Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask views on the 5-year-old cycling and Sajid Javid video?

282 replies

allswellthatends · 15/11/2022 03:03

Maybe this has been debated to death already because the story came out Nov 11 but it's not showing up on search here. A dad's helmet camera catches a driver passing his 5yo by what he felt was too close, and Sajid Javid and Jeremy Vine got into a disagreement about what the driver should have done.

I live in London and I think (hope) I'm very good with cyclists if only because I'm not usually in a rush. Also I cycle, and my children cycle more. And I'm used to the countryside rule of not coming too close to horse riders . In this particular case, a small child, I would have stopped completely or slowed to a crawl.

Still, London roads are very narrow, traffic is generally quite slow-moving anyway, and so observing a 1.5m distance isn't always practical. It seemed to me that it also makes a difference if the driver is coming towards the cyclist (who can therefore see the car) or from behind (which as a cyclist I find much more unnerving). The type of cyclist in general: 20-35 year-old racing steadily, I'm less worried than with a shaky-ish person on a heavy rental bike; I'll stop for a cyclist panting uphill. I totally get why my fellow-cyclists don't always stop for red lights: sometimes it's safer to go first while the cars are forced to stop, and also it's bad to lose your momentum and your balance. Then again I LOATHE those cargo bikes where parents move very slowly in a vehicle that blocks the full road, with precious cargo, but commonly at school/work rush hour. And cyclists who don't wear reflective gear and lights at night are idiots IMHO. (Actually so are pedestrians. Don't you folks realise that even to the most careful driver you're basically invisible?)

I kind of want to hear some thoughtful real-world practices from my fellow drivers and cyclists and parents.

OP posts:
Mardyface · 15/11/2022 13:06

It is the behaviour of cars and motorists that cause the 'lethal combination'. They should change their behaviour/ we should change the structure of roads to account for this - not tell children not to go out on bikes. It's exactly like saying women shouldn't go out on their own at night.

Venetiaparties · 15/11/2022 13:06

CapMarvel · 15/11/2022 13:03

A kid strapped into a car seat is far more likely to be in accident than when I take my kids for a cycle on quiet rural roads. Like it or not that is an absolute fact.

And it's still deflecting from the issue that the behaviour that needs to change is the people in the cars, not the people on bikes.

That is your view, I don't share it, at all.
It is your life (and your child's) and your decision.

OneTC · 15/11/2022 13:06

Victim blaming and making allowances for aggressors.

Really reminds me of something else but can't put my finger on it...

SleeplessInEngland · 15/11/2022 13:05

I watched the video and don't have much of opinion about it but I find it really weird that such a high profile politican would wade in on the matter. A real "don't these people have anything more important to do?" moment.

Tillsforthrills · 15/11/2022 13:04

Parent completely wrong.

CapMarvel · 15/11/2022 13:03

A kid strapped into a car seat is far more likely to be in accident than when I take my kids for a cycle on quiet rural roads. Like it or not that is an absolute fact.

And it's still deflecting from the issue that the behaviour that needs to change is the people in the cars, not the people on bikes.

Venetiaparties · 15/11/2022 13:00

OneTC · 15/11/2022 12:45

This makes no sense.

Okay. Let me spell it out slowly for you.

You can raise people to understand the 'rules' as much as you like, it doesn't mean they actually care or will abide by them! Your child is still at massive risk with 'alternative transport' because there are so many risk factors involved with little children cycling on main roads.

If you can't see that risk, or feel it is not there I can't help you. You will most likely find out the hard way. Young children in carriers/bikes on busy roads or main roads is a lethal combination. We don't even cycle or ride here and it is very quiet, because you will always get amazon drivers or the odd teenager hacking along with no care for you and your kid.

I don't care if YOU think it is fine. Most people don't agree with you, because most people are aware of the number of knobs driving on the road that are reckless and indifferent to the fragility of your child's tiny body and bones.

OneTC · 15/11/2022 13:00

Do you honestly think any parent will give one jot about being part of an improvement programme if their child is killed?

PP didn't suggest an improvement programme, just how to ride a bike properly, a genuine life skill that will become even more relevant in years to come

Should just not train kids for proper road use?

Do you think you'd feel better if your kid gets run over because you didn't teach them?

Mardyface · 15/11/2022 13:00

Venetiaparties · 15/11/2022 12:43

😂

What an eloquent use of the 'crying with laughter' emoji.

CapMarvel · 15/11/2022 12:53

Venetiaparties · 15/11/2022 12:42

If people are bought up to understand the rules of the road from a young age and to use alternative transport that is how things improve

Do you honestly think any parent will give one jot about being part of an improvement programme if their child is killed? Or disabled for life due to a serious accident?

Fairly obviously I'm not advocating anyone take a kid out on busy roads, but on the kind of quiet street that was in the video with traffic calming measures etc? Yep. I take my kids out on roads around my village all the time and they are far better road users than a lot of adults we come across.

OneTC · 15/11/2022 12:45

Venetiaparties · 15/11/2022 12:42

If people are bought up to understand the rules of the road from a young age and to use alternative transport that is how things improve

Do you honestly think any parent will give one jot about being part of an improvement programme if their child is killed? Or disabled for life due to a serious accident?

This makes no sense.

Venetiaparties · 15/11/2022 12:43

Mardyface · 15/11/2022 12:34

It is not safe for small children to cycle on the road. It is not safe for them to walk on the pavement either. Both are unsafe because of cars not because of their own existence. The problem is the cars and the way they are driven not the children using up space in the world.

As it happens I grew up in the countryside and now live in London and have seen cars parking on and driving across the pavement lots of times in both places. So you are obviously not looking closely enough.

😂

OneTC · 15/11/2022 12:42

I personally have no problem with people riding carefully on pavements, works fine in other countries where it's allowed.

The suggestion earlier in the thread that no one would mind if this 5 year old was in the pavement was obviously posted by someone new to MN Grin

Venetiaparties · 15/11/2022 12:42

CapMarvel · 15/11/2022 12:35

Cyclists/pedestrians/horse riders etc are not safe on the roads due to the actions of motorists.

Saying "oh, they shouldn't be on the road" is just deflecting. If people are bought up to understand the rules of the road from a young age and to use alternative transport that is how things improve.

If people are bought up to understand the rules of the road from a young age and to use alternative transport that is how things improve

Do you honestly think any parent will give one jot about being part of an improvement programme if their child is killed? Or disabled for life due to a serious accident?

VitaminX · 15/11/2022 12:40

I cycle on the pavements with my children (5 and 7) and my 7 year old cycles independently on the pavements for precisely the reason that you cannot trust motorists and I feel at their age it is safer. I also use(d) the bike trailer mainly on the pavements. But we still have motorists reversing out of their drives across the pavement at us without looking.

And some people would be very cross that we do ride on the pavements. You cannot win, you can only make the choices that you personally feel are best. I personally teach my children that a lot of drivers are idiots and that while you should know the rules, you should never trust them to follow the rules. That means for example always making sure that cars are actually stopping before you go over on the green man - I cannot count the number of times I've been waiting to cross with my children and some fuckwit has blown right through the red light with their machine that would crush a child to death.

Rinatinabina · 15/11/2022 12:36

I’d be a bit worried about letting a 5yr old ride on narrow roads like that. He’s very small, seems dangerous. Reminds me a bit of DD (2) swimming teacher, she’s never used armbands because they give her false confidence. I would be worried that a small child would believe that he was actually safe on a road because he’s not.

CapMarvel · 15/11/2022 12:35

Cyclists/pedestrians/horse riders etc are not safe on the roads due to the actions of motorists.

Saying "oh, they shouldn't be on the road" is just deflecting. If people are bought up to understand the rules of the road from a young age and to use alternative transport that is how things improve.

Mardyface · 15/11/2022 12:34

It is not safe for small children to cycle on the road. It is not safe for them to walk on the pavement either. Both are unsafe because of cars not because of their own existence. The problem is the cars and the way they are driven not the children using up space in the world.

As it happens I grew up in the countryside and now live in London and have seen cars parking on and driving across the pavement lots of times in both places. So you are obviously not looking closely enough.

Venetiaparties · 15/11/2022 12:33

Mardyface · 15/11/2022 12:31

Yes I wonder where you live that nobody ever drives on the pavement for any reason @Venetiaparties . I have also been driving 30 years and see it all the time.

Also you can have a go at me for allowing my children to cycle on the road/ driving a big cargo cycle but as it happens I don't do it because it makes me too anxious. I just think that children should be entitled to ride on the road safely and it is only cars and their self-centred drivers that make it dangerous. A man teaching his child to take up deserved space on the road is the safest way to go about it.

Keep going then, it is your risk not mine.

OneTC · 15/11/2022 12:33

It was you that brought up the carless utopia of pavements 😅

Venetiaparties · 15/11/2022 12:31

We live in the country, so we don't always have pavements. The few pavements we have are never used for cars! Not to park on, or drive over or use for any reason. The nearest town has plentiful parking, and double yellow lines so people don't use them to park.

I don't know why on earth you would be so incredulous about it! Narrow thinking.

If I lived in a place that driving and parking on the pavements was a thing, I would probably ensure we kept to the inside of the pathway and ensure walking children were on the inside. The point of this thread is to talk about cycling and young children and not walking. You can start another thread about walking on pavements if you want to, but this one is about the dangers of little kids being on bikes and the danger they are in.

Some weirdos on here seem to think the children are safe. They are not.

Mardyface · 15/11/2022 12:31

Yes I wonder where you live that nobody ever drives on the pavement for any reason @Venetiaparties . I have also been driving 30 years and see it all the time.

Also you can have a go at me for allowing my children to cycle on the road/ driving a big cargo cycle but as it happens I don't do it because it makes me too anxious. I just think that children should be entitled to ride on the road safely and it is only cars and their self-centred drivers that make it dangerous. A man teaching his child to take up deserved space on the road is the safest way to go about it.

OneTC · 15/11/2022 12:30

And keep their eyes closed every time they're in a town

OneTC · 15/11/2022 12:29

I can only assume they live somewhere very rural where they don't have pavements, and never drive more than 2 miles from their house

CapMarvel · 15/11/2022 12:28

Venetiaparties · 15/11/2022 11:59

We never have had pavement parking, ever. Is that even a thing? And I have been driving for thirty years and have never seen a car mount the pavement, ever. The only time it really happens is in a terrorist incident.

If you want to subject your child to the dangers of the road, that is a matter for you but you can not compare the safety of a child in a flimsy cart in the middle of the road surrounded by speeding cars, lorries and buses with a child secure in a heavily tested car seat in a solid modern car. The two are incomparable which is why most people do not cycle with children - particularly in rush hour traffic. It is very very unsafe.

Go on google street view in just about any urban area and you'll see cars parking with 2 wheels on the pavement.

I simply do not believe you have not seen this, ever.