Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I change my sons name to please my MIL?

459 replies

97DS · 15/11/2022 04:57

Ever since we found out baby was going to be a boy DH and I have had his name chosen. MIL has made subtle digs throughout pregnancy at how she’s not a fan of the name, and if we’ve considered anything else. I just dodge the question and ignore it because I don’t have the energy to argue with her. She can be very opinionated and very stubborn.
baby is now a week old, and not officially registered yet but we have announced his full name to friends/family/social media.
MIL has gone out of her way at every opportunity to make a comment on his name. Even after a traumatic birth which landed me in theatre with major haemorrhaging, her first text to DH was asking what baby’s name is going to be.

She’s been talking to family behind our back saying how disappointed she is, as well as pulling DH aside to privately ask if we would change the name. MIL is purposely avoiding saying his name, and has opted to calling him Jnr instead… That’s just the issue with his 1st name. Keep reading…

she also has a massive issue with his middle name too. DH has 2 middle names (X & Y) and when we chose baby’s name, we decided to use middle name Y so it followed the family tree as a tribute to the dads (Y runs quite far back in the male side of the family tree) and also, Y is my fathers middle name too so it seemed very sentimental to us all.
We’ve had a lot of compliments on his name from DH’s side of the family because we chose middle name Y. But MIL has kicked off BIG TIME. Pulling out crocodile tears and directly asking DH to change the middle name to something that tributes MIL’s family instead.
However, there’s only 2 male names to pick from if we were to consider it, and both names are awful, I genuinely don’t like them, and they don’t even go with baby boys 1st name, and would make the surname seem like a mouthful if you were to say it out loud.
My argument is, it’s not her baby so it’s not her business what his name is. She had the opportunity 30 years ago to tribute her family and that’s why DH’s middle name is X. But baby’s name isn’t meant to be a tribute to her family, it’s a tribute to DH’s family, as well as my own.

Yes we could just keep the peace and add a 2nd middle name that she wants, but I don’t want that. As his mother, I should be the one who has final say and I don’t want him to have 2 middle names, and I certainly don’t want to change his name under the pressure and influence of MIL. DH has agreed with me throughout pregnancy what his name is, but now MIL is getting into his head and playing a guilt card, DH is now having 2nd thoughts because he doesn’t like to upset MIL. I know it’s not what he wants either but his MIL is so good at minipulating everything to get her own way. She puts words into DH’s mouth and convinces him they’re his own. So now DH and I argue over this.
what’s your thoughts? AIBU to stick my guns and keep my sons name how it is, or should I reason with MIL, and change the name just to keep her happy?

OP posts:
Moveoverdarlin · 15/11/2022 09:41

I would say to DH ‘I carried him, I pushed him out, I haemorrhaged, I have final say, I have included YOUR family names. I can’t incorporate the names of FOUR grandparents’s ancestors NEITHER you or I have ever met. That’s it. The end. Sorry you’re Mum is upset, but she’s ruining this time for us. I like the name, you like the name and so does everyone else.’

TheFeistyFeminist · 15/11/2022 09:40

OP, stand your ground. This sets the standard for how she will try to be around this baby. If you budge here, she'll push at every decision.

You and DH agree on the name for the child, register the child, and brook no further discussions.

Correct her every time she calls him something other than his name. In a few short years, he'll be able to do that for himself if he needs to but for now, set the pattern. Limit contact if needs be, until she realises how serious you are.

Congratulations on the birth of your son. Hunker down and enjoy this very special time together.

larkstar · 15/11/2022 09:37

This sounds like a slippery slope. What else does she think she's entitled to an opinion on?

bigfamilygrowingupfast · 15/11/2022 09:37

Tell MIL to bog off!

Smartstuffed · 15/11/2022 09:36

You know the answer to this is NO. Do not budge on your son's name. He is your and your husband's son. If you give way I think you'll be seeing more of this interference on other matters in the future. Thin end of the wedge and all that.

It sounds hellish so if she persists just call her 'Val' - short for Valkyrie - each time she mentions it or calls your son 'Junior'. You may be called out for being childish but your response is that she's not being mature herself about your right and your choice.

LadyMarmaladeAtkins · 15/11/2022 09:35

No!!

Stick to your guns and use this as an opportunity to make it very clear, very early, that it's your baby and she can butt out unless specifically invited to be physically present or give an opinion.

97DS · 15/11/2022 09:34

At 4am my brain didn’t work so I don’t think it came across how I wanted.
Basically the 2 male names from MIL side of the family are both men who are deceased, who DH never met/too young to remember, or ever heard of before until now.
MIL had close relationships with these people, but they are not DH’s family (he doesn’t know who they are) I was implying they were MIL’s family because DH has never met or heard of them. So why name a baby after someone in MIL’s family that we have no association with. whereas when I refer to DH’s family, it’s directly family who he grew up with, had a close bond with and who’s death was very difficult to deal with, heartbreaking

OP posts:
coconutpie · 15/11/2022 09:28

As a few have already mentioned upthread, this is a hill to die on. Do not change the name. And do not entertain this crap from MIL - say to her that the name is this and you will not be discussing it any further with her so it is not to be mentioned again. You need to put up major boundaries against this woman as I suspect this is not the only thing she will have an issue with.

Pleasecreateausername13 · 15/11/2022 09:27

My dad called my nephew junior for the first 6 months as he didn’t like his name. Years later it’s all a distant memory and he now calls nephew by his name.

Call your baby whatever you want, she’ll get used to it.

97DS · 15/11/2022 09:26

Your point makes sense however for us the middle name was more sentimental than the surname. They all have the same surname by default because like you said it’s the dads last name given usually, but us having full control over the middle name and deciding to use it was very meaningful to DH’s family, whereas the surname itself is not meaningful it was expected

OP posts:
Itloggedmeoutagain · 15/11/2022 09:25

You don't want to change it
That's all that matters

Blueeyedgirl21 · 15/11/2022 09:25

The fact that she lives in wales… WTAF 🤣🤣🤣

MrsMattMurdock · 15/11/2022 09:23

She can fuck off

BellePeppa · 15/11/2022 09:23

Even if I preferred her choice over yours I’d still say don’t do it. It’s not her call to name your baby!

AlwaysFoldingWashing · 15/11/2022 09:22

@Chooksnroses you sound like a lovely MiL, wish there were more of you lol

3ShotsOfEspresso · 15/11/2022 09:21

Sorry - yaNbu. MN really needs an edit button.

97DS · 15/11/2022 09:21

We live in wales already, and funnily enough, SO DOES SHE 😂 can’t hate the Welsh that much if you still leave here

OP posts:
3ShotsOfEspresso · 15/11/2022 09:20

YABU.

Equally, for balance, no-one really gives a sh*t about middle names. Excepts MILS.

Iamclearlyamug · 15/11/2022 09:19

Rtmhwales · 15/11/2022 05:38

Tell MIL you've never really cared for her name and ask her to change it and then you'll consider it for DS. Preferably both her first name and middle name.

Oh please do this 😅😅

crossstitchingnana · 15/11/2022 09:19

My dm didn't like our name and mil wanted a family middle name. We carried on with our choices.

If you can't have autonomy as a new parent, when can you? They've had their time.

I cannot imagine dictating to my kids like this. Only if they wanted a name like Knob would I have an opinion.

Chooksnroses · 15/11/2022 09:18

I'm a Grandmother and Great Grandmother and have 14 Grandchildren and 3 Great Grandchildren. When those children were named I wasn't always very keen initially. But then it wasn't my place to give an opinion. I'd had my chance to name babies when mine were born. Now I love every name, because I associate each one with a much loved child or young person.
Your Mother in Law doesn't have the right to insist you change your child's name. She should have swallowed her disappointment, and said, as I always did, "What a lovely name".

97DS · 15/11/2022 09:18

I don’t think I worded it right but what I meant by DH’s family was implying him- he is the direct family link for the Y name because it’s his middle name firstly.
The Y name came from a longer line before him, and was his grandads name. He had a very close relationship with grandad before he passed.
There’s only 2 male names on MIL side of the family. Both deceased before DH Was born/old enough to know them, and both of these people DH had never met or heard much of. It’s MIL who had the relationship with these people, so I don’t see why we should consider adding or changing the name to honour someone that doesn’t mean anything to us/DH.

OP posts:
hesbeingabitofadick · 15/11/2022 09:16

If your DH is wavering...show him the thread.
There's a fairly decent 98% of us that would show his Mum the door and possibly kick her arse for good measure on the way out Xmas Smile

1001Daffodils · 15/11/2022 09:15

There is absolutely no way I'd be backing down and if she continues with the "junior" shit I'd also be making it clear that if she didn't cut it out her access to the baby would be severely limited.

You neither need nor want a bullying influence in your child's life. She needs to be behave, and rapidly. Your husband also needs to decide whether being married to you is more important than treading on eggshells around his xenophobic mother.

Frankly even if you've called your son Caernarfon I'd be backing you all the way reasonably certain you won't have done this

Mlb123 · 15/11/2022 09:13

97DS · 15/11/2022 04:57

Ever since we found out baby was going to be a boy DH and I have had his name chosen. MIL has made subtle digs throughout pregnancy at how she’s not a fan of the name, and if we’ve considered anything else. I just dodge the question and ignore it because I don’t have the energy to argue with her. She can be very opinionated and very stubborn.
baby is now a week old, and not officially registered yet but we have announced his full name to friends/family/social media.
MIL has gone out of her way at every opportunity to make a comment on his name. Even after a traumatic birth which landed me in theatre with major haemorrhaging, her first text to DH was asking what baby’s name is going to be.

She’s been talking to family behind our back saying how disappointed she is, as well as pulling DH aside to privately ask if we would change the name. MIL is purposely avoiding saying his name, and has opted to calling him Jnr instead… That’s just the issue with his 1st name. Keep reading…

she also has a massive issue with his middle name too. DH has 2 middle names (X & Y) and when we chose baby’s name, we decided to use middle name Y so it followed the family tree as a tribute to the dads (Y runs quite far back in the male side of the family tree) and also, Y is my fathers middle name too so it seemed very sentimental to us all.
We’ve had a lot of compliments on his name from DH’s side of the family because we chose middle name Y. But MIL has kicked off BIG TIME. Pulling out crocodile tears and directly asking DH to change the middle name to something that tributes MIL’s family instead.
However, there’s only 2 male names to pick from if we were to consider it, and both names are awful, I genuinely don’t like them, and they don’t even go with baby boys 1st name, and would make the surname seem like a mouthful if you were to say it out loud.
My argument is, it’s not her baby so it’s not her business what his name is. She had the opportunity 30 years ago to tribute her family and that’s why DH’s middle name is X. But baby’s name isn’t meant to be a tribute to her family, it’s a tribute to DH’s family, as well as my own.

Yes we could just keep the peace and add a 2nd middle name that she wants, but I don’t want that. As his mother, I should be the one who has final say and I don’t want him to have 2 middle names, and I certainly don’t want to change his name under the pressure and influence of MIL. DH has agreed with me throughout pregnancy what his name is, but now MIL is getting into his head and playing a guilt card, DH is now having 2nd thoughts because he doesn’t like to upset MIL. I know it’s not what he wants either but his MIL is so good at minipulating everything to get her own way. She puts words into DH’s mouth and convinces him they’re his own. So now DH and I argue over this.
what’s your thoughts? AIBU to stick my guns and keep my sons name how it is, or should I reason with MIL, and change the name just to keep her happy?

I can't believe the manipulative , selfish , drama queen fool is crying over a middle name that is honouring both her own son (so her family anyway!) and your family and trying to get your husband to feel guilty when you had a traumatic birth and its lucky you and your son are now safe and well because it very easily could have been very different. You are completely in the right and if you gave in then she would likely try it on with other things in the future. I'm sorry you have had this shit to put up with on top of everything else , but use it to remain strong in the future when she's acting up again xxx