Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not let my daughter get her ears pierced at Claires?

108 replies

Hdaniels11 · 14/11/2022 17:29

My Dd has just turned 9 and has been begging me to let her have her ears pierced so i agreed but i told her that we will have to go to a "proper" piercing place and not Claire's. I didn't really know much about Claire's until i started looking into it and apparently it's got a really bad reputation for piercings and i have read multiple things online about how piercing guns are bad?Im not sure how true that is tho. My Dd specifically wants them done at Claire's because she loves the shop and that's where all her friends got them done but i don't want to risk her going there and getting a nasty infected piercing. I do feel mean saying she can't go there but i don't know what else to do.
Should i give her a choice between getting them done at a reputable place or no piercing at all?

OP posts:
PeloFondo · 14/11/2022 19:00

It's less painful too with a needle. My pierce is "big breath in, and out" and it's done
I had mine done at 15 at Beverley hill nails or whatever it was called - the gun got stuck and she had to redo the hole she had just made and it was so sore
After that I had all the rest done with a needle

viques · 14/11/2022 19:00

I would tell her she needs to wait until the start of the summer holidays so her ears have time to heal properly.

CaronPoivre · 14/11/2022 18:59

Ours were waited until they were sixteen. We were the parents, it was our decision to make. You get to choose if, when and where it is done.

RocketPanda · 14/11/2022 18:58

Upthread not uptrend. Bloody autocorrect.

RocketPanda · 14/11/2022 18:56

That's actually a great suggestion by a poster uptrend, if you see someone with piercings ask them where they got them done. I guarantee 99% of them will not say Claires.

Greenshake · 14/11/2022 18:55

9 is so young to have pierced ears, which I appreciate may be an unpopular opinion. I first got mine done at 14 with a gun - no problems at all. In my later teens we all went to the local hippy-type shop where it was £2.50 a piercing and I ended up with 11 studs over time - again, a gun was used without issue.

Ericaequites · 14/11/2022 18:55

If possible, have your daughter’s ears done with stainless steel studs. They are most hypoallergenic. I’m an ancient American who had my ears done at the pediatrician’s office with sterilized equipment.

LadyMarmaladeAtkins · 14/11/2022 18:50

I think that ear piercing guns should be banned on infection risk grounds, that only licenced piercing parlours and licenced staff should be allowed to do them, and that ear piercing should be banned until the child is at least 16 and preferably 18 and certainly should not be allowed when the child is far to young to give informed consent. But at the moment both are deemed okay, so I'm not judging you OP.

bodyartforms.com/blog/why-you-shouldnt-be-pierced-with-piercing-gun.asp

Leaving that aside, I don't believe in rewarding pestering and think that 9 is a bit young for it anyway thinking about a primary age child looking after them during play and PE, dealing with an infection, and being upset during the piercings, so my answer to her would be "you can have your ears pierced at a proper piercing parlour which I will research, when you are X age - if you pester me before then, you'll have to wait until you are old enough to get them done by yourself".

Loics · 14/11/2022 18:45

user1471550451 · 14/11/2022 18:35

The guns use single sterile cartridges so are perfectly sanitary.
Piercing guns are acceptable if they are piercing lines not cartilage . With a gun you can do both ears at the same time - I have had both kinds of piercing and there is no way after the first one went in either of my it kids would sit for the second with a needle piercing . Claire’s is fine .

That's not the hygiene problem with guns.

"Guns can be contaminated with bloodborne pathogens dozens of times in one day, ear piercing guns are often not sanitized in a medically recognized way. Plastic ear piercing guns cannot be autoclave sterilized and may not be sufficiently cleaned between use on multiple clients."

Enko · 14/11/2022 18:44

I know noome in real life who have used Claires.

Piercing studios are not always more expensive I've just checked prices for my local one and claires. Local piercing studio is £20-30 depending on what earrings you chose. Claire earrings from what I can see starts at £21. I live in SE too so not somewhere cheap.

I did not give my girls the choice whe.l. they wanted it done we went to a piercing studio. I asked around everything I saw someone with a lot of piercings I asked "mind if I ask if you got your piercings locally as my dd wants her ears done?" I asked 5 people 4 of then said the same place the 5th recommended a place in London. I've since learned the place we were sent to isnconsidered one of the best. Tatoo places in the area. It was clean tidy and they were friendly and taught the girls how to look after their ears and why this was important.

unknown10 · 14/11/2022 18:42

Use the search option, there was a post last week about Clare's

Stay away!

LadyMarmaladeAtkins · 14/11/2022 18:41

Totally agree. It's much better to have them done with completely sterile equipment by expert piercers. And in privacy! They can make sure the piercings are situated in the best possible place for the shape on the lobes and even up uneven lobes with clever placement so that earrings look matched but dangly earrings don't hang lopsided one lower than the other.

We did precisely this for one of our children (the rest didn't want ears pierced) and that child later went back to the same place for 2nd piercings in each lobe, of their own volition (when old enough to make that choice).

LolaSmiles · 14/11/2022 18:40

With a gun you can do both ears at the same time - I have had both kinds of piercing and there is no way after the first one went in either of my it kids would sit for the second with a needle piercing . Claire’s is fine .
If a child isn't capable of giving informed consent to having both ears pierced and you don't believe they would consent to the second after the first was done, I'd question whether they were able to give informed consent 🤷‍♀️.

Roserunner · 14/11/2022 18:39

We got DDs done a few years ago at a piercing studio. The women was great and made sure that DD wanted them done and explained what would happen. They healed really quickly and only cost £20 which I thought was really reasonable.

MidnightMeltdown · 14/11/2022 18:38

I had mine pierced in Claire's when I was about 9. I've never had any problems with them at all.

They've never been infected or painful

LolaSmiles · 14/11/2022 18:37

OhmygodDont I know what you mean.
It's not snobbery.
It's common sense that the people who choose to do their research, have looked into piercings for more than the 5 seconds it takes to conclude I had mine done with a gun and there's no problem and/or but if you don't let a primary school age child have the final say on where they get body modifications done then you'll be the uncool parent in the eyes of a 9 year old will probably conclude that the best place for piercings isn't in the middle of a shop with someone who's done a short training course on using a piercing gun.

There's a lot more information now than there used to be. It's bad enough not to look at the risks of shop gun piercings before sitting your child in a chair. It's even worse to know the risks and decide to ignore them because your primary school aged child wants to say they've had it done in Claire's

(I've had all my piercings done with guns as a child and adult, but know better now)

Bintymcbintface · 14/11/2022 18:37

Dixiechickonhols · 14/11/2022 18:31

Only Issue with that is piercer may want certain quality of earrings or metal. I wouldn’t want her to get hopes up and be upset. I’d just say we’ll get them pierced at x. Most piercers will have a choice of suitable earrings.

This!! Piercers often use the jewellery they have on offer in their place as they know where it came from and the quality of it. Maybe you could offer to take her to pick a pair of earrings once the original piercing has healed, honestly though the ones on offer wherever you take her will be just as pretty and the quality will be much better/safer

OhmygodDont · 14/11/2022 18:37

user1471550451 · 14/11/2022 18:35

The guns use single sterile cartridges so are perfectly sanitary.
Piercing guns are acceptable if they are piercing lines not cartilage . With a gun you can do both ears at the same time - I have had both kinds of piercing and there is no way after the first one went in either of my it kids would sit for the second with a needle piercing . Claire’s is fine .

At our local tattoo shop you get both done at the same time with needles. They get two tattooists/piercers in at the same time having measured marked and double checked.

user1471550451 · 14/11/2022 18:35

Lobes not lines!!

user1471550451 · 14/11/2022 18:35

The guns use single sterile cartridges so are perfectly sanitary.
Piercing guns are acceptable if they are piercing lines not cartilage . With a gun you can do both ears at the same time - I have had both kinds of piercing and there is no way after the first one went in either of my it kids would sit for the second with a needle piercing . Claire’s is fine .

Dixiechickonhols · 14/11/2022 18:31

Hdaniels11 · 14/11/2022 18:22

Thanks for the advice! I've compromised with her and said she can pick out a pair of earrings in Claire's and get them pierced at a different place.

Only Issue with that is piercer may want certain quality of earrings or metal. I wouldn’t want her to get hopes up and be upset. I’d just say we’ll get them pierced at x. Most piercers will have a choice of suitable earrings.

Wibbly1008 · 14/11/2022 18:31

I’ve had a wonky piercing for many years. It’s a constant pain. Get them done properly, she’ll thank you for it later !

BungleandGeorge · 14/11/2022 18:29

I didn’t know you got blunt earrings for guns, that doesn’t sound a good idea. The ones I had were sharp and really not a great deal different to a needle and then pushing a post through. I’m not disagreeing the needle may be slightly better and I’d rather have someone who is a trained piercer doing them. Most places won’t use guns for anything but lobes.
would be interesting to see evidence for infections. There would be a risk of a needle stick injury with a needle. I’ve had infections from both methods

FOTTFSOFTFOASM · 14/11/2022 18:26

I don't know about the relative merits of piercing places and techniques, and I know you've agreed to let your DD have hers done, OP - but the answer to my DDs when they were 9 was "no". There are plenty of good fakes, if they want to play at having pierced ears.

Bintymcbintface · 14/11/2022 18:26

Nope avoid Claires, overpriced, unhygienic and the people doing the piercing have done nothing more than a day course on how to use the piercing gun. Piercing guns really can't be properly sanitised due to all the wee fiddly parts, secondly they cause so much unnecessary trauma to the site, a one time use only needle is not only way more hygienic but much less painful and promotes better healing time. Tattoo parlours usually have in house piercers with all the proper kit