Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To leave 2 under 2 in the house while I walk to get dc no 3 from childminder 5 doors down the road

493 replies

threeisacharm18 · 14/11/2022 16:21

Quick pulse - as the title says I have 2 under 2 at home with me now. Dc No 1 is school age and gets picked up by the childminder who lives 5 doors from us.

Should I pack up the 2 babies in a pushchair to walk 2 mins up the road to get dc 1 or risk it and leave them in the bouncer while I run up the road to get dc no 3?

OP posts:
Chasingclouds100 · 20/11/2022 21:45

Conkersareback · 20/11/2022 17:59

Not just a potential accident though is it - what about if the car gets stolen whilst the baby is inside - like I mentioned before, I have actually seen this happen!

I thought it was a kidnap! I actually think this is about as unlikely as rocking horse shit!

Sorry for delay in replying I have been looking after my 4 children, it’s tiring work sometimes as my youngest are toddlers but I would really love another one for no other reason than to add to our lovely little family - I’m 45 now so probably won’t happen which I’m absolutely fine with but lately I have been thinking about going back to university to study midwifery when my youngest start school and don’t need me so much. (My eldest are already at school and are becoming more independent now - even toileting themselves!!) I’m already a paediatric RGN but I haven’t worked in a permanent job for 5 years because my babies are so young and I could never leave them alone in the house of course as that would be neglectful, but I do NHS bank work of a weekend when my Husband is able to take care of our 4 children - sorry I digress oh yes it is of a weekend that I fill my car with petrol on the the way to work, and once I saw a car be stolen off the petrol forecourt with a small child inside (kidnapped) whilst the mother went inside the shop to pay for her petrol - no word of a lie, it actually happened but of course some people won’t believe it as they don’t see the danger in this scenario. Sorry I seem to have told everyone my life story here - Im sure nobody is interested in the details of my life - only my stalkers but it is a Sunday night and they are probably too busy colour co-ordinating their dogs to match their sofas!! 🙄🙄🙄

ImaniMumsnet · 20/11/2022 20:22

Hi everyone,

We would like to encourage everyone to continue the discussion with the talkguidelines in mind and in a way that is in the spirit of the site. Making judgements about other users parenting is not something we consider to be in the spirit of the site. If there is anything that concerns you or any posts you feel break talkguidelines - please report them to us.

Conkersareback · 20/11/2022 19:52

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Chasingclouds100 · 20/11/2022 19:46

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Conkersareback · 20/11/2022 17:59

Not just a potential accident though is it - what about if the car gets stolen whilst the baby is inside - like I mentioned before, I have actually seen this happen!

I thought it was a kidnap! I actually think this is about as unlikely as rocking horse shit!

Chasingclouds100 · 18/11/2022 14:20

vdbfamily · 18/11/2022 13:58

Can you really not see that the risk of harm to a child hit directly by a car on a garage forecourt is far far far greater than being strapped safely in a car seat when the car is hit.

Not just a potential accident though is it - what about if the car gets stolen whilst the baby is inside - like I mentioned before, I have actually seen this happen!

vdbfamily · 18/11/2022 13:58

Chasingclouds100 · 18/11/2022 13:42

I’m sorry but I completely disagree! Everyone knows the difference between a normal baby cry and a distressed baby cry - if you went to the loo you would be able to hear that distressed cry (or the other child calling for help) - if you are 5 doors away you would not be able hear that distressed cry. And I disagree about the petrol forecourt also - a stationery car is just as likely to be hit with a child in as a pedestrian(s) would be. The bottom line is that you just do not leave a child or children alone at home without any adult supervision - anything could happen, children are far too precious to put at risk!

Can you really not see that the risk of harm to a child hit directly by a car on a garage forecourt is far far far greater than being strapped safely in a car seat when the car is hit.

Chasingclouds100 · 18/11/2022 13:42

vdbfamily · 18/11/2022 11:36

I am not saying that, just saying that what if I am hit by a car is a very strange argument.
Every decision involves a risk assessment which is why most parents choose to leave children in car when paying for fuel because it is genuinely more dangerous to drag several small kids across a busy forecourt then leave them in the car for a few minutes. However if car was out of sight completely you would probably decide to take them with you.
There is very little harm that is likely to occur to a baby asleep in a cot or playing happily in a play pen in the period of time it would take you to collect a child from 5 doors away. If you fail to turn up because you have been mown down by a car or collapsed of a heart attack the childminder would probably notice fairly quickly and raise alarm. You could even phone first and say please have child ready at door as need to be quick. It really takes no longer than going to toilet.

I’m sorry but I completely disagree! Everyone knows the difference between a normal baby cry and a distressed baby cry - if you went to the loo you would be able to hear that distressed cry (or the other child calling for help) - if you are 5 doors away you would not be able hear that distressed cry. And I disagree about the petrol forecourt also - a stationery car is just as likely to be hit with a child in as a pedestrian(s) would be. The bottom line is that you just do not leave a child or children alone at home without any adult supervision - anything could happen, children are far too precious to put at risk!

vdbfamily · 18/11/2022 13:38

AuxArmesCitoyens · 18/11/2022 13:21

You literally do not have to stop for anything and could be there and back in less than 5 minutes.

So you see someone who has just been mugged / an old lady falling over and breaking her arm / a dog being run over and just walk past?

For me it's about balancing risk and potential outcome. If I did do this and something happened, the consequences could be really bad. And then I would have to live with the knowledge it could have been avoided. So I don't do it.

If any of those scenarios happened you would have to take a view as to how much you could help. Dialling 999 and asking someone else to support because you need to get back to young kids would be acceptable. How much actual support would you be able to actually give to any of those scenarios if you have 3 young children with you. You could also be running home, dialling 999 and scooping up your 2 babies within minutes, to return and offer whatever support you felt you needed to in the very unlikely event that an old lady gets mugged between your house and 5 doors down, if there really was no one else around who could help

AuxArmesCitoyens · 18/11/2022 13:21

You literally do not have to stop for anything and could be there and back in less than 5 minutes.

So you see someone who has just been mugged / an old lady falling over and breaking her arm / a dog being run over and just walk past?

For me it's about balancing risk and potential outcome. If I did do this and something happened, the consequences could be really bad. And then I would have to live with the knowledge it could have been avoided. So I don't do it.

AuxArmesCitoyens · 18/11/2022 13:18

depends on the size of the houses and gardens, surely? My point is there is a material difference between leaving the kid while you have a shower / are in your own garden, which is the increased likelihood of delay from the presence of other people. I agree on the face of it that 5 doors is not much in a typical urban street, but if there are people about then you're multiplying potential delaying scenarios to a point that I (and lots of other people, clearly[ find unacceptable.

vdbfamily · 18/11/2022 13:14

AuxArmesCitoyens · 18/11/2022 13:06

  1. you at home with your baby = low risk, you can intervene quickly if need be
  1. baby in home, you in garden, slightly higher risk: harm might come to you or the baby, risk of delay acceptably low
  1. baby in home, you out and about with N other people. chance of harm to baby in 5 minutes = low, chance of harm to you = low, chance of being unexpectedly delayed by harm to you or any of the N people you pass in the street = unacceptably high. Risk to baby of you being delayed by 20 minutes due to [insert any number of unexpected events that happen daily[ = unacceptably high.

Why is there a high risk of delay walking 5 doors down street, particularly if you have phoned childminder and requested child is ready.
You literally do not have to stop for anything and could be there and back in less than 5 minutes. There is very little that could happen in 5 minutes to a safely located baby at home. Leave door unlocked if worried about being locked out. The point is that you plan this, you don't do it on a whim. BAbies need to be in safe place and settled, cold needs to be ready and handed over promptly, don't leave anything on cooker, don't leave cigarette smouldering on sofa, don't leave child playing with scissors or having a tantrum at the front door.
You can mitigate risk and this is not a high risk activity, it really is not!

AuxArmesCitoyens · 18/11/2022 13:06
  1. you at home with your baby = low risk, you can intervene quickly if need be
  1. baby in home, you in garden, slightly higher risk: harm might come to you or the baby, risk of delay acceptably low
  1. baby in home, you out and about with N other people. chance of harm to baby in 5 minutes = low, chance of harm to you = low, chance of being unexpectedly delayed by harm to you or any of the N people you pass in the street = unacceptably high. Risk to baby of you being delayed by 20 minutes due to [insert any number of unexpected events that happen daily[ = unacceptably high.
MollieMarie · 18/11/2022 11:57

vdbfamily · 18/11/2022 11:36

I am not saying that, just saying that what if I am hit by a car is a very strange argument.
Every decision involves a risk assessment which is why most parents choose to leave children in car when paying for fuel because it is genuinely more dangerous to drag several small kids across a busy forecourt then leave them in the car for a few minutes. However if car was out of sight completely you would probably decide to take them with you.
There is very little harm that is likely to occur to a baby asleep in a cot or playing happily in a play pen in the period of time it would take you to collect a child from 5 doors away. If you fail to turn up because you have been mown down by a car or collapsed of a heart attack the childminder would probably notice fairly quickly and raise alarm. You could even phone first and say please have child ready at door as need to be quick. It really takes no longer than going to toilet.

👏 👏 👏

Finally someone with a bit of sense on this thread!

vdbfamily · 18/11/2022 11:36

Chasingclouds100 · 18/11/2022 11:17

What so they will never leave the house now because of outside risks when supervised by an adult??

I am not saying that, just saying that what if I am hit by a car is a very strange argument.
Every decision involves a risk assessment which is why most parents choose to leave children in car when paying for fuel because it is genuinely more dangerous to drag several small kids across a busy forecourt then leave them in the car for a few minutes. However if car was out of sight completely you would probably decide to take them with you.
There is very little harm that is likely to occur to a baby asleep in a cot or playing happily in a play pen in the period of time it would take you to collect a child from 5 doors away. If you fail to turn up because you have been mown down by a car or collapsed of a heart attack the childminder would probably notice fairly quickly and raise alarm. You could even phone first and say please have child ready at door as need to be quick. It really takes no longer than going to toilet.

Chasingclouds100 · 18/11/2022 11:17

vdbfamily · 18/11/2022 09:50

I wish people would stop using the argument that you might get hit by a car so you should really take them. Just think about that. What chance would a 1 and 2 year old have is they are hit by a car. If they are safely in their cots and settled, they are much safer at home in that circumstance. Even if you were killed outright, it would not take long for your NOK to be contacted or the childminder to hear the sirens and discover it is you and you don't have the other 2 with you so the alarm would be raised in no time. We are talking about 5 doors away not a shopping trip.
I would not leave in a bouncer though.
I have already said this on this thread but when I had to collect my oldest from preschool, it was genuinely more dangerous to take the other 2 with me. They always slept after lunch and I was genuinely away for no longer than 5 minutes. They were nearly killed crossing the road with me one time. Hit and run that involved a court case, so it is not a made up risk...It actually happened.
I really think people's decisions are more based on how they think others will judge them than actual risk

What so they will never leave the house now because of outside risks when supervised by an adult??

vdbfamily · 18/11/2022 09:50

I wish people would stop using the argument that you might get hit by a car so you should really take them. Just think about that. What chance would a 1 and 2 year old have is they are hit by a car. If they are safely in their cots and settled, they are much safer at home in that circumstance. Even if you were killed outright, it would not take long for your NOK to be contacted or the childminder to hear the sirens and discover it is you and you don't have the other 2 with you so the alarm would be raised in no time. We are talking about 5 doors away not a shopping trip.
I would not leave in a bouncer though.
I have already said this on this thread but when I had to collect my oldest from preschool, it was genuinely more dangerous to take the other 2 with me. They always slept after lunch and I was genuinely away for no longer than 5 minutes. They were nearly killed crossing the road with me one time. Hit and run that involved a court case, so it is not a made up risk...It actually happened.
I really think people's decisions are more based on how they think others will judge them than actual risk

Marcie14 · 17/11/2022 13:43

I would definitely take them with you. What if something happened to you on the way and you couldn’t get back to them?Yes it’s a short distance, but unexpected accidents/events can happen.

ljs22 · 17/11/2022 09:39

AuxArmesCitoyens · 16/11/2022 20:30

The difference with being in your garden / shower is the bigger risk of being delayed due to shit happening to other people. For instance if you were the only witness to someone collapsing in the street.

Exactly. Or a car mounts the pavement and knocks you over. Or a malfunctioning lock on your front door which means you can't get back inside your house...

Yes these are extreme examples, but not impossible. When you leave the house you increase the risks to both yourself and your children left behind, it's really not hard to understand this.

AuxArmesCitoyens · 16/11/2022 20:30

The difference with being in your garden / shower is the bigger risk of being delayed due to shit happening to other people. For instance if you were the only witness to someone collapsing in the street.

Chasingclouds100 · 16/11/2022 14:47

Slv199 · 16/11/2022 14:00

But do remember if anything does happen you will find yourself answering to the police and/or social services as to why you left not 1 but 2 underage children home alone.

Exactly this

Slv199 · 16/11/2022 14:34

rangagirl · 16/11/2022 14:14

@Slv199... yes, that's a good point.

However, as I said, I don't see it as any different than leaving your children in the bed when you go outside to hang up the clothes... the chores HAVE to be done, right? If something happens in that moment, then are you a negligent parent?

I don't think so - I'm just thinking of my brother's house, where you have to walk around the side and up a long flight of stairs to get between the door and the clothesline, so if the children shrieked, you'd hear it from the clothesline... but it would still take several seconds to run around and up the stairs to get inside. My uncle's house when his kids were little had the clothesline right at the back of a HUGE yard - so it would take several seconds to get back to the house and again up the internal stairs to get to the children if they shrieked.

And would my brother or uncle (or their wives) be a negligent parent because they left the house to do a chore that has to be done?

A good nanny cam would tell you if the babies are in need... and a few doors down is close enough that you can be home very quickly. Although how often are children left alone in their bedroom to nap (or whatever), and the parent is in another room... but with no nanny camera, the kid gets hurt anyways and no one knows until they go check on the kid! Is THAT person a negligent parent?

I just don't think that things like this are as black and white as something you NEVER EVER DO because it's super high risk, or something that's 100% safe to do. It's somewhere in the middle, I think.

In situations such as these, I think about the newspaper headlines if something goes wrong. It's all down to how people will judge you and if people in general think you are doing something irresponsible or not. Also, could you live with yourself if a child died however because you weren't with them.

rangagirl · 16/11/2022 14:14

@Slv199... yes, that's a good point.

However, as I said, I don't see it as any different than leaving your children in the bed when you go outside to hang up the clothes... the chores HAVE to be done, right? If something happens in that moment, then are you a negligent parent?

I don't think so - I'm just thinking of my brother's house, where you have to walk around the side and up a long flight of stairs to get between the door and the clothesline, so if the children shrieked, you'd hear it from the clothesline... but it would still take several seconds to run around and up the stairs to get inside. My uncle's house when his kids were little had the clothesline right at the back of a HUGE yard - so it would take several seconds to get back to the house and again up the internal stairs to get to the children if they shrieked.

And would my brother or uncle (or their wives) be a negligent parent because they left the house to do a chore that has to be done?

A good nanny cam would tell you if the babies are in need... and a few doors down is close enough that you can be home very quickly. Although how often are children left alone in their bedroom to nap (or whatever), and the parent is in another room... but with no nanny camera, the kid gets hurt anyways and no one knows until they go check on the kid! Is THAT person a negligent parent?

I just don't think that things like this are as black and white as something you NEVER EVER DO because it's super high risk, or something that's 100% safe to do. It's somewhere in the middle, I think.

Slv199 · 16/11/2022 14:00

rangagirl · 16/11/2022 13:44

I've been swinging back and forth on this one... I really understand both sides of the argument.

But I've thought of something you could try - when you duck out to pick up the older kid, make sure the babies are secure and safe in bed or the bouncy thingy or wherever... and get a really good nanny camera (or several) that covers the room and links to your phone! You can literally watch them sleeping or whatever on your phone the ENTIRE time you are walking a few metres up the street to collect the little ones.

If you notice something - like a little one climbing from the cot and running to open the bedroom door - well, you're close enough to bolt back within seconds... which makes it no different to leaving your baby asleep whilst you go out to the clothesline and hang out the washing (which takes a few minutes).

My mum left my tiny baby brother sleeping at home one time... because little 3 year old me had gotten out and gone up the street to the corner store for lollies! One of her friends recognized me and drove to get my mum... she knew I'd never come with her without mum. She didn't have a baby car seat, so my mum had no choice but to leave my baby brother for a few minutes to go back with her friend to get me!

Obviously I don't remember that - nor does my brother - but apparently no harm came to either of us in 2 or 3 minutes! So... talk to your spouse and see what they think. It could work - you're only a few houses away for one or two minutes... not running off for hours to go drinking! :p

But do remember if anything does happen you will find yourself answering to the police and/or social services as to why you left not 1 but 2 underage children home alone.

rangagirl · 16/11/2022 13:44

I've been swinging back and forth on this one... I really understand both sides of the argument.

But I've thought of something you could try - when you duck out to pick up the older kid, make sure the babies are secure and safe in bed or the bouncy thingy or wherever... and get a really good nanny camera (or several) that covers the room and links to your phone! You can literally watch them sleeping or whatever on your phone the ENTIRE time you are walking a few metres up the street to collect the little ones.

If you notice something - like a little one climbing from the cot and running to open the bedroom door - well, you're close enough to bolt back within seconds... which makes it no different to leaving your baby asleep whilst you go out to the clothesline and hang out the washing (which takes a few minutes).

My mum left my tiny baby brother sleeping at home one time... because little 3 year old me had gotten out and gone up the street to the corner store for lollies! One of her friends recognized me and drove to get my mum... she knew I'd never come with her without mum. She didn't have a baby car seat, so my mum had no choice but to leave my baby brother for a few minutes to go back with her friend to get me!

Obviously I don't remember that - nor does my brother - but apparently no harm came to either of us in 2 or 3 minutes! So... talk to your spouse and see what they think. It could work - you're only a few houses away for one or two minutes... not running off for hours to go drinking! :p

Swipe left for the next trending thread