Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel sad that children in poverty may believe it’s their fault at Xmas?

86 replies

Amigoingmadslowly · 14/11/2022 19:07

I am always emotional about strange things. I find so many sad things going on in this shitty world that it’s hard to see the good. Today I found myself tearful (not for the first time) at the thought that there may be children that get no Xmas presents because their parents can’t afford them. That’s sad but do these children believe it is because they have been naughty and Santa has brought them nothing? Could there be more done to make sure that doesn’t happen? This was on the back of a discussion about how many presents kids get and whether Santa brings all or parents give all and Santa gives one. Clearly there is no ‘normal’ way to do that. But at least these children are getting gifts!

OP posts:
Athenen0ctua · 28/11/2022 18:46

CheeseIsMyPatronus · 28/11/2022 18:38

I thought telling children only 'good' ones got gifts and 'bad' ones get nothing went out with the ark!

85yo FIL says it, but no one else, and he's always been a bit... well, Daily Mail on caffeine in his views.

There are still parents who use it as a threat to control their children. Some tell their children that that toy elf reports back to FC too. DS was once told by a child that he must have been naughty as he got much less than them, that was only about 10 years ago!

Whatifiwereareindeer · 28/11/2022 18:43

Slightly tangential but this is one reason why I absolutely loathe the linking of Christmas presents/Santa to behaviour. I cannot imagine what kind of behaviour a child would have to exhibit before I took away presents at Christmas, and I don’t believe any reasonable non abusive parent actually tells their child Santa brought them nothing because of their behaviour. So why make stupid idle threats or talk about “naughty or nice” lists in the first place?

Itsnotallblackandwhite · 28/11/2022 18:42

When I was about 5 or 6 OP, (early ‘70’s), my sister and I woke up to no presents on Christmas Day. I knew I hadn’t been naughty so just assumed that Father Christmas didn’t come to our house because we were poor.

I assume that children who believe in Father Christmas and don’t get anything will think that it’s either because they’ve been naughty, or they’re just not worth it.

Every Christmas I think about children who are waking up to nothing and maybe getting even more abuse during the holiday because there’s more drinking going on with the adults around them. It’s not a magical time of year for too many children 50 years after my own experience.

CheeseIsMyPatronus · 28/11/2022 18:38

I thought telling children only 'good' ones got gifts and 'bad' ones get nothing went out with the ark!

85yo FIL says it, but no one else, and he's always been a bit... well, Daily Mail on caffeine in his views.

5128gap · 28/11/2022 18:31

I doubt it OP. I work with families in very vulnerable circumstances and I've yet to come across a child old enough to understand Christmas who doesn't also have a rudimentary understanding of their parents means. Its not just at Christmas they see the effects of poverty. Its when there's no money for the electricity, new shoes and so on. Most children know its parents not santa who buys the gifts so expectations can be sadly realistic. Also as pp have mentioned, there are a lot of initiatives to ensure children get something at Christmas. Even when they're ignored the rest of the year.

Wibbly1008 · 28/11/2022 18:26

Sadly I’ve worked with families who are so hooked on drugs they sell their kids toys and clothes to fund their habit. Even stuff donated gets flogged on. Unless these issues are dealt with there will always be kids who get nothing sadly.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 28/11/2022 18:25

"I don't really understand this, where and how?"

The value of second hand toys is practically nil, so people give them away to friends and acquaintances, post them on Freecycle, sell them at church sales or on eBay for £1 or leave them outside their house with a "please take" sign. I got most of DS's toys that way until he started getting fussy at the age of 4.

I once bought a huge ELC toy garage in perfect condition for £1 on eBay. I felt bad when I collected it but the seller was happy to get rid of it, as was I two years later when I sold it for £1 on Gumtree.

PeekAtYou · 28/11/2022 18:21

@gogohmm I assume that Dunelm do it in conjunction with a charity or local services or something so these children are in need of a gift or two.

PeekAtYou · 28/11/2022 18:20

Who on earth is teaching children that if they get nothing at Christmas that they are responsible?

Christmas songs, movies and stories have Father Christmas visiting all of the children in the world unless they are naughty. ("The naughty list")

PeekAtYou · 28/11/2022 18:18

@FatAgainItsLettuceTime That's just heartbreaking.

Athenen0ctua · 28/11/2022 18:05

Who on earth is teaching children that if they get nothing at Christmas that they are responsible?
Some people tell their children that if they are naughty then FC won't come. Some even have a creepy elf to spy on the children for FC. These children might tell other children.

gogohmm · 28/11/2022 18:03

@PeekAtYou

Whilst I don't want to downplay the child's situation, children when asked do come out with strange requests, my dd asked for marshmallow's and a tennis ball aged 4 / she had loads of balls!

StoneofDestiny · 28/11/2022 18:02

Who on earth is teaching children that if they get nothing at Christmas that they are responsible?
I think children will appreciate even the smallest things wrapped up - think of the old Christmases that came with a stocking filled with a tangerine and a few bits and pieces. I was trawling round charity shops today and was impressed how virtually new toys were in there for a pound or two. Sadly we are raising children's expectations to have the latest gadget and the whole content of the Argos catalogue!
Several charities have new gifts donated to distribute at Christmas (I believe the Salvation Army is one).
It's really the backlash of making Christmas a shopping festival driven by retail mania rather than enjoying the real meaning behind it.

gogohmm · 28/11/2022 18:01

@MistyRock

Whenever it's known a family is struggling, getting a collection of good quality second hand gifts is the easy part. There's plenty of orgs that donate new toys and hampers too - but it's the other 364 days they will struggle

ILOVECHEESE79 · 28/11/2022 17:56

I'm poor and both my DC will be getting a couple of small things each at Christmas.
They've picked up about Father Christmas from school, but neither child has any sense of not getting presents because they have been 'bad', but that's because I don't try to emotionally blackmail them with FC.
They know I don't have much money that FC delivers what parents can afford.
🤷

HermioneWeasley · 28/11/2022 17:56

cash for kids collect presents or (even better) money to buy suitable gifts. I think lots of toys for little kids get donated in collections but they’re usually short of things suitable for teenage boys.

FatAgainItsLettuceTime · 28/11/2022 17:54

PeekAtYou · 28/11/2022 17:52

On social media I saw some pics from the Dunelm Christmas tree appeal and some of the photos were heartbreaking- one child asked for a packet of biscuits for Christmas 😭

I went to dunelm at the weekend and nearly broke down into full on sobs and I'm not a cryer generally. There were several tags asking for a hat and scarf to keep warm. I just wanted to give every kid a hug and take them to the shop for a full winter wardrobe each.

PeekAtYou · 28/11/2022 17:52

On social media I saw some pics from the Dunelm Christmas tree appeal and some of the photos were heartbreaking- one child asked for a packet of biscuits for Christmas 😭

MistyRock · 28/11/2022 17:51

TheYearOfSmallThings · 28/11/2022 17:26

You can get plenty of toys for nothing if money is all you lack. Any child that receives nothing comes from a family with problems greater than poverty (unless of course they come from a country that doesn't celebrate Christmas).

I don't really understand this, where and how?

antelopevalley · 28/11/2022 17:50

My mum when I was very young used to hide one of my toys a few months before Christmas - all given by neighbours - and then wrap it up for Xmas. I still believed in santa.

FatAgainItsLettuceTime · 28/11/2022 17:50

Look at supermarkets, toy shops and hospitals in your area. Most have toy donation schemes to make sure the kids they work with get at least one present. My DH is really passionate about this and collects toys all year to donate to Toys on the Table which is a local initiative that works with Social Services.

Danikm151 · 28/11/2022 17:35

As much as some people say there are charities that will help. There are and always will be families that slip through the cracks.
parents too proud to accept the help
too scared to say they need help in case their children get taken away
appear to be ok but really aren’t

it is sad

aintnothinbutagstring · 28/11/2022 17:35

I'm sure there's lots of people trying to declutter old toys to make room for new and putting stuff on freecycle.

RobinRobinMouse · 28/11/2022 17:34

@TheYearOfSmallThings I completely agree, some years I had essentials wrapped up or second hand/free things, there's usually a way to sort something, even if it's homemade. I make sure dd knows she's lucky and we donate a toy she chooses at the shop and discuss how FC needs some help sometimes. I'm not going to stop doing FC for her, the magic is real for her and not doing it won't help children who don't get presents.

DenholmElliot11 · 28/11/2022 17:26

I'm with you OP. I know there are charities that provide toys for children but it's usually decent parents who access those charities.

arsehole (for whatever reason) parents, wouldn't bother asking a charity for gifts - and yes it's heartbreaking when a child genuinely believes that she didn't get a gift because she hadn't been good enough