Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask views on the 5-year-old cycling and Sajid Javid video?

282 replies

allswellthatends · 15/11/2022 03:03

Maybe this has been debated to death already because the story came out Nov 11 but it's not showing up on search here. A dad's helmet camera catches a driver passing his 5yo by what he felt was too close, and Sajid Javid and Jeremy Vine got into a disagreement about what the driver should have done.

I live in London and I think (hope) I'm very good with cyclists if only because I'm not usually in a rush. Also I cycle, and my children cycle more. And I'm used to the countryside rule of not coming too close to horse riders . In this particular case, a small child, I would have stopped completely or slowed to a crawl.

Still, London roads are very narrow, traffic is generally quite slow-moving anyway, and so observing a 1.5m distance isn't always practical. It seemed to me that it also makes a difference if the driver is coming towards the cyclist (who can therefore see the car) or from behind (which as a cyclist I find much more unnerving). The type of cyclist in general: 20-35 year-old racing steadily, I'm less worried than with a shaky-ish person on a heavy rental bike; I'll stop for a cyclist panting uphill. I totally get why my fellow-cyclists don't always stop for red lights: sometimes it's safer to go first while the cars are forced to stop, and also it's bad to lose your momentum and your balance. Then again I LOATHE those cargo bikes where parents move very slowly in a vehicle that blocks the full road, with precious cargo, but commonly at school/work rush hour. And cyclists who don't wear reflective gear and lights at night are idiots IMHO. (Actually so are pedestrians. Don't you folks realise that even to the most careful driver you're basically invisible?)

I kind of want to hear some thoughtful real-world practices from my fellow drivers and cyclists and parents.

OP posts:
CharlieCoCo · 15/11/2022 12:27

as someone who got hit by a cyclist when i was walking across the road at a green man and he cycled, fast, through a red light, resulting in me having long term, possibly permenant injuries, if you cant stop at a red light, you arent a safe enough cyclist to stop in an emergancy and therefore shouldnt be on the road.

in terms of the video, yes the driver should have given more space between his car and the child, or even stopped. but as we can see he didnt and whether the child has a right or not to be on the road, given how some people drive (or cycle), the having a 5 year old on the road isnt the safest decision.

OneTC · 15/11/2022 12:25

Where do you live though where you don't see people parking (often illegally) on pavements?

VitaminX · 15/11/2022 12:25

If you claim you've never seen a car driving across a pavement to/from a driveway you're a liar. If you claim you've never seen a car parked with 2 wheels up on the pavement in the UK (not all countries allow this, but it's endemic in the UK) you're a liar.

Here's a thread from a couple of years ago with lots of people saying they simply must park on pavements. Don't pretend this doesn't happen, it's just stupid.

www.mumsnet.com/talk/_chat/3687611-Would-you-like-a-ban-on-cars-parking-on-pavements

Venetiaparties · 15/11/2022 12:22

Damnautocorrect · 15/11/2022 12:17

It happens every day where I am. I’ve had stand up rows with lorry drivers who have done it outside my children’s primary school. I’ve hit cars and vans that think it’s appropriate to drive up the pavement at children. I’ve reported any sign written van that’s done it.

at my children’s secondary there’s parents who drive round corners on the pavement. It’s mental. Utterly mental.

The craziness of your area sounds terrifying, and to add unprotected infants and small children into the mix in flimsy carts or bikes is positively suicidal quite frankly just because they are 'entitled to use the road' is totally bat shit.

Zealots that would rather point score with random drivers instead of keeping their children safe from harm should be reported for neglect. The children are too young to agree to be put at such horrendous risk.

newnamethanks · 15/11/2022 12:21

Father's an idiot, so is the driver.

Damnautocorrect · 15/11/2022 12:17

OneTC · 15/11/2022 12:04

We never have had pavement parking, ever. Is that even a thing? And I have been driving for thirty years and have never seen a car mount the pavement, ever. The only time it really happens is in a terrorist incident.

You've never seen off road parking?

It happens every day where I am. I’ve had stand up rows with lorry drivers who have done it outside my children’s primary school. I’ve hit cars and vans that think it’s appropriate to drive up the pavement at children. I’ve reported any sign written van that’s done it.

at my children’s secondary there’s parents who drive round corners on the pavement. It’s mental. Utterly mental.

OneTC · 15/11/2022 12:15

fernfen · 15/11/2022 12:11

This never happend though.

And you understand it did happen with fatal consequences nearly 600 times in 15 years yes?

OneTC · 15/11/2022 12:14

Oh yeah the other thread where you said that supermarket shelves would be empty because of cyclists.

Good one 🤣

OneTC · 15/11/2022 12:12

fernfen · 15/11/2022 12:11

This never happend though.

What didn't?

The 600 deaths in 15 years caused by cars on the pavement?

fernfen · 15/11/2022 12:11

OneTC · 15/11/2022 12:08

Oh so you do understand that cars spend quite a lot of time, cumulatively, traversing a pedestrian space though?

This never happend though.

MeridasMum · 15/11/2022 12:10

BlueRaincoat1 · 15/11/2022 03:46

My DS is 6 and a really good cyclist. He was really good at 5. My DH cycles a lot, he is very careful and mindful of the rules of the road.

I simply cannot understand allowing a 5 year old to cycle on a road with cars. Is he legally allowed? I guess so. Should cars be really careful. Of course. Is the dad technically correct, maybe he is- whatever. But I think it's completely irresponsible. The child is 5. What if a dog jumped out, or a delivery cyclist whizzed past at speed, or there was a shit driver. Who cares if you were 'right' and your child was 'allowed' to be there. I think the dad put his child in a dangerous situation.

This, all the way!!

OneTC · 15/11/2022 12:08

Venetiaparties · 15/11/2022 12:06

Not mounted on pavements, no.

Oh so you do understand that cars spend quite a lot of time, cumulatively, traversing a pedestrian space though?

CecilyP · 15/11/2022 12:06

why do we live in a country where it’s considered normal for a 5 year old not to be able to ride on the road safely and people

Because 5 year olds are tiny and ride tiny little bikes. Nobody would object to a child that young riding on the pavement.

Venetiaparties · 15/11/2022 12:06

OneTC · 15/11/2022 12:04

We never have had pavement parking, ever. Is that even a thing? And I have been driving for thirty years and have never seen a car mount the pavement, ever. The only time it really happens is in a terrorist incident.

You've never seen off road parking?

Not mounted on pavements, no.

fernfen · 15/11/2022 12:05

Im amazed at the sheer idiocracy of people who claim its legal so its fine for 5 year olds to be cycling in the middle of the road.

Wow whoopy doo, the law says its fine so stick a tiny kid on a tiny bike on a road where huge metal boxes weighing many tons are shuttleing back wards and fowards. If you think this is fine then your not even worth conversing with, Idiots.

OneTC · 15/11/2022 12:04

We never have had pavement parking, ever. Is that even a thing? And I have been driving for thirty years and have never seen a car mount the pavement, ever. The only time it really happens is in a terrorist incident.

You've never seen off road parking?

Venetiaparties · 15/11/2022 11:59

Mardyface · 15/11/2022 11:47

Please don't call me an Ostrich @Venetiaparties , I don't like it and it's not accurate. If you don't see anyone parking on the pavement in your area you're unlucky or really unobservant. To park on the pavement you have to drive on it - and people do with full intention of entering pedestrian space. They also drive across pavements to get places. Add in the accidental pavement mounting and it is unsafe. I don't have access to the statistics between pedestrian/cyclist casualties but I doubt there's much in it.

We never have had pavement parking, ever. Is that even a thing? And I have been driving for thirty years and have never seen a car mount the pavement, ever. The only time it really happens is in a terrorist incident.

If you want to subject your child to the dangers of the road, that is a matter for you but you can not compare the safety of a child in a flimsy cart in the middle of the road surrounded by speeding cars, lorries and buses with a child secure in a heavily tested car seat in a solid modern car. The two are incomparable which is why most people do not cycle with children - particularly in rush hour traffic. It is very very unsafe.

LadyApplejack · 15/11/2022 11:57

The way I see it is if a 5 year old were to be hurt by a motorist driving badly, the driver is probably an arsehole. The father who lets a tiny child cycle on the road and relies on others' good driving is also an arsehole.

Livpool · 15/11/2022 11:54

Dallimore · 15/11/2022 09:03

I totally get why my fellow-cyclists don't always stop for red lights: sometimes it's safer to go first while the cars are forced to stop, and also it's bad to lose your momentum and your balance.

This is probably the most ridiculous statement I've ever read on here, and I've read a lot of them. My friends 18 year old niece recently died when a car smashed into her head on after swerving to avoid a cyclist who'd decided the red light didn't apply to them. But hey, as long as the cyclist is safer then that's fine isn't itHmm

Completely agree.

I walk my son to and from school. The number of cyclists that have almost crashed into me or someone else because they went through a red light is ridiculous. They need to wait

Mardyface · 15/11/2022 11:47

Please don't call me an Ostrich @Venetiaparties , I don't like it and it's not accurate. If you don't see anyone parking on the pavement in your area you're unlucky or really unobservant. To park on the pavement you have to drive on it - and people do with full intention of entering pedestrian space. They also drive across pavements to get places. Add in the accidental pavement mounting and it is unsafe. I don't have access to the statistics between pedestrian/cyclist casualties but I doubt there's much in it.

OneTC · 15/11/2022 11:40

Venetiaparties · 15/11/2022 11:14

It is nothing like it!

If your children are in a car they are doubly protected by a car seat and strong metal casing and cars are designed to withstand very powerful collisions these days.

If you are walking you are not sharing your walking space with anyone, the pavement is a safe place free of cars and bikes. It is very rare for a car to use pavements.

On a road you are at the mercy of every single car and motorbike. A completely different ballgame, don't be an ostrich. The levels of risk are stratospheric compared to a child travelling in a car seat nestled in a strong car.

Whereas in reality nearly 600 people were killed by cars driving on the pavement between 2005 and 2018

Kennykenkencat · 15/11/2022 11:32

Guavafish1 · 15/11/2022 07:27

The car driver is wrong and didn’t follow the Highway Code!

The father put his child in a dangerous position. There are so many idiots on the road .. drunks/drugs, without insurance or license etc. The most dangerous thing about driving is other drivers.

Wish the UK was more cycle freely like in Netherlands and other European cities. There are clear sections for bikes, trams, cars and pedestrians.

For that to happen we would have had to have been bombed to high heaven by the Nazis

Blame the RAF for doing there job so well we kept towns and cities standing and the fact there are many alive today who wouldn’t be if their gps/ ggps hadn’t survived such bombings that cleared the old structures

FirewomanSam · 15/11/2022 11:31

OneTC · 15/11/2022 10:06

Wether you agree with the father or not the child was in the road and the driver chose to drive badly around them.

That's it, the long and the short. You don't risk someone's life with your own manoeuvre because you think they're doing something stupid

This is really all that needs to be said.

You’re entitled to think that the father was stupid, pig-headed, a ‘prick’ and whatever else for letting his child ride in the road. You can choose not to ever let your kids do so because you don’t think it’s safe. None of that changes what actually happened or who was actually, legally and according to the Highway Code, in the wrong here: the driver.

And the argument that the driver maybe can’t see something child-height at that distance is idiotic. If they can’t see anything below that height then they also presumably can’t see traffic cones, pot holes, birds, squirrels… if you’re seriously saying you can’t see any low-level stuff over your bonnet then you urgently need to adjust your seat!

OneTC · 15/11/2022 11:23

Venetiaparties · 15/11/2022 10:25

I can not stand the type of parents that use the cargo bikes with tiny children barely strapped in, no helmets in flimsy carts on main roads with cars speeding by at 40mph and they still do it! Because they believe they are entitled to use the road regardless, like making a point on the back of their child's safety.

It is absolutely lethal, more so in the winter, in rush hour traffic is chaotic and dangerous and no drivers won't always notice until it is far too late.

Then they get angry - but the roads are what they are, and the danger is what it is, if you want to subject tiny kids to the exhaust fumes, the danger and the risk of huge metal machines going at breakneck speed - so be it, but it is YOUR risk and YOUR child at stake.

It's not a belief they're entitled to use it, it's a fact

Venetiaparties · 15/11/2022 11:14

Mardyface · 15/11/2022 11:09

You are subjecting your precious tiny children to all of the above, and more, every single second you are all on a busy road. This is true if you are driving a car or walking down the street too.

It is nothing like it!

If your children are in a car they are doubly protected by a car seat and strong metal casing and cars are designed to withstand very powerful collisions these days.

If you are walking you are not sharing your walking space with anyone, the pavement is a safe place free of cars and bikes. It is very rare for a car to use pavements.

On a road you are at the mercy of every single car and motorbike. A completely different ballgame, don't be an ostrich. The levels of risk are stratospheric compared to a child travelling in a car seat nestled in a strong car.