Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To , just once ,ask is anyone else fed up of being the squeezed middle?

535 replies

Wildandallthatjazz · 14/11/2022 17:12

Thats it really. !

Yes , on mn , its seen as a privilege to have a mortgage, a job etc .

But sometimes it feels hard and you just wish that you got a break . Recognition of the hard slog maybe .

I am not begrudging those on benefits who got the extra payment support, its more about just wanting to have a treat / a bonus/ etc .. a spare bit of money.. a boost .. the heating on … or maybe recognition that the middle can struggle too ?

I totally accept that people can struggle and need help , sort of also feel the struggling middle are invisible ? ( and not seen to have the’ right ‘to have a little moan as it does you good sometimes )

I do think we are incredibly lucky to live in a county with a welfare state, nhs, free gp care I really do .
But sometimes, it just would be nice not to feel you are paying taxes , working as much as possible, and to be able not to feel squeezed all the time and the need to just have a grump about it .

sometimes it is good to let of steam .. when you cant IRL

and then you move on in a more positive fashion .

OP posts:
namechanging21 · 14/11/2022 21:17

Endwalker · 14/11/2022 20:49

For those who think loads of people are playing the system, benefit fraud makes up a tiny percentage of the overall welfare spend and by tiny I mean around 1-2%.

The total number of people claiming DWP benefits is around 23 million. Of that around 12.5 million are pensioners, 9.5 million are working age, and the remainder are children in receipt of Disability Living Allowance.

There will be some.overlap where people are claiming more than one benefit but of that 9.5 million working age adults, around 1.9 million are in receipt of ESA (what used to be part of Incapacity Benefit). 1.3 million are in receipt of Carers Allowance. Around 2.7 million are in receipt of PIP.

Around 5.6 million receive Universal Credit. Around 40% of these are in work. The remainder are either in the 'looking for work' category meaning they have requirements to meet or else face sanctions, or they are in the 'no requirement to work' category meaning they are unable to work for specific reasons (e.g., caring responsibilities, disability, etc).

There are only around 301,000 claimants in the 'looking for work' category who have been unemployed for more than a year - a small percentage of the 5.6 million in receipt of UC.

DWPs own estimate is 4% of benefit expenditure was £8.6 billion lost due to Fraud and Error in 21/22.

£8.6 billion!

Lauren1983 · 14/11/2022 21:16

QualityAndQuantity · 14/11/2022 21:11

That’s hard for your DP, if he’s on minimum wage (or very close to it) yet having to do shifts. Is that a permanent arrangement?

Yes permanent. The shifts are not too bad really 6.30am to 3.30pm and 9.30am to 6pm. In his last job he did nights one week and days the next which was a lot worse.

Erber · 14/11/2022 21:15

Absolutely. I would consider myself to be in this category even though we don't have a mortgage. Over the past 10 years myself and partner have always worked, mostly full time except when I was on mat leave and for a couple of years when I was a student I worked part time. We've always been low earners and we're previously entitled to some child tax credit to top up our income.

Last year myself and my partner both got new jobs and in doing so doubled our household income. We've been very frugal over the last year paying off debt we accrued over the last few years (due to simply not having enough coming in to cover the bills). We haven't seen any benefit at all for our hard work and lost our entitlement to benefits, so no help with cost of living crisis. We've lost far more than We've gained. It's a massive kick in the teeth to work so hard and never get anywhere. We live in a high poverty area (because that's the only place we can afford to rent) and it is frustrating that 90% of people are unemployed yet have more disposable income than us. I don't blame them at all, I blame the people in charge!

WindyKnickers · 14/11/2022 21:15

I think one of the problems is that we have, as a country, certainly the middle classes and upper WC, had it pretty good for a long time until recently. Very low interest rates have meant people have big mortgages and big houses, we have got used to having nice cars on finance, regular foreign holidays, disposable income to spend on whatever. All things that were very nice but were only there because the cost of living was actually artificially low. Now we have the perfect storm of post Brexit, post covid spending, war in Europe and the financial markets are taking the strain but as previous interest rates were very low for a very long time we now struggle to adjust our lifestyles to what we can afford. I'm not sure more government hand outs is the answer really. I think we all need a wake up call that actually frittering our money away was a luxury and that isn't the way forward. Downsizing our lives (fewer "treats", smaller mortgages etc) and reducing our expectations is probably where we need to head.

ghostyslovesheets · 14/11/2022 21:12

maybe look to the employers who used the furlough scheme to pay workers while being very rich themselves - people whose workplaces were closed had no choice - did you expect bar staff to go and stand in empty pubs all night?

QualityAndQuantity · 14/11/2022 21:11

Lauren1983 · 14/11/2022 21:06

I work 2 days a week not one. Sorry if that was not clear. My DP gets a set hourly wage, the shifts are just standard - no extra pay. The overtime is not guaranteed. It might push us up a grand or two at most and then we will probably have to pay back the £600 tax credits we have been given this year.

That’s hard for your DP, if he’s on minimum wage (or very close to it) yet having to do shifts. Is that a permanent arrangement?

MidnightMeltdown · 14/11/2022 21:10

Endwalker · 14/11/2022 20:49

For those who think loads of people are playing the system, benefit fraud makes up a tiny percentage of the overall welfare spend and by tiny I mean around 1-2%.

The total number of people claiming DWP benefits is around 23 million. Of that around 12.5 million are pensioners, 9.5 million are working age, and the remainder are children in receipt of Disability Living Allowance.

There will be some.overlap where people are claiming more than one benefit but of that 9.5 million working age adults, around 1.9 million are in receipt of ESA (what used to be part of Incapacity Benefit). 1.3 million are in receipt of Carers Allowance. Around 2.7 million are in receipt of PIP.

Around 5.6 million receive Universal Credit. Around 40% of these are in work. The remainder are either in the 'looking for work' category meaning they have requirements to meet or else face sanctions, or they are in the 'no requirement to work' category meaning they are unable to work for specific reasons (e.g., caring responsibilities, disability, etc).

There are only around 301,000 claimants in the 'looking for work' category who have been unemployed for more than a year - a small percentage of the 5.6 million in receipt of UC.

In work maybe, but what about full time work? Many people will work just a few hours a week so that they can claim as much as possible.

dorib · 14/11/2022 21:09

I guess it is a matter of opinion, but I feel that is pretty unfair and I hope payment for furlough will be loaded towards those that benefited from it.

I see this argument constantly & it makes me despair at the lack of intelligence! How can you not pay someone when you have forced their job to stop? And no I wasn't furloughed & yes I worked throughout. The idea that you can do a lockdown & prevent people from working & tell them to stay home but without any money is dumber than dumb.

Lauren1983 · 14/11/2022 21:06

QualityAndQuantity · 14/11/2022 20:31

Those numbers don’t add up. Just working 40 hours per week is £20,000 per year on minimum wage, and you’re then getting over £5,000 per year for your one day per week.

How can your total income be only this if your husband is doing shirt work and also getting lots of overtime?

I work 2 days a week not one. Sorry if that was not clear. My DP gets a set hourly wage, the shifts are just standard - no extra pay. The overtime is not guaranteed. It might push us up a grand or two at most and then we will probably have to pay back the £600 tax credits we have been given this year.

BosaNova · 14/11/2022 21:04

Stressedmum2017 · 14/11/2022 20:58

I've been both and its far harder and more miserable being a single parent topped up by benefits, renting. Yeah it is tough not being completely loaded like some but would I swap and be in the position I was in a few years ago? Absolutely not, and if everyone was honest, none of you would swap.

That's what makes me laugh about all those complaining about benefit claimers living the life of riley, yet don't do it themselves because truth is if they were genuinely convinced they would be better off they could all jack their jobs in tomorrow and join the housing register but they dont because deep down they know full well they wouldn't be better off.

It may come you know. This is fairly new to many people. Once they get into minus in a bit, they might really be in exact same financial situation as if they were on benefits....

VeronicaFranklin · 14/11/2022 21:03

Yep I agree,

I mentioned something on here a while back about how those with a two working parent household who aren't entitled to any help with childcare costs will struggle in current climate...and honestly it became a competition of who was worst off between everyone.

I got told just because me and my DH both work (although I'm on mat leave atm) and we have an affordable mortgage we worked hard to get and we live within our means that we are lucky and aren't allowed to complain that we will struggle with current cost of living.

Everyone will struggle, some more than others. There is always someone better and someone worse off than you. Doesn't mean you can't complain about how you are feeling or your personal circumstances. Everyone's situation is different.

Of course I feel for those reliant purely on benefits, especially those with ill health who aren't able to work or try better their situation, but that isn't to say I can't also be allowed to say actually as a two working parent household I'm scared to put the heating on with a 4 month old baby who is currently asleep beside me in two vests, a sleep suit and 3.5 tog grobag...and that I'm worried about not being financially viable for me to go back to work because of the cost of childcare taking all of my salary effectively meaning I'll be working full time just to cover cost of someone else looking after my DD.

I think everyone just needs to have a bit of understanding that most people will suffer in the current climate one way or another and that we all need to be more gentle with one another.

Foolsandtheirmoney · 14/11/2022 21:02

Ijustreallyoveogs · 14/11/2022 17:27

We are the squeezed middle and definitely are going without things .
We do not put the heating on .
I am in bed straight after work.
We dont eat any meat.
We live on lentils.. tofu.. veg.
We cant afford holidays, any treatments like nails done.
Am actually anxious about adult dc coming home for christmas as I will have to put the heating on for them ,as well as I am worried about the cost of feeding them.
If I was on benefits , then I feel I would be justified in complaining, but because we have a mortage and are squeezed middle I would indeed say I feel invisible .

I'm really curious what makes you think you are in the 'squeezed middle'? If you can't afford heating and food you sound pretty poor to me, not 'middle'. Are people like you just the 'aspirational middle' when you are poor but don't want to think of yourself that way?

I'm not in the UK but we have a below average income right now due to some health issues I am having and we live better than you. If you are considered 'the middle' in the UK then what is poor?

I'm not picking on you inparticular your post just stood out.

dorib · 14/11/2022 21:01

find people often quote the house price judging it on today's income - yes it looks like anyone could buy a house - but the reality was different. Many people stretched themselves like they do today, and 15% interest rates caused many people to lose their homes.

The point is the disparity between houses & income & the fact salaries have seen hardly any growth in the last 20 years.

MetellaInHortoEst · 14/11/2022 21:00

transformandriseup · 14/11/2022 17:45

I hear you.

However, having grown up in the 80s/90s in a one parent family on benefits living in social housing I can hand on heart say that I would rather be the squeezed middle that I am now than how it was then. Yes, I'd like a pay rise to match inflation. Yes, I'd like my mortgage interest rate not to be 5%. Yes I'd like my electricity to cost what it did 12 months ago. But it isn't as bad as living through a recession at the bottom of the pile.

I agree, I grew up in a household reliant on benefits and I don't envy anyone who has no choice but to claim. Me being envious of those who receive handouts is not going to improve my own situation.

Only on MN are the professional classes this open about envying the poor. I had a flirtation with poverty. I agree nobody here would like it.

Stressedmum2017 · 14/11/2022 20:58

I've been both and its far harder and more miserable being a single parent topped up by benefits, renting. Yeah it is tough not being completely loaded like some but would I swap and be in the position I was in a few years ago? Absolutely not, and if everyone was honest, none of you would swap.

That's what makes me laugh about all those complaining about benefit claimers living the life of riley, yet don't do it themselves because truth is if they were genuinely convinced they would be better off they could all jack their jobs in tomorrow and join the housing register but they dont because deep down they know full well they wouldn't be better off.

CopOut27 · 14/11/2022 20:57

The stats are something like this:

68m population
12m pensioners
8m in education (not including higher)
0.5m disabled

Then of the working population:
6m receive UC

In total 23m people claim some form of DWP benefit (and can receive more than 1). That’s a third of the population.

—

Everyone pays tax on goods bought but do the maths on income tax and the people who don’t receive direct payment benefits (ie. the middle and higher earners) and who aren’t baby boomer pensioners have a huge tax burden, along with corporation tax, stamp duty and IHT etc.

ghostyslovesheets · 14/11/2022 20:55

Endwalker · 14/11/2022 20:49

For those who think loads of people are playing the system, benefit fraud makes up a tiny percentage of the overall welfare spend and by tiny I mean around 1-2%.

The total number of people claiming DWP benefits is around 23 million. Of that around 12.5 million are pensioners, 9.5 million are working age, and the remainder are children in receipt of Disability Living Allowance.

There will be some.overlap where people are claiming more than one benefit but of that 9.5 million working age adults, around 1.9 million are in receipt of ESA (what used to be part of Incapacity Benefit). 1.3 million are in receipt of Carers Allowance. Around 2.7 million are in receipt of PIP.

Around 5.6 million receive Universal Credit. Around 40% of these are in work. The remainder are either in the 'looking for work' category meaning they have requirements to meet or else face sanctions, or they are in the 'no requirement to work' category meaning they are unable to work for specific reasons (e.g., caring responsibilities, disability, etc).

There are only around 301,000 claimants in the 'looking for work' category who have been unemployed for more than a year - a small percentage of the 5.6 million in receipt of UC.

Thank you for posting this - honestly the number of people on MN who think people on benefits are all workshy and lazy is frustrating.

also the current estimated cost of HS2 is £106bn - for comparison - still it makes my journey to London 5 mins shorter! yippy!

MichelleScarn · 14/11/2022 20:55

For those who think loads of people are playing the system, benefit fraud makes up a tiny percentage of the overall welfare spend and by tiny I mean around 1-2%.

if the government know these people must be easy to stop, or is that number those who are actually caught and convicted?

thesurrealist · 14/11/2022 20:52

Sorry but I can't begrudge any scheme that benefits children, particularly those from demographics known to be at a disadvantage. Improving outcomes for these children is vital.

I don't think anyone begrudges children help, but there are adults who also need help to support them now. It's all very well considering future tax payers, but to do so at the disadvantage of current tax payers seems ridiculous.

MidnightMeltdown · 14/11/2022 20:51

BuwchGochGota · 14/11/2022 17:40

I hear you.

However, having grown up in the 80s/90s in a one parent family on benefits living in social housing I can hand on heart say that I would rather be the squeezed middle that I am now than how it was then. Yes, I'd like a pay rise to match inflation. Yes, I'd like my mortgage interest rate not to be 5%. Yes I'd like my electricity to cost what it did 12 months ago. But it isn't as bad as living through a recession at the bottom of the pile.

So did I, but benefits are a lot more generous these days than they were then

Endwalker · 14/11/2022 20:49

For those who think loads of people are playing the system, benefit fraud makes up a tiny percentage of the overall welfare spend and by tiny I mean around 1-2%.

The total number of people claiming DWP benefits is around 23 million. Of that around 12.5 million are pensioners, 9.5 million are working age, and the remainder are children in receipt of Disability Living Allowance.

There will be some.overlap where people are claiming more than one benefit but of that 9.5 million working age adults, around 1.9 million are in receipt of ESA (what used to be part of Incapacity Benefit). 1.3 million are in receipt of Carers Allowance. Around 2.7 million are in receipt of PIP.

Around 5.6 million receive Universal Credit. Around 40% of these are in work. The remainder are either in the 'looking for work' category meaning they have requirements to meet or else face sanctions, or they are in the 'no requirement to work' category meaning they are unable to work for specific reasons (e.g., caring responsibilities, disability, etc).

There are only around 301,000 claimants in the 'looking for work' category who have been unemployed for more than a year - a small percentage of the 5.6 million in receipt of UC.

ThatsGoingToHurt · 14/11/2022 20:48

I’m lucky but feel like I’m stuck between a rock and and a hard place. Both me and DH work FT. I’m permanently exhausted from having 2 under 5. Stuck with paying full nursery fees for the next 10 months until the funded hours kicks in. Can’t afford any help e.g. a cleaner to take some of the load. I’m the higher earner so if I drop to PT we will take a massive hit on our finances and it won’t be worth it. If I did drop my hours we wouldn’t qualify for any extra help.

Ironically, once DS gets the funded hours I may be able to cut my hours but from now until he’s 3.4 it’s a slog. Paying nursery fees since 2018, having a pandemic and losing my job, etc has reduced our savings to zero.

Cuppasoupmonster · 14/11/2022 20:48

ShiningStarQueen · 14/11/2022 20:26

Such crap advice. If you go part time then you pay less into your pension so you’ll still be poor when your old 🙄

Why is pension potential the only yardstick of financial success or happiness on here? If I could go part time and get a top up I would - fuck the pension, why spend my life busting my ass for what will be an underwhelming retirement anyway?

thesurrealist · 14/11/2022 20:46

Yes I do. I'm on my own with a mortgage and my dad has just moved in with me because he can no longer afford his rent. I'm not a bad earner, but feeling so stretched as I'm financially supporting my dad, my bills have increased because he's with me and I, still helping out my brother who is living in a flat after moving from the house he and dad lived in, but he's earning NMW so can't afford to be completely independent.
I get no help at all.

MooseAndSquirrelLoveFlannel · 14/11/2022 20:39

I am a JAM

Just....About.....Managing

By summer next year we will be in the not managing at all cohort.

Mix of increased mortgage, increased utilities, increased council tax etc etc etc.

What's scary is, we have a pretty decent salary! Yet I have less money now than when I earned £23k a year!!