Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To get a beagle?

143 replies

mashh · 14/11/2022 04:07

My parents think I am. DF says they are hunting dogs so are hard to train and very noisy. DM says they are working dogs, not family dogs and no one really gets them as domestic pets.

DP grew up with one so is happy to have one but says his childhood dog was stubborn and had bad recall. I personally just don't want a big dog and preferably a low maintenance breed. Aibu to consider beagles?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
spottygymbag · 14/11/2022 09:28

Close friends family had ex-airport working beagles when they were retired. They were beautifully cared for and kept entertained and exercised (rural property) but still caused no end of chaos.
One got in through the sun roof of a Ute and ripped the whole interior to pieces trying to find the food it could smell.
Also snuck into the kitchen, stole a whole salmon and buried it in the garden (he was trained to locate certain foods but not eat it).
Very beautiful, intelligent and lovely but prone to mischief!

whiteroseredrose · 14/11/2022 09:18

I've always loved Beagles (to look at, as a PP said).

Strangely enough, when we did a 'which dog is best for you' quiz before we got Ddog, a Beagle was in the top 3 as a family dog / not guard dog. We did our research which mentioned having a strong scent drive, and then saw a distraught woman in Richmond Park whose two Beagles had just run off.

So we got a wonderful Border Terrier instead.

thelobsterquadrille · 14/11/2022 09:18

We have a beagle.

In terms of grooming he's incredibly low maintenance but I wouldn't say he was a low-maintenance breed in general - he's an amazing house dog though.

He has separation anxiety and can't be trusted off the lead unless at the beach or in a secure field. Otherwise it's nose down, ears off and away he goes.

If you're looking for a dog that will trot away next to you on a walk then they're not the breed for you! They need lots of input when they're out and about and they're very easily distracted.

But at home he is amazing. As long as he's had a walk and some food he will sleep and cuddle the day away. He loves fuss, loves people and loves nothing more than curling up next to you under a blanket.

To get a beagle?
JustMaggie · 14/11/2022 09:14

We have a beagle. I would say she is definitely low maintenance when it comes to her coat. She can come home muddy after her walk but she always goes to sleep when she gets home. When she wakes up she's dry and all the mud is gone. She's a self cleaning dog 😃

VickyEadieofThigh · 14/11/2022 08:59

Beagles can be very loving dogs, as others have said - but (also as said) they usually have a LOT of issues that can be difficult to manage and live with.

Our neighbours have 2 and and jeez, are they NOISY feckers! They yodel all the time, even on walks, especially when they spot another dog.

A colleague's daughter got a pair of beagles as family pets; unfortunately, she and her husband worked full-time - the dogs destroyed the house in their boredom. Mind, other dogs might well do that!

Other beagles in our town are all overweight - too greedy and not exercised enough (because they need a lot of daily exercise).

There are lots of other dogs which would be massively easier to manage - someone mentioned lurches, which rescues are full of, because they're not fashionable. They're brilliant dogs.

Stellaris22 · 14/11/2022 08:48

We have a scent hound and we never let her off lead in wooded areas, she smells squirrels and her ears turn off. Most other areas she's fine off lead, but you do have to have lots of treats. Obedience and training is perfectly possible, but they have a 'what's in it for me' attitude eg you can ask her to sit, but until she sees a reward she won't do it.

Lovely dogs though and the only breed for me now. Ours only barks when out and her favourite thing is playing with her doggy pals.

DelurkingLawyer · 14/11/2022 08:38

God no. My PIL had a beagle. It was incredibly greedy, obsessed by food and it put its front paws on the table at every meal and barked constantly. Untrainable, no recall, stank. The only time I ever liked it was when it bit my father in law after refusing to go for a walk with him.

Stifledlife · 14/11/2022 08:37

HUGE personality, but you pay for it.
Constant shedding of little spiky hairs. Will steal food.. any food, right in front of you. (We lost the christmas turkey the first year - the dog climbed on a bar stool, grabbed it and took off. Keystone style chase with Benny hill music ensued).
They also can be anxious.
No agression and love everyone and everything.
When the head goes down the brain leaves the builidng and the PP that said the ears become purely decorative is spot on. The upside is the dog can always find you and being a hound owner is a mind shift. Invest in a tracker if you are going to let them off lead.
They are loving, funny, full of personality, stubborn, prone to destruction and disappearance, and definitely not easy.

FettleOfKish · 14/11/2022 08:23

DH lived with a Beagle (his Ex's dog) and it's about the only breed he wouldn't consider were we to get a dog.

Couldn't take him off the lead, ever, no recall whatsoever if he was interested in something else, food obsessed, wildly high maintenance.

FearofQueefing · 14/11/2022 08:19

BUT the downsides are .. off lead, it is true that the nose goes down and the ears become purely decorative.

Can't emphasise this enough. We have a Basset Fauve - French scent hound with very similar temperament to a Beagle. These type of dogs cannot be trusted off lead in an open space. The scent instinct is unbelievably strong and once they have a sniff of game they follow their own path and recall goes out the window. If you think about it, Beagles are bred to run in packs and be followed by humans on horseback. They give chase and you have to follow - that's how they are wired....

Know a few Beagle owners who say they are lovely with people and very affectionate family dogs. But very stubborn independent spirit. You'll never fully train them.

Skiphopbump · 14/11/2022 08:02

I come across a two year old beagle while dog walking.. The owner is exasperated and says she can’t take her eye off him for a moment as he will eat what ever he finds - he’s had operations to remove items he’s swallowed. He can be pet off the lead but is easily distracted, he’s also lovely and friendly but he sounds such hard work. I don’t know how typical he is for the breed.

Untitledsquatboulder · 14/11/2022 07:50

You could do the beagle test?

Get a brick, an ordinary house brick will do. Take it to the woods, throw it into the bushes then spend two days calling for it to come back. After 2 days retrieve brick, go home and rip up your own sofa. Shut brick in laundry room for its own safety. Spend the evening sat in the wreckage listening to a recording of of a beagle howling every 5 minutes. See how many of your neighbours come over to complain.

If this sounds fun you'd be a good fit for a beagle. Lovely dogs, but an expensive pain in the arse.

fruitstick · 14/11/2022 07:28

I wanted a beagle for exactly the same reasons as you. However I did some research and decided it was not for me. Also, have you actually heard one? The howl is quite something.

I also noticed there were a lot of beagles available as rescues - all about 9 months/ a year

My niece had a beagle but had to rehome him because he had massive separation anxiety and they couldn't leave the house.

In the end we got a cocker spaniel. Not without his challenges but a little easier to manage than a beagle I think.

NiceTwin · 14/11/2022 07:27

They can be lovely, in fact I don't know of any that have a side to them.
But! My God they can be noisy.

Of the 10 I know well, only 3 of them are "normal" on the noise front. The others howl, bark and bay for fun. Not just for a short amount of time either, they have some stamina!!

I would say yabu to even consider one.

Thisislifefornow · 14/11/2022 07:27

I personally wouldn't recommend a beagle. We have a 2year old beagle that we have had since he was 9 weeks old.oh my days , it's been and still is sometimes hard work. For the 1st year he nipped the children constantly and destroyed the house. He isn't easy to walk and has no recall outside of the home. Again he is greedy and constantly begging or sniffing around for food. We love him but it's been a real tough ride.

babytum · 14/11/2022 07:22

I have a rescue beagle, I found out in the first month why she was turned in to the shelter 🙈.

definitely not low maintenance, obsessed with food to a level you wouldn’t believe, incredibly intelligent but very stubborn. Sheds so much I feel like loosing my mind but the most beautiful nature you could imagine.

I wouldn’t get a beagle again because of the shedding more than anything else but she’s here 5 years now and wouldn’t be without her. Even though she drives me insane sometimes

BigBunkers · 14/11/2022 07:20

Beagles are not low maintenance!

We've got a couple in the family and my god they are greedy. Like distractingly so. Lovely dogs, great temperament, but definitely naughty.

Hibernationsetting · 14/11/2022 07:17

Beagle? Low maintenance? Hilarious.

and as for someone saying “easy to train”?! Not in my experience! Fuck that.

SnarkyBag · 14/11/2022 07:17

Beagles are gorgeous I grew up with two. So affectionate and funny but as others say not low maintenance.

Now if you want low maintenance may I suggest the humble lurcher massively overlooked as a wonderful family dog. Not always the brightest tool in the shed but still fabulous!

BumbleShyBee · 14/11/2022 07:13

Beagles are the best family dogs!! Ours is super sweet and friendly, has been a great support for our autistic son. She is incredibly calm and puts up with endless toddler pulls on her ears and whacks on her head. 100% agree with previous posters about the strong food motivation - but this does make them easy to train. They are really smart dogs. Ours does not howl or bark and can be left at home by herself for a few hours at a time with no issues. She's very friendly with other dogs and is just a delight. She goes to a dog park every morning for a massive run and play and then sleeps the rest of the day. Absolutely eats everything in sight (my parents recently left biscuits and a wedge of blue vein cheese on the kitchen table, all gone as soon as their backs were turned) so guests soon learn to keep food up high and to lock bedroom doors!!

BankseyVest · 14/11/2022 07:11

I've got a Welsh hound crossed with a Beagle. She's the most loving, happy family dog I've ever owned. She's never shown an ounce of aggression towards humans or other dogs.

Scent hounds aren't naturally good with recall, some just can't be trained, 'head down, arse up' whilst walking. But mine is very food orientated, so easy to train in other areas. But means she will eat anything so weight needs to be monitored.

Snoken · 14/11/2022 07:05

Agree with most others, do not get a Beagle unless you are planning to let it work, and I mean properly work. They need hours of exercise daily to not be too destructive in the house, they are noisy, headstrong and just unpredictable and almost impossible to train to a high degree of reliability. They are also very, very cute of course, but it sounds like you want a low maintenance dog, and that is definitely not a Beagle.

muddlingthrou · 14/11/2022 07:03

We have a beagle and she is amazing. Perfect with children, doesn't have an aggressive bone in her body and super sweet. HOWEVER I wouldn't class them as low maintenance dogs. We've put so much work into her recall and it's still not 100% - if there's a picnic to dive bomb or a deer to track, we simply can't compete.

Teadrinkingmumofone · 14/11/2022 07:01

You clearly haven't done any research on beagle if you're considering getting one as they're low maintenance!
If you want a low maintenance dog I'd suggest a stuffed toy.

Onegingerhead · 14/11/2022 06:57

I wonder what are the smell comments. All dog smell (GSD owner here), especially after they get wet (rain or river likewise).
Beagles I know are the handful

Swipe left for the next trending thread