Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To get a beagle?

143 replies

mashh · 14/11/2022 04:07

My parents think I am. DF says they are hunting dogs so are hard to train and very noisy. DM says they are working dogs, not family dogs and no one really gets them as domestic pets.

DP grew up with one so is happy to have one but says his childhood dog was stubborn and had bad recall. I personally just don't want a big dog and preferably a low maintenance breed. Aibu to consider beagles?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
userxx · 14/11/2022 20:10

Dustbins on legs.

allfurcoatnoknickers · 14/11/2022 20:10

@mashh My JRTx Beagle lives in a city - we're in a garden flat, but the garden isn't huge, so no good for proper exercise. She's about 5, but she's an excellent moocher/potterer. Likes running errands and mooching around on the lead with me, seeing interesting things and smelling interesting smells. She just really likes being out and about so is surprisingly compatible with city living.

I think she's happiest when we do lots of little trips multiple times a day.

StealingYourWiFi · 14/11/2022 20:09

We had a beagle as a family dog growing up. She passed away age 14 a couple of years ago. We let her off the lead at the field by our house only however she would sometimes go missing for hours so we just used to go home and she’d turn up eventually. She stole a sausage off a bbq that a group of teens were having one day at the field…also an ice cream out of a toddlers hand.

she was utterly good driven and would manage to get food off the worktop (frozen packs of chicken breasts, loaves of bread) we couldn’t have a bin cause she used to empty it out. The shedding was UNREAL. Hoovering every day.

she ate 10ft of skirting board, multiple shoes, furniture, etc. to be fair my parents were first time dog owners and I think as kids we choose a beagle purely on looks. My dad had GSs growing up.

I have a cockerpoo now who is an absolute dream BUT she’s so boring compared to my beagle 😂😂

BeagleMum9 · 14/11/2022 20:05

@mashh I haven't posted a pic but agree the pictures I've seen are gorgeous dogs.

This thread has kept me amused today. I have done jobs in between reading and posting though 😃.

mashh · 14/11/2022 19:58

BeagleMum9 · 14/11/2022 19:56

Hope you find the dog for you @mashh .

Mine doesn't smell bad. My Mum would definitely tell me.

She's just sat on DH's knee. She adores him. I love most dogs so good luck.

Thank you! Your dog has such interesting colouring x

OP posts:
BeagleMum9 · 14/11/2022 19:56

Hope you find the dog for you @mashh .

Mine doesn't smell bad. My Mum would definitely tell me.

She's just sat on DH's knee. She adores him. I love most dogs so good luck.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 14/11/2022 19:55

mashh · 14/11/2022 19:50

Wow thank you for allllll the replies - wasn't expecting so many.

To the poster who said there will be funny beagle stories - there definitely have been! Some have genuinely made me lol

To the poster who said that Americans might breed beagles for cuteness/less hound qualities compared to British beagles - you might be onto something there.

Thank you for alll the cute pictures of your dogs 🧡

Why do some people think they smell particularly bad?

Overall you've given me loads to consider, probably won't get one but I'll definitely keep them in mind. We live in a city so major daily walks might be an issue. Will definitely keep in mind rescuing an older dog who might not have loads of energy to expend though

An old Beagle will pootle along for 2 hours quite happily - he just won't sprint off into the distance quite so frequently, especially if you have snacks and teach him a hand signal for 'come and get them!'. And then he'll snore in front of the fire for the next three hours.

mashh · 14/11/2022 19:50

Wow thank you for allllll the replies - wasn't expecting so many.

To the poster who said there will be funny beagle stories - there definitely have been! Some have genuinely made me lol

To the poster who said that Americans might breed beagles for cuteness/less hound qualities compared to British beagles - you might be onto something there.

Thank you for alll the cute pictures of your dogs 🧡

Why do some people think they smell particularly bad?

Overall you've given me loads to consider, probably won't get one but I'll definitely keep them in mind. We live in a city so major daily walks might be an issue. Will definitely keep in mind rescuing an older dog who might not have loads of energy to expend though

OP posts:
allfurcoatnoknickers · 14/11/2022 18:43

I've got a JRTx beagle, so a mixture of two absolute lunatic breeds and she's a rescue from an unknown background. She's absolutely great. Very gentle, loves kids, doesn't really howl. She's lazy as anything too - likes going for a stroll about about 30 minutes of zooming off the lead and she's absolutely exhausted.

She sheds like mad though, is obsessed with food and will go bin diving if you take your eyes off he. Thanks to the JRT she also has a serious jump in her and I've caught her on the worktop before.

momonpurpose · 14/11/2022 17:34

We have a rescued beagle for 6 years now. He was returned to the shelter a few times basically for being a beagle. I have heard the are hard to house train but for us he's been a dream rarely an accident. The barking took a long time to control and sometimes he loses his mind howling. But honestly I don't think the are half as bad as people say. He is dumb as a box of rocks but we adore him

cava14una · 14/11/2022 17:11

Now that secure dog fields are more common I might rethink having a Beagle.
We had one as a family dog from when I was about 12.
He was fine on the lead hated the car and if he got a scent well he was gone!!
He had low cunning when it came to pinching food but I taught him to do an obstacle course and he was great with people and other dogs.
Never found him smelly and he was fine with our cats.
He lived until 16 years old and only needed the vet in the last few years.
With access a dog park I think they would be fine as a family pet.

thelobsterquadrille · 14/11/2022 16:39

Shiningstarr · 14/11/2022 15:02

@BeagleMum9

Is this not normal for a beagle then? To do all that constant howling? I just thought that's what they did.

I'm obviously not a dog person by the way, so know very little.

Of course it's not normal.

Any dog that's not getting adequate attention and stimulation will howl and bark constantly - the breed is irrelevant.

Beagles are loud when they bay, but they only really do that when on a scent as they've been bred to call their handler to them when they find their quarry.

zingally · 14/11/2022 16:31

My mum grew up with a beagle during her teens and 20s. Describes him as a wonderful dog, great with everyone and everything, but had horrible recall and was pretty thick.

Have you considered a whippet? Temperamentally similar I feel, but better behaved.

oldperson1 · 14/11/2022 16:31

We had a beagle , not low maintenance and really hard to train as a puppy.
They also are very greedy dogs also until he got older we had to keep him on the
lead as not very good on recall.
On saying all that he was the most loyal loving good natured dog you could wish to have , my kids adored him.
Still miss him we had him for 17 years and tbh thinking back we could have done a better job of training him.

LiesDoNotBecomeUs · 14/11/2022 16:24

Most of the people searching for their dogs in our local woods 'own' beagles.😁

Beagles like to run long distance - so might well leave you miles behind if you don't keep them clipped to a lead. Don't worry though - they are capable of hunting for and eating their dinners in the wild. (My brother's catches and eats squirrels and pigeons even in their garden.)

They can climb high fences (like cats or foxes) and trees.

ThreeRingCircus · 14/11/2022 16:17

I like beagles and DSis has one who is lovely but low maintenance he is not!

Frequency · 14/11/2022 16:09

She is both a dog and also his favourite toy. It took a lot of work to get him to realise the chihhaua did not actually belong to him and was allowed to leave the room/be carried/held by people.

Frequency · 14/11/2022 16:08

She's wearing a little fleece jumper we get from My Chi and Me. I'm not a fan of dressing up dogs for the sake of dressing them up but she feels the cold a lot. She wears fleece jumpers in the winter and a coat on walks most of the year round.

mychiandme.co.uk/collections/just-for-pups/products/chihuahua-puppy-fluffy-striped-blue-and-white-vest-with-rocking-horse-motif

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 14/11/2022 16:04

@Frequency

What is the chihuahua wearing? ( I’m guessing that’s a dog, though it might be his favourite toy?)

pattihews · 14/11/2022 15:36

I think there are two kinds of beagles, the American variety, which have been bred for cuteness and seems to have had some of the worst hound instincts bred out of it, and the traditional British version.

I grew up with the British variety. They are dogs that, ideally, need to be walked off-lead for at least a couple of hours a day. I spent many hours of my adolescence standing in open countryside and woodland calling for him to come back and hearing him baying in the distance as he chased a scent. The older he became, the more stubborn and occasionally growly he became. There were certain toys and items that he was very protective over and we had to be careful around him when he had them. On the positive side we could walk him through a field of sheep and he'd take no notice, he travelled well and was generally friendly. Easy to keep clean. Minimal grooming required.

Don't buy a dog for its looks. Best dog I've ever had (and I've had several) is the mutt currently asleep in his basket under my desk. Playful, gentle rescue dog who'll walk 15 miles if I do but is happy to make do with a quick walk round the block if the weather's bad.

AndorP · 14/11/2022 15:35

When I think of a low maintenance dog, beagle is not the breed that comes to mind!

Greyhound, whippet, or lurcher? We have an ex-racing greyhound and he is lovely. Very chilled. Not bothered for hours of walking, mostly happy to snooze and to come to a human for a fuss/food every couple of hours. Lovely. Has the same issue as other scent/sight hounds though in that his ears deactivate when he goes into chase mode. But thankfully he is lazy so his sprints don't last long!

Probablymagrat · 14/11/2022 15:21

I had one as a child, she was a lovely dog and would sell her soul for a treat, so was quite easy to train. Apart from recall once she got a scent. My poor mum chased her across many a field and through hedges trying to catch the little bugger.

I would not call beagles low maintenance, she was very family orientated and loved us all. But this also a downside of being prone to separation anxiety. We left her with relatives once when we went on holiday. She was a nightmare apparently, howling at the door for hours, refusing to eat, trying to escape. Thereafter we only went on holiday in the UK and took her with us.

She lived until she was 15, and I would not have it any other way, but our family had to make many changes to accommodate her needs, and had lots of anxious times when she decided to go rogue on a walk and we couldn't find her.

But having said that, any dog will change your life.

Seaweedandsalt · 14/11/2022 15:20

mothertrucking · 14/11/2022 13:51

I've never met anyone who is a Beagle that hasn't been destructive or that hasn't suffered with separation anxiety

Ours doesn't do destructive or has separation anxiety. In fact ours goes to bed at 10pm at night and on OH's day off is lucky if she comes downstairs before midday to ask to go out for a wee.

She is used to being left on her own for up to five hours without a worry, she just sleeps.

evilharpy · 14/11/2022 15:13

Someone I know had a beagle. No aggression whatsoever, totally placid around people. She didn't howl and wasn't at all destructive, but my god, the food obsession. I've never seen anything like it. When I hadn't known her very long I lost an entire pizza to her. They lost an entire raised bed and several planters of strawberries and veg in the garden before she was caught. You couldn't take her to a dog-friendly pub or cafe, it would have been carnage.

She also stank, it was really unpleasant. It was her coat rather than her ears as someone mentioned above. You could smell it as soon as you walked through the door.

Difficult to walk as if she picked up a smell or spotted something she wanted, she was off.

Very very clever. But very high maintenance. When she died they got a staffy who is far easier to live with.

Roomba · 14/11/2022 15:10

Shiningstarr · 14/11/2022 15:02

@BeagleMum9

Is this not normal for a beagle then? To do all that constant howling? I just thought that's what they did.

I'm obviously not a dog person by the way, so know very little.

Our beagle has never been like this. She has whimpered a little bit if we have to go out and leave her, but she stops as soon as we're gone and settles quickly (can see & hear on security cameras). She'll whimper quietly if she needs letting out. Never any howling.

Swipe left for the next trending thread