Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To , just once ,ask is anyone else fed up of being the squeezed middle?

535 replies

Wildandallthatjazz · 14/11/2022 17:12

Thats it really. !

Yes , on mn , its seen as a privilege to have a mortgage, a job etc .

But sometimes it feels hard and you just wish that you got a break . Recognition of the hard slog maybe .

I am not begrudging those on benefits who got the extra payment support, its more about just wanting to have a treat / a bonus/ etc .. a spare bit of money.. a boost .. the heating on … or maybe recognition that the middle can struggle too ?

I totally accept that people can struggle and need help , sort of also feel the struggling middle are invisible ? ( and not seen to have the’ right ‘to have a little moan as it does you good sometimes )

I do think we are incredibly lucky to live in a county with a welfare state, nhs, free gp care I really do .
But sometimes, it just would be nice not to feel you are paying taxes , working as much as possible, and to be able not to feel squeezed all the time and the need to just have a grump about it .

sometimes it is good to let of steam .. when you cant IRL

and then you move on in a more positive fashion .

OP posts:
pavillion1 · 14/11/2022 22:47

And yet you lack the ability to look past your own set of circumstances.

No not at all , I'm working longer hours because my co workers are finically secure so they only need part time hours .. yet they'll get the bonus .

Babooshka1991 · 14/11/2022 22:46

Yes I agree, they take so much in tax, massive bill increases, gets worse every year. I had addict parents and worked so hard to get a postgraduate degree ( so big student loan payments too) and build a good career. But my sibling on benefits has more spare cash, better car, nice holidays .

Erber · 14/11/2022 22:46

@CopOut27 I guess, I don't have the answers and won't pretend to. Obviously we need to give people the incentive to work but I don't think cutting benefits or penalising people that work less is the right way to go about it. It would be nice if our current government could stop pissing money up the wall though.

The reality is wages have not kept up with inflation for a long time so in real terms people have been losing money for years. Considering that, then covid, brexit and the cost of living crisis average people just have nothing left to give.

It is demoralising constantly working our asses off and having nothing to show for it. We've paid off about 80% of our debt now but the last 20% will be much harder and take much longer because it costs so much more just to live. The reality is we'll probably never be able to come up with a deposit or get a mortgage. I haven't had a haircut since 2020, we've never had a family holiday, we have a 15 year old car that I consider essential because it would cost us 3x as much for both myself and my partner to commute to work than it costs to run.

It's also very difficult to try and teach my kids that hard work pays off when in reality they're seeing the opposite. When their school friend whose parents have 5 kids and have never worked a day in their lives can afford to have birthday parties, days out and a holiday every year. Again, not their fault, they seem lovely, their kids seem well looked after and I know very little of their situation other than what can be immediately seen from the outside. But it's hard to try and explain these things to them.

BlackcurrantSorbet · 14/11/2022 22:45

Why do people behave like this?

The fact is, it isn't the people on higher salaries but PAYE who are screwing over the poor. In fact they're the ones who've been keeping everything afloat since 2008. But mostly they have very little left to give now. As many posters have pointed out, the Government needs to be targeting business owners, capital, etc.

There is a huge difference between income and wealth, and PAYE income has been taxed already as far as is sustainable, because it's easier and politicians are lazy.

Cuppasoupmonster · 14/11/2022 22:44

VillageCottageEmo · 14/11/2022 22:37

I assume you support the strike action then?

I agree with you, but then there’s threads like this, with that haughty “let them eat cake” attitude and it’s so grim.

I have a PhD and busted my ass the entire pandemic, but I’m not here feeling pissed off that others got furlough, because my entire job is Public Health, thems the breaks. Nor do I resent people on criminally low wages, living in unstable housing getting extra help.

Perhaps the moaners could take their own advice that’s doled out here constantly recently?

  • Be gainfully employed not self employed
  • Skill up
  • Take a second job
  • Start a cleaning business

No, we need people to do ‘working class’ jobs. Middle class people’s kids aren’t generally going to be the ones collecting bins, delivering parcels, working in supermarkets or doing similar essential work.

I think savings need to be made with a personal responsibility drive. The majority of people are perfectly able to control their weight, drinking, smoking etc but choose not to and plead mental health, or just verbally abuse anyone who challenges them.

People should be planning for their retirement - this British culture of elderly people insisting on living in unsuitable rural homes is ruining the ambulance service. We need elderly people to live in retirement apartments and in better connected areas, and not just when they reach their 90s.

We should be deducting CMS payments straight from men’s wages.

Those are just a few ideas off the top of my head.

FacebookPhotos · 14/11/2022 22:44

This idea that you have that you are hard done-by and that those subsidising you have it too easy isn’t tenable.

Nobody is subsiding me. I work in the private sector and receive no benefits at all. Haven’t since I was a child - even then it was universal child benefit. You’d have to go back to when I was 4 and my single mum (often unable to feed herself) claiming benefits to class me as subsidised. Unless you count free schooling up to 18 as subsidy?! I don’t even rely on the NHS for non-emergency care anymore, I have private dental and health plans.

I don’t consider myself particularly hard done by. But I am deeply unhappy with the distribution of wealth in the country. I think it causes problems with cohesion in society and it says something pretty bad about us as a populace that we (collectively) are happy for those with wealth to get wealthier while the poorest get poorer.

QualityAndQuantity · 14/11/2022 22:43

dorib · 14/11/2022 22:39

What facts am I pulling out of my bottom? That the "rich" don't tend to be on paye? Or that people who are payed via a company pay less tax than those on paye?

From the article I linked

"According to the report, business income – from either self-employment or owning and running a company – accounts for 21% of total incomes for the top 1% of adults and 29% for the top 0.1%, compared with just 9% for the rest of the population at large."

"It said business owner-managers could effectively choose to take income out of their company through the form of a salary, dividends, or capital gains – allowing them to benefit from lower rates of tax."

The report pointed to a preferential 10% rate of capital gains tax, called business asset disposal relief, while saying that company owner-managers were able to access tax rates of just 27% on income taken in the form of capital gains."

"In comparison, the average tax rate on wage earners in the top 1% is 42%"

The facts about who pays what, overall, as per the data which I posted but which you seem to have not bothered to read.

BlackcurrantSorbet · 14/11/2022 22:42

I believe they said £600k revenue, not profit. And that they had started their business not long ago.

dorib · 14/11/2022 22:42

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

FlamingBells · 14/11/2022 22:42

I know what you mean, I've swapped a brilliant flexible but low paid job for the opposite with more money. I had to go for a higher paid job because bills were tight for a 1.5 wage household.

The job I had was brilliant especially during the holidays with full flexibility. This saved me so much money on childcare etc but just didn't pay enough to live. A lot of jobs don't pay enough for the work that they expect you to do. Dh earns a decent wage but we still wouldn't be able to live comfortably on his salary alone.

BosaNova · 14/11/2022 22:41

VillageCottageEmo · 14/11/2022 22:39

600K but you live next door to a NMW worker and SAHM who smokes? Cool story, bro.

Turnover is not a profit (sadly😂)

VillageCottageEmo · 14/11/2022 22:41

ganachee · 14/11/2022 22:40

The super rich are bleeding everyone dry. They also massively increased their wealth during covid.

Exactly. People are pointing the finger down, not up.

ganachee · 14/11/2022 22:40

The super rich are bleeding everyone dry. They also massively increased their wealth during covid.

To , just once ,ask is anyone else fed up of being the squeezed middle?
VillageCottageEmo · 14/11/2022 22:39

Mamato3boysand2dogs · 14/11/2022 22:37

@VillageCottageEmo

It's a young business "love". So, yes, it takes all hours, 7 days a week at this stage.

Still, we turned over nearly £600k in our last financial year, so pretty viable and very gainfully employed.

Now, go back to your doorstep, light another fag and ring your mates to bitch about your benefits being late. Idiot.

600K but you live next door to a NMW worker and SAHM who smokes? Cool story, bro.

dorib · 14/11/2022 22:39

What facts am I pulling out of my bottom? That the "rich" don't tend to be on paye? Or that people who are payed via a company pay less tax than those on paye?

From the article I linked

"According to the report, business income – from either self-employment or owning and running a company – accounts for 21% of total incomes for the top 1% of adults and 29% for the top 0.1%, compared with just 9% for the rest of the population at large."

"It said business owner-managers could effectively choose to take income out of their company through the form of a salary, dividends, or capital gains – allowing them to benefit from lower rates of tax."

The report pointed to a preferential 10% rate of capital gains tax, called business asset disposal relief, while saying that company owner-managers were able to access tax rates of just 27% on income taken in the form of capital gains."

"In comparison, the average tax rate on wage earners in the top 1% is 42%"

VillageCottageEmo · 14/11/2022 22:38

pavillion1 · 14/11/2022 22:36

Me .. The company I work for has just told us that they are giving a £500 cost of living pay out to those who are earning under Xyz... I'm so disappointed in them . I earn more than XYZ because I have to , it keeps us afloat .. 7 days a week varied shifts but to them I don't need to help .

And yet you lack the ability to look past your own set of circumstances.

Mamato3boysand2dogs · 14/11/2022 22:37

@VillageCottageEmo

It's a young business "love". So, yes, it takes all hours, 7 days a week at this stage.

Still, we turned over nearly £600k in our last financial year, so pretty viable and very gainfully employed.

Now, go back to your doorstep, light another fag and ring your mates to bitch about your benefits being late. Idiot.

VillageCottageEmo · 14/11/2022 22:37

Cuppasoupmonster · 14/11/2022 22:33

But people in professional or MC jobs have often
studied for years to achieve those jobs. I don’t want a nurse or doctor treating me to be on the same salary as somebody who packs parcels. It isn’t greedy or selfish to say that higher stress jobs should come with a higher reward.

I assume you support the strike action then?

I agree with you, but then there’s threads like this, with that haughty “let them eat cake” attitude and it’s so grim.

I have a PhD and busted my ass the entire pandemic, but I’m not here feeling pissed off that others got furlough, because my entire job is Public Health, thems the breaks. Nor do I resent people on criminally low wages, living in unstable housing getting extra help.

Perhaps the moaners could take their own advice that’s doled out here constantly recently?

  • Be gainfully employed not self employed
  • Skill up
  • Take a second job
  • Start a cleaning business
pavillion1 · 14/11/2022 22:36

Me .. The company I work for has just told us that they are giving a £500 cost of living pay out to those who are earning under Xyz... I'm so disappointed in them . I earn more than XYZ because I have to , it keeps us afloat .. 7 days a week varied shifts but to them I don't need to help .

QualityAndQuantity · 14/11/2022 22:34

dorib · 14/11/2022 22:07

Do you mean wage earners paying through PAYE, or all earners?

Quite, the rich don't tend to be on paye

As you seem determined to pull “facts” out of your bottom, please do try to educate yourself here;

www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/personalandhouseholdfinances/incomeandwealth

BlackcurrantSorbet · 14/11/2022 22:34

dorib · 14/11/2022 22:19

@CopOut27 I said upthread I think income tax is high enough. I'm not talking about paye though, ime the "rich" aren't generally on paye.

Agreed. They absolutely aren't. But you can guess who'll be targeted again on Thursday can't you? Not the rich, it'll be hammering higher paid PAYE employees in the middle yet again. These are the people who've already been hammered for the last decade. It's not sustainable.

VillageCottageEmo · 14/11/2022 22:33

Mamato3boysand2dogs · 14/11/2022 22:32

Completely agree.

Me and DH run our own business working all the hours of the day, 7 days a week. 3 kids. Mortgage. We get no help in any way shape or form, in fact we are taxed more! We pay more for trying our best and being entrepreneurial.

Yet our close neighbours get a new handout every week it seems!

He works a basic warehouse job, 5 days, not 7. She doesn't work. Stays at home with their FOUR kids. I see her on the doorstep having a fag in her dressing gown as I leave my house for work each morning.

It's laughable. Work hard, earn your own money, aspire not to raise your kids on government handouts and foodbanks and your reward? You get fucked at every corner.

Have you tried being gainfully employed? Surely if it requires two of you working seven days a week, all hours, it’s not as viable a business as you think, love.

QualityAndQuantity · 14/11/2022 22:33

FacebookPhotos · 14/11/2022 22:27

I’m not sure where people get the idea from that the top 10% or 1% aren’t paying their fair share.

Of course they aren’t. Their income is largely derived from other people working for them. Almost nobody is capable of being in the top 1% as a sole trader. And those at the bottom end of the salary scales tend to be subsidised through the benefit system. Wouldn’t it be simpler if businesses just paid ordinary workers properly in the first place? Even if it meant the upper echelons being paid less.

To be in the top 1% in the UK means you are on an income of around £160,000. A huge number of people in that bracket are salaried people in “normal” jobs such as doctors and lawyers.

This idea that you have that you are hard done-by and that those subsidising you have it too easy isn’t tenable.

Cuppasoupmonster · 14/11/2022 22:33

VillageCottageEmo · 14/11/2022 22:27

But they WoRk ReAlLy HaRd - as if the HCAs, care assistants, retail workers, people that pack their Amazon parcels don’t Hmm

But people in professional or MC jobs have often
studied for years to achieve those jobs. I don’t want a nurse or doctor treating me to be on the same salary as somebody who packs parcels. It isn’t greedy or selfish to say that higher stress jobs should come with a higher reward.

Mamato3boysand2dogs · 14/11/2022 22:32

Completely agree.

Me and DH run our own business working all the hours of the day, 7 days a week. 3 kids. Mortgage. We get no help in any way shape or form, in fact we are taxed more! We pay more for trying our best and being entrepreneurial.

Yet our close neighbours get a new handout every week it seems!

He works a basic warehouse job, 5 days, not 7. She doesn't work. Stays at home with their FOUR kids. I see her on the doorstep having a fag in her dressing gown as I leave my house for work each morning.

It's laughable. Work hard, earn your own money, aspire not to raise your kids on government handouts and foodbanks and your reward? You get fucked at every corner.