Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Goodbye Monarchy, as is

458 replies

Poopoolittlerabbit · 14/11/2022 00:00

that’s it really. I’m not fussed about the ‘king’ -
happy to downgrade the entire system.
the jewels, the palaces, the changing of the guard belong to the country, and/or people … if Charles buggers off we keep all the tourist attractions, and all that people say makes the royal family worth while ££
now the Queen has gone, the ‘firm’ needs to go
done with them. AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Poopoolittlerabbit · 15/11/2022 07:43

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

xJ0y · 15/11/2022 07:38

Well, she wasn't a child but she wasn't an adult either

Blossomtoes · 15/11/2022 07:36

Shall we stick to the facts? He didn’t have sex with children. He’s alleged to have had sex with a trafficked woman, that’s quite bad enough without embroidering it. And far from there being any possibility of a come back, steps are being taken to sideline him through an amendment to the Counsellors of State Bill this week. There’s no way he’s going to re-enter public life.

Poopoolittlerabbit · 15/11/2022 07:03

Good news for all your Royal fans, Prince Andrew ( he’s the one who had sex with children that his good mate, convicted Paedophile Epstein, grimes and acquired for his and then was protected from the law by his family and mother. The Queen)
is reporting looking for a come back into public life.

OP posts:
balalake · 15/11/2022 07:01

I want to keep the monarchy, though would like to see some reform. Taking any theoretical political role for example, so that the House of Commons would vote in and out a Prime Minister.

Poopoolittlerabbit · 15/11/2022 07:00

‘Democracy is a necessary evil’

wow, that’s some statement. Given the alternatives.

OP posts:
carefulcalculator · 15/11/2022 06:58

But politicians are by definition, not good people completely disagree with this sweeping statement. Many are good people, many try to make positive change. We have three big problems in our system - FPTP gives entrenched majorities in some seats meaning complacency, FPTP gives too much power to party structures, appointment of unelected Lords is institutionalised corruption. But it is wrong to write off all politicians.

Time we had meaningful constitutional change in the UK.

Florenz · 14/11/2022 22:48

Poopoolittlerabbit · 14/11/2022 18:18

‘IF we had an elected head of state, what kind of person do you suppose would put themselves forward for that position?’

by your argument we should do away with democracy altogether then? Maybe get ourselves a nice dictator instead? Hell, why not just get rid of the Commons, give Charlie the powers to properly rule and just have him and the House of Lords running the show.

Democracy is a necessary evil. If we have to have a government, run by politicians, it's the least worst way of selecting the people involved. But politicians are by definition, not good people. And if we can have a head of state that is not a politician, nor selected by politicians, that can only be a good thing.

cakeorwine · 14/11/2022 21:03

Florenz · 14/11/2022 18:06

IF we had an elected head of state, what kind of person do you suppose would put themselves forward for that position? And undertake all the political machinations, horse trading and skullduggery necessary to get the job? It's the kind of job that no-one that is sane and honest would ever want.

Many countries seem to have found a way of getting a Head of State without it going to someone who was born into the role.

It will be interesting to see if countries where the Queen was Head of State and now Charles is - to see if things change and what they do,

carefulcalculator · 14/11/2022 20:17

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime · 14/11/2022 09:07

I’m not mistaking anything.
I honestly couldn’t care less either way. It would have zero impact on me and my life if we got rid of them or if they stay.
Some people are very happy with the current set up where we vote for our MP, the party who get the most MP’s choose a Prime Minister and the Monarch oversees it all.
I don’t think they’re stupid or mistaken. I think they just have a different opinion to you. That’s all.

It isn't a genuine difference of opinion IMO, it is a strawman argument.

theworldhas · 14/11/2022 20:05

The vast majority of British people used to believe that the benefits of slavery outweighed the negatives, that the existence of God was self evident, and that the idea of giving women the vote was preposterous. They weren’t brainwashed - their beliefs and worldview was simply the product of the environment and society in which they were raised. Monarchy is no different.

theworldhas · 14/11/2022 20:03

@MattDillonsEyebrows

But it doesn’t look like you’ve been brainwashed by ‘a fawning media and the glorified concept of a monarchy’ @theworldhas so why would anyone else be?

where did I say everyone is brainwashed? However, if you are disputing that consistent media bias (or the work of the global advertising industry for that matter) is unable to seriously affect the decisions people make and views people hold then I would suggest that pretty much all available research suggests you are wrong. Research in psychology shows that people views are very easily influenced/ easy to manipulate indeed.

Canthave2manycats · 14/11/2022 19:26

Blossomtoes · 14/11/2022 17:01

I didn’t say anything about timescale. The point is that we don’t have a rewind button. We can’t change my great, great grandparents having to leave Ireland for a better life, we can’t prevent my great, great grandma ending up in the workhouse. What’s the point of apologising? They’re not here to hear it. What we can do is honour them and respect their struggle. I may be deluded but I think they’d be pleased to see how generations of their descendants have made the most of the opportunities they created for us.

Excellent point. I'm in NI and have lived under the mire of the past all my life. I don't want to know about the past (except to learn from it) - I want to thrive into the future. I am sick of people holding grudges for long-imagined hurts, and in many cases, people who really have no idea why they hold them!!

Slavery was not unique to the UK, nor were human rights issues. We've evolved. Things that were commonplace 100 years ago, 50 years ago, 10 years ago even, are not acceptable today. What good are reparations or apologies to victims who are long gone?

Poopoolittlerabbit · 14/11/2022 19:02

Oh and happy birthday Charlie! No offence, mate it’s not personal. At least you’re not as creepy as your sex offending brother.

OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 14/11/2022 18:34

IF we had an elected head of state, what kind of person do you suppose would put themselves forward for that position

Google the Irish Presidents and you'll be very pleasantly surprised

Poopoolittlerabbit · 14/11/2022 18:18

‘IF we had an elected head of state, what kind of person do you suppose would put themselves forward for that position?’

by your argument we should do away with democracy altogether then? Maybe get ourselves a nice dictator instead? Hell, why not just get rid of the Commons, give Charlie the powers to properly rule and just have him and the House of Lords running the show.

OP posts:
Poopoolittlerabbit · 14/11/2022 18:12

‘I imagine at some point Jewish people will say the Holocaust was so long ago it doesn't matter anymore’

fucking. Hell. I’m fairly certain they won’t EVER say the murder of 6m + Jews doesn’t matter.
Just like Irish people haven’t forgotten about how the British government sat and watched as their children starved to death.

OP posts:
Florenz · 14/11/2022 18:06

IF we had an elected head of state, what kind of person do you suppose would put themselves forward for that position? And undertake all the political machinations, horse trading and skullduggery necessary to get the job? It's the kind of job that no-one that is sane and honest would ever want.

vera99 · 14/11/2022 17:20

Blossomtoes · 14/11/2022 17:01

I didn’t say anything about timescale. The point is that we don’t have a rewind button. We can’t change my great, great grandparents having to leave Ireland for a better life, we can’t prevent my great, great grandma ending up in the workhouse. What’s the point of apologising? They’re not here to hear it. What we can do is honour them and respect their struggle. I may be deluded but I think they’d be pleased to see how generations of their descendants have made the most of the opportunities they created for us.

Very true - apparently at the turn of the 19th century one of my ancestors was hung for sheep stealing in Cumbria - probably out of poverty and hunger as was the plight of most of the peasants and emerging working class of that era.

The struggle of ordinary people fighting for their rights and justice against the might of the state that stands over them with the RF at the very apex is the true heroic story of Britain. The Battle of Peterloo (Manchester) should be remembered as Waterloo but tellingly is not.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peterloo_Massacre

Blossomtoes · 14/11/2022 17:01

I didn’t say anything about timescale. The point is that we don’t have a rewind button. We can’t change my great, great grandparents having to leave Ireland for a better life, we can’t prevent my great, great grandma ending up in the workhouse. What’s the point of apologising? They’re not here to hear it. What we can do is honour them and respect their struggle. I may be deluded but I think they’d be pleased to see how generations of their descendants have made the most of the opportunities they created for us.

vera99 · 14/11/2022 16:55

Blossomtoes · 14/11/2022 15:40

I’m a descendant of those people. My great, great grandparents were Irish immigrants fleeing the famine. What good would an apology do? None.

I imagine at some point Jewish people will say the Holocaust was so long ago it doesn't matter anymore or more likely they never will. The British as victors like a version of history where they are always the good guys but it's not true and that's where the RF need to tread carefully, particularly with all the Commonwealth stuff that the late Queen deemed so important. Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.

Blossomtoes · 14/11/2022 15:40

vera99 · 14/11/2022 09:16

Yes, the Irish famine where 1 million died and 1 million fled the country reducing the population by 25% whilst the British establishment looked on and did nothing 1845 -1849 - no wonder that the Union Jack is called the butcher's apron and not a single apology ....

'The genocide of the Great Famine is distinct in the fact that the British created the conditions of dire hopelessness, and desperate dependence on the potato crop through a series of sadistic, debasing, premeditated and barbarous Penal Laws, which deliberately and systematically stripped the Irish of even the least semblance of basic human freedom.' When blight struck the Irish were 'totally vulnerable'. This was a 'nuanced genocide', he continues, one that manipulated fate 'by pushing a people to the brink of annihilation and turning away so not to hear the wailing

I’m a descendant of those people. My great, great grandparents were Irish immigrants fleeing the famine. What good would an apology do? None.

vera99 · 14/11/2022 15:21

Lampzade · 14/11/2022 11:07

Sad but true

The Queen wasn't that much really except she knew to keep schtum and smile away and never let in the daylight into the magic of monarchy and she had the 'good luck' ' to come to the throne post-war and be young and beautiful and grown into the role. Meanwhile, Chaz has had 74 years to become King of the Annoying Inkpots and Pens.

Poopoolittlerabbit · 14/11/2022 15:12

‘But do the Scottish love the RF? My Scottish family and friends certainly don't.’

there seems to be some fondness for the Queen for hiding out in Balmoral whenever she could and for her fondness for Scotland, but I personally don’t know many Royalist Scots…

OP posts:
Mercurial123 · 14/11/2022 14:44

Mummyoflittledragon · 14/11/2022 02:38

Why does it always boil down to a them against us mentality? The Queen mum was of Scottish descent and HMQ made a big effort to include all the nations. She loved Scotland most of all.

But do the Scottish love the RF? My Scottish family and friends certainly don't.