Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not let my daughter get her ears pierced at Claires?

108 replies

Hdaniels11 · 14/11/2022 17:29

My Dd has just turned 9 and has been begging me to let her have her ears pierced so i agreed but i told her that we will have to go to a "proper" piercing place and not Claire's. I didn't really know much about Claire's until i started looking into it and apparently it's got a really bad reputation for piercings and i have read multiple things online about how piercing guns are bad?Im not sure how true that is tho. My Dd specifically wants them done at Claire's because she loves the shop and that's where all her friends got them done but i don't want to risk her going there and getting a nasty infected piercing. I do feel mean saying she can't go there but i don't know what else to do.
Should i give her a choice between getting them done at a reputable place or no piercing at all?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MuddlingThrough1724 · 14/11/2022 22:02

I worked at Claires for about 3 weeks one summer, the training was non-existant and I would always go to somewhere specialist, or at least where training is more than one go with the Piercing gun on a piece of card. 😬

Badgerstmary · 14/11/2022 21:57

Op I had no intention of allowing my dd to have her ears pierced at Claire’s until I looked into it & found that Claire’s was the only place near me where both ears could be pierced at the same time. I couldn’t fault them & bought the dearer earrings. They explained everything very well & were very professional.

Grumpybutfunny · 14/11/2022 21:53

Is it the studs she wants? You can buy them and ask the piercer to put them in. A proper piercing place might be off putting for a young child tho Maria Tash is £££ but more Claire's like. To be honest I had mine done with a gun x3 and they healed fine. Piercing guns can't go in an autoclave but can be sterilised with liquids.

WiddlinDiddlin · 14/11/2022 21:47

Pearfacebanana · 14/11/2022 21:14

Genuine question if you don't use the gun, how do they do it with a needle?

https://youtube.com/shorts/YRwvq9uueYU?feature=share

This is useful though I am not sure what they're using might be fake skin like piercers use to practice on...

The gun clamps the ear around where the hole will be, and then the spring loaded mechanism forces the post of the stud through the flesh of the earlobe.

Whilst some posts are pointier than others, none of the ones available for use with guns could be described as actually sharp. So theres likely a lot of crush and bruising. The gun can fail to force the post all the way through or in some cases (generally via poorly trained staff) the gun can cause part of the stud to end up inside the ear lobe (this also can happen if the lobe is infected and swells hugely).

The needle method uses a forceps clamp to clamp the ear around where the hole is marked to go, and then the needle is pushed through - as it is SO sharp it goes through very easily and so there is far less chance of bruising or crushing (though if someone is heavy handed with the clamps that can happen. It is less likely as its much easier to see the ear lobe with this method, there isn't a clunky gun in the way).

Then once the needle is through the earring is put in the end of the hollow needle, pull back and that pulls the post through the hole and the ball or sparkly front is screwed on. These flat back types are much more comfy, theres no pokey end sticking out of a butterfly cap, and they have enough room to allow for the ear swelling slightly.

Some people don't clamp - they use the back of the needle cap to provide resistance - you can see it clearly here ignore what he's doing threading the sleeper through both holes, its the same piercing type.

Here he uses a needle with a sleeve, remove needle, leave sleeve, push the post or the sleeper up the sleeve and pull that back to leave the post/sleeper in the new hole.

As you can see from the first video... this is quick and very low pain when done properly.

I had my first piercings done in a jewellers with a gun and they HURT, all subsequent piercings done in a piercers, with a needle, including tongue - verrrrrry little pain indeed and much faster healing too.

Energeticenoch · 14/11/2022 21:41

Meh, we did Claire’s, no issues this is a total MN thing. It’s not an issue

Mahanii · 14/11/2022 21:35

We had a really good experience at Claires - the piercer explained everything as she was going along, was so reassuring to my daughter, drew the holes on first and let us check and double check, got another piercer to come and do the other ear at the same time, paused while my daughter had a little panic, gave her as much time as she needed then eventually did it quickly and painlessly - no infection afterwards and my daughter remembers it as a positive experience.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 14/11/2022 21:34

Piercing guns are the problem, no matter who is using them, Claire's or otherwise. They can't be cleaned properly because they're plastic and can't be autoclaved. The store's arguments are that only the stud touches the ear therefore the practice is safe: discount this. Cross contamination is still possible. Detritus from the blunt force required to lodge the stud into the ear will still be present because it can't be autoclaved off.

I can't believe these places are still licensed to use these things. And please tell me they are not being used on cartilage?

For me it would be needles or nothing (and I never had any less than 1.6 gauge because it reduces the risk of migration). Rings are best for healing but you can get some pretty longer barbells with stones in the balls.

I'd say your response was spot on, OP.

WiddlinDiddlin · 14/11/2022 21:25

user1471550451 · 14/11/2022 18:35

The guns use single sterile cartridges so are perfectly sanitary.
Piercing guns are acceptable if they are piercing lines not cartilage . With a gun you can do both ears at the same time - I have had both kinds of piercing and there is no way after the first one went in either of my it kids would sit for the second with a needle piercing . Claire’s is fine .

No you can't.

With TWO guns and TWO people, you can pierce both ears at the same time.

You can also have two piercers with needles doing that at the same time.

Whatwouldscullydo · 14/11/2022 21:24

Ha I went all the way to a " reputable place " having looked at reviews and sent emails to clarify the use of needles etc when I went to get dd1s done. The tattooist/piercer promptly took the earrings dd chose and used the plastic packing they were in to pierce her ears. To he fair there was no noise. It wasn't actually too painful and they were straight. Unfortunately dd got made to take them out at school several months later and was unable to get them back in. Like her dad she pretty much heels the instant they are removed.

We attempted a second time several years later and they were done with a needle. Slightly wonky it has to be said and despite having been in for 9/10 months when the ball fell off the front ajd the earring fell out we still couldn't get anything back in after .

Still wouldn't use Claires though

Pearfacebanana · 14/11/2022 21:14

Genuine question if you don't use the gun, how do they do it with a needle?

Katkinsgreyy · 14/11/2022 20:32

I got mine done there when I was 10. I'm 30 now!
I remember 2 staff members pierced my ears at the same time. One side the gun got stuck and the jewellery was kind of half in half out!

Anjo2011 · 14/11/2022 20:22

If there is anywhere that pierces with a needle that would be my first choice every time . More accurate and hygienic. I would also go for real gold earrings. Both of my dds have had piercings with a needle, no problems at all.

Snugglemonkey · 14/11/2022 20:08

user1471550451 · 14/11/2022 18:35

The guns use single sterile cartridges so are perfectly sanitary.
Piercing guns are acceptable if they are piercing lines not cartilage . With a gun you can do both ears at the same time - I have had both kinds of piercing and there is no way after the first one went in either of my it kids would sit for the second with a needle piercing . Claire’s is fine .

If your kids cannot sit for a second, they are definitely not ready to have their ears pierced!

walkersareback · 14/11/2022 19:53

OhmygodDont · 14/11/2022 18:00

A certain group of people tend to use claires. The same kinda group who tend get their babies ears done before they are even dry and I don’t mean those who do it for cultural reasons.

Those who wait and still use Claire’s tend to not be very well educated on the risks of such things and just see it as a fun girly mummy trip to buy pretty things and pretty earrings.

That's a little harsh. My dd has hers done at Claire's - only done by the manager - who was excellent. She didn't do the actual piercing until we we're absolutely happy with the position - little black dot on earlobe. No problems at all re infection or pain.

Many years ago I had mine done at a jewellers - uneven and painful - had them redone - with a gun although not at Claire's ( I am very old no Claire's in my time) I have not had any problems.

Snugglemonkey · 14/11/2022 19:48

Yanbu. I will never, ever consent to any child if mine being pierced at Claire's. I do not understand how they still get that business given that the issues with using them are so well known.

workingeverysingkeday · 14/11/2022 19:43

Hdaniels11 · 14/11/2022 18:22

Thanks for the advice! I've compromised with her and said she can pick out a pair of earrings in Claire's and get them pierced at a different place.

I wouldn't be putting their crap earrings in either.
Get some proper metals. Titanium gold or silver.

Genevieva · 14/11/2022 19:39

If necessary tell her some horror stories. The girls in Claire's get 5 minutes training. The gun they use cannot be cleaned properly and they are not subject to the health and safety inspections that piercing / tattoo parlours are subject to. The place we took my daughter to regularly gets girls who have been to Claire's and then suffered complications - anything from wonky piecing, to infections that meant the piercing had to heal up and be redone, to the piercing gun getting stuck on the child's ear and the shop assistant in Claire's being unable to release it.

pocketvenuss · 14/11/2022 19:37

Seriously, the idea that some part time barely trained shop staff will put holes in your ears is just such an incredibly crazy idea. How about getting them to give you a tattoo and colour your hair whilst they are at it. Hell why not go all the way and ask if they would do some eye correction surgery at the same time

December11 · 14/11/2022 19:35

DD got her ears pierced in Claires about 6 years ago. They were misaligned, and one was pierced way too close to the edge of her ear.
met had to let it heal, and then went to a piercing studio who did a much better job.

recently was in Claires where there was only one sales assistant, she was so stressed between doing piercings and also managing the till. It’s not the right environment for piercings, would avoid.

pocketvenuss · 14/11/2022 19:31

mathanxiety · 14/11/2022 18:02

@OhmygodDont

Did you mean to come across as such a caricature of snobbery?

The problem is, Claire's is a retail store. They are not regulated as a piercer. As a result they don't need to have the council health and safety checks and certifications that piercing places have. Proper piercing places and tattooists have to be certificated. They are regularly checked. No warning hygiene checks are done by the council. I wouldn't eat from a food establishment that held a 1 star food hygiene score. I also wouldn't have any piercings by an unregulated, non hygiene checked shop performed by a shop person who handles money, stock and has no idea about sterilising anything let alone their hands. But each to their own.

Brendabigbaps · 14/11/2022 19:20

Professional piercer (piercing studio, tattoo parlour) all the way.
no jewellery shops, they’re just as bad as Claire’s.

LuckyStone · 14/11/2022 19:19

Do NOT go to Claires for this. I have a friend who used to work at Claires and I know her stories about the ear piercings... You do not want that for your DD trust me.

newtb · 14/11/2022 19:09

Back in the day - 50 years ago, we weren't allowed jewellry at school, so all had them done just before VIth form as we didn't wear uniform. 9 seems far too young to me, too.

WonderingWanda · 14/11/2022 19:00

I read all about it before my dd got hers done earlier this year We picked a reputable place that did lots of piercings with a needle and not a gun, they were lovely and it was all very clean. We pa aid extra for the expensive titanium non allergenic earrings, bought the aftercare, followed all the instructions and they just won't heal. Her ears immediately came out in bruises which the Internet assured me was one of the side effects of using a gun and that wouldn't happen with a needle. Then we did the 6 weeks, they looked healed so we took them out, she tried a pair of gold earrings (which we cleaned) and her ears reacted and got an infection. Went back to original earrings and cleaning everyday and it's now been another 6 weeks and they are still scabbing and bleeding but not infected. I got my ears pierced with a gun as a kid and they were fine after a few weeks. Not sure that there isn't a bit of ear piercing snobbery out there really. Did everything the right way and have had no end of problems. I think that some people's ears are just more sensitive than others.

1982mommaof4 · 14/11/2022 19:00

We went to Claire's and paid over the odd, just for my daughter's ear to become infected and now she cannot wear earrings