Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask views on the 5-year-old cycling and Sajid Javid video?

282 replies

allswellthatends · 15/11/2022 03:03

Maybe this has been debated to death already because the story came out Nov 11 but it's not showing up on search here. A dad's helmet camera catches a driver passing his 5yo by what he felt was too close, and Sajid Javid and Jeremy Vine got into a disagreement about what the driver should have done.

I live in London and I think (hope) I'm very good with cyclists if only because I'm not usually in a rush. Also I cycle, and my children cycle more. And I'm used to the countryside rule of not coming too close to horse riders . In this particular case, a small child, I would have stopped completely or slowed to a crawl.

Still, London roads are very narrow, traffic is generally quite slow-moving anyway, and so observing a 1.5m distance isn't always practical. It seemed to me that it also makes a difference if the driver is coming towards the cyclist (who can therefore see the car) or from behind (which as a cyclist I find much more unnerving). The type of cyclist in general: 20-35 year-old racing steadily, I'm less worried than with a shaky-ish person on a heavy rental bike; I'll stop for a cyclist panting uphill. I totally get why my fellow-cyclists don't always stop for red lights: sometimes it's safer to go first while the cars are forced to stop, and also it's bad to lose your momentum and your balance. Then again I LOATHE those cargo bikes where parents move very slowly in a vehicle that blocks the full road, with precious cargo, but commonly at school/work rush hour. And cyclists who don't wear reflective gear and lights at night are idiots IMHO. (Actually so are pedestrians. Don't you folks realise that even to the most careful driver you're basically invisible?)

I kind of want to hear some thoughtful real-world practices from my fellow drivers and cyclists and parents.

OP posts:
ArialAnna · 16/11/2022 08:54

*So after all the pages and pages of bleating you don't even allow your children to cycle on the road after all!

Classic!

Jesus what a total waste of time.*

If you read my original post, I was specifically challenging your (and the OP's) judgemental views on cargo bikes. I wasn't talking about kids road cycling themselves, though as I said earlier, I wouldn't negatively judge this. As you obviously have difficulties with reading and comprehension, there's not much point engaging with you further on this topic.

Sandinmyknickers · 16/11/2022 08:44

misssunshine4040 · 15/11/2022 23:46

Again they are not comparable are they. Neither is talking about pushing a pram across a street.
Driving you kids in cars is almost unavoidable but as the previous poster said, cars are designed to withstand collisions and car seats and offer protection. A bike and a cart do not.

Hobbies for kids young enough to fit into carts on bikes are the not what's being discussed ? 4 and 5 year olds won't be skiing down a full face ski slope nor will they be riding a pony off a lead rein until competent.

Cycling again is absolutely,... In a park, not in rush hour traffic at the age of 5.
Why is this such a problematic view ?

Driving you kids in cars is almost unavoidable

Well this is going to blow your mind, but not everyone owns cars

Sandinmyknickers · 16/11/2022 08:39

FixTheBone · 15/11/2022 10:51

undertaking to sit alongside a car that might turn left, and may not even be aware of the cyclist, or not give enough space in order to avoid a car turning right, is a more dangerous space in my opinion.

The safest space in traffic stopped at lights is to move slightly toward the middle of the road, behind the queue of traffic so the car infront of you has clear sight of you in their rear view, and the car behind isn't tempted to overtake as you set off because you aren't tight into the kerb.

Once I started doing this, I felt hugely more visible and hence safe, it also avoids the ire of the diskhead drivers who'll deliberately pass as close as possible to make some kind of point / revenge for the cylcist seemingly making quicker progress - and I know it shouldn't be the way of things, but, there's no point winning the argument if you're dead.

Out of curiosity, did you do this in London? I cycle in London and do this sometimes when there is really no space om the left (and i tend to err on the side of caution rather than squeeze through where a lot of other cyclists might squeeze through), but I often feel like I'm causing more anger at me from other bikes piling up behind or trying to go round either side, a d taking up a full place in traffic when the car behind seems to want to be bumper to bumper as if those extra few centimeters will get them there faster. I try to make the right decision reading each situation but sometimes it doesn't seem so clear cut, and sometimes filtering looks like the preferred alternative for all.

Devoutspoken · 16/11/2022 08:26

Missunshine - you have a very carcentric view of the world, driving your kids in cars is not 'almost completely unavoidable', if you don't have a car.

Devoutspoken · 16/11/2022 08:22

Venetian, she said she did not allow her 5 year-old child to cycle on the road, she didn't say all children forever. Incidentally, my kids have just gone off to school on their bikes.

CecilyP · 16/11/2022 08:20

CapMarvel · 15/11/2022 19:15

"Every time I walk or drive past I think of him. It shouldn't happen, but it does every day."

It doesn't though, but do you know what does...? Yes, you guessed it, severe road traffic accidents involving cars.

Statistically speaking you are at far more risk in a car than you are on a bike, but things like facts and stuff are clearly not your strong point.

Again, you have not taken into account the shear number of person/miles travelled in motor vehicles each year compared to the number of person/miles travelled on bikes.

CecilyP · 16/11/2022 08:03

Lunar, what your figures do not take into account is the comparative numbers of pedestrians - everyone, and pedestrian journeys, compared to the small number of cyclists and cycling journeys. And every cyclist is sometimes a pedestrian. It is probably a only a minority who do more cycle journeys than walking journeys.

Venetiaparties · 16/11/2022 07:55

ArialAnna · 16/11/2022 07:19

But you have no actual evidence, that children are at more risk than adults. You are just basing that on your own risk perception and fears. I would expect children to be safer than adults on the whole, as they are normally being supervised by a responsible adult.

Do I cycle my kids to school in a cargo bike - Yes

Would I cycle with my kids in a trailer behind me? No, I wouldn't feel comfortable with it personally - I like to be able to see them

Would I let my 5 year old cycle in the road? No, at this age and around where we live it's safer for them to cycle on the pavement. But I can see in certain circumstances (e.g. roads with lots of driveways) it may well be safer for them to ride in the road with the adult.

But I wouldn't criticise other parents for doing either of the above. Just because I'm not comfortable with it myself, doesn't mean they are taking an unreasonable risk. Unless you have hard statistical evidence that it's significantly more risky than all the other risky things in life we let our children do (e.g. skiing, horse riding, car rides) then you should keep your judgemental views to yourself.

So after all the pages and pages of bleating you don't even allow your children to cycle on the road after all!

Classic!

Jesus what a total waste of time.

And just to say you can't randomly call people trolls just because they disagree with you!

Venetiaparties · 16/11/2022 07:54

OneTC · 15/11/2022 19:53

What is the specific risk aversion to cycling? I'm surprised you ride horses and presumably let your kids ride them? From a horse owning family and know quite a few people who've been very badly injured and one killed when out riding. In my mind it seems like the more dangerous activity, although haven't checked stats.

Conversely I know loads more people that ride bikes, mostly commuting in London and although most people I know, including myself, have been in pretty hairy accidents I only know one person who's had a life changing injury (blind) from being in a crash

My dc are not interested in riding horses they are teens, I ride horses but just trotting. I have never fallen from my horse to date and would never go out on the roads - it is very dangerous. The same as cycling.

misssunshine4040 · 16/11/2022 07:46

ArialAnna · 16/11/2022 07:19

But you have no actual evidence, that children are at more risk than adults. You are just basing that on your own risk perception and fears. I would expect children to be safer than adults on the whole, as they are normally being supervised by a responsible adult.

Do I cycle my kids to school in a cargo bike - Yes

Would I cycle with my kids in a trailer behind me? No, I wouldn't feel comfortable with it personally - I like to be able to see them

Would I let my 5 year old cycle in the road? No, at this age and around where we live it's safer for them to cycle on the pavement. But I can see in certain circumstances (e.g. roads with lots of driveways) it may well be safer for them to ride in the road with the adult.

But I wouldn't criticise other parents for doing either of the above. Just because I'm not comfortable with it myself, doesn't mean they are taking an unreasonable risk. Unless you have hard statistical evidence that it's significantly more risky than all the other risky things in life we let our children do (e.g. skiing, horse riding, car rides) then you should keep your judgemental views to yourself.

Surely the fact that by their size and fragility alone makes them more vulnerable to a road accident than an adult.
Perception of risk, reaction time etc added to the fact that their small body stands no chance next to a car?

It's common sense, no one needs statistics to see this.
I did try and look some up but there isn't adequate data as not enough people use them to collect it.
Austria are considering their stance on them when a car rear ended a bike trailer killing 2 infants.

You do you and cycle with your kids in a bike but fact is, if your bike got clipped or worse then it's just unthinkable to put them in that situation.

I did read that children presenting in hospital under 9 from bike accidents were mostly passengers on their parents bikes/ trailers

ArialAnna · 16/11/2022 07:19

But you have no actual evidence, that children are at more risk than adults. You are just basing that on your own risk perception and fears. I would expect children to be safer than adults on the whole, as they are normally being supervised by a responsible adult.

Do I cycle my kids to school in a cargo bike - Yes

Would I cycle with my kids in a trailer behind me? No, I wouldn't feel comfortable with it personally - I like to be able to see them

Would I let my 5 year old cycle in the road? No, at this age and around where we live it's safer for them to cycle on the pavement. But I can see in certain circumstances (e.g. roads with lots of driveways) it may well be safer for them to ride in the road with the adult.

But I wouldn't criticise other parents for doing either of the above. Just because I'm not comfortable with it myself, doesn't mean they are taking an unreasonable risk. Unless you have hard statistical evidence that it's significantly more risky than all the other risky things in life we let our children do (e.g. skiing, horse riding, car rides) then you should keep your judgemental views to yourself.

misssunshine4040 · 16/11/2022 02:15

Because we are not talking about people of all ages!!
Yes I accept that being a pedestrian is more dangerous than cycling to people of all ages but we are discussing 5 year olds cycling on roads with traffic. Not people of all ages.

Young children in trailers attached to bikes and little children on the roads cycling to school etc at 5 years old is an unreasonable risk. No one is talking about the rest of the population.

Where did anyone say they were referring to the general population when discussing the risks?

Lunar270 · 16/11/2022 02:09

misssunshine4040 · 16/11/2022 01:01

Even brake.org the road safety charity advise children under 10 should not cycle near motorised traffic.

Highly impractical. Young children cycle all round the estates where I live. Cars are also everywhere on the estates. It's impossible for young kids to cycle anywhere in many towns without coming across motorised vehicles, mainly because cars dominate every part of the UK. You might as well tell kids never to leave the house. Great idea.

Quite why you refuse to accept that being a pedestrian is far more dangerous and kills more people of all ages is beyond me.

Brake are against everything so there's no surprise there.

RoSPA have published figures for cyclists here:

www.rospa.com/road-safety/advice/cyclists-and-motorcyclists/accident-rates

An article on pedestrian casualties can be found here:

www.livingstreets.org.uk/news-and-blog/press-media/new-dft-stats-reveal-increase-in-pedestrian-fatalities

There's quite a contrast.

misssunshine4040 · 16/11/2022 01:01

Even brake.org the road safety charity advise children under 10 should not cycle near motorised traffic.

misssunshine4040 · 16/11/2022 00:57

Lunar270 · 15/11/2022 23:50

No it's not comparable because walking in the street is much more dangerous than cycling.

Not for a 5 year old it's not ffs!

Changechangychange · 16/11/2022 00:18

Venetiaparties · 15/11/2022 12:06

Not mounted on pavements, no.

You’ve literally never seen anything like this?

Maybe you need to get out more? It is really normal in towns with narrow streets.

to ask views on the 5-year-old cycling and Sajid Javid video?
Lunar270 · 15/11/2022 23:50

No it's not comparable because walking in the street is much more dangerous than cycling.

misssunshine4040 · 15/11/2022 23:46

Devoutspoken · 15/11/2022 21:43

Miss sunshine, but driving down a motorway at 80 miles an hour with kids in your car is an acceptable risk? Or how about skiing? that's a hugely popular family activity in some sectors of society - is it just cycling you disapprove of?

Again they are not comparable are they. Neither is talking about pushing a pram across a street.
Driving you kids in cars is almost unavoidable but as the previous poster said, cars are designed to withstand collisions and car seats and offer protection. A bike and a cart do not.

Hobbies for kids young enough to fit into carts on bikes are the not what's being discussed ? 4 and 5 year olds won't be skiing down a full face ski slope nor will they be riding a pony off a lead rein until competent.

Cycling again is absolutely,... In a park, not in rush hour traffic at the age of 5.
Why is this such a problematic view ?

Lunar270 · 15/11/2022 23:06

misssunshine4040 · 15/11/2022 21:30

Yes but crossing the road etc is an unavoidable risk isn't it.
Using a cargo bike and placing your child purposely in the way of fast moving traffic with minimal protection is a choice and a risk that is unnecessary.
Cars are the problem of course but we don't live in a society that is kind to cyclists and it feels like a huge risk for what? Just wait until until your kids are older

A bit like the hundreds of parents pushing prams and buggies into the road before stepping into it themselves really.

I often see parents enter zebra crossings when they haven't established whether anyone is going to stop. It's even more frightening than seeing someone on a bike.

Stats are firmly against pedestrians sadly but is interesting how people ignore stats in favour of their own fears and interpretation.

Devoutspoken · 15/11/2022 21:43

Miss sunshine, but driving down a motorway at 80 miles an hour with kids in your car is an acceptable risk? Or how about skiing? that's a hugely popular family activity in some sectors of society - is it just cycling you disapprove of?

OneTC · 15/11/2022 21:35

At what age do you recommend approving their imminent deaths?

misssunshine4040 · 15/11/2022 21:30

Yes but crossing the road etc is an unavoidable risk isn't it.
Using a cargo bike and placing your child purposely in the way of fast moving traffic with minimal protection is a choice and a risk that is unnecessary.
Cars are the problem of course but we don't live in a society that is kind to cyclists and it feels like a huge risk for what? Just wait until until your kids are older

ArialAnna · 15/11/2022 21:12

@misssunshine4040 I was talking about the risks to children, within the context of adults cycling them on cargo bikes. I don't get your point to be honest - yes in an accident with a car a cargo bike would come off badly, but so do pedestrians when hit by a car. And before you say that's less likely because pedestrians are on the pavement whereas cars are in the road, the statistics would suggest otherwise. Plently of opportunity for pedestrians to get hit when crossings roads / driveways. What will make everyone safer is less cars on the road, so I stand by my opinion that parents cycling their kids should be encouraged rather than villified.

misssunshine4040 · 15/11/2022 20:34

ArialAnna · 15/11/2022 20:06

@Venetiaparties what a bunch of tosh you write!

I don't cycle to make a point. I cycle because it gets me places quicker, it's easier to park, it's healthier, I'm not adding extra air pollution to the atmosphere & it uses less energy. As odd as it would seem to you I'm sure, I would feel guilty if I drove a short journey which could be walked or cycled. That said, I would never cycle anywhere I would consider too dangerous to cycle. All life involves a certain level of risk and it's up to the individual to judge what's sensible.

I noticed you didn't answer my point about your horse riding being a highly risky activity when you examine the statistics (which does make me suspect you are indeed a troll, as another poster suggested). I do not personally know of a single child injured while on a bike ridden by a parent, but I do know of one severely paralysed falling off a horse. But you crack on with your delusions if that's what keeps you happy...

No one is talking about the dangers for adults?! They are pointing out the risks for small children!

Why are people deliberately skirting around the unavoidable truth that small children on bikes and sat in cargo bike would be crushed and severely injured if not dead if a car accident happened on the road?!

ArialAnna · 15/11/2022 20:06

@Venetiaparties what a bunch of tosh you write!

I don't cycle to make a point. I cycle because it gets me places quicker, it's easier to park, it's healthier, I'm not adding extra air pollution to the atmosphere & it uses less energy. As odd as it would seem to you I'm sure, I would feel guilty if I drove a short journey which could be walked or cycled. That said, I would never cycle anywhere I would consider too dangerous to cycle. All life involves a certain level of risk and it's up to the individual to judge what's sensible.

I noticed you didn't answer my point about your horse riding being a highly risky activity when you examine the statistics (which does make me suspect you are indeed a troll, as another poster suggested). I do not personally know of a single child injured while on a bike ridden by a parent, but I do know of one severely paralysed falling off a horse. But you crack on with your delusions if that's what keeps you happy...