Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say no to my mum living with us?

261 replies

Cowardlytiger · 14/11/2022 09:08

My mum is really struggling at the moment. She has a long history of mental health problems and since my dad died 18 months ago this has all got a lot worse. I’ve done my best to support her (sorting probate, sorting out paying all her bills, speaking to her every day on the phone, finding somewhere for her to live jn supported living close to us) but she says things are still terrible with daily panic attacks and feeling anxious all the time and she hates living alone. But I really, really don’t want her living with us - I have two kids to think about too and, although this sounds very unsympathetic, she is quite hard to deal with (she will cry on the phone to me for an hour or so each day telling me about how awful everything is and how awful my dad was to her etc etc) and I just feel I cannot cope with any more of it - and worry it would not be good for my kids either. But am I just being a selfish cow?

OP posts:
knittingaddict · 14/11/2022 15:34

msbevvy · 14/11/2022 11:10

Why not?

My mum did it and it wrecked her marriage and my childhood.

My Dad started staying out till all hours after work to avoid my Grandma and was a bad tempered drunk when he finally got in.

My Mum's health suffered and she ended up in hospital after it all got too much for her.

I don't think you meant to quote my post. It seems we agree.

ASandwichNamedKevin · 14/11/2022 15:32

Cowardlytiger · 14/11/2022 09:28

I guess the reason to refuse is because it’s not what I want to do, not what my husband wants and not what the kids want. Is that valid or just selfish? I don’t know.

That's the perfect reason to refuse, you're putting the needs and wellbeing of 4 people before 1 person.

It's also okay to step back a bit from what you are doing, but would be kind to do so gradually. I'm fully prepared to help my parents with life admin, I do a lot of it, and shopping/cleaning and have the means to pay for some things to make their lives easier. But I also have chosen to bring DC into the world and have a desire to bring them up in a happy home, and not introduce extra stress into everyone's lives.

oakleaffy · 14/11/2022 15:19

@MaybeIWillFuckOffThen
Your story is very harrowing, but you are absolutely not to blame.
Your mother’s damage was too deep for you to begin to put right.

A true story of an ex addict ( Caspar Walsh) described enmesment with his father-
Caspar had a complicated relationship with his addict father ( Who could be utterly charming at times)

Caspar’s father chose to commit suicide, and it was shortly after Caspar had not picked up the phone to his Dad, because he didn’t hear the calls.
The answerphone contained messages.

Caspar said it was 3am.
He didn’t want to call his dad back, but had a bad feeling.

Suffice to say, his dad had taken his own life.

It is a beautifully written book, and describes the mixed emotions of losing a parent in this way so honestly - It absolutely wasn’t Caspar’s fault that his complex dad had chosen this way out.

Suicide of a parent is tough.
The book is “ Criminal “ by Caspar Walsh.

It may resonate with you.

You absolutely are not to blame.

🌼

HowcanIhelp123 · 14/11/2022 15:14

Maybe this has already been covered, but if she is 'too anxious' to make the journey to visit the assisted living near you ... how would she not be too anxious to make the same journey to live with you? It's the same journey.

Your mum has issues with alcohol and anxiety which makes people very selfish. She wants to live with you so she is refusung other options.

YNBU OP, she can't live with you.

canteatlovefood · 14/11/2022 15:03

Even without the drip feed I think she is being very selfish.
My own mum had to move her mum to a nursing home last year, and she should have gone there years before! But she said she would never forgive them (her and siblings) if they put her in a home so they struggled for years trying to work and care for her.

My mum now wouldn't dream of putting that situation onto me or my sister. Especially with young kids in the mix.

Gh12345 · 14/11/2022 14:58

I don’t think you’re being unreasonable both ways, but it could maybe be too much for your kids and marriage. I actually think in the long run it’s better to get her in her own place and look after herself. I saw someone else post about letting her sleep over once a fortnight or week. I think that would be better.

mamabear715 · 14/11/2022 14:55

@MaybeIWillFuckOffThen
Just wanted to send hugs & say I am thinking of you & anyone else in / who was in an awful situation. x

Aworldofmyown · 14/11/2022 14:47

No. She is 70 not 90! More than capable she just needs to re learn how to live! Support her with that, if you move her in you could have 25 years of being her carer.

ivykaty44 · 14/11/2022 14:46

(although I probably sound very negative about it all here) I do understand that she is in ab awful place and desperately needs help and support (and more than the NHS is giving her at the moment). So I feel bad for her. But I just can’t have her live with us

and what about your grief, losing your father? How bad does she feel for you? family isn't a one way street.

Cruisebabe1 · 14/11/2022 14:42

Caramelsmadfuzzytail · 14/11/2022 12:11

When my mother was dying I was asked if I was going to be her carer. My answer was a resounding Fuck,No! And I never felt guilty about it. She had a partner, there were other family members, she was an emotionally absent mother all my life and I didn't particularly want to watch her die.
It sounds like you are becoming her parent.
If you don't want her there, don't have her there.

I agree with you, isn’t it strange that emotionally abusive mothers always seem to selectively forget their behaviour when they get old and expect us to look after them. My mother told me I was a mistake when I was young , so I didn’t make the mistake of buying into her emotional blackmail.

WeAllHaveWings · 14/11/2022 14:39

You will need to be firm with her and make her two choices clear.

Stay put - where it isnt working out and her health is likely to deteriorate, possibly resulting in going into a care home earlier
Go visit assisted care home - to see if it would work for her, possibly allow her to live independently for much longer

Make it clear there is no 3rd choice (living with you). I had to have a similar conversation with my mum it isn't easy, but I have no regrets.

katseyes7 · 14/11/2022 14:34

My maternal grandma lived with us in the 1960s when l was very young. In a two bedroom flat.
She had one bedroom, l shared the other with my parents. Until she died when l was ten.
She was in very poor health, she'd had several strokes and was blind, deaf and paralysed, and doubly incontinent.
My parents and one of my aunts (her daughter) looked after her. I remember very clearly being told to sit down and not make a noise, with colouring books and pens, and given sweets. Totally understandable, but really not the best for anyone concerned. There weren't the care facilities back then that there are now, but even if there had been, l doubt we could have afforded them.
My main memory of being a child is having to be quiet and not bother anyone, and of the house smelling of 'illness'. No inside toilet, no bathroom. Tin bath, outside loo.
I appreciate things are different now, but my mother invested a huge amount of time and energy looking after my grandma. I was largely left to my dad and my own devices.
It would be a huge undertaking and upheaval, OP, and would undoubtedly impact on your family. I don't blame you for being reluctant to have her live with you.
I hope you are able to sort out something that's best for all of you. x

Cruisebabe1 · 14/11/2022 14:32

Stevie6 · 14/11/2022 09:28

Not wanting to and it not being right for her family is a perfectly valid reason no to

Well said Stevie 6

TicTac80 · 14/11/2022 14:26

OP, you're definitely not selfish to refuse to have her live with you. Please don't do it. You know she's an alcoholic (she was drink driving with you in the car when you were a child!), you know she's been evicted from a flat due to her behaviour, and you know it how was for you, growing up with a mother who has all these problems. You know that you can't fix her, she has to want to be fixed in the first place, and she doesn't sound like she wants to.

Don't put yourselves through that stress (my XH was/is an alcoholic - I wouldn't wish that crap on my worst enemy, it really is a form of hell). I also think it's no bad thing that she lives so far away from you - it means that it's less likely that she'll show up at your place drunk, and it means that you're less likely to be dragged into having to deal with dramas everytime she does get drunk. I know I sound awful, but you must do what is right for you, your DH and your DC.

FWIW, we did look after my grandparents at home, during their last illnesses: care was shared amongst my aunties, uncles and cousins (including myself). HOWEVER: most of my family are doctors/nurses (so knew what to expect and how to look after them); my grandparents were absolutely lovely, always really wonderful, polite and gentle. They didn't smoke and drink, they were never rude or unkind. Their health problems were physical (so they had full cognition and capacity) and they did what they could for helping themselves too. Had it been that they had dementia, it could have been a different story (and it definitely would have been a hell of a lot harder to manage!). We had a rota in place where there were enough of us to help them (and give each other breaks etc), there was enough space in the different houses of my aunties and uncles...and my grandparents happily accepted carers to come in too (family paid for this). But that is a situation that doesn't happen often (I know this as I'm a nurse): there were enough of us in the family able to help out (and work together/around each others' jobs/lives etc), space wasn't an issue and the family were able (financially) to facilitate additional help/equipment when needed.

Drfosters · 14/11/2022 14:12

Honestly you have to stay firm and say no. My mum was in your exact position so I have experience of being a child on this. She did stand firm but did spend 15 years ‘popping in’ which was hard when she had kids and a full time job. But for the sake of her marriage there was just no way my grandmother was moving in. I was older though so I helped my grandmother activities to do and in the end she found a group to socialise with. It wasn’t perfect but if my grandmother had moved in it would have been much worse.

CruCru · 14/11/2022 14:11

Supersimkin2 · 14/11/2022 11:52

‘final years’ = 20-plus years, two decades, of 24/7 care of a demented, clinically depressed human in your own home will damage you more than it helps her.

A lot more.

I agree. Apart from anything else, if the mum is in her late 70s, the OP will be in her forties or fifties. If the mum lives for 20 years then there’s a good chance the OP will be a carer when she is in her seventies. None of us stay young and got forever.

Plus, frankly, this is going to do the OP’s marriage no good whatsoever.

Coyoacan · 14/11/2022 14:11

I am a grandmother myself and I would not want to ruin my only daughter's life and that of my grandchild by inflicting myself on them, especially when there is an assisted living option.

By the way, is your mother taking vitamin B? The alcohol is obviously excaberating her problem with panic attacks by removing vitamin B from her system.

Subbaxeo · 14/11/2022 14:10

I’m 60 and would shudder at the thought of placing such a burden on my children when I’m older. You help her a lot-don’t go down the route of moving her in. In the past, people didn’t have the same lifestyles as now or lived so long-don’t let people guilt trip you into doing this.

Fleurdaisy · 14/11/2022 14:05

Not a good idea, and I say this as someone who is fairly close to your mum’s age.
I think she has to find other ways to support her needs, I think living with you is her way of seeing a “fix” for her problems.
I think looking at professional support, local support groups for anxiety, social contact for her ( hobby groups? u3A? local church? ) might be helpful.
You can contact Cruse for bereavement support, they may be able to help.

1983Louise · 14/11/2022 14:05

I wouldn't do it, we all need boundaries in place even with close family members. Have you tried limiting the amount of time you speak to her, 10 minutes maybe then say you have to go. Encourage her to see the assistant living place, in our area if you turn down accommodation a few times you're then placed at the back of queue. You're obviously doing your best but please don't let her take over your life.

CookPassBabtridge · 14/11/2022 14:01

Nope would never do it, my home is my sanctuary.. we are not in the past now, and we are not in another country where this is common thank god.
The people I've seen do it have hated it and relationships have suffered.

Thelnebriati · 14/11/2022 13:57

Don't do it. I have panic disorder and PTSD, and wouldn't inflict myself on my family.
Your Mum needs to take her meds and engage with therapy. Its possible she isn't actually taking her meds if she is still having severe attacks, or she may need to try a different type. She sounds like she needs extra support, but that has to come from her GP and mental health professionals because you don't have the power to fix her. You would if you could.

There are mental health support help lines she should call, and Mind have an active online community.
This support line is also for families and carers;
www.supportline.org.uk/problems/mental-health/

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 14/11/2022 13:54

CaitoftheCantii · 14/11/2022 13:49

Don’t do it - my late grandmother moved in with us when I was in my teens, and she single-handed broke my mother. The fall-out was indescribably awful and has left scars that still hurt more than 30 years later…

Also grew up with my late grandmother. My mother was her carer for 30 years - worse when she got older and was confined to a wheelchair. Mum had no life of her own and her only time off was an hour a day shopping.

Dogtooth · 14/11/2022 13:54

I don't think her living with you is the best for anyone. She needs to be supported with her mental health and then find a way to get back out into the world through exercise, community groups etc that will build her confidence and independence and give her company.

If you let her move in with you, it sounds like she'd be staying in a lot, wholly dependent on your family for company, not doing much for herself. That's not best for her either.

Can you put a limit on the time you spend with her, and keep that boundary? Eg 20 min phone call a day, have her round for dinner once a week. But don't make it so your time is a blank cheque for her to dump everything and anything on you for hours and hours. Could bereavement counselling help her?

Mirabai · 14/11/2022 13:53

The obvious thing, if she refuses to come and look at assisted living accommodation near you, is to find her the same thing local to where she is now. Then at least she will be at a distance.

I wonder, given her issues, whether assisted will be sufficient? She may be better off in a care home with everything done for her and her medication and alcohol intake monitored. And she might also be less lonely.

One other thing to consider - if the assisted living development doesn’t have a care home with nursing care attached, she will have to move again when she deteriorates. If you can find a retirement village with everything on site it’s a major advantage.

Swipe left for the next trending thread