Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask views on the 5-year-old cycling and Sajid Javid video?

282 replies

allswellthatends · 15/11/2022 03:03

Maybe this has been debated to death already because the story came out Nov 11 but it's not showing up on search here. A dad's helmet camera catches a driver passing his 5yo by what he felt was too close, and Sajid Javid and Jeremy Vine got into a disagreement about what the driver should have done.

I live in London and I think (hope) I'm very good with cyclists if only because I'm not usually in a rush. Also I cycle, and my children cycle more. And I'm used to the countryside rule of not coming too close to horse riders . In this particular case, a small child, I would have stopped completely or slowed to a crawl.

Still, London roads are very narrow, traffic is generally quite slow-moving anyway, and so observing a 1.5m distance isn't always practical. It seemed to me that it also makes a difference if the driver is coming towards the cyclist (who can therefore see the car) or from behind (which as a cyclist I find much more unnerving). The type of cyclist in general: 20-35 year-old racing steadily, I'm less worried than with a shaky-ish person on a heavy rental bike; I'll stop for a cyclist panting uphill. I totally get why my fellow-cyclists don't always stop for red lights: sometimes it's safer to go first while the cars are forced to stop, and also it's bad to lose your momentum and your balance. Then again I LOATHE those cargo bikes where parents move very slowly in a vehicle that blocks the full road, with precious cargo, but commonly at school/work rush hour. And cyclists who don't wear reflective gear and lights at night are idiots IMHO. (Actually so are pedestrians. Don't you folks realise that even to the most careful driver you're basically invisible?)

I kind of want to hear some thoughtful real-world practices from my fellow drivers and cyclists and parents.

OP posts:
OneTC · 15/11/2022 19:53

Venetiaparties · 15/11/2022 19:00

The point is your kids may not even get the opportunity to see the climate change, they may never see the rising oceans or forest fires because you were too busy trying to save the whole world in your own mind to really deeply consider the safety of your own children.

You can't save the world - sorry to break it to you.

I recycle religiously, never buy plastic, have an electric car, we have been vegetarian for 35 years plus and we live as sustainably as possible - what difference have I made to the rising temperatures? Zilch. Why? Because it is mass industry that is causing the issue here mainly. Farming on an industrial scale. It does not matter about the blood, sweat and tears I have shed to try and look after the small part of the planet I occupy, until something is done at government level on a mass scale globally there really is literally no point.

If something terrible happens to one of your children do you really think you will care about the planet then? Do you really think you will look back and say it was all worth it because you made a point???

I mean can you answer that seriously ariel because it really matters.

You are insisting that you must make your climate point and that will be done by cycling with small children, but look at the COST you could pay. Look at the danger you are all in. Of course you can say that we are all giving up on the climate - no, we are not - there are safer, better and more efficient ways of making your feelings known rather than risking the lives of your most precious children.

I can not celebrate the fact you are doing this at all. I hope you don't choose to continue on the very dark and rain soaked mornings and afternoons? Drivers often just can not see you, even if you are flashing and lit up like a Christmas tree. The terrible weather combined with the dark conditions makes driving very difficult even with the best will in the world.

No one wants to kill or injure a cyclist, most drivers are very careful but a cyclist died near our house three weeks ago, the lilac flowers are still tied to the lamp post, it saddens me that he lost his life and now won't be here for Christmas, or ever again. Every time I walk or drive past I think of him. It shouldn't happen, but it does every day.

What is the specific risk aversion to cycling? I'm surprised you ride horses and presumably let your kids ride them? From a horse owning family and know quite a few people who've been very badly injured and one killed when out riding. In my mind it seems like the more dangerous activity, although haven't checked stats.

Conversely I know loads more people that ride bikes, mostly commuting in London and although most people I know, including myself, have been in pretty hairy accidents I only know one person who's had a life changing injury (blind) from being in a crash

Lunar270 · 15/11/2022 19:52

Bloody hell @Venetiaparties overly heavy or what.

Best get all those pedestrians off the pavement too while you're at it, just so all those cars can carry on.

CapMarvel · 15/11/2022 19:15

"Every time I walk or drive past I think of him. It shouldn't happen, but it does every day."

It doesn't though, but do you know what does...? Yes, you guessed it, severe road traffic accidents involving cars.

Statistically speaking you are at far more risk in a car than you are on a bike, but things like facts and stuff are clearly not your strong point.

Devoutspoken · 15/11/2022 19:06

If something terrible happens to one of your children in a car, are you going to change your rigid carcentric views? Something needs to change and things are changing albeit v slowly

Venetiaparties · 15/11/2022 19:00

ArialAnna · 15/11/2022 15:35

You can't change reality - nor can you hope that at some point your sacrifice is going to make the slightest bit of different to climate change when you consider the output of even singular countries like the US or China. Your effort is like a tiny drop in the ocean, and as endearing as it is to be virtual signalling your support for the climate as you strap your kids into a death trap, you may end up paying the ultimate price in doing so.

With that attitude, nothing is going to change. So your answer is we all give up and to hell with it?! Accept rising sea levels / increasing forest fires / heatwaves / flooding / increased mass immigration and social chaos with people flocking out of increasing unhabitable areas? Just because it all seems a bit hard and overwhelming to try and stop it? And geez, you say I'm the irresponsible parent?

And do you actually have any evidence cargo bikes are death traps?! Like actual statistics? Or is this based on your perception of that looks a bit dangerous, so therefore it must be? Also I find it hilarious that you say cargo bikes are too dangerous when you say you horse ride - which is one of the most risky activities you can do. I believe its statistically more dangerous than skiing and motorcycling. Look it up before you start criticising other parents choices.

The point is your kids may not even get the opportunity to see the climate change, they may never see the rising oceans or forest fires because you were too busy trying to save the whole world in your own mind to really deeply consider the safety of your own children.

You can't save the world - sorry to break it to you.

I recycle religiously, never buy plastic, have an electric car, we have been vegetarian for 35 years plus and we live as sustainably as possible - what difference have I made to the rising temperatures? Zilch. Why? Because it is mass industry that is causing the issue here mainly. Farming on an industrial scale. It does not matter about the blood, sweat and tears I have shed to try and look after the small part of the planet I occupy, until something is done at government level on a mass scale globally there really is literally no point.

If something terrible happens to one of your children do you really think you will care about the planet then? Do you really think you will look back and say it was all worth it because you made a point???

I mean can you answer that seriously ariel because it really matters.

You are insisting that you must make your climate point and that will be done by cycling with small children, but look at the COST you could pay. Look at the danger you are all in. Of course you can say that we are all giving up on the climate - no, we are not - there are safer, better and more efficient ways of making your feelings known rather than risking the lives of your most precious children.

I can not celebrate the fact you are doing this at all. I hope you don't choose to continue on the very dark and rain soaked mornings and afternoons? Drivers often just can not see you, even if you are flashing and lit up like a Christmas tree. The terrible weather combined with the dark conditions makes driving very difficult even with the best will in the world.

No one wants to kill or injure a cyclist, most drivers are very careful but a cyclist died near our house three weeks ago, the lilac flowers are still tied to the lamp post, it saddens me that he lost his life and now won't be here for Christmas, or ever again. Every time I walk or drive past I think of him. It shouldn't happen, but it does every day.

MsMelody · 15/11/2022 19:00

But even older and more street aware kids rarely cycle now because it’s so much more dangerous - far more cars, far more car journeys, bigger SUV type cars. Back in the 1990s, when I was 12, I went out on my bike on the road in the dark to do a paper round after school and it was perfectly normal. Now when I visit my parents in the same village I feel nervous on the pavements with my own kids due to the volume of massive cars speeding down the main street at 40mph (I’d estimate ten times more cars and mostly high fronted ones). It hasn’t always been this way - in the last 30 years the priority of cars has got higher and higher. It used to be normal for kids to cycle.

misssunshine4040 · 15/11/2022 18:37

@Venetiaparties I completely agree with everything you have been posting.

All this taking kids in cars is dangerous.. well yes obviously no one is disputing this but the level of risk rises enormously when you put tiny tots in cargo bikes and v small kids on the roads on bikes.
Wait till kids are older and more street aware before sending them out on the roads.

All common sense.......

Devoutspoken · 15/11/2022 16:28

It's a 'dangerous and deadly choice' to drive kids everywhere

Devoutspoken · 15/11/2022 15:59

Venetiaparties, cars are the real death trap, statistically

CapMarvel · 15/11/2022 15:44

Venetiaparties · 15/11/2022 15:08

I'm right, you're not

Did you seriously just post that!!! 😂
Are you ten years old??

Righto!
As I said, I feel (very) sorry for your kids......

Just a statement of fact.

And I don't want or need you to feel sorry for my kids. They are learning to use the road responsibly rather than being locked in a car by a misguided, ill-informed ignoramus.

ArialAnna · 15/11/2022 15:35

You can't change reality - nor can you hope that at some point your sacrifice is going to make the slightest bit of different to climate change when you consider the output of even singular countries like the US or China. Your effort is like a tiny drop in the ocean, and as endearing as it is to be virtual signalling your support for the climate as you strap your kids into a death trap, you may end up paying the ultimate price in doing so.

With that attitude, nothing is going to change. So your answer is we all give up and to hell with it?! Accept rising sea levels / increasing forest fires / heatwaves / flooding / increased mass immigration and social chaos with people flocking out of increasing unhabitable areas? Just because it all seems a bit hard and overwhelming to try and stop it? And geez, you say I'm the irresponsible parent?

And do you actually have any evidence cargo bikes are death traps?! Like actual statistics? Or is this based on your perception of that looks a bit dangerous, so therefore it must be? Also I find it hilarious that you say cargo bikes are too dangerous when you say you horse ride - which is one of the most risky activities you can do. I believe its statistically more dangerous than skiing and motorcycling. Look it up before you start criticising other parents choices.

Venetiaparties · 15/11/2022 15:32

CecilyP · 15/11/2022 15:29

Just about sums it up, math! And it’s always a dad!

What mother allows her dh to take their little child into that situation though? Over my dead body would any child of mine be in that position. What an idiot for risking his child in that way. I can't imagine his family and wife's response when they saw the footage.

CecilyP · 15/11/2022 15:29

Just about sums it up, math! And it’s always a dad!

mathanxiety · 15/11/2022 15:09

YYY to the 'snake pit' comment.

The dad is a complete tool.

Damnautocorrect · 15/11/2022 15:09

i’ll be honest. It is crazy and scary. The children have education days with lorries, the lack of visibility is scary.

You want your children to go out on their bikes, meet their mates, you want them to be able to walk to school. But frankly, it’s just not safe.

my teens cycle on the pavement, they dismount and walk round the few pedestrians they meet. We don’t have many cycle lanes, those we do have are on the pavement (which arguably is safer).

Venetiaparties · 15/11/2022 15:08

I'm right, you're not

Did you seriously just post that!!! 😂
Are you ten years old??

Righto!
As I said, I feel (very) sorry for your kids......

havemybreakfastthen · 15/11/2022 15:07

Yes, the driver could have stopped, but so could the cyclist.

I wouldn't have had my five year old riding a bike in the road.

I think the parent was wrong and put his child at risk to prove a point.

Venetiaparties · 15/11/2022 15:04

**difference to

Venetiaparties · 15/11/2022 15:04

ArialAnna · 15/11/2022 14:07

I take my kids to school in the cargo bike, albeit all along 20mph residential roads with cars parked both sides (so no cars tend to travel very fast, as they have to frequently to give way to cars coming from the other direction).

@Venetiaparties I find your assertion that I do not love my children or care for their safety, deeply offensive. It's also very clear that you do not have a clue about what you are talking about. Firstly helmets. It really depends on the style of the cargo bike as to whether helmets are appropriate or not. Some cargo bikes have high backed seats and incorporate a roll cage. In this circumstance a helmet would force the child's head into an unnatural position which might be more dangerous in the event of a collision. For open box style bikes without a roll cage, helmets are probably advisable. Secondly, air pollution - several studies have shown that you are exposed to more pollutants whilst travelling inside a car, than cycling on the road (something to do with the air flow). And if you are very worried about air pollution why are you driving short distances?! It's like people complaining about crowds during lockdown, when they are part of that crowd! 😂 Stop being part of the problem and start being part of the solution.

There's also that little mess known as 'climate change' that you and I are leaving for our kids to sort out in the future. No one is perfect on this front, and we all could do much more. But if someone is trying to make a positive change, like cycling to school instead of driving, we should be cheering them on, not knocking them down.

Why on earth would I cheer you on? It is such a dangerous and deadly choice to make for a child of any age. We do cycle alot, but not on the roads, never on the roads. We also ride horses, again never ever on the roads.

You can't change reality - nor can you hope that at some point your sacrifice is going to make the slightest bit of different to climate change when you consider the output of even singular countries like the US or China. Your effort is like a tiny drop in the ocean, and as endearing as it is to be virtual signalling your support for the climate as you strap your kids into a death trap, you may end up paying the ultimate price in doing so.

Why are you happy to take the risk with your precious children?
How can you possibly trust that people are always going to do the right thing when it comes to driving within the speed limits and safely near them?

I would love to imagine I can change the world if I cycle everywhere tomorrow, even if we ALL cycled in the UK everywhere tomorrow it would make no difference at all. They are the facts, because the biggest polluters will make no changes at all.

You would be better to feed your children a vegetarian diet, consider buying an electric car and keep the cycling for weekends only around cycle paths to make the same difference to the climate - rather than the extraordinary risk you are taking with your children's lives now.

misssunshine4040 · 15/11/2022 14:52

CapMarvel · 15/11/2022 13:03

A kid strapped into a car seat is far more likely to be in accident than when I take my kids for a cycle on quiet rural roads. Like it or not that is an absolute fact.

And it's still deflecting from the issue that the behaviour that needs to change is the people in the cars, not the people on bikes.

Perhaps, but no one is talking about quiet country roads? It's about built up busy areas

OneTC · 15/11/2022 14:41

Segregated cycle lanes are generally preferable but at this time of year they are puddles and leaves and the divider means that street sweeper machines can't clean them

garlictwist · 15/11/2022 14:39

Cajac · 15/11/2022 13:15

Near me there is a very busy road. There is a really good cycle path that cost the council a tonne to out in place. And cyclists still ignore it and cycle in the road. I don’t understand why at all? It’s such a dangerous road, yet some of them insist. Seems crazy to me.

I don’t cycle so I can’t comment on what the father should and shouldn’t have done or where the child should have been or who had right of way. But as a driver I am frightened of cyclists and motorbikes and I hate driving anywhere near them and as a result I always give loads of room, stay well back or stop for them to move.

Also I have been hit as a pedestrian by a cyclist when I was a child, it’s not acceptable for you to run red lights and not follow the Highway Code.

Not all cycle lanes are fit for purpose.

I don't cycle in the one of the cycle lanes on my way to work because it goes past five pubs and is always chock full of glass. It's safer to be on the road.

OneTC · 15/11/2022 14:34

In some other countries they let cars turn left at red lights. Mind blowing for UK drivers but weirdly they manage it without everyone dying all the time.

imo red lights should be a stop line for bikes, rather than being held at the signal you should have to stop and then proceed with caution

garlictwist · 15/11/2022 14:32

Ducksinthebath · 15/11/2022 06:58

Totally lost me at the red light point. The rules of the road apply to cyclists just as much as anyone else. If stopping would cause a loss of balance then insufficient breaking distance is being allowed for.

Seems to me cyclists want to have their cake and eat it too.

I jump the red light on my bike at certain junctions - not where there are pedestrians crossing - but sometimes it is much safer to do so. In fact, at some junctions in my city they have added new lights to say cyclists can go when it's still red for cars in recognition of this fact.

There is one big four way junction. The pedestrians cross on the green man and the cars are held on red until they've finished crossing. This is to stop cars from turning left and hitting them whilst they're crossing. But there are no pedestrians crossing if you're going straight on.

I always go straight on while the pedestrians are crossing to the left and the light is red for cars. If you wait for the lights to go green before you set off on your bike you get a big rush of cars behind you on a very narrow bit of road and you have nowhere to go unless you get a head start.

misssunshine4040 · 15/11/2022 14:26

Venetiaparties · 15/11/2022 08:30

A child so young should not be on the road, especially London roads at all. Some drivers simply do not care. So every time you take your child out on a bike or a carrier on the roads you are dicing with death. The roads are congested, the distraction is immense and there are inevitably serious accidents and death.

It is totally irresponsible to subject your child to that level of risk in the city, and even here on the country lanes drivers regular speed well over sixty.

Your call, but I would say 100% the parents responsibility and you can not simply hope and pray other road users will do the right thing. In many cases they simply won't/ have a million deliveries to do and don't have the time to be courteous/ don't notice too distracted by other things are bad drivers or simply have not noticed a young child on the road.

Death trap springs to mind.

This,

I cringe inside when I see little kids on busy city roads in these cargo bikes.
Why would you trust other road users to be safe around your most precious beings?
What if an accident happened? They would stand no chance.
I can't get my head around it