then that's his name. There's so much more to be thinking about right now!
My Dbrother and DSIL gave their son a name that I and the rest of the family really dislike, but we wouldn't dream of telling them - it would be so selfish and disrespectful. Their son, their choice.
Congratulations!💐

Treaclemine · 15/11/2022 14:38

I totally agree that you should stick by your decision and tell Mil that she has no say in the matter.
But, while really involved in something else, a thought arrived and suggested that maybe what is behind in this is that she was overridden in the choice of her baby's name by her Welsh ex. Could that be behind it? It does seem a bit wild of her unless something like that lay behind it.

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 15/11/2022 14:38

Please don't change the name.

I stood my ground when MIL asked us to include FILs middle name as a middle name for DS and I'm glad I did.

She did huff a bit about us being the first in a long line to not use the name, but I pointed out that baby was getting their surname and DS is an individual and I don't think it's fair to carry about a legacy of other people.

SantaOnFanta · 15/11/2022 14:34

You name YOUR baby what YOU want and that is the end of the story.

Why are in laws so weird, MIL was going mad when baby was THREE days old because why did it not have a bank account yet????

Elliania · 15/11/2022 14:32

Keep the name - it's clearly important and of sentimental value to you and your husband.

If MIL insists on calling the baby "Jnr" then correct her. Every single time. If she still does it - well then maybe she could call him "My grandson I don't see very often." Imagine in a few years time when he's old enough to understand - how hurtful for him if he realises his Grandma hates his name and a part of his heritage. This needs to be nipped in the bud.

PissedOffAmericanWoman · 15/11/2022 14:25

If you change it to please your MI you will regret it later and quite very likely resent her trust me.

My sister kicked up a big fuss because the name we picked for our daughter rhymes with her daughters name but she's always had to have a say in absolutely every single one of my major life decisions and she loves to sabotage me. A couple years later I'm glad I didn't give in. We worked through her drama as exhausting as it was but we worked hard through that very difficult pregnancy. We take care of the baby and pay for her stuff. We chose her name we have that right!

Don't let anyone take your right to name your baby!

NoDoor · 15/11/2022 14:24

Fuck her.
Your naming and the reasons why sound lovely. She’s had her chance. I would also use family traditions from divorced parents.
of she doesn’t like the name she can not visit, easy.

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 15/11/2022 14:20

mikulkin · 15/11/2022 13:25

That is your and OP's assumption. Apparently you all know what is happening in his head

According to the OP he was happy with the names until his mum would....not......stop..... harassing...... him. Use common sense. It's not an 'assumption', it's an assumption that he would all of a sudden willingly agree to it. It is very clear to anyone with room level IQ that he is being manipulated and guilt-tripped by his mum. Room level IQ says this. It's not rocket science.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 15/11/2022 14:17

JadeSeahorse · 15/11/2022 14:11

Don't you dare change your gorgeous baby's name!

I am sat here thinking of all those fabulous Welsh male names. (I bet his name is adorable. 🥰)

Tough titty she can't bear anything Welsh any longer.🤬 Your baby, your choice!

Please get him registered urgently.

I now have a sudden compulsion to warble 'Sosban Fach' at the top of my lungs.

BadNomad · 15/11/2022 14:16

People usually pick middle names either because they like them, or to honour someone. You've decided to honour just the men in your family. It is what it is. It doesn't sound like you have a particularly good relationship with your MIL anyway, so including her in the name probably won't change anything anyway.

Personally, if it was me, and we all had the husband's surname, I think I would scrap the middle name and use my maiden name as a middle name instead. That way both families are represented.

Asking22 · 15/11/2022 14:13

Who are these people who think they get to have that much of a say on other people's lives? Don't do itOP or it will set the way for all other decisions that has fuck all to do with her.

JadeSeahorse · 15/11/2022 14:11

Don't you dare change your gorgeous baby's name!

I am sat here thinking of all those fabulous Welsh male names. (I bet his name is adorable. 🥰)

Tough titty she can't bear anything Welsh any longer.🤬 Your baby, your choice!

Please get him registered urgently.

OceanbreezeSun · 15/11/2022 14:04

Do not change it.
If she feels like she gets her own way on this - she will continue to pull stunts like this throughout your dcs life. I would point blank refuse to discuss it further with her and dh. If she senses you are giving in, she will keep chipping away. Make it clear you are not changing names and that’s it.

She sounds horrible, you have my sympathy.

AndEverWhoKnew · 15/11/2022 14:03

Baby McBabyFace does have a certain ring to it. Grin

Dreamingcats · 15/11/2022 14:01

Hell no.
If she doesn't like your names, presumably the only way to keep her happy (for now) would be to let her choose them herself.
Even if you called the baby Boaty Mcboatface it's not her baby or her decision in any way.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 15/11/2022 14:00

Dontaskdontget · 15/11/2022 13:21

Re middle name, tell her she’ll have to wait until you have a girl. Then give MIL’s first name as a middle name.

Re the child’s first name of course it is up to you, but we as a chorus of strangers can’t possibly say anything helpful about it without knowing the name. So I’ll say if it’s something like Rori, yanbu, but if it’s something like Goleuddydd then think again in the interests of the child.

OP might want to give her daughter her own mother's middle name.

Responding here to a separate post:

she is upset that the baby has Welsh name, his father's surname and the middle name from his father's side, it feels like he has chosen his dad over her given that they are divorced.

Welcome to the female world. We are constantly having a man's name chosen above our own - for some it's an informed personal choice to take a husband's name on marriage but many women do still come under pressure to conform. I know people who married some time ago, before a refusal to relinquish your own family name was the done thing, and many say they regret it and would make a different choice if they had their time over. Amazingly, some people still also think women are under a legal obligation to do so.

Parents choose the name of the baby. This isn't a process of negotiation.