Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To get a beagle?

143 replies

mashh · 14/11/2022 04:07

My parents think I am. DF says they are hunting dogs so are hard to train and very noisy. DM says they are working dogs, not family dogs and no one really gets them as domestic pets.

DP grew up with one so is happy to have one but says his childhood dog was stubborn and had bad recall. I personally just don't want a big dog and preferably a low maintenance breed. Aibu to consider beagles?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
morekidsthanhands · 14/11/2022 15:10

We have a beagle she's 4 and I love her to bits. Great with the kids, super loving and funny. She needs a lot of exercise which is great as so do I Cake. And I am home alone at night a lot and walk her alone and she makes me feel safe.

I wouldn't describe her as low maintenance though. We can't have her off lead, she howls at the slightest noise, we put her in a pen at meal times as she is very food motivated, she has issues with her anal glands which is common for the breed and as grim as it sounds and she has chewed a lot of bloody stuff.

BeagleMum9 · 14/11/2022 15:08

Shiningstarr · 14/11/2022 15:02

@BeagleMum9

Is this not normal for a beagle then? To do all that constant howling? I just thought that's what they did.

I'm obviously not a dog person by the way, so know very little.

They all can howl. Mine doesn't very often. She did a couple of times at the vets and when someone tried to dry her with a hairdryer - she was not happy. Never done it at other times.

I don't know if I've just got lucky though.

Roomba · 14/11/2022 15:07

We have a two year old Beagle and tbh we didn't find her hard to train compared to other breeds. Perhaps we were just very lucky with her temperament, I can't say. She does need a LOT of exercise, but she's taken out for very long woodland or fell walks every day for hours (ex is a dog walker who specialises in longer walks/runs so she goes out with him and the other dogs and loves it). They need to be kept busy or can be destructive (but same for most dogs).

She is very inquisitive, happy to be left in the house for a couple of hours but when we're in usually wants to sit on or next to one of us as much as possible. She is a bit cheeky and loves digging up house and garden plants to bury her treats under - she also hides treats and "special" items like DS's sweaty socks behind the sofa for later.

She's very friendly, affectionate and great with kids of all ages plus other dogs. She did silk a bit when we looked after another Beagle for a few days, but they became firm friends after a couple of days. And she smells far less than other breeds I've known (or maybe I've just gone noseblind? 😂).

Bearfrills · 14/11/2022 15:04

MyGrandmaLizzie · 14/11/2022 14:13

From experience Beagles fart much more than other breeds

Ours was until we started using this

www.poochandmutt.co.uk/products/bionic-biotic

We also cut out the fattier meats such as lamb and duck and use a dog food with added vegetables (Winalot Sunday dinner is current favourite).

She is now far less windy and doesn't often have the runs like she did when we first got her.

We did briefly try a raw diet but that made her tummy troubles worse.

LovelyBitOfSquirrrel · 14/11/2022 15:03

We have a beagle and he’s a great family dog. Sleeps a lot, very cuddly and doesn’t shed much. Only downside is we don’t have him off lead but tbh we’re just very cautious, his recall is actually pretty good. With any breed you’ll hear nightmare stories but every dog is different and you’ll get back what you put in.

Shiningstarr · 14/11/2022 15:02

@BeagleMum9

Is this not normal for a beagle then? To do all that constant howling? I just thought that's what they did.

I'm obviously not a dog person by the way, so know very little.

BeagleMum9 · 14/11/2022 15:01

@Frequency He is very cute.

Frequency · 14/11/2022 14:57

We have two other dogs. One hates the beagle cross and will attack him on sight. The beagle thinks this is a game, he doesn't seem to understand what aggression is.

This dog chooses to live upstairs with the cats who also hate the beagle cross (he's too big and bouncy for them). We have taught the beagle he is not allowed to open the door to the stairs or go upstairs. The chihuhua plays with him but gets worn out quicker than he does which leads to him barking at her loudly until she is sent upstairs out of his reach.

He is well trained. His recall is mostly fine (except if he spots a toddler or picnic). He knows multiple commands including wait, back up, give, settle and go to mat and will follow them 90% of the time. The other 10% of the time is when there is something too exciting going on eg too many new guests or other dogs playing closeby.

None of that stops him surfing the counters the second my back is turned and he is taller than your average beagle. There is nowhere in my kitchen he cannot reach. Ditto toys. If it's on the floor, as far as he is concerned, it is fair game to chew it to death or bury it in the garden. I've had to dig up and wash more of DC's friends trainers and shoes than I care to remember despite them all being warned shoes can only be left upstairs. If there is nothing on the floor to bury when he feels like digging he will dig for the sake of digging or find something off the kitchen counter or coffee table to bury.

He doesn't have SA at all. All the other animals sleep upstairs and are kept upstairs when we go out because the beagle's bounciness could easily accidentally injure the smaller animals. He is 100% fine when left alone.

To get a beagle?
BeagleMum9 · 14/11/2022 14:55

Shiningstarr · 14/11/2022 14:54

Beagles are annoying dogs (sorry)

We used to have one that lived in the house directly behind us, their back garden backed onto ours. It would be in the garden constantly howling. Honestly they make the most annoying, irritating noise.

This beagle would howl at anything and everything. So many complaints from all neighbours (not us as I had enough to deal with).

Was glad when they moved.

The dog was not being looked after well and was obviously unhappy.

Shiningstarr · 14/11/2022 14:54

Beagles are annoying dogs (sorry)

We used to have one that lived in the house directly behind us, their back garden backed onto ours. It would be in the garden constantly howling. Honestly they make the most annoying, irritating noise.

This beagle would howl at anything and everything. So many complaints from all neighbours (not us as I had enough to deal with).

Was glad when they moved.

thelobsterquadrille · 14/11/2022 14:48

bonzaitree · 14/11/2022 13:31

OP, don't get a beagle.

They aren't bred to be family pets, and therefore when kept in a domestic setting are very destructive, hard to train, strong willed and will run off.

I have seen family members at breaking point with beagles and a colleague who had a kitchen so badly damaged it had to be replaced.

Repeat. Do not get a beagle.

Nonsense.

They are a specialist breed but they only become destructive and unmanageable if you don't put the work in.

Suzi888 · 14/11/2022 14:48

No dog is low maintenance.
I’ve only seen, well heard one at daycare. Gorgeous dog, but noisy as hell.

I’m not sure any dog is low maintenance to be honest.

BeagleMum9 · 14/11/2022 14:46

We had a Springer once - that's what I call hard work.

BeagleMum9 · 14/11/2022 14:45

Frequency · 14/11/2022 14:34

The OP's DM is wrong though. I know quite a few people who've had/have them as pets

She's not completely wrong. They are working breeds. Yes, their loving, trusting nature is perfect for a family pet but if you're not dog orientated and can't/won't give your beagle a job that plays to it's strengths they will find their own job (i.e digging up the garden or figuring out how to access the food cupboard).

We play scent games and do clicker training with ours but it's still not enough to wear him out. He can and will still find trouble if we don't ensure anything and everything he could possibly eat or destroy is kept out of his reach and/or locked away.

Have you got another dog? We have and I think that helps because they play together even at 9 years old. The only time she gets separation anxiety is if we take the other dog to the groomers or vets without her. She doesn't care if the humans leave.

She can clearly let us know if she wants a treat but is satisfied with one and doesn't pester for more. The smell of meat cooking does get her going though.

I think we have just trained her well.

They obviously can be trained as they were used in Airports in Australia as sniffer dogs.

Intransigentcat · 14/11/2022 14:37

My sibling has one and she is adorable but God, that dog is hard work.

I've walked her a few times and other beagle owners have approached me and said dont worry they calm down when they get to seven or eight (as she has dragged me bodily along the pavement or field). My sister has put a vast amount of time into her and she is still as wilful as ever. She trained her last dog a terrier in no time.

Also their ears pong like nobody's business. All of the ones I've met are really smelly pooches.

I'd still have one as she is so affectionate , I love her to bits but having spent time with one I would be very aware of how high maintenance they are. She is just never still and always on the lookout for food or something to dismantle.

Frequency · 14/11/2022 14:34

The OP's DM is wrong though. I know quite a few people who've had/have them as pets

She's not completely wrong. They are working breeds. Yes, their loving, trusting nature is perfect for a family pet but if you're not dog orientated and can't/won't give your beagle a job that plays to it's strengths they will find their own job (i.e digging up the garden or figuring out how to access the food cupboard).

We play scent games and do clicker training with ours but it's still not enough to wear him out. He can and will still find trouble if we don't ensure anything and everything he could possibly eat or destroy is kept out of his reach and/or locked away.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 14/11/2022 14:29

Can you handle the Beagle Stream of Consciousness? It's a constant background noise of humfhhhh, ergggg, huff, huh? SQUIRREL!DUCK!DOG!CAT! Urrddďdd, hfffffff, mmmmmm (this tastes nice), irrŕŕmrmmmm, pleeeeeeeese feed me I'm starving, grumpfffggg, OWOWOWOWOWOWOWOWIWOWOWOQOWIWIWIWIWOWOWOWOWOWOWOWOWOWOWOOWOWOOWOWOWOWOOWOOWOWOWOWOOWOWOWOWOWOWOWOWOOWOW with their accompanying constant tail language being thwack, thud, crash, bang, thwack, thud thud thud, crash, whip (across the shins, usually), thud, etc.

I absolutely adore beagles and everything about the contrary little buggers. But I also have cats that spend their days and nights wittering away at me. And I'm going deaf, so they shout. Beagles are perfect for me, but they're quite a niche choice for the terminally patient, hard of hearing (unless it's the sound of the cupboards, fridge and oven being quietly opened in between fake snores) and food orientated owner.

BeagleMum9 · 14/11/2022 14:28

DM says they are working dogs, not family dogs and no one really gets them as domestic pets.

The OP's DM is wrong though. I know quite a few people who've had/have them as pets.They are very gentle around children (not that I'd leave any dog with a small child just incase). My other dog has been nasty to my Beagle a few times and she has never snapped back at him.

I'm not saying they are perfect but temperament wise they are very kind and gentle.

RincewindsHat · 14/11/2022 14:17

As many pps have said, beagles are not low maintenance - you're not unreasonable to consider one, but go into it with your eyes open, prepare to be dealing with all the negative traits listed on this thread (then it'll be a nice surprise if you end up with one that breaks the mould) and if you honestly wouldn't want all of the above breed traits in your own dog, consider something else.

MyGrandmaLizzie · 14/11/2022 14:13

From experience Beagles fart much more than other breeds

Frequency · 14/11/2022 14:11

re: toys

We get WufWuf delivered monthly. You get 2-3 toys and 1-2 chews or bags of treats. He loves it. He recognises the box and loses his shit the second he spies it. Although most of the toys are soft toys because they are delievered to him monthly they tend to last long enough for the next box to arrive (albeit missing a few parts and most of their stuffing).

Cuck00soup · 14/11/2022 14:10

it is true that the nose goes down and the ears become purely decorative

Yup! But we live rurally so it's easy enough to walk over fields or through woods on a long line and let her sniff to her heart's content.

At home, she's like a more sociable cat. Always looking for the best place to curl up and loves a cuddle, but very much on her own terms. She's devoted to our other dog who she mothers and grooms.

Have to say we don't have the food issues, but a friend had one a few years ago and had to put a lock on her fridge, such was the dog's determination. I'd have another anyday.

HostessTrolley · 14/11/2022 14:08

We've always had lab crosses but were looking for another dog and fell in love with the photos and descriptions of this terrorist at our local rescue.

She's almost two and is without a doubt the loveliest, cuddliest, funniest dog. If I could spend half the day walking and half the day on the sofa tickling her belly she would be the perfect dog. But I need to do stuff, like work. So far we've had a totally trashed garden - astroturf and sofa destroyed, pots dug up, plants, erm, manicured, any tools left out wrecked, bags of compost etc that were by the shed dragged across the garden, ripped open and helpfully distributed. In the house, skirting boards chewed, she loves a bra (but only my comfy ones...) or a FlipFlop, food repeatedly stolen, oak coffee table now has no corners or edges without perforations, we've replaced the sky tv remote multiple times and she's still obsessed by the current one, just so much destruction. And that's alongside a frequently replenished toy box full of a wide range of 'indestructible' and enrichment toys that don't come cheap when you're buying them every week. This is with 3-4 walks per day (morning, lunchtime, 5pm, bedtime) with off lead time in different places (park, woods, country park etc), her recall is getting worse not better as she's settling in with us and gaining confidence.

I love her to bits and wouldn't be without her, but she's definitely not a low maintenance dog. I've just been woken up (night shift last night) by a dog on my chest, nuzzling into my shoulder. We've worked out that ears, nose, brain - only one will be in operation at any given time.

ooh - she's not especially smelly or particularly vocal - she just joins in when my other dog barks.

i need to get up now as I can hear a chewing/ripping sound outside my door and I need to go see what she's got this time...

To get a beagle?
kingtamponthefurred · 14/11/2022 14:07

They make a lot of noise. Unless you live on a farm in the middle of nowhere, your neighbours would probably prefer that you chose a quieter breed.

Southwig22 · 14/11/2022 14:01

There are plenty of small dogs that are likely to be more suitable. There are plenty of sites e.g. the UK and American Kennel clubs that help you select a suitable breed.

Why do you want a beagle? The comments you've had from other family members are fairly representative of the breed to be honest (cue every other MN'er jumping to tell me their beagle was the quietest, most well trained dog in history)

Swipe left for the next trending thread