Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To , just once ,ask is anyone else fed up of being the squeezed middle?

535 replies

Wildandallthatjazz · 14/11/2022 17:12

Thats it really. !

Yes , on mn , its seen as a privilege to have a mortgage, a job etc .

But sometimes it feels hard and you just wish that you got a break . Recognition of the hard slog maybe .

I am not begrudging those on benefits who got the extra payment support, its more about just wanting to have a treat / a bonus/ etc .. a spare bit of money.. a boost .. the heating on … or maybe recognition that the middle can struggle too ?

I totally accept that people can struggle and need help , sort of also feel the struggling middle are invisible ? ( and not seen to have the’ right ‘to have a little moan as it does you good sometimes )

I do think we are incredibly lucky to live in a county with a welfare state, nhs, free gp care I really do .
But sometimes, it just would be nice not to feel you are paying taxes , working as much as possible, and to be able not to feel squeezed all the time and the need to just have a grump about it .

sometimes it is good to let of steam .. when you cant IRL

and then you move on in a more positive fashion .

OP posts:
dorib · 14/11/2022 22:09

Of course there is an issue of loopholes and corporation tax, but on an individual level the wealthy are already being heavily taxed.

Are they?

BlackcurrantSorbet · 14/11/2022 22:07

@Spectre8 I agree at how single people are treated. The main thing to fix this is to equalise the tax thresholds so that they are based on household/ family unit. A couple living together should not get twice the tax free allowance that a single adult household does. Or earn twice as much before paying higher rate tax etc. Fixing that would solve a lot of poverty, for both single people and single parent households and be entirely fair.

dorib · 14/11/2022 22:07

Do you mean wage earners paying through PAYE, or all earners?

Quite, the rich don't tend to be on paye

XingMing · 14/11/2022 22:07

Local property taxes in the US, which fund council type spending including school/education costs, typically account for most local government spends.

FacebookPhotos · 14/11/2022 22:06

1% of earners are on over 160k.

Do you mean wage earners paying through PAYE, or all earners?

Either way, I’d (slowly) increase minimum wage. Which would reduce the benefits bill and increase income tax intake. We’d be paying more for some state employees (or those indirectly employed by the state). But, ultimately, we’d be pushing the burden of paying workers away from the state and back on to businesses. If your business cannot function whilst paying at least enough to cover housing, food and heating, then your business is not viable.

The welfare state should exist for those unable to work. Whether that be long term due to disability, or short term job-seeking. It shouldn’t be there to subsidise businesses, and their owners.

PeloFondo · 14/11/2022 22:04

Spectre8 · 14/11/2022 20:29

The most invisible of all is the single childfree person, who regardless of political party is never given any help. There are benefits for vulnerable people, poor people, families with children, the elderly.

The best we get is a meagre 25% off council tax, yet we still end up paying more than a household with 2 incomes who split the bills yet will use more services and pay less per person for it.

So any empathy for other sectors that moan just gets less and less now because there is alot of help provided. As a single childree free person the taxes I pay help pretty much every section of society and I barely get any help. Its grtting the point where anytime I here of more help to be given I just think fuck off.

Same here

VillageCottageEmo · 14/11/2022 22:03

Having been raised on a council estate, then been a poor, single mother in a private rented house, to what I am now - a squeezed, middle class, home owning, decent earning still single mother, I know what I prefer being.

Difference is, I’m now choosing to not eat meat any more, be more frugal with the heating, invested in smart bulbs/plugs, etc. I have choices.

A decade ago, I had no choices. I had one meal a day, made from Smart Price ingredients, debt racking up on the pre pay gas meter due to standing charges, debt collectors hounding me for the thousands my abusive ex racked up in my name, me and DD1 wore hats in the bed we shared as I could only afford to plug the (from Freecycle) electric heater on in one room, I spent my days in the library to try and keep warm, I was in the thick of PTSD and suicidal.

So nah, this ain’t that.

But if you’ve never, not even for a second, had to genuinely stop and think about spending money, then I can see how this would feel like hardship.

MarshaBradyo · 14/11/2022 22:00

Cuppasoupmonster · 14/11/2022 21:55

The problem is the U.K. public require more spending than ever. We’re obese, unhealthy and ageing with dwindling younger population. People expect government intervention in virtually every aspect of their lives. But we’re not making any more money to keep up, and the lockdowns have basically tipped us over the edge.

Agree with all this but final straw lockdowns and war too. Energy inflation has been a killer after demands for lockdown.

XingMing · 14/11/2022 21:58

It might be a good idea to recalculate council tax every time a property was sold.

Cuppasoupmonster · 14/11/2022 21:57

QualityAndQuantity · 14/11/2022 21:53

I think that most lower and middle earners have no idea how heavily the highest earners are taxed. The assumption is that they all dodge most of it whereas the facts are that the top 1% of earners in the UK earn 14% of all wages but pay 30% of all income tax.

Exactly. Of course there is an issue of loopholes and corporation tax, but on an individual level the wealthy are already being heavily taxed.

Covetthee · 14/11/2022 21:56

WindyKnickers · 14/11/2022 21:15

I think one of the problems is that we have, as a country, certainly the middle classes and upper WC, had it pretty good for a long time until recently. Very low interest rates have meant people have big mortgages and big houses, we have got used to having nice cars on finance, regular foreign holidays, disposable income to spend on whatever. All things that were very nice but were only there because the cost of living was actually artificially low. Now we have the perfect storm of post Brexit, post covid spending, war in Europe and the financial markets are taking the strain but as previous interest rates were very low for a very long time we now struggle to adjust our lifestyles to what we can afford. I'm not sure more government hand outs is the answer really. I think we all need a wake up call that actually frittering our money away was a luxury and that isn't the way forward. Downsizing our lives (fewer "treats", smaller mortgages etc) and reducing our expectations is probably where we need to head.

Sorry this is incredibly depressing

Most people havent chosen to have high mortgages, we’ve just had no choice! its either rent and pay someone else’s mortgage or take what was given for bog standard 2/3 bedroom house. Some people (not you) are making out like we’re living in mansions

the squeezed middle being spoken of are all in normal houses, nothing extravagant.

as for ‘frittering’ money away, god forbid people actually enjoyed a bit of their money that they fucking worked for!

sorry not having a go at you but its this general attitude of people had it too good for too long and it MUST come crashing down, it could have continued for most people if we had a competent government who actually had their People’s interest at heart rather their own pockets.

dorib · 14/11/2022 21:56

There is far too much burden on income tax & yes I include the people earning 160k. We need more wealth tax, so increased CGT, IHT, dividends etc I would also base council tax on house value as a % like France

Cuppasoupmonster · 14/11/2022 21:55

The problem is the U.K. public require more spending than ever. We’re obese, unhealthy and ageing with dwindling younger population. People expect government intervention in virtually every aspect of their lives. But we’re not making any more money to keep up, and the lockdowns have basically tipped us over the edge.

MarshaBradyo · 14/11/2022 21:54

QualityAndQuantity · 14/11/2022 21:53

I think that most lower and middle earners have no idea how heavily the highest earners are taxed. The assumption is that they all dodge most of it whereas the facts are that the top 1% of earners in the UK earn 14% of all wages but pay 30% of all income tax.

yeh I think looking at tax burden is a good way to see it

XingMing · 14/11/2022 21:53

It's called fiscal drag. The Chancellor stops allowing inflation increases to raise the tax thresholds... at every level.

QualityAndQuantity · 14/11/2022 21:53

Cuppasoupmonster · 14/11/2022 21:48

Okay, I’m questioning it. What now? Nothings going to change. 1% of earners are on over 160k. However if you earn 160k your take home is 94k, 66k will be tax. How much more do you think they should pay?

I think that most lower and middle earners have no idea how heavily the highest earners are taxed. The assumption is that they all dodge most of it whereas the facts are that the top 1% of earners in the UK earn 14% of all wages but pay 30% of all income tax.

QualityAndQuantity · 14/11/2022 21:51

FacebookPhotos · 14/11/2022 21:38

Nothing seems to be an even playing field and the ‘middle’ seems the easiest target.

And will continue to be. As long as those in power can count on the “middle” turning against the poorest rather than questioning who exactly is making shedloads of money right now. Because you can get your bottom dollar that almost nobody in the top 5% gives a crap about the CoL crisis.

But this government has moved the tax burden significantly upwards. We’ve a higher additional rate of tax than under Labour, most tax benefits have been removed from higher earners, the tax- free allowance included, while minimum wage has increased by far more than inflation and the tax-free allowance for lower earners has been significantly increased.

Cuppasoupmonster · 14/11/2022 21:48

FacebookPhotos · 14/11/2022 21:38

Nothing seems to be an even playing field and the ‘middle’ seems the easiest target.

And will continue to be. As long as those in power can count on the “middle” turning against the poorest rather than questioning who exactly is making shedloads of money right now. Because you can get your bottom dollar that almost nobody in the top 5% gives a crap about the CoL crisis.

Okay, I’m questioning it. What now? Nothings going to change. 1% of earners are on over 160k. However if you earn 160k your take home is 94k, 66k will be tax. How much more do you think they should pay?

namechanging21 · 14/11/2022 21:46

BosaNova · 14/11/2022 19:43

Well I am mid 30s and I am 100% positive there will be no pension by the time I reach the required age of 178...

Now seriously, I don't count on getting state pension

You might want to look away now @BosaNova, but if you work and pay into a pension on top of everything else during your working life there are those that now think you shouldn't get a state pension anyway! I've read threads/comments on here recently (and on a Radio 5 Live phone in so not just planet MN) that those of us with an occupational or private pension shouldn't receive a state pension as well because that's unfair!!

CurlyhairedAssassin · 14/11/2022 21:45

thecatsthecats · 14/11/2022 17:35

This probably isn't what you want to hear, but what the hell, it's what I think.

I think that the "squeezed middle" is a lot more normal a state for people than anything else. Being rich and being poor are quite artificial compared to having to work, cover your expenses and live a little.

99.99% of life on this planet for the entirety of history has to strive to survive and basically muddle through getting enough food, shelter etc.

It's only a very small percent of life on earth that is (artificially) resource rich, and a very small percent that is (artificially) resource poor. I don't find it useful to hanker after a standard of living and income which is more than needed.

(probably not popular, but like I say - it's a perspective that helps me)

I think the issue for most people is the double whammy of not only having less to do things that make life more pleasant, but working harder for it at the same time. That's the real kick in the gut. I work in education and have for many years. My first FT job after uni in the late 90s wasn't very well paid but the conditions and workload was fine, there was no pressure as staffing levels were adequate so all you needed to do was be great your job, reliable and a team player. It almost didn't matter that the pay was shit because the work was fine, and it covered the expenses of what made life pleasant for me, which was a drink in the pub with DH mid week and a bigger night at the weekend, maybe going to a gig, or staying in with a bottle of wine and a takeaway. I had a simple life and could manage it on my shitty salary so life was enjoyable and we didn't need or want many material things.

Now.....I am back in a similar grade of job. But bloody hell, the workload and pressure is not good at all. I have to work many hours unpaid to try and stay on top of things, which I NEVER had to do in my first job. DH has had a few promotions since we first met and is slogging his guts out for more money but he also wonders if it's all worth it. Workload, pressure and stress is horrendous.

We are of an age where we are starting to hear of people not much older than us who are having heart attacks or strokes and dying just after they've retired. I don't want to get to retirement age and feel like life has been just one long slog and then you die. We are really really really lucky in that due to an inheritance we have been able to pay our mortgage off so we have a roof over our head with no cost which I am very thankful for. But even we are noticing that the rest of our income is eaten up quickly.

If both our work pressures and workloads were the same as they were in our 20s, with salary much the same, I think price increases would be almost bearable. Liveable with anyway, because you'd understand that your money couldn't go as far. But now, everyone is working twice as hard for half the money. That's honestly what it feels like.

Can you tell I yearn for the late 90s?! The good old days!

Endwalker · 14/11/2022 21:45

BlackcurrantSorbet · 14/11/2022 21:41

I used to think like that too, but it's pretty shit to know that you and your children will be seen as a demographic who it's OK to take from, but isn't deserving of any help when needed.

Absolutely this. I have a well-paid job. But I'm also disabled, a lone parent with a mortgage and have two children with additional needs. We do not get any help, with anything, are penalised by the tax system for being a one-adult household, and are then told that we can afford to pay more. We can't.

You should do a benefits calculator as based on the information given you should consider applying for PIP for yourself and DLA for your children. This can then gateway entitlement to other benefits- for example, being in receipt of disability benefits could push you into the threshold for eligibility to UC, you may be entitled to additional discount on your council tax liability, you would be able to apply for a Max card to give you discounts on participating days out/attractions, you may be eligible for a blue badge, and so on.

VeronicaFranklin · 14/11/2022 21:44

Endwalker · 14/11/2022 21:24

And people do have sympathy with it. I wholeheartedly agree that it's a shit situation that is going to get even shittier for a lot of people but anger should be directed at the top. The government could mitigate against these issues, they could take measures to improve rhe situation,but they choose not to because they'd rather line their own pockets and those of their friends.

Having said that, punching down and taking it out on those at the bottom isn't going to magically improve your situation. If the government take away their benefits, they aren't going to hand it over to the middle. They're going to keep it and society is going to fracture even further alongside all the knock-on effects of increased poverty.

Having said that, punching down and taking it out on those at the bottom isn't going to magically improve your situation.

I wouldn't say I was taking anything out on 'those at the bottom' to improve my situation. What even defines you as being 'at the bottom' ?

Why is the assumption that all those entirely on benefits are 'at the bottom' I know a family who are solely on benefits and bring in more than my working household income combined. So they aren't 'at the bottom' by any means. It's naive to think that all people claiming benefits are worse off than those who aren't. But then I also know someone who has a disabled child who is a single parent is on benefits and can barely scrape by, has to access a food bank weekly and relies on the kindness of others.

The whole benefit system is flawed.

If the government take away their benefits, they aren't going to hand it over to the middle.

I wouldn't expect the government to take benefits off of anyone who genuinely needs it to 'hand it over' to the middle, but at the end of the day when it makes more financial sense for me to give up my full time job with the NHS which I love due to childcare costs which means I'd be working full time to pay all of my salary to someone else to care for my child, then the system is broken. No incentives anymore for parents to work anymore. It's sad. Which ultimately will mean more parents give up work, less people paying into the pot and more taking out.

BlackcurrantSorbet · 14/11/2022 21:41

I used to think like that too, but it's pretty shit to know that you and your children will be seen as a demographic who it's OK to take from, but isn't deserving of any help when needed.

Absolutely this. I have a well-paid job. But I'm also disabled, a lone parent with a mortgage and have two children with additional needs. We do not get any help, with anything, are penalised by the tax system for being a one-adult household, and are then told that we can afford to pay more. We can't.

FacebookPhotos · 14/11/2022 21:38

Nothing seems to be an even playing field and the ‘middle’ seems the easiest target.

And will continue to be. As long as those in power can count on the “middle” turning against the poorest rather than questioning who exactly is making shedloads of money right now. Because you can get your bottom dollar that almost nobody in the top 5% gives a crap about the CoL crisis.

Worriedpartner1234 · 14/11/2022 21:35

Yep. Nothing seems to be an even playing field and the ‘middle’ seems the easiest target.

A friend of mine falsely claims benefits and works cash in hand as a lash technician. She has 3 kids and gets around £1500 a month in universial credit + £300 from her ex partner. She has had 2 cost of living payments, free school meals, vouchers in holidays etc.

Swipe left for the next trending thread