Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask views on the 5-year-old cycling and Sajid Javid video?

282 replies

allswellthatends · 15/11/2022 03:03

Maybe this has been debated to death already because the story came out Nov 11 but it's not showing up on search here. A dad's helmet camera catches a driver passing his 5yo by what he felt was too close, and Sajid Javid and Jeremy Vine got into a disagreement about what the driver should have done.

I live in London and I think (hope) I'm very good with cyclists if only because I'm not usually in a rush. Also I cycle, and my children cycle more. And I'm used to the countryside rule of not coming too close to horse riders . In this particular case, a small child, I would have stopped completely or slowed to a crawl.

Still, London roads are very narrow, traffic is generally quite slow-moving anyway, and so observing a 1.5m distance isn't always practical. It seemed to me that it also makes a difference if the driver is coming towards the cyclist (who can therefore see the car) or from behind (which as a cyclist I find much more unnerving). The type of cyclist in general: 20-35 year-old racing steadily, I'm less worried than with a shaky-ish person on a heavy rental bike; I'll stop for a cyclist panting uphill. I totally get why my fellow-cyclists don't always stop for red lights: sometimes it's safer to go first while the cars are forced to stop, and also it's bad to lose your momentum and your balance. Then again I LOATHE those cargo bikes where parents move very slowly in a vehicle that blocks the full road, with precious cargo, but commonly at school/work rush hour. And cyclists who don't wear reflective gear and lights at night are idiots IMHO. (Actually so are pedestrians. Don't you folks realise that even to the most careful driver you're basically invisible?)

I kind of want to hear some thoughtful real-world practices from my fellow drivers and cyclists and parents.

OP posts:
Mardyface · 15/11/2022 11:09

You are subjecting your precious tiny children to all of the above, and more, every single second you are all on a busy road. This is true if you are driving a car or walking down the street too.

Towcester · 15/11/2022 11:09

NeverDropYourMooncup · 15/11/2022 07:27

Because somebody invented the internal combustion engine, the industrial revolution happened and throughout this, the fundamental laws of physics and biology never changed?

3000 years ago, a dad like this would have been bitching about why snakes were allowed to exist and how unfair it was that one nearly bit his five year old when he took it to play in a fucking snake pit.

So what, just because something is invented doesn't mean we have to let it dictate our future if it is not the best solution. The government need to have the balls to make radical changes. Local councils are doing half arsed schemes which are not joined up and sometimes dangerously inadequate.

fernfen · 15/11/2022 10:55

A 5 year old on a bike in the middle of the road is bloody idiotic. Some wagon/lorry drivers struggle to see full size adults and even cars, a 5 year old is bloody tiny and easy to miss if any one has a lapse of concentration.

Watching the video the kid also wobbles towards the other side before the car comes. The father is a prick end of, it might be legal for a 5 year old to ride on roads but its also legal to jump of a bloody cliff.

Venetiaparties · 15/11/2022 10:52

Damnautocorrect · 15/11/2022 10:27

I hate them and do give them much more space as a result of seeing just how vulnerable they are.

same as kids crossing roads I give way a lot and expect them to get it wrong. More so at the start of the school year with the year 7’s, it takes a skill to read the roads

Obviously most people would be careful, but many are not!

Some drivers are on mobile phones, fiddling with the radio, day dreaming, angry drivers, talking on loud speaker, sorting out kids fighting out in the back, arguing, lost, feeling exhausted, drained, not able to concentrate, music is too loud, old and frail, poor eye sight, distracted by too much rain, lights, other drivers, lack of experience if new driver, boy racers, poor judgement, on the way to hospital, in labour, driving for too many hours - to name just a few.

This is all normal on the roads and behaviour I see most days

You are subjecting your precious tiny children to all of the above, and more, every single second you are all on a busy road.

FixTheBone · 15/11/2022 10:51

Devoutspoken · 15/11/2022 08:29

Fixthebone, it's not about trying to overtake vehicles, it's about the cyclist getting to a safer space

undertaking to sit alongside a car that might turn left, and may not even be aware of the cyclist, or not give enough space in order to avoid a car turning right, is a more dangerous space in my opinion.

The safest space in traffic stopped at lights is to move slightly toward the middle of the road, behind the queue of traffic so the car infront of you has clear sight of you in their rear view, and the car behind isn't tempted to overtake as you set off because you aren't tight into the kerb.

Once I started doing this, I felt hugely more visible and hence safe, it also avoids the ire of the diskhead drivers who'll deliberately pass as close as possible to make some kind of point / revenge for the cylcist seemingly making quicker progress - and I know it shouldn't be the way of things, but, there's no point winning the argument if you're dead.

CapMarvel · 15/11/2022 10:48

OneTC · 15/11/2022 10:06

Wether you agree with the father or not the child was in the road and the driver chose to drive badly around them.

That's it, the long and the short. You don't risk someone's life with your own manoeuvre because you think they're doing something stupid

This, with bells on.

The age of the kid is completely irrelevant. He was cycling competently irrespective of his age.

The driver was the one who broke the rules of the road.

FixTheBone · 15/11/2022 10:43

Bingbangbongbash · 15/11/2022 07:58

@FixTheBone

I’m always going to overtake stationary vehicles because otherwise I have to sit behind their exhaust pipes. Why should I have to breathe foul air to make your life easier?

That's fair enough, but don't complain when they overtake you whilst passing through a junction when it was completely avoidable.

I cycled to and from work through the centre of Liverpool for ten years. Never did the undertaking at lights thing, never bothered by exhausts. I used to settle into the traffic just behind the stopped cars, moving slightly out from the kerb, to discourage people from overtaking until I was back up to speed, and so I wasn't inadvertently in the blind spot of someone turning left because I'd pulled alongside them.

Before electric vehicles, I probably had better acceleration over 10-15m on a bike than most cars from a stand still, so never held anyone up, and never had anyone trying dangerous overtakes close to me across a junction because they were also avoiding someone turning right.

Lunar270 · 15/11/2022 10:39

Damnautocorrect · 15/11/2022 10:14

The PP above mentioned having an mx5 and people completely missing it.
i 100% agree this is part of the problem, I’ve got a small car and people create extra lanes around it because they can “squeeze” through. It gets missed at round abouts because it’s small. You have to drive defensively as a result. If it happens to a four seater car, it will happen to cyclists etc worse.

I wonder if the car driver even saw the small child or just thought “I can squeeze through”. The child would be lower than a lot of SUV rear screens and completely out of view for a lot of them. multi lane round abouts / junctions where the car on the right lane creep forward blocking your view is an absolute pain in smaller lower cars.
Car manufacturers used to be regulated as to bumper heights etc, it caused design constraints but certainly seems sensible.

as for the EV push and exhaust fumes. Have you seen the machinery involved in mining the battery metals?!

I agree about the small car thing and my approach to driving has definitely changed over the years as more SUV's have hit the roads. I have to drive way more defensively nowadays as it seems that SUV drivers are only looking for other SUV drivers!

Personally I think a lot of drivers think they can squeeze through or they assess slower road users and force themselves in front to avoid being held up. Safety sadly takes second place over personal gain.

I'm with you 100% with your post except the EV battery thing sadly. EV's push exhaust fumes away from cities where they kill thousands every year. Outside of schools where parents idle their cars to keep warm etc. Yes battery mining is probably not pleasant but compared to what? Oil extraction and transportation? It's probably on par or better so why raise that when no-one bats an eyelid with fossil fuel? Plus battery mining has gone on for years to power personal electronic devices, where usage is far more widespread. Yet EV's get the bad rep, which is totally disproportionate/unreasonable.

Mardyface · 15/11/2022 10:29

I do think that it whether or not the law is in your favour, if you're driving a car you stay as far away as you can from a five year old riding a bike. And honestly if you are a driver and you think you wouldn't have seen the kid on the bike in that video you need to stop driving.

FruitToast · 15/11/2022 10:28

They are both 'wrong'. The car driver clearly took action just the wrong action. The father should not be letting a 5 year old cycle on the road. 5 year olds don't have the skills to safely judge risk, anticipate what a driver may or may not do and take the correct evasive action if necessary. It's advised children can't cross a road safely until 8 years old (at a minimum). If they don't have the skills to cross a road they definitely shouldn't be cycling on one!!

Damnautocorrect · 15/11/2022 10:27

Venetiaparties · 15/11/2022 10:25

I can not stand the type of parents that use the cargo bikes with tiny children barely strapped in, no helmets in flimsy carts on main roads with cars speeding by at 40mph and they still do it! Because they believe they are entitled to use the road regardless, like making a point on the back of their child's safety.

It is absolutely lethal, more so in the winter, in rush hour traffic is chaotic and dangerous and no drivers won't always notice until it is far too late.

Then they get angry - but the roads are what they are, and the danger is what it is, if you want to subject tiny kids to the exhaust fumes, the danger and the risk of huge metal machines going at breakneck speed - so be it, but it is YOUR risk and YOUR child at stake.

I hate them and do give them much more space as a result of seeing just how vulnerable they are.

same as kids crossing roads I give way a lot and expect them to get it wrong. More so at the start of the school year with the year 7’s, it takes a skill to read the roads

Venetiaparties · 15/11/2022 10:25

I can not stand the type of parents that use the cargo bikes with tiny children barely strapped in, no helmets in flimsy carts on main roads with cars speeding by at 40mph and they still do it! Because they believe they are entitled to use the road regardless, like making a point on the back of their child's safety.

It is absolutely lethal, more so in the winter, in rush hour traffic is chaotic and dangerous and no drivers won't always notice until it is far too late.

Then they get angry - but the roads are what they are, and the danger is what it is, if you want to subject tiny kids to the exhaust fumes, the danger and the risk of huge metal machines going at breakneck speed - so be it, but it is YOUR risk and YOUR child at stake.

Damnautocorrect · 15/11/2022 10:24

I’ve just gone back and watched the video again. The driver would have seen the child even in the shit weather. However they had BOTH committed to overtake the parked cars at roughly the same time, and due to the double parking the cyclist would have priority under the new Highway Code rules. However in practice in this instance I think they both expected the other to give way and both could have driven / ridden more defensively and could easily have been resolved by one backing off slightly to get to the gap.

the child would still be hidden by some SUVs and vans though. Certainly with the high windows of them. Although children should be safe cycling on the roads, I wouldn’t risk it.

OneTC · 15/11/2022 10:21

Is anyone really suggesting that driver can't see below waist height at the distance shown in the video? So you think they've got no idea what's right in front of them?

Yeah sounds likely

Herejustforthisone · 15/11/2022 10:20

The driver was slow, it was dark-ish and raining, the car’s headlights were on BUT the kid doesn’t appear to have any lights on at all.

The car probably should have stopped but did appear to slow down, the kid probably shouldn’t have been on the road.

MavisChunch29 · 15/11/2022 10:19

I drive a Sharan (7 seater SPV) and until recently a Tiguan (4x4), now we have a smaller car. All really excellent visbility front, rear and all round and you'd definitely see a five year old on a bike in a bright red jacket.

OneTC · 15/11/2022 10:18

Father and child riding in accordance with the law.

Driver driving contrary to the highway code.

MN Car fanatics: bUt ThE fAtHeR.

MavisChunch29 · 15/11/2022 10:16

Do any of you drive? Do you really think you can see a 5-year old well, riding a tiny bike, over the bonnet of a car?

I wouldn't drive a car with such a big bonnet that I couldn't see a 5 year old in the road on a bike or otherwise. And in a van you usually have excellent front visibility. The "I didn't see you, mate" excuse is always inexcusable, as you ALWAYS should have seen the more vulnerable road user.

Damnautocorrect · 15/11/2022 10:14

The PP above mentioned having an mx5 and people completely missing it.
i 100% agree this is part of the problem, I’ve got a small car and people create extra lanes around it because they can “squeeze” through. It gets missed at round abouts because it’s small. You have to drive defensively as a result. If it happens to a four seater car, it will happen to cyclists etc worse.

I wonder if the car driver even saw the small child or just thought “I can squeeze through”. The child would be lower than a lot of SUV rear screens and completely out of view for a lot of them. multi lane round abouts / junctions where the car on the right lane creep forward blocking your view is an absolute pain in smaller lower cars.
Car manufacturers used to be regulated as to bumper heights etc, it caused design constraints but certainly seems sensible.

as for the EV push and exhaust fumes. Have you seen the machinery involved in mining the battery metals?!

MavisChunch29 · 15/11/2022 10:13

My view is that regardless of the age of the cyclist, vans should never be passing that close or driving impatiently. The lad looked like a good, steady, confident cyclist on the video.

PuttingDownRoots · 15/11/2022 10:10

If you can't see a kid, you shouldn't be on the road. Hzards I've seen recently... dogs cats, children... and a swan wandering around on a duel carriageway.

OneTC · 15/11/2022 10:06

Wether you agree with the father or not the child was in the road and the driver chose to drive badly around them.

That's it, the long and the short. You don't risk someone's life with your own manoeuvre because you think they're doing something stupid

OneTC · 15/11/2022 10:04

Do any of you drive? Do you really think you can see a 5-year old well, riding a tiny bike, over the bonnet of a car?

yes have I have driven for 30 years. The driver could easily see the kid and had clearly taken some kind of action but just the wrong kind of action.

The age of the child would be unknown to the driver and shouldn't inform the quality of your driving

Freedomfromguilt · 15/11/2022 10:03

The father put his child in harms way to prove a point.
A 5 year year old should not be cycling on the road whatever the law states, children do not see the dangers that an adult would spot. Although in this case the child seemed to have more sense than the father and if that was my child my DH ears would still be ringing.
The car should have waited, lots of cars should do things that they don't. If everyone drove perfectly and within the law there would be no accidents and no need for seatbeats, airbags or carseats. Drivers are human and sometimes make the wrong choices and we should understand that and do everything we can to protect ourselves and our children.

LumpOfCoalAndASatsuma · 15/11/2022 09:57

The 5-year-old child saw the danger and asked "should I pull over to the side" and his dad said no. The driver should have given way, but did slow down, probably thinking "WTF, is that a small child on a bike in the middle of the road on a bike?" It wasn't a boy racer.

Do any of you drive? Do you really think you can see a 5-year old well, riding a tiny bike, over the bonnet of a car?

Yes, drivers need to be really careful of cyclists, and a very good driver will be mindful and give way. However, it doesn't take brains to pass a test, does it?

In a lovely utopia, everyone would be riding around on bikes, with no cars, but unfortunately this is not the way of the world. What if it was a fire engine screaming down the road or an ambulance?

I actually saw a terrible accident last year involving a cyclist. It was a young woman knocked off a bike by a lorry. She died.

Yes, motorists need to be careful of cyclists, but MY GOD, that dad is irresponsible. What's next? Marbles on the motorway?

Swipe left for the next trending thread