Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I change my sons name to please my MIL?

459 replies

97DS · 15/11/2022 04:57

Ever since we found out baby was going to be a boy DH and I have had his name chosen. MIL has made subtle digs throughout pregnancy at how she’s not a fan of the name, and if we’ve considered anything else. I just dodge the question and ignore it because I don’t have the energy to argue with her. She can be very opinionated and very stubborn.
baby is now a week old, and not officially registered yet but we have announced his full name to friends/family/social media.
MIL has gone out of her way at every opportunity to make a comment on his name. Even after a traumatic birth which landed me in theatre with major haemorrhaging, her first text to DH was asking what baby’s name is going to be.

She’s been talking to family behind our back saying how disappointed she is, as well as pulling DH aside to privately ask if we would change the name. MIL is purposely avoiding saying his name, and has opted to calling him Jnr instead… That’s just the issue with his 1st name. Keep reading…

she also has a massive issue with his middle name too. DH has 2 middle names (X & Y) and when we chose baby’s name, we decided to use middle name Y so it followed the family tree as a tribute to the dads (Y runs quite far back in the male side of the family tree) and also, Y is my fathers middle name too so it seemed very sentimental to us all.
We’ve had a lot of compliments on his name from DH’s side of the family because we chose middle name Y. But MIL has kicked off BIG TIME. Pulling out crocodile tears and directly asking DH to change the middle name to something that tributes MIL’s family instead.
However, there’s only 2 male names to pick from if we were to consider it, and both names are awful, I genuinely don’t like them, and they don’t even go with baby boys 1st name, and would make the surname seem like a mouthful if you were to say it out loud.
My argument is, it’s not her baby so it’s not her business what his name is. She had the opportunity 30 years ago to tribute her family and that’s why DH’s middle name is X. But baby’s name isn’t meant to be a tribute to her family, it’s a tribute to DH’s family, as well as my own.

Yes we could just keep the peace and add a 2nd middle name that she wants, but I don’t want that. As his mother, I should be the one who has final say and I don’t want him to have 2 middle names, and I certainly don’t want to change his name under the pressure and influence of MIL. DH has agreed with me throughout pregnancy what his name is, but now MIL is getting into his head and playing a guilt card, DH is now having 2nd thoughts because he doesn’t like to upset MIL. I know it’s not what he wants either but his MIL is so good at minipulating everything to get her own way. She puts words into DH’s mouth and convinces him they’re his own. So now DH and I argue over this.
what’s your thoughts? AIBU to stick my guns and keep my sons name how it is, or should I reason with MIL, and change the name just to keep her happy?

OP posts:
Anomonda · 16/11/2022 19:41

I wouldn’t let her in the house until she apologised. Nothing like a MIL to ruin the most life changing / important / emotional first memories with your baby. She basically has no respect for you or your DH. I’d tell her to get to f* and wouldn’t lose sleep over it.

Patricia333 · 16/11/2022 19:40

Coming in late to the debate but, OP, please please stick to your guns.

My DD will be 40 next month. DH and I chose names A and B. The “announcement” in 1982 was by card and newspaper. One week later, MIL nabs DH to say she doesn’t like “B” - it was her MIL’s name and she doesn’t want it for her DGD even though she’d given it to her own daughter. “B” is a name I have always liked and is in both our families. But MIL claimed her MIL was an awful women. DD not yet registered so time to change our minds. After prolonged discussion, my DH suggested a variation of “B” and I gave in. Regret it to this day.

You like it - that is all that matters.

dlizi4 · 16/11/2022 19:29

97DS · 15/11/2022 04:57

Ever since we found out baby was going to be a boy DH and I have had his name chosen. MIL has made subtle digs throughout pregnancy at how she’s not a fan of the name, and if we’ve considered anything else. I just dodge the question and ignore it because I don’t have the energy to argue with her. She can be very opinionated and very stubborn.
baby is now a week old, and not officially registered yet but we have announced his full name to friends/family/social media.
MIL has gone out of her way at every opportunity to make a comment on his name. Even after a traumatic birth which landed me in theatre with major haemorrhaging, her first text to DH was asking what baby’s name is going to be.

She’s been talking to family behind our back saying how disappointed she is, as well as pulling DH aside to privately ask if we would change the name. MIL is purposely avoiding saying his name, and has opted to calling him Jnr instead… That’s just the issue with his 1st name. Keep reading…

she also has a massive issue with his middle name too. DH has 2 middle names (X & Y) and when we chose baby’s name, we decided to use middle name Y so it followed the family tree as a tribute to the dads (Y runs quite far back in the male side of the family tree) and also, Y is my fathers middle name too so it seemed very sentimental to us all.
We’ve had a lot of compliments on his name from DH’s side of the family because we chose middle name Y. But MIL has kicked off BIG TIME. Pulling out crocodile tears and directly asking DH to change the middle name to something that tributes MIL’s family instead.
However, there’s only 2 male names to pick from if we were to consider it, and both names are awful, I genuinely don’t like them, and they don’t even go with baby boys 1st name, and would make the surname seem like a mouthful if you were to say it out loud.
My argument is, it’s not her baby so it’s not her business what his name is. She had the opportunity 30 years ago to tribute her family and that’s why DH’s middle name is X. But baby’s name isn’t meant to be a tribute to her family, it’s a tribute to DH’s family, as well as my own.

Yes we could just keep the peace and add a 2nd middle name that she wants, but I don’t want that. As his mother, I should be the one who has final say and I don’t want him to have 2 middle names, and I certainly don’t want to change his name under the pressure and influence of MIL. DH has agreed with me throughout pregnancy what his name is, but now MIL is getting into his head and playing a guilt card, DH is now having 2nd thoughts because he doesn’t like to upset MIL. I know it’s not what he wants either but his MIL is so good at minipulating everything to get her own way. She puts words into DH’s mouth and convinces him they’re his own. So now DH and I argue over this.
what’s your thoughts? AIBU to stick my guns and keep my sons name how it is, or should I reason with MIL, and change the name just to keep her happy?

IMO, It is you and DH's child, nobody else's opinion matters. People who love you both and the child should be accepting of your decisions and if you both love the name then THAT is the name! For me, a gazillion names were thrown around ( mostly to piss off my mum lol) she liked none of them - evil laugh - I swear for a month i daily gave a flower name, she hated all (so did i and i knew it ws a boy, she did not lol) Then I started on continents and random names . On the day he was born, she exclaimed OMG! I was liking the name India for a girl. 🙄
Sometimes you can not do right for doing wrong - in others eyes - but it's not their life or child, it is yours and they are extremely lucky to be part of that I say
and wish you and yours every best wish and hope those lucky peeps take part!

Mummyofmaniacs · 16/11/2022 19:27

Congratulations on the birth of your lovely son 🎈
Commiserations on having an evil MIL 👿
Go NOW and register your baby's name! (before you or DH get beaten down)
Enjoy him

alexdgr8 · 16/11/2022 19:21

custardbear · Yesterday 05:07

Put words back into your DH's mouth 'we've already chosen his name and that's the end of it.
----------
yes. OP, you and your husband rehearse saying this phrase, both of you, and nothing else, whenever she alludes to the matter.

thetis · 16/11/2022 19:19

You are being unreasonable to post this. No one in their right mind would consider changing their child's name in these circumstances

Annierob · 16/11/2022 19:18

Your baby, you choose the name.

mags2024 · 16/11/2022 19:12

Absolutely not. l cannot say l was wild about my grand daughters name, probably more surprised as l had always just thought they were choose a more classic name. However l would rather cut my tongue out than upset my relationship with my dil. l also fear if you give in there may be other issues she may want to influence.

Enko · 16/11/2022 19:11

Nope. Don't give in stick to your choice.

When ds was born and we announced his name my mother replied "That's HORRIBLE" FFW 11 years and she told me "I always liked the name Conrad it's such a good strong name".... it had become her grandson whom she loved.

Mil will get over it.

balalake · 16/11/2022 19:07

I think your DH should make it clear that any more objections will mean reduced or no contact with her grandson.

Vikinga · 16/11/2022 19:06

It sounded bonkers but it is probably to do with her divorcing her Welsh husband and your child has a Welsh name (he's Welsh), same middle name and same surname. I'd probably be a bit pissed off too but wouldn't say anything.

Mandyjack · 16/11/2022 19:06

97DS · 15/11/2022 05:10

She’s just not a fan of the spelling, or pronunciation. It’s a Welsh name, because DH is Welsh, but she’s not Welsh and since divorcing DH’s Welsh father may years ago she has taken a dislike to anything that associates, including a Welsh name.

That explains why she's not happy about the name if it reminds her of her ex

Mandyjack · 16/11/2022 19:05

What a nasty controlling cow!
My daughter is having a baby and no way would I expect her to choose a name we like it's completely up to her and her DH. They are using my late MILs name as a middle name which I think is lovely as she was close to her Nan.

ThistleTits · 16/11/2022 19:03

@97DS
Don't you dare change your child's name because and adult is having a hissy fit. Oh and nip that junior rubbish in the bud too.
She doesn't get to have any input into picking names.

Madamum18 · 16/11/2022 19:00

I think you and DH need to speak to her openly, tell her that it is obvious that she is not keen on the names that you have chosen but both of you are and that is what your son is called. Tell her to please accept it and stop commenting both to you and others. Then don't get into further discussion, just keep repeating the point.

Also I suspect there will be further problems for you with her "not liking" how you are looking after him etc etc ...you and DH need to be ready to step in quickly, tell her to back off and that much as you want her to enjoy her grandson you will both not put up with criticism of what you are doing. Tell her that you will be grateful for her advice and experience if and when you ask for it.

DGay · 16/11/2022 19:00

DGay · 16/11/2022 18:33

Tell hubby to put on his big biy pants and tell his mom NO! We will not change OUR baby's name, PERIOD!

Big boy pants

Crackof · 16/11/2022 18:59

My mother made my sister change her newborn baby's name back in the day. Massive temper tantrum. She's an absolute nightmare and we've been NC for years. I'm shuddering thinking about her.

Penguinsaregreat · 16/11/2022 18:55

Oh wow. She had her chance to call her child what she wanted. Now it’s your choice and make sure it is your choice. You gave birth to your son. Don’t back down be very firm.

Zeborah · 16/11/2022 18:54

Your MIL is a bully. Please do not give into her. Your baby your choice .

Missingpop · 16/11/2022 18:51

Your son your choice; tell mother in law to go fly her broomstick; god why do these women feel the need to interfere; to play the emotional card is so low; I’d be honest with your Dh & say we chose his name months ago we’ve loved it for months & im not willing to change it she’s just going to have to suck it up & if I’m being honest I don’t actually like the name X so even if we have a second son in years to come I won’t want to use it then either !!!!

Annatinks · 16/11/2022 18:49

My parents in law have a foreign (their home country) surname that is as common as Smith there. DH offered to change his surname to mine for several reasons (it felt “exotic” to him, I already had a daughter and we planned more children so it meant all my kids have the same family name and my family name was due to “die out” as no sons so he wanted to offer that to my parents) we sought my in laws permission which they readily granted (like enthusiastically thinking it was a good thing to have an English name) then BAM we had our first baby and suddenly they’re furious with us because baby has my surname. They come from a EU country where parents don’t change names upon marriage and kids take father’s surname with mothers as an optional prior barrel segment.
My MiL reluctantly accepted it, my FiL spent the first few weeks of sons life calling him Smith instead of his first name. It hugely pissed me off but gradually reduced and now he uses baby’s Christian name fine with just the odd dig here and there about surname.

Stand by your guns - this is YOUR baby!

NeedAChangeAsIAmSoooOuting · 16/11/2022 18:45

Yanbu it doesn't even need saying of course you get to pick your own child's name. Tell her to f off.

SofaLola33 · 16/11/2022 18:44

I would be getting DH to have a conversation with her to tell her how out of line she is, that she has no say and you both do not appreciate her attitude and criticism! Her focus should be on the excitement of being a grandmother and not her selfish bitterness x

Iloveacurry · 16/11/2022 18:40

Your baby, your choice of names. She had her choice when she had kids. Nothing to do with her.

Daisybridge · 16/11/2022 18:38

Your baby your choice.