Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To , just once ,ask is anyone else fed up of being the squeezed middle?

535 replies

Wildandallthatjazz · 14/11/2022 17:12

Thats it really. !

Yes , on mn , its seen as a privilege to have a mortgage, a job etc .

But sometimes it feels hard and you just wish that you got a break . Recognition of the hard slog maybe .

I am not begrudging those on benefits who got the extra payment support, its more about just wanting to have a treat / a bonus/ etc .. a spare bit of money.. a boost .. the heating on … or maybe recognition that the middle can struggle too ?

I totally accept that people can struggle and need help , sort of also feel the struggling middle are invisible ? ( and not seen to have the’ right ‘to have a little moan as it does you good sometimes )

I do think we are incredibly lucky to live in a county with a welfare state, nhs, free gp care I really do .
But sometimes, it just would be nice not to feel you are paying taxes , working as much as possible, and to be able not to feel squeezed all the time and the need to just have a grump about it .

sometimes it is good to let of steam .. when you cant IRL

and then you move on in a more positive fashion .

OP posts:
LiquoriceAllsort2 · 14/11/2022 23:32

Endwalker · 14/11/2022 20:49

For those who think loads of people are playing the system, benefit fraud makes up a tiny percentage of the overall welfare spend and by tiny I mean around 1-2%.

The total number of people claiming DWP benefits is around 23 million. Of that around 12.5 million are pensioners, 9.5 million are working age, and the remainder are children in receipt of Disability Living Allowance.

There will be some.overlap where people are claiming more than one benefit but of that 9.5 million working age adults, around 1.9 million are in receipt of ESA (what used to be part of Incapacity Benefit). 1.3 million are in receipt of Carers Allowance. Around 2.7 million are in receipt of PIP.

Around 5.6 million receive Universal Credit. Around 40% of these are in work. The remainder are either in the 'looking for work' category meaning they have requirements to meet or else face sanctions, or they are in the 'no requirement to work' category meaning they are unable to work for specific reasons (e.g., caring responsibilities, disability, etc).

There are only around 301,000 claimants in the 'looking for work' category who have been unemployed for more than a year - a small percentage of the 5.6 million in receipt of UC.

Genuine question, do you think that the people caught committing benefit fraud are the only ones doing it?

The figure given by the DWP for fraud must be like HMRC give for tax evasion is based on numbers caught but I would hazard a guess the number is greater.

worcestersauce29 · 14/11/2022 23:32

I am one of those currently not paying tax. I paid tax on my salary for 40 years and always at the basic rate. I do not claim any top ups etc. I suspect that there are many in my position.

IneedanewTV · 14/11/2022 23:31

Benefits and pensions to increase by 10%.

I'm looking at a 2-4% pay rise - if I’m lucky. No bonuses or increments. Just the cost of living increase. Being in local government for many years I had nil pay rise. Something wrong somewhere! Starting to think I’m a fool, mortgage going up £300 month in January, energy gone up £200 a month and going up again in January. Diesel to get to work is nearly £2 a litre. There is a limit - I don’t have lots of spare cash sitting around.

OnlyTheBravest · 14/11/2022 23:19

This is a problem that has been building for decades and subsequent governments have done nothing to address the root of the problem.

Everyone has the right to a home, adequate food and basic utilities. Unfortunately, in the quest for more wealth slowly every industry has been turned into a profitable business. It has led to the situation that just acquiring the basics requires an increasingly higher salary, which is unsustainable.

I have no idea what the solution is. I want a system that looks after the young, the old and the vunerable but does not leave the average worker feeling that they only exist to work and pay the bills. Earning an average wage should mean that you get to have a few nice extras.

caringcarer · 14/11/2022 23:17

To be honest I don't know anyone who is not feeling the pinch. Mortgage rates going right up, fuel very expensive, heating so expensive also and food getting more expensive every time I shop. I keep thinking what next, but I suppose that will be power cuts in January.

dorib · 14/11/2022 23:11

@FarFromTheStart ? what benefits?

It's really not unusual to inherit a large sum if you're a Londoner due to the insane house price growth.

Babyroobs · 14/11/2022 23:07

SweetParsnips · 14/11/2022 22:57

There’s a competing narrative - depending which newspapers you read - benefits are either so ridiculously low that people can’t eat/heat their homes (Daniel Blake territory) or people are ‘living the high life’ at taxpayers expense. I personally know people in both those categories. Not being goady- I genuinely don’t understand why there are such disparities. And the tougher things get for the people in the middle, the more the people at the bottom are going to be blamed.

Absolutely agree. I am a benefits advisor and see both sides. Some people are absolutely struggling on basic UC. Others ( particularly some pensioners) are really not doing bad at all. Disability benefits for people over state pension age, I feel are very easy to get compared to those for working age people and very generous premiums for pension credit etc. Even one penny of pension credit guarantee a week will get your rent and council tax paid in full. However things are changing because I think the government have realized now how unsustainable it is. The new state pension has risen so less people in the future will need to claim pension credit and all the expensive means tested freebies that come with it. Mixed age couples now have to claim Uc rather than pension credits and it is a lot less generous, people are a lot worse off and the younger of the couple obviously has work commitments on UC unless they are too ill to work or are a carer. So no more having a much younger spouse who chooses not to work and the pensioner can claim pension credits for them. Things are going to be a lot less generous in the future for sure as the current benefit spending is unsustainable.

Mamato3boysand2dogs · 14/11/2022 23:07

FarFromTheStart · 14/11/2022 22:59

Maybe they should sign off then, and support themselves if it’s so bad.

It’s really not compulsory.

Very well said.

autienotnaughty · 14/11/2022 23:05

It's the new way of life. The middle class have become the new working class, the working class are the new poor. And the poor are barely surviving. But the rich stay rich.

FacebookPhotos · 14/11/2022 23:01

The economy is absolutely dependent on people willing to work their arse off as SMEs. It's incredibly hard work.

This is true. And precisely why I favour tapered corporation tax relief based on profits. Pay you staff properly, make a fair wage yourself, be better off than PAYE. Pay your staff peanuts, make huge sums yourself, be taxed to the heavens by corporation tax.

Mamato3boysand2dogs · 14/11/2022 23:00

And yes, the £600k was turnover. Profit was £253,000.

Wouldn't expect @VillageCottageEmo to understand such complicated financial terms though.

SMEs (@VillageCottageEmo - google for you on this one) do indeed contribute a lot and it is hard work, especially with kids.

Thanks to the posters who pointed that out 😊

FarFromTheStart · 14/11/2022 23:00

dorib · 14/11/2022 22:56

There is a huge difference between income and wealth, and PAYE income has been taxed already as far as is sustainable, because it's easier and politicians are lazy.

Exactly & I say this as someone who could easily inherit 2m, across DH & myself. It's completely disproportionate though.

Family on benefits, but you’ll inherit £2m?

Right you are hen.

FarFromTheStart · 14/11/2022 22:59

VillageCottageEmo · 14/11/2022 22:49

Really? Cos my family members on benefits have shit lives.

Maybe they should sign off then, and support themselves if it’s so bad.

It’s really not compulsory.

SweetParsnips · 14/11/2022 22:57

There’s a competing narrative - depending which newspapers you read - benefits are either so ridiculously low that people can’t eat/heat their homes (Daniel Blake territory) or people are ‘living the high life’ at taxpayers expense. I personally know people in both those categories. Not being goady- I genuinely don’t understand why there are such disparities. And the tougher things get for the people in the middle, the more the people at the bottom are going to be blamed.

dorib · 14/11/2022 22:56

There is a huge difference between income and wealth, and PAYE income has been taxed already as far as is sustainable, because it's easier and politicians are lazy.

Exactly & I say this as someone who could easily inherit 2m, across DH & myself. It's completely disproportionate though.

Mamato3boysand2dogs · 14/11/2022 22:56

@VillageCottageEmo

"Cool story bro". In one 3 word sentence, you display the level of your intellect perfectly!

However, I'll humour you. I said our "very close" neighbour, not next door neighbour and clearly you haven't noticed the huge, expensive family homes being given to council tenants? No? Well shock horror, we have!

Yes, the family I describe actually live in a converted B&B which is a council property! 6 bedrooms no less. And they pay FUCK ALL for it while we WORK for every penny we get. Every fucking penny.

I have such a clear mental image of you.

FacebookPhotos · 14/11/2022 22:55

The reality is wages have not kept up with inflation for a long time so in real terms people have been losing money for years. Considering that, then covid, brexit and the cost of living crisis average people just have nothing left to give.

Increasing minimum wage would help solve this problem. Instead of “trickle down” economics that patently doesn’t work, why don’t we try “rise up” economics? Raise the wages of the lowest paid with a Triple Lock. Those above minimum wage would have a solid argument for significant increases when negotiating salary increases. No more race to the bottom. Race to the top.

pavillion1 · 14/11/2022 22:55

You know that for a fact about all of them? None are disabled? Lone parents? Married but have DCs with disabilities? Etc

Yes I do , we only have a team of 10 where I work .

VillageCottageEmo · 14/11/2022 22:52

TheKeatingFive · 14/11/2022 22:51

So if it’s not making a profit, and it’s a young business, it shouldn’t be stated that it’s viable. And if they’ve both recently jacked in normal employment to do so, that’s privilege.

Presumably it is making a profit, just not 600K worth and it sounds like they're doing well for recently started business. You're not covering yourself with glory here with your comments. The economy is absolutely dependent on people willing to work their arse off as SMEs. It's incredibly hard work.

Neither is PP, but when it’s the working class being attacked based on assumptions, that’s cool. Fucking middle class cry babies.

TheKeatingFive · 14/11/2022 22:51

So if it’s not making a profit, and it’s a young business, it shouldn’t be stated that it’s viable. And if they’ve both recently jacked in normal employment to do so, that’s privilege.

Presumably it is making a profit, just not 600K worth and it sounds like they're doing well for recently started business. You're not covering yourself with glory here with your comments. The economy is absolutely dependent on people willing to work their arse off as SMEs. It's incredibly hard work.

VillageCottageEmo · 14/11/2022 22:49

Babooshka1991 · 14/11/2022 22:46

Yes I agree, they take so much in tax, massive bill increases, gets worse every year. I had addict parents and worked so hard to get a postgraduate degree ( so big student loan payments too) and build a good career. But my sibling on benefits has more spare cash, better car, nice holidays .

Really? Cos my family members on benefits have shit lives.

VillageCottageEmo · 14/11/2022 22:49

pavillion1 · 14/11/2022 22:47

And yet you lack the ability to look past your own set of circumstances.

No not at all , I'm working longer hours because my co workers are finically secure so they only need part time hours .. yet they'll get the bonus .

You know that for a fact about all of them? None are disabled? Lone parents? Married but have DCs with disabilities? Etc

VillageCottageEmo · 14/11/2022 22:48

BlackcurrantSorbet · 14/11/2022 22:42

I believe they said £600k revenue, not profit. And that they had started their business not long ago.

So if it’s not making a profit, and it’s a young business, it shouldn’t be stated that it’s viable. And if they’ve both recently jacked in normal employment to do so, that’s privilege.

PP is also such a snot about the neighbours, and if both types of working people live next to each other, that infers any number of scenarios about where PP lives, what their previous income was, and why she’s so fucking bitter.

Babyroobs · 14/11/2022 22:47

Misunderestimated · 14/11/2022 21:31

The DWP, its civil servants and governments since 2000 have really fucked up here. For 'traditional' 20th century roles, with women having more children with poorer medical backup, caring responsibilities for parents and men working for fifty years, the pension ages of 60 and 65 were fair - women lived longer, but in poorer health.
In return, taxpayers adopted 60 or 65 as ages to retire.Because MPs treat us badly (they could take the moral high ground and take their platinum-plated pensions two years later than the rest of us, but I'm not holding my breath), people have opted out of the government view and are now opting for semi-retirement in their fifties, taking much-needed skills and experience out of the market, just when they are needed the most.

Half of my friendship group are all retiring at 55 with big pensions, one a banker, one a civil servant aged 56 retiring for life on almost the same as what she was earning whilst working, and 2 NHS. I don't think we'll ever have it this good going forward. Ans yes I am jealous before anyone asks !

JennyForeigner · 14/11/2022 22:47

ThatsGoingToHurt · 14/11/2022 20:48

I’m lucky but feel like I’m stuck between a rock and and a hard place. Both me and DH work FT. I’m permanently exhausted from having 2 under 5. Stuck with paying full nursery fees for the next 10 months until the funded hours kicks in. Can’t afford any help e.g. a cleaner to take some of the load. I’m the higher earner so if I drop to PT we will take a massive hit on our finances and it won’t be worth it. If I did drop my hours we wouldn’t qualify for any extra help.

Ironically, once DS gets the funded hours I may be able to cut my hours but from now until he’s 3.4 it’s a slog. Paying nursery fees since 2018, having a pandemic and losing my job, etc has reduced our savings to zero.

I absolutely feel for you on that irony. We have three, the oldest of whom just qualified for 30 hours. The other two are unfunded with another two years to go.

I have never in my life had to earn more to stand still. You have to work harder than at any time in your life, while hardly seeing the kids you would do anything for, except in the middle of the night or as one virus or another leaves you scrabbling round for childcare. Maternity leave in the context of three years to survive like that is nothing, and mine was only ever statutory anyway so I couldn't afford more than the minimum.

It just feels unwinnable, and frankly very sad for the kids.