Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not let my daughter get her ears pierced at Claires?

108 replies

Hdaniels11 · 14/11/2022 17:29

My Dd has just turned 9 and has been begging me to let her have her ears pierced so i agreed but i told her that we will have to go to a "proper" piercing place and not Claire's. I didn't really know much about Claire's until i started looking into it and apparently it's got a really bad reputation for piercings and i have read multiple things online about how piercing guns are bad?Im not sure how true that is tho. My Dd specifically wants them done at Claire's because she loves the shop and that's where all her friends got them done but i don't want to risk her going there and getting a nasty infected piercing. I do feel mean saying she can't go there but i don't know what else to do.
Should i give her a choice between getting them done at a reputable place or no piercing at all?

OP posts:
WiddlinDiddlin · 14/11/2022 18:24

BungleandGeorge · 14/11/2022 17:58

Whilst I’d go for a piercing studio I can’t really understand all the hatred of guns. The earrings are sharp, it’s not a blunt end that is pushed through and I’m pretty sure they’d have been banned if there were cases of transfer of blood borne infection from them. My biggest worry would be inexperienced staff putting them in wonky!

The point on the posts is nowhere NEAR as sharp as a piercing needle, nothing like it. And not all the studs made and sold for piercing guns have a point at all some are indeed absolutely blunt.

Just no comparison at all.

Ear piercing guns work by forcing the stud through the ear, crushing the tissue around the hole.

Needles work due to the incredible sharpness of the needle sliding through the ear making a hole the right size for the stud post.

Hdaniels11 · 14/11/2022 18:22

Thanks for the advice! I've compromised with her and said she can pick out a pair of earrings in Claire's and get them pierced at a different place.

OP posts:
Jalepenojello · 14/11/2022 18:21

Definitely no to piercing guns. Go somewhere with a needle. Everyone I know knows Claire’s is grim for piercings.

gegs73 · 14/11/2022 18:20

OhmygodDont · 14/11/2022 18:07

Oh I see I shouldn’t have engaged really both those who take offence have had guns at Claire’s. Says it all really.

🤣🤣 🤣🤣

MrsCLogan · 14/11/2022 18:19

I would compromise- take her to a professional piercer for the piercings but get her to pick out some cute earrings from Claire’s for when they have healed (presumably that’s part of the reason she wants to have them done at Claire’s)

Also, don’t bother with buying specialised cleaning solutions that are more than one step, any saline/ salt water solution will work. (Claire’s will almost definitely push you to buy theirs.)

humpty74 · 14/11/2022 18:19

I've got multiple ear piercings, the first 2 sets I had done with guns and were ok, but pretty sore healing. The last ones were with a needle and much much less sore. There could be an element of me being older and taking better care of them, but it felt a lot less traumatic for my ears (although i was far more worried about having it done in a more intimidating shop with a scary needle).

My friend had hers done with a gun around the same time as I did and the idiots who did it did something wrong so the posts were scraped before they went in and she got an unpleasant infection in both ears.

Quiet calm room with someone who knew exactly what they were doing, less pain in the piercing and the healing vs sitting on a stool in the window of a chaotic noisy shop full of 12 year olds and sparkly stuff while the girl was giggling while setting the gun up. I know where I would go if I wanted more.

RocketPanda · 14/11/2022 18:17

DD2 is trained in piercing. Earrings are not sharp and not designed to be pushed through skin. They might taper but the end of them is blunt. She can tell a gun piercing just by feeling the cartilage around the hole. No gun will ever be completely sterile. You wouldn't be happy if a phlebotomist didn't change their gloves between patients. The risk of passing on an infection is minimal but you wouldn't take the chance. Same for piercing. Fresh gloves and fresh needle opened in front of the client, rather than a quickly wiped down gun.

Loics · 14/11/2022 18:13

@OhmygodDont It doesn't matter that it's a fact that guns are not as hygienic and have the potential to cause more damage - it'll be put down to snobbery.
I actually bought some sterling silver studs from Claire's recently - would I get my piercings done there? Hell no! I don't have daughters, but hypothetically wouldn't mind taking them in if they wanted to browse, I just don't want to relive my own mother's horror of my child coming to me with an ear spewing out pus and blood wondering what the heck I should do!

OoooohMatron · 14/11/2022 18:10

Definitely go to a reputable piercing place. Why not let her pick some earrings from Claires for when they've healed. They have hypoallergenic earrings and have a lot of choice so great for buying earrings just not for piercing.

giggly · 14/11/2022 18:08

Well I’ll go against the grain here, both my dd have had piercing done at Claire’s with not a bit of bother . Staff were lovely and reassuring to my dd. One dd got another done at a piercing / tattoo place and it became infected.
I don’t anyone in real life that has had a problem with Claire’s.

RedHelenB · 14/11/2022 18:08

GaahhhhPfff · 14/11/2022 17:46

I just don't understand that in RL everyone uses Claire's and on MN it's a scary big no no.

Really weird, mumsnet snobbery I'm afraid. They're the sane about Clarks shoes

shakalala · 14/11/2022 18:07

My daughter had hers done at Claire's, one of her ears became infected and it never fully recovered. Go somewhere better :(

RedHelenB · 14/11/2022 18:07

My dds were 7 and absolutely fine having their ears done at Claines.
Having said that, I wouldn't get them done in the Christmas holidays cos they won't have time to heal and be able to take them out for PE. Summer holidays are best.

OhmygodDont · 14/11/2022 18:07

Oh I see I shouldn’t have engaged really both those who take offence have had guns at Claire’s. Says it all really.

gegs73 · 14/11/2022 18:05

mathanxiety · 14/11/2022 18:02

@OhmygodDont

Did you mean to come across as such a caricature of snobbery?

I was thinking exactly the same.

OhmygodDont · 14/11/2022 18:05

mathanxiety · 14/11/2022 18:02

@OhmygodDont

Did you mean to come across as such a caricature of snobbery?

I couldn’t laugh harder at being a snob tbh, in my leggings covered in tattoos drinking wine out of a plastic cup 😏😂.

More likely to actually have those kinds of women use such places that use guns in pretty accessory shops or beauty parlours as they wouldn’t be seen dead in a tattoo shop.

Loics · 14/11/2022 18:05

mathanxiety · 14/11/2022 17:59

My kids all got theirs done at Claire's. Some went back for second piercings when they were teens.

They had no problems.

If you believe all the scary stories you read online about all the normal things tweens and teens want to do, you'll lose the confidence of your child.

Survivorship bias. My mum let me get my ears pierced with a gun (neither of us knew the risks back then). I still remember it spewing out pus after it got infected despite following the aftercare advice given to the letter.
It's a fact that it's less hygienic and is more traumatic to the area being pierced - not just opinion. Fine if you want to take the risk, it might be okay. But sounds like OP wants to take the option with a much, much lower risk of damage and infection.

Also, the aftercare kit for which Claire's will no doubt charge a fortune - professional piercers will recommend warm salt water to clean your ear piercings - a lot less pricey I imagine!

mathanxiety · 14/11/2022 18:02

@OhmygodDont

Did you mean to come across as such a caricature of snobbery?

OhmygodDont · 14/11/2022 18:00

A certain group of people tend to use claires. The same kinda group who tend get their babies ears done before they are even dry and I don’t mean those who do it for cultural reasons.

Those who wait and still use Claire’s tend to not be very well educated on the risks of such things and just see it as a fun girly mummy trip to buy pretty things and pretty earrings.

mathanxiety · 14/11/2022 17:59

My kids all got theirs done at Claire's. Some went back for second piercings when they were teens.

They had no problems.

If you believe all the scary stories you read online about all the normal things tweens and teens want to do, you'll lose the confidence of your child.

SallyWD · 14/11/2022 17:59

My daughter had hers done with a needle but I must say I know loads of girls who've had it done at Claires and they've been absolutely fine. I do think people exaggerate a little..

BungleandGeorge · 14/11/2022 17:58

Whilst I’d go for a piercing studio I can’t really understand all the hatred of guns. The earrings are sharp, it’s not a blunt end that is pushed through and I’m pretty sure they’d have been banned if there were cases of transfer of blood borne infection from them. My biggest worry would be inexperienced staff putting them in wonky!

Loics · 14/11/2022 17:58

GaahhhhPfff · 14/11/2022 17:46

I just don't understand that in RL everyone uses Claire's and on MN it's a scary big no no.

There are quite a few people who won't use them. It's no secret they aren't trained properly (another poster mentioned this), gun piercings are more susceptible to infection and causes more trauma to the area, that's just a fact of gun piercings, which Claire's use.
I've just looked at their piercing page and saw they do cartilage piercings - bugger risk of damage with a gun than the lobe - and nose piercings - which is bloody awful. You should never, ever have a nose piercing from a sales assistant who's had minimal training with a gun, it's actually ridiculous they're allowed to do that.

gegs73 · 14/11/2022 17:58

Maybe a little unreasonable to me , but its your child’s ears 😊 I had mine pierced at Claire’s about 4 years ago and they were absolutely fine. No problems. They are so busy in there that I’m sure the people doing it have lots of experience. DS had his pierced at Superdrug in the summer, again they were really good, used a gun but great.

Tattoo/piercing places are good too, but more expensive. I had a piercing at such a place and the earrings available were eye wateringly expensive. Also not what I would want to keep in long term once the holes had healed. Some places also don’t pierce under 18s even if accompanied by a parent so you would have to hunt around more.

holierthanthou73 · 14/11/2022 17:58

There’s definitely been a thread before about this and the use of guns. No go to a proper place