Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel sad that children in poverty may believe it’s their fault at Xmas?

86 replies

Amigoingmadslowly · 14/11/2022 19:07

I am always emotional about strange things. I find so many sad things going on in this shitty world that it’s hard to see the good. Today I found myself tearful (not for the first time) at the thought that there may be children that get no Xmas presents because their parents can’t afford them. That’s sad but do these children believe it is because they have been naughty and Santa has brought them nothing? Could there be more done to make sure that doesn’t happen? This was on the back of a discussion about how many presents kids get and whether Santa brings all or parents give all and Santa gives one. Clearly there is no ‘normal’ way to do that. But at least these children are getting gifts!

OP posts:
RobinRobinMouse · 28/11/2022 20:50

I wouldn't explain anything as I've never seen a child compare who gave what, ever. I work with children and I've seen gifts compared but not the giver. If it did come up I'd just explain that Father Christmas and his magic is different for different people.

Athenen0ctua · 28/11/2022 20:41

Most children don't get far less than her anyway, she is fortunate of course, but there are many who buy and spend far more than we do for their children.
I think @YaWeeFurryBastard meant that most children get far less from FC. How do you explain why many other children would get just the stocking from FC?

RobinRobinMouse · 28/11/2022 19:57

@YaWeeFurryBastard Sneer at me all you like, this has been the tradition in our family for 3 generations. When we choose a toy to donate each year we talk about how sometimes Father Christmas can't quite get around to everyone and so he needs a bit of help, being naughty or nice doesn't come into it. Most children don't get far less than her anyway, she is fortunate of course, but there are many who buy and spend far more than we do for their children.

YaWeeFurryBastard · 28/11/2022 19:52

RobinRobinMouse · 28/11/2022 19:19

Everything from us is from FC; that is a stocking and a main present. The presents being from Father Christmas is a really important part of our tradition. Sorry to those who disagree with this approach, but we will be continuing it. If we ever find ourselves short of money I will find something to wrap up from him.

Please do tell which culture this tradition comes from? It’s not just about whether you are short of money, it’s the fact your children will tell other children what they got from Father Christmas. How do you explain the fact that most other children get far less? Do you just tell your kids they’re better behaved than the rest?

Bigslippers · 28/11/2022 19:51

I get emotional about things like this but as an ex foster carer I worry throughout the year that there are kids being abused/neglected etc who think its their fault.

If a parent is poor it doesn’t mean that the children will have a rubbish Christmas it’s probably the opposite- the child as long as they have a loving parent will have the best day ever with what ever they have and appreciate it too. The gift of love and patience 365 days a year is a thousand fold better than a room full of gifts with a parent who isnt enjoying their kids

Most kids are over indulged at Christmas so 50 presents to them could equal one to a child in poverty.

Christmas makes us extra emotional but it should be the other 364 we also need to get emotional about

TheWorstWeek · 28/11/2022 19:50

My DC get their stocking and "main" present from Santa but we don't follow the traditional naughty/nice thing. We've talked about how there arent really naughty kids, just kids that sometimes do naughty things and Santa understands that. I've also sort of told them that Santa checks with us as parents that the present is okay/appropriate for them so I could explain if something was too expensive why they didn't get it.

I do think sometimes adults overthink the Santa thing. I grew up pretty poor. Never got anything on my Santa list but was always super grateful and never thought twice about my friends who got everything they asked for. It's just how it was.

As part of a Christmas advent calendar we do daily activities one of which is buying some items for the local toy bank. They have a wish list on Amazon so we pick a few little things from that to donate. And then do a food bank one too!

YaWeeFurryBastard · 28/11/2022 19:50

Athenen0ctua · 28/11/2022 19:41

People can buy what they like, I just don't understand why it all needs to be from FC not the parents. If children go to school saying that FC got them a games console or a brand new bike then that can make other children wonder what they have done wrong.

Exactly, but as evidenced on this thread some parents just don’t give a shit about others!

It’s completely different to going on holiday which can be explained in an age appropriate way that it’s because of a lack of funds, not because of the behaviour as a child.

ClareBlue · 28/11/2022 19:47

RTE say on national television on Christmas eve. "Have you been good this year so santa can bring your lresents" and that creepy elf thing is monitoring good behaviour to reward with presents. Time to cut the link.

MyIgloo · 28/11/2022 19:47

Heart breaking to think of all the children who slip through the net and believe they are naughty and that’s why Santa didn’t come 😔

Christmas is definitely going to be a tight one for us, I can’t imagine how other parents feel

Athenen0ctua · 28/11/2022 19:41

x2boys · 28/11/2022 19:35

Some kids always have more then others ,we haven't been abroad since ds1 was 18 months and hes16 on boxing day, and we haven't had any kind of holiday for four years,it is what it is some kids will be jetting off every school break, you can't tell people the way they do. "Santa" is wrong .

People can buy what they like, I just don't understand why it all needs to be from FC not the parents. If children go to school saying that FC got them a games console or a brand new bike then that can make other children wonder what they have done wrong.

ClareBlue · 28/11/2022 19:40

I used to work with some extreme situations with housing and there was plenty of children waking up on Christmas day with parents either not there or passed out on whatever, along with who ever was invited to party in the house that night. Those parents weren't accessing charities for their children and the small ones absolutely did believe it was because they were bad. It's everywhere telling them santa only comes if you are good. What are they supposed to think. The older children just believe they generally don't deserve anything in life. They carry this through to adulthood.
It is a damaging narrative for very young children in extreme poverty with disfunctional families. Just one more way to make them feel excluded and worthless.

UndertheCedartree · 28/11/2022 19:39

I think it is really sad that people link behaviour to getting presents. I always made sure my 2 knew that FC gives gladly and is not mean spirited.

A while ago now I was in hospital for 3 years and it was very difficult to claim benefits. I was so grateful for all the support we got. There was the food bank, Salvation army through school and Children's services that got my DC advent calendars, Christmas gifts and Christmas food 😊

x2boys · 28/11/2022 19:35

Athenen0ctua · 28/11/2022 19:17

I agree. Some think they should be able to do FC how they want without a thought of how it could affect others. If FC brings one (reasonably priced/sized) present or a stocking then that is achievable for other parents.

Some kids always have more then others ,we haven't been abroad since ds1 was 18 months and hes16 on boxing day, and we haven't had any kind of holiday for four years,it is what it is some kids will be jetting off every school break, you can't tell people the way they do. "Santa" is wrong .

JustAnotherHappyFatty · 28/11/2022 19:33

The youngest children (that would be of an age to believe in father christmas) are the ones that receive most donations or can be bought relatively inexpensive gifts and still be impressed.

I really feel for the older primary aged and younger high school aged kids, they really see the difference in what they (don't) receive compared to their peers.
Teenage boys are very under represented when people choose to donate gifts.

x2boys · 28/11/2022 19:30

Gingerkittykat · 28/11/2022 19:23

The whole point is that the most vulnerable kids (the ones with heroin addict parents etc) are the ones who are most likely to miss out and then feel bad about themselves. I really hope the various Christmas appeals reach those kids.

This is true we have had stuff thrown at us because my youngest son is disabled,but whilst we are not rich we can Xmas presents for the kids ,it needs to be targeted better ,but I'm not sure how.

Gingerkittykat · 28/11/2022 19:23

TheYearOfSmallThings · 28/11/2022 17:26

You can get plenty of toys for nothing if money is all you lack. Any child that receives nothing comes from a family with problems greater than poverty (unless of course they come from a country that doesn't celebrate Christmas).

The whole point is that the most vulnerable kids (the ones with heroin addict parents etc) are the ones who are most likely to miss out and then feel bad about themselves. I really hope the various Christmas appeals reach those kids.

RobinRobinMouse · 28/11/2022 19:19

Everything from us is from FC; that is a stocking and a main present. The presents being from Father Christmas is a really important part of our tradition. Sorry to those who disagree with this approach, but we will be continuing it. If we ever find ourselves short of money I will find something to wrap up from him.

Athenen0ctua · 28/11/2022 19:17

YaWeeFurryBastard · 28/11/2022 18:55

This is why it really pisses me off when certain dickheads have “Santa” bring all the (expensive) presents like games consoles etc. utterly ridiculous behaviour that only serves to make other children feel bad. Get your kids whatever you want but for the love of god please let Father Christmas bring stocking fillers so other children don’t feel shit.

I agree. Some think they should be able to do FC how they want without a thought of how it could affect others. If FC brings one (reasonably priced/sized) present or a stocking then that is achievable for other parents.

bridgetreilly · 28/11/2022 19:06

Some people have set themselves up for it by telling their children in previous years that all presents are from Santa. I think that’s a bad idea for all kinds of reasons, but it makes it especially difficult if you then have to explain why Santa doesn’t bring very much this year.

BasiliskStare · 28/11/2022 19:05

When I was young ( about 5) I want a spirograph set - anyone remember those ) My parents who did not have much money at the time bought it as my "main present" with a few little homemade things Oh and a ukulele - because I was wee & apparently I wanted a guitar. A neighbour gave my mum one. On Christmas Eve my mother and Granny were all very pleased , until I said I wanted a snake. They went out and looked and got one from a newsagents for about a shilling.

I agree with PP s who say nothing to do with being good , but nice to hear of charities who can rehome toys. I will look up - most of DS's are long gone but would contribute to one in my area if it is the difference between a child having a present or not. I do not refer here to games consoles , more having something to unwrap.

dottiedodah · 28/11/2022 19:03

Lots of shops here south coast have somewhere to drop presents off for poor children and the local pub as well. Sad to think of the divisions in our society, made worse lately

PeekAtYou · 28/11/2022 19:00

Isn't the popular Elf on the Shelf supposed to be a character who reports good and bad behaviour to Santa every night ? They didn't have this when my children were younger but I've seen them in shops and mentioned on social media so presume that they are popular.

YaWeeFurryBastard · 28/11/2022 18:55

This is why it really pisses me off when certain dickheads have “Santa” bring all the (expensive) presents like games consoles etc. utterly ridiculous behaviour that only serves to make other children feel bad. Get your kids whatever you want but for the love of god please let Father Christmas bring stocking fillers so other children don’t feel shit.

CheeseIsMyPatronus · 28/11/2022 18:50

@Athenen0ctua - god, that's depressing. What an horrifically low standard of parenting, threatening no gifts. I honestly thought it was backward old gits who said that.

(Yes, FIL is an old git, but he's our old git)

Athenen0ctua · 28/11/2022 18:50

Whatifiwereareindeer · 28/11/2022 18:43

Slightly tangential but this is one reason why I absolutely loathe the linking of Christmas presents/Santa to behaviour. I cannot imagine what kind of behaviour a child would have to exhibit before I took away presents at Christmas, and I don’t believe any reasonable non abusive parent actually tells their child Santa brought them nothing because of their behaviour. So why make stupid idle threats or talk about “naughty or nice” lists in the first place?

I absolutely hate it too. Sadly, many parents do still attempt to control their children's behaviour through idle threats.

Swipe left for the next trending thread