Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my brother's new girlfriend is rude.

32 replies

Scyla · 14/11/2022 13:26

I've just had a weekend at my brother's place in the Mediterranean. He has lived there for years. He and I both got divorced about ten years ago and so we have seen quite a lot of each other since and enjoy talking about life, the universe etc whilst drinking wine in the sunshine. Recently a new woman appeared in his life and I really liked her when I first met her last year, she's lively and fun and enjoys hosting and cooking. They have had a bumpy year or two as she wants total commitment whilst bro wanted only part time and to keep some personal time. It's a bit uneasy as neither are really getting what they want.

Anyway she's now decided I need fixing up as I am also wrong about relationships.
I dated for a while after divorcing but gave up as I was having no luck, just bad experiences. I no longer want it need to be involved with anyone and I'm enjoying the solo life.
She started off with saying "and now we need to find Scyla a man" about a year ago. I said I didn't want that.

A year later I'm fed up of hearing about it. This weekend she got very drunk and at dinner was all literally shouting at me wagging her finger in my face about how wrong I am and how I'm not happy. I tried to laugh it off because it's so stupid, a woman I have only known for a year a so seems to believe she has a better handle on my emotions despite barely knowing me or my life at all than I do, it's silly. But then she started saying that my problems (I don't have any problems) are because the worst thing I did was to leave my husband.(ten years before this woman appeared in my brother's life.)

Honestly I think she went to far there. She was ranting this at me. It's definitely changed my affection for her right now, I feel like she's out of order. Do I just ignore it because she was drunk and just think it doesn't matter or does it? I'm happy for people to be as drunk as they like as long as they don't turn aggressive and behave like a twat but I wonder if I'm being unreasonable with this particular drunk twat!. As I said this has been getting steadily worse.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
mustgetoffmn · 03/01/2023 17:51

potniatheron · 03/01/2023 15:28

Cluster B personality disorders. Think Jameela Jamil, Megan Markle or Jack Monroe
www.webmd.com/mental-health/what-are-cluster-b-personality-disorders

thank you

potniatheron · 03/01/2023 15:28

sue20 · 31/12/2022 12:30

What’s a cluster B personality when it’s at home???

Cluster B personality disorders. Think Jameela Jamil, Megan Markle or Jack Monroe
www.webmd.com/mental-health/what-are-cluster-b-personality-disorders

IsEveryDayReallyASchoolDay · 02/01/2023 19:10

Has your brother been saying to her that he doesn't think you're happy and she's therefore verbalising it after she's had a drink?

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 31/12/2022 12:35

In this instance @suez a vox pop bastardisation of some complex psychiatry!

sue20 · 31/12/2022 12:30

potniatheron · 14/11/2022 15:43

This is a very astute observation @Mlb123

Anyway, your brother's girlfriend sounds like she has a drink problem. And a cluster B personality disroder or ten.

Avoid.

What’s a cluster B personality when it’s at home???

sue20 · 31/12/2022 12:27

She was drunk. Does she drink a lot possibly a problem? We can do inappropriate stuff when drunk really she should apologise but she might not remember the extent of her rant. Was DB also drunk? It’s up to him to speak with her about her behaviour.

re her views it’s none of her business. For some reason there are those who get deep satisfaction from telling everyone around them how to live. It comes from not having that very sorted for yourself.

potniatheron · 14/11/2022 15:43

Mlb123 · 14/11/2022 15:07

I can't help but wonder if she has an ulterior motive to wanting you with a man rather than just your happiness. You say he wanted part time and she was insistent upon total commitment so it's not beyond the realm of possibility that she wants you loved up, so she can ensure more hold over your brother and that you will be both busy in a new relationship and less likely to pay attention to things happening with your brother's relationship and maybe she even thinks that it will sway your brother more into thinking that it's ok with the total commitment thing if you are also in a couple and possibly doing things as a foursome. Either way she is cheeky, rude and this is further evidence of what you already know/suspect and that is that she is controlling xx

This is a very astute observation @Mlb123

Anyway, your brother's girlfriend sounds like she has a drink problem. And a cluster B personality disroder or ten.

Avoid.

Scyla · 14/11/2022 15:27

I agree drinkfeckarse! I have been trying to give her the benefit of the doubt because I know being happy single does seem unsettling to people.

But, it's the lack of respect for me and insistence that I don't know my own mind that's troubling and how she wants to turn this fantasy she has made up about me being unhappy and with problems into a psychodrama - it goes way beyond her having a little discomfort.

OP posts:
makenomistake · 14/11/2022 15:25

In front of everyone I'd say "unlike you,
I have lots of friends and don't need a man to make me happy"!

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 14/11/2022 15:13

I dont think I'd tell him its changed your opinion of her and you dont like her any more (or not unless he starts to say similar or asks any questions). In these situations then people naturally get defensive and start defending the other person rather than taking your concerns seriously. There is also the risk that he tells her, she is all 'I only want your sister to be happy!' and turns you into the enemy. She may not have an ulterior motive other than not be able to believe you can't be happy without a man, plenty of people are like this.

I'd make it clear though that this assassination of your private life and refusal to believe you can be happy without a man is not acceptable and next time you will say so, but youd rather him say something to her beforehand to avoid a drunken argument. And ask questions about how he feels about all the talk of marriage, does he think they are compatible long term etc to get him thinking about it for himself rather than 'my sister thinks this is a bad idea'

mam0918 · 14/11/2022 15:10

Scyla · 14/11/2022 13:26

I've just had a weekend at my brother's place in the Mediterranean. He has lived there for years. He and I both got divorced about ten years ago and so we have seen quite a lot of each other since and enjoy talking about life, the universe etc whilst drinking wine in the sunshine. Recently a new woman appeared in his life and I really liked her when I first met her last year, she's lively and fun and enjoys hosting and cooking. They have had a bumpy year or two as she wants total commitment whilst bro wanted only part time and to keep some personal time. It's a bit uneasy as neither are really getting what they want.

Anyway she's now decided I need fixing up as I am also wrong about relationships.
I dated for a while after divorcing but gave up as I was having no luck, just bad experiences. I no longer want it need to be involved with anyone and I'm enjoying the solo life.
She started off with saying "and now we need to find Scyla a man" about a year ago. I said I didn't want that.

A year later I'm fed up of hearing about it. This weekend she got very drunk and at dinner was all literally shouting at me wagging her finger in my face about how wrong I am and how I'm not happy. I tried to laugh it off because it's so stupid, a woman I have only known for a year a so seems to believe she has a better handle on my emotions despite barely knowing me or my life at all than I do, it's silly. But then she started saying that my problems (I don't have any problems) are because the worst thing I did was to leave my husband.(ten years before this woman appeared in my brother's life.)

Honestly I think she went to far there. She was ranting this at me. It's definitely changed my affection for her right now, I feel like she's out of order. Do I just ignore it because she was drunk and just think it doesn't matter or does it? I'm happy for people to be as drunk as they like as long as they don't turn aggressive and behave like a twat but I wonder if I'm being unreasonable with this particular drunk twat!. As I said this has been getting steadily worse.

Sounds like my SIL.

Shes bubbly, friendly and super nice suck up to everyone when sober but a complete fucking gobshite women hating nightmare when drunk who is convinced she knows better than everyone and agressively mansplains your life to you working herself up more and more until she starts threatening to kick your ass for what ever thing she deems you are doing wrong in your own life.

In my case I don't deserve to be married because I had the audacity to keep my maiden name so obviously this also means I'm a shit mother who shouldn't have kids because their names don't match mine... like utterly batshit.

Mlb123 · 14/11/2022 15:07

Scyla · 14/11/2022 13:26

I've just had a weekend at my brother's place in the Mediterranean. He has lived there for years. He and I both got divorced about ten years ago and so we have seen quite a lot of each other since and enjoy talking about life, the universe etc whilst drinking wine in the sunshine. Recently a new woman appeared in his life and I really liked her when I first met her last year, she's lively and fun and enjoys hosting and cooking. They have had a bumpy year or two as she wants total commitment whilst bro wanted only part time and to keep some personal time. It's a bit uneasy as neither are really getting what they want.

Anyway she's now decided I need fixing up as I am also wrong about relationships.
I dated for a while after divorcing but gave up as I was having no luck, just bad experiences. I no longer want it need to be involved with anyone and I'm enjoying the solo life.
She started off with saying "and now we need to find Scyla a man" about a year ago. I said I didn't want that.

A year later I'm fed up of hearing about it. This weekend she got very drunk and at dinner was all literally shouting at me wagging her finger in my face about how wrong I am and how I'm not happy. I tried to laugh it off because it's so stupid, a woman I have only known for a year a so seems to believe she has a better handle on my emotions despite barely knowing me or my life at all than I do, it's silly. But then she started saying that my problems (I don't have any problems) are because the worst thing I did was to leave my husband.(ten years before this woman appeared in my brother's life.)

Honestly I think she went to far there. She was ranting this at me. It's definitely changed my affection for her right now, I feel like she's out of order. Do I just ignore it because she was drunk and just think it doesn't matter or does it? I'm happy for people to be as drunk as they like as long as they don't turn aggressive and behave like a twat but I wonder if I'm being unreasonable with this particular drunk twat!. As I said this has been getting steadily worse.

I can't help but wonder if she has an ulterior motive to wanting you with a man rather than just your happiness. You say he wanted part time and she was insistent upon total commitment so it's not beyond the realm of possibility that she wants you loved up, so she can ensure more hold over your brother and that you will be both busy in a new relationship and less likely to pay attention to things happening with your brother's relationship and maybe she even thinks that it will sway your brother more into thinking that it's ok with the total commitment thing if you are also in a couple and possibly doing things as a foursome. Either way she is cheeky, rude and this is further evidence of what you already know/suspect and that is that she is controlling xx

gannett · 14/11/2022 14:59

Scyla · 14/11/2022 14:16

I will tell him that what she said was not on and that I no longer like her. I don't. The lively fun personality turned into a shouty harridon at a dinner. I asked her not to do it and she refused to stop.

Peekaboo is right, she is horrible.

Definitely do this. He probably thinks because you made light of it the next day it's been smoothed over but row back on that - she crossed a line and he should know that.

Did she even attempt to apologise the next day? Lots of people say silly things when drunk but I feel like you have the measure of her and what she wants.

amiold · 14/11/2022 14:53

You don't need to call her to him about her behaviour.

I'd just suggest next time you're out there, she stays at home as you didn't really enjoy her time. If he asks why, elaborate. If he insists she's there cut your trips short

Scyla · 14/11/2022 14:50

He didn't try to stop her. I feel like it's escalating and he's not realising as she's far more extravert than him. I am going to have to spell it out.

I stay neutral with him on their relationship. I don't try to influence him. But I will tell him I don't think this escalating behaviour is a good sign and has changed what I think of her.

OP posts:
GreenManalishi · 14/11/2022 14:42

Presumably your brother was present while she ranted at you drunk over dinner, didn't he have anything to say in the moment?

I'd be honest with him and say that you felt the behaviour that you both witnessed from her was really inappropriate. Tell him that you are happy to visit but you will be visiting to spend time with him, and are not available to be the object of any drunken ranting on your next visit.

Whether she is after his money, or pressuring him for commitment he is not prepared to give, that is his business. How she deals with you, is yours.

Scyla · 14/11/2022 14:38

@MavisChunch29

It makes me feel like that now!

Thanks for all the advice, I feel a bit better about being angry over it. I made light of it the next day but I'm shocked at how poor her judgement is if she thinks this is okay.

OP posts:
ChaToilLeam · 14/11/2022 14:30

She sounds absolutely horrible. How dare she! And yes, sounds like she has eyes on your brother’s 💰 too. No wonder she wants a happy single like you out of the picture!

MavisChunch29 · 14/11/2022 14:28

I would have really struggled not to give her good slap while she was ranting, to be honest.

Scyla · 14/11/2022 14:16

I will tell him that what she said was not on and that I no longer like her. I don't. The lively fun personality turned into a shouty harridon at a dinner. I asked her not to do it and she refused to stop.

Peekaboo is right, she is horrible.

OP posts:
Scyla · 14/11/2022 14:11

Argh
She doesn't want me to be a happy single when she is trying to convince dB he has to marry her to be happy. Oh dear.

I don't think he will, I think she has gone to far with him too over his daughter on another issue. She's definitely trying a takeover. It's a bit too obvious!

OP posts:
forrestgreen · 14/11/2022 14:11

Tell your db that she was out of order and then next time she starts you'll set her straight. If he wants to be brotherly and tell her first, all the better.

Scyla · 14/11/2022 14:09

It's true! She doesn't want me

OP posts:
onmywayamarillo · 14/11/2022 14:01

I think she was saying to you all the things she wanted to say to him!
Hopefully your brother will get rid soon

PeekabooAtTheZoo · 14/11/2022 14:00

She's horrible. And your brother needs to stop sleepwalking along with her grand plans or he'll find himself stuck with her and it doesn't sound like he wants that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread