Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel sad that children in poverty may believe it’s their fault at Xmas?

86 replies

Amigoingmadslowly · 14/11/2022 19:07

I am always emotional about strange things. I find so many sad things going on in this shitty world that it’s hard to see the good. Today I found myself tearful (not for the first time) at the thought that there may be children that get no Xmas presents because their parents can’t afford them. That’s sad but do these children believe it is because they have been naughty and Santa has brought them nothing? Could there be more done to make sure that doesn’t happen? This was on the back of a discussion about how many presents kids get and whether Santa brings all or parents give all and Santa gives one. Clearly there is no ‘normal’ way to do that. But at least these children are getting gifts!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Ponderingwindow · 01/12/2022 17:40

Naughty or nice is not a message that anyone should be reinforcing with any child. Behaving for Santa is just creepy and has consequences like what op describes

in terms of gifts themselves, we donate every year. It’s not the same as a parent choosing the perfect gift for their individual child though. I try to send things that I am also giving my own child. That way at least I know it’s something I think is quality, I’m hitting older ages now which are often overlooked, and maybe the child who gets the gift will have similar interests.

Justthisonce12 · 01/12/2022 17:23

So ive donated but the toys on the site are at least 25% more than Amazon. I do wish theyd shop around a bit for decent deals or the shops involved would forgo a bit of margin

TheTantrumoftheToddlerIsThere · 30/11/2022 22:39

www.hartlepoolgivingtree.co.uk

Anyone wishing to donate to a needy child/adult can also donate online via the Hartlepool giving tree (just in case someone wants to donate but don’t have a Dunelm close by) 🙂

bridgetreilly · 29/11/2022 22:30

People do know that you don’t have to do things the way you have always done them, right? You can think about how you have done them, see how it might be harmful to others or even your own children in the future, and then start doing it differently. That’s allowed. You can even start new, better, traditions.

UsingChangeofName · 29/11/2022 19:25

Slight tangent, but I know some have mentioned Dunelm Tree Appeal, Cash for Kids, and other ways to give to Children who might be more in needs. I found out today that our local Children's Hospice have an Amazon Wishlist which might be something some people might want to look at - or, of course a Hospice closer to where you live. Smile

LadyMarmaladeAtkins · 29/11/2022 19:15

That’s sad but do these children believe it is because they have been naughty and Santa has brought them nothing?

You are not wrong. This is one of several reasons I have never subscribed to this 'naughty or nice' rubbish when bringing up children. It used to make me very annoyed when they brought it up at school.

Cathy31 · 29/11/2022 17:35

All the presents dh and I buy for our kids -main present, extras, and stocking - are from Santa. Presents from family and friends go under the tree and are from family and friends. It's what my whole family have always done. Never linked to good behaviour. I remember being painfully aware of how little I got compared to others as a teenager - when Santa was a thing of the past. But not as a child. I just remember the feeling of magic from Christmas mornings then. Agree Santa shouldn't be linked to behaviour, but not that everyone should only have one present from Santa. Some children will still get more than others, it doesn't solve that problem.

purpleboy · 29/11/2022 14:56

I don't think we should start telling parents how many presents they can give from Santa, although I do understand the reasoning behind those who think we should.
But I'm really glad I came across this thread as I had no idea about the Dunelm tree appeal, so I'll be going into my local one Saturday with DD so she can choose who to buy for. Such a great idea.

ItsaMetalBand · 29/11/2022 14:28

Whatifiwereareindeer · 28/11/2022 18:43

Slightly tangential but this is one reason why I absolutely loathe the linking of Christmas presents/Santa to behaviour. I cannot imagine what kind of behaviour a child would have to exhibit before I took away presents at Christmas, and I don’t believe any reasonable non abusive parent actually tells their child Santa brought them nothing because of their behaviour. So why make stupid idle threats or talk about “naughty or nice” lists in the first place?

DS got worried over this - some kid in school told him that the security sensors in the living room were a Santa Cam and his nervousness increased when DH came home with the bloody elf on the shelf as well. As well as Santas robin also looking in the windows, it freaked him out.

So our workaround was that parents can choose to opt out of all sorts of spy systems, which we had done as we like our privacy. And that in order to go on Santa's naughty list a child would have to be deliberately cruel to another child or an animal. Accidents and mistakes don't count, such as dropping the cat. And since we knew of no kid that naughty safe to say it's rare that a kid goes on the naughty list. Ordinary misbehaviour doesn't count.

We've never linked Christmas presents to day to day behaviour.

AlwaysLatte · 28/11/2022 23:28

This is why I hate it when some people insist on giving the children plies of stuff from Santa
Totally agree! We've only ever given stockings 'from santa' - everything else is from their family and friends. Otherwise how do people explain the tags on the gifts, and thank people?

AlwaysLatte · 28/11/2022 23:26

I hate this whole Christmas gifts linked to behaviour thing. We've never done it. Just horrible. Especially since I'm sure any 'naughty' behaviour is dealt with at the time and done and dusted.

x2boys · 28/11/2022 23:22

Nanalisa60 · 28/11/2022 22:29

This is why I hate it when some people insist on giving the children plies of stuff from Santa, I have a frend who are primary teachers and they break there heart every year on the first day back after Christmas, some just have got so much and some have hardly got anything. If all families would just stick to the one present from Santa rule it would be so much fairer. And let’s face it the big man only has enough room on that magic sleigh for one present per child if he is to get wright round the world in one night !!

so please give your child one thing from Santa , and the rest from you and your family and friends.
i

Regardless of whose bringing the gifts some children will.has a pile of presents and other kids will have non it's sad but that's the way it is.

Nanalisa60 · 28/11/2022 22:29

This is why I hate it when some people insist on giving the children plies of stuff from Santa, I have a frend who are primary teachers and they break there heart every year on the first day back after Christmas, some just have got so much and some have hardly got anything. If all families would just stick to the one present from Santa rule it would be so much fairer. And let’s face it the big man only has enough room on that magic sleigh for one present per child if he is to get wright round the world in one night !!

so please give your child one thing from Santa , and the rest from you and your family and friends.
i

Athenen0ctua · 28/11/2022 22:10

@UsingChangeofName DS has always linked presents to who gave them to him, I didn't realise that was unusual? He'd say X from by mum, Y from my nan and grandad..

UsingChangeofName · 28/11/2022 21:43

I think a lot of people are being a bit unrealistic here.
Children of an age to believe in Father Christmas, don't compare with their friends what they got and, if they happen to mention they got whatever the 'big toy' is this year, none of their peers asks who it is from.
@RobinRobinMouse is right. Families are different and have different traditions and that has nothing to do with some children getting more or less.

SkylightSkylight · 28/11/2022 21:26

CheeseIsMyPatronus · 28/11/2022 18:38

I thought telling children only 'good' ones got gifts and 'bad' ones get nothing went out with the ark!

85yo FIL says it, but no one else, and he's always been a bit... well, Daily Mail on caffeine in his views.

Nope. You only have to read some threads on here to know 'being hood or Santa won't bring you anything' is still alive & kicking!!!

Bestcatmum · 28/11/2022 21:17

I meant to add I knew they didn't exist by the time I was 4, one of my earliest memories.

RobinRobinMouse · 28/11/2022 21:16

A mix of both. Most definitely get more than one main under the tree gift. Dd doesntbget any from us, just that. As I say, I'm unlikely to need to explain that at all as children sometimes excitedly compare what they've got but not who it was from anyway. I've only ever heard the delivery man thing and parents getting the credit on here, elsewhere it seems completely normal for children to get presents from FC. That's why they write him a letter and sit on his knee telling him what they'd really really like.

Bestcatmum · 28/11/2022 21:16

I can assure you thats kids in poverty (I was one) are much more streetwise than this and know full well there is no santa.
I remember knowing that santa, the tooth fairy et al did not exist.
Its generally the well off that have children who believe in santa when they are 10 years old.

Athenen0ctua · 28/11/2022 21:11

@RobinRobinMouse Do her friends who get more than her get it from FC or their parents? If presents are from parents then it's much easier to explain why some children get more than if they are from FC.

PrincessArora · 28/11/2022 21:10

@RobinRobinMouse You do what you think is best. Have a lovely Christmas.

RobinRobinMouse · 28/11/2022 21:05

@Whiskyvodka You could say the same about any gifts. Dd gets one main present from FC and a stocking. She gets less than a lot of her friends. Should those parents buy less so mine doesn't feel hard done by? I disagree with the delivery man story, but wouldn't try and stop others doing it that way if they choose.

RobinRobinMouse · 28/11/2022 21:01

@PrincessArora Because Father Christmas brings my child a stocking AND a present?

Whiskyvodka · 28/11/2022 21:00

RobinRobinMouse · 28/11/2022 19:19

Everything from us is from FC; that is a stocking and a main present. The presents being from Father Christmas is a really important part of our tradition. Sorry to those who disagree with this approach, but we will be continuing it. If we ever find ourselves short of money I will find something to wrap up from him.

It’s not just about your dc though.
When your dc tell friends at school that FC brought all their amazing presents then other dc may wonder why they were not given equally good presents.
Far better to explain that families give the gifts and FC delivers them.

PrincessArora · 28/11/2022 20:55

Wow. Just wow. I can’t believe the attitude of a few people on this thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread