Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Children Being Noisy During 2 Min Silence?

95 replies

AmIAnOldBag · 14/11/2022 09:41

I was at a Remembrance Service yesterday. It was outdoors. There were about 8 children running about, across from the speaker (so in the middle of the service). They were just being kids, screaming and squealing, playing together. Just to be clear, I'm not blaming the kids for being kids. They were about 7-11 years old.

However, their parents made no attempt at rallying them up, or keeping them calm or quiet during the 2 minute silence (or any of the 30min service). One parent had her son beside her the full time (he looked about 9, not sure though). She was standing beside us, and put her hands on her lips in a 'shh' motion before the silence, told him it was to remember the soldiers and he had to stand beside her and stay quiet, and he got the message. Even if he hadn't, I would still appreciate her attempt!

The parents to the other kids (who were running around playing), just did nothing. I felt a bit sad that people were there remembering their relatives in some cases, yet a lot of noise was happening during the silence and the rest of ceremony.

It's in a rural area so although it was outside, there wasn't any traffic noise etc so the kids perhaps seemed louder because of this.

Anyway, AIBU for thinking some of the parents shouldve stepped in before the 2min silence to keep things reasonably quiet?

OP posts:
LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 14/11/2022 14:48

DomesticShortHair · 14/11/2022 13:59

I agree with your dad’s view completely.

I do too. Your dad sounds a very special and sensible person, knittedcardi. I'll take the word of a veteran any day over the posturing and shushing from adults who should know better.

If you want to stand stock still and pay your respects then do. Quietly and without swivelling your eyes and neck around to see what others are doing.

Some people just love to control what others do, even when it's not within their gift and performative really does cover it.

Alloftheboys · 14/11/2022 14:38

Selfish parents.

Emmacb82 · 14/11/2022 14:32

I honestly thought you were going to be talking about toddlers! I don’t understand the point of taking your children to a service like this if you are not going to teach them the respect of staying silent for those two tiny minutes. And those children would have done a silence at school on the 11th. I have a 6 year old who would have looked around him to see everyone else was silent and he would have stayed quiet without needing to be told.
Unfortunately we have bred a generation that put themselves and their own above everybody else. If precious Jonny wants to play football during the silence then why shouldn’t he.

mycatisannoying · 14/11/2022 14:28

Sadly, this doesn't surprise me. Mine would have been told to stand still and be quiet or I'd take them home.
Gentle parenting my arse!

JenniferBarkley · 14/11/2022 14:25

It's just such a weird choice to bring them but not have them observe the silence. I'm not British and don't observe it - so I don't go to a service. Confused

Dinosauratemydaffodils · 14/11/2022 14:18

Absolutely unacceptable. Thought you were going to say toddlers to be honest. Yesterday ds (7) went with his Scout Group, they all managed to stand still and silent for 2 minutes, as did his 4 year old sister. Then he had to do the same before his football match and again everyone managed.

Tir3dToddl3rMum · 14/11/2022 14:03

Yesterday was my sons 3rd birthday and we went to Thomas Land. They held the 2 mins silent. My 3 year old stood in silence. I was on my knees cuddling him but he was silent and he waited in place which was hard for him as he could see his Nonna (grandmother) who was about 50 feet away from him as she was making her way over to him with my siblings and her husband. My son adores his Nonna but he stood, in silence and waited like a good boy. My mum was so proud of him and once he could move, he ran to her.

It is all about good parenting. If my 3 year old can be still and silent then a 7 to 11 year old can.

DomesticShortHair · 14/11/2022 13:59

KnittedCardi · 14/11/2022 11:14

I am conflicted on this one, and very mindful of what my Dad would've thought. He was a WWII tank commander in Africa and Italy, had some pretty bad experiences, would never talk about it much. But we regularly visited his friends in their graves in Italy when we went on holiday, and I often went with him, for him it was a very personal experience.

He was however of the opinion that much of our remembrance activities are too many and too much. Much of it is performative, and there should be no compulsion to take part or to wear poppies. Just his view, but interesting.

He would have thought that children playing nearby, was lovely, and was what he had fought for.

If the children were not actually at the memorial, or facing it, but playing away from it, I personally think that is fine.

I agree with your dad’s view completely.

ABJ100 · 14/11/2022 12:43

TrashyPanda · 14/11/2022 10:04

Wow

of course NT kids that age should be able to stand in silence for a few minutes.

I knew someone was bound to come up with this. 🙄. Off course all those rude children had SN 🙄Yanbu op, my 6yo knows better, an 11yo there's no excuse, even for a 9yo.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 14/11/2022 12:29

Nocaloriesinchocolate · 14/11/2022 11:19

Totally agree, OP. When 11th falls on a weekday I always make sure I’m either at home or somewhere on my own so I dont get irritated at anyone breaking the silence

Same with me. Four minutes isn't a lot to ask.

courgettigreensadwater · 14/11/2022 12:26

Between 7-11 years old I would 100% expect them to be quiet for the two minutes. Tbh. Any child over about the age of three who does not have SN I would think should be quiet.

RuthW · 14/11/2022 12:17

Disgusting. Any child over 3 without special needs should be able to stay still and quiet for 2 minutes.

Then again patients at work look at us gone mad when we ask them to wait a moment while we stay silent. I totally missed the one on Friday as I couldn't get a patient off the phone.

I was driving yesterday, but found a place to park at 10.55.

LittleOwlorNot · 14/11/2022 12:05

My almost 2 year old and I were in a supermarket during the 2 minute silence on Friday. He was in the trolley seat and I put my arm around him, gave him something to hold and bless him, he rested his head against my chest and stayed quiet!
I think those children should have been standing quietly with their parents and actually, should know that at their age.

budgiegirl · 14/11/2022 12:02

If a group you could maybe send an email to their leaders saying that for next year could they be taught how to behave

I doubt there's a scout leader in the country that would allow their young people to behave like this. I'm a cub leader, and we took over 50 children to a memorial service yesterday - a parade, followed by a church service and an outdoor service by our war memorial for the 2 minute silence, followed by another parade. Over 2.5 hours in total, and the children were impeccably behaved. I was very, very proud of them. We have one child with severe ADHD, and he managed to stay quiet and still for the silence, by humming very softly to himself.

I would have been really frustrated by the parents of the children you described - I agree that wearing poppies etc should be a personal choice, but why take your kids to such an event, and then not control them for the silence? It makes no sense, and would make me very cross.

Mariposista · 14/11/2022 11:41

Lazy, disrespectful parents who have clearly not taught their children the importance of RD in our country, what it means and why the 2 minute silence is significant.

AmIAnOldBag · 14/11/2022 11:36

Oh yes, it was a bagpipe that started the silence and then ended it here! Can see the cannon being scary for dogs and babies!

OP posts:
Grumpyoldpersonwithcats · 14/11/2022 11:31

Off topic, but as a child during the large parade and service in St Giles in Oxford, there was always a cannon fired to mark the start of the two minutes silence. I rather miss it.

Thesearmsofmine · 14/11/2022 11:29

YANBU with toddlers it’s understandable but at those ages they should be expected and able to keep quiet. My social media timeline was full of children of those ages taking part in remembrance services, my own included, at our service the youngest there was 6 and was a little unsure but still able to keep silent.

Sugargliderwombat · 14/11/2022 11:29

I teach 4 year olds and they can do it.

80sMum · 14/11/2022 11:24

LiveIngSun · 14/11/2022 11:15

By us there was an amazing start to the 2 min silence. So many children, yet you could hear the birds despite all the toddlers and babies in the crowd. The young scouts and guide members were beautiful. Massive crowd yet so still.

Then they, without any public warning, brought an actual working cannon. Hidden a little bit so many didn’t see it if they approached from a popular direction. Not just for decoration. Someone had decided that they’d start and end the silence this year with the cannon.

So as it started… BOOM. Every dog in the area started barking, you could hear it from houses all around. Babies cried, kids jumped and exclaimed. A few tried to
run away or screamed.

Just as we calmed them down… BOOM.

Oh dear! I whose idea that was?! Sorry, but I did laugh when I read your post!

Comefromaway · 14/11/2022 11:24

LiveIngSun · 14/11/2022 11:15

By us there was an amazing start to the 2 min silence. So many children, yet you could hear the birds despite all the toddlers and babies in the crowd. The young scouts and guide members were beautiful. Massive crowd yet so still.

Then they, without any public warning, brought an actual working cannon. Hidden a little bit so many didn’t see it if they approached from a popular direction. Not just for decoration. Someone had decided that they’d start and end the silence this year with the cannon.

So as it started… BOOM. Every dog in the area started barking, you could hear it from houses all around. Babies cried, kids jumped and exclaimed. A few tried to
run away or screamed.

Just as we calmed them down… BOOM.

That's bad. My autistic teens would have gone into meltdown at such an unexpected noise, it would have triggered dh's Menieres and that is before you think of any veterans who might have PTSD.

80sMum · 14/11/2022 11:21

Elderemo · 14/11/2022 10:43

I work in hospitality. We had bbc1 on the TV, with volume, showing the service. We made all of the customers aware in advance that we would be observing the silence.

Out of 21 occupied tables everybody was very respectful, except one. A table with two adults and two 8/9 year old children who chatted and laughed throughout. So bloody disrespectful.

Gosh, that's terrible! They must have been aware that they were the only people talking. How horribly disrespectful of them.

badbaduncle · 14/11/2022 11:21

The 10% of people voting YABU are the 10% with these loud annoying children. I feel very sorry for the DC as they grow up thinking they can do WTF they want and don't learn social cues so end up finding it difficult to fit in to higher education/work settings. My Aunt was like this and her DC have all been repeatedly sacked but are now, in their late 30s/40s accept the issues and parent their own children very differently.

Nocaloriesinchocolate · 14/11/2022 11:19

Totally agree, OP. When 11th falls on a weekday I always make sure I’m either at home or somewhere on my own so I dont get irritated at anyone breaking the silence

KnittedCardi · 14/11/2022 11:16

@AmIAnOldBag Ah, we crossed posted. Then yes, they should not have been allowed to play in front of, or between those present. The parents should have asked them to move away from the service.

Swipe left for the next trending thread