Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Goodbye Monarchy, as is

458 replies

Poopoolittlerabbit · 14/11/2022 00:00

that’s it really. I’m not fussed about the ‘king’ -
happy to downgrade the entire system.
the jewels, the palaces, the changing of the guard belong to the country, and/or people … if Charles buggers off we keep all the tourist attractions, and all that people say makes the royal family worth while ££
now the Queen has gone, the ‘firm’ needs to go
done with them. AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
TheKeatingFive · 14/11/2022 07:31

If it was all sold off, the amount of money we’d get from new private owners would be 40% max as it would be subject to normal taxation rules.

Why would it need to be sold off? It would go straight to the public purse. It's managed by an independent body as it stands.

TodayInahurry · 14/11/2022 07:30

A lot of nasty ant royalists, the Royal Family is fine, leave them away. The youth are being brainwashed at university to hate everything about the UK

Florenz · 14/11/2022 07:30

The last time we had a public vote it gave us Brexit and people are still moaning that people didn't understand what they were voted for, people voted the "wrong" way, against their own interests, etc etc.

I'd be happy for us to have regular referendums on all kinds of things but they don't always go the way you want them to go, and people have to be willing to accept that.

MyLovelyPen · 14/11/2022 07:29

www.republic.org.uk/

@Mixednuts574 the link above takes you to the campaign group for the abolition of the monarchy. It makes for some interesting reading.

TheKeatingFive · 14/11/2022 07:29

If we abolished the monarchy, the Royal Family would still exist, probably richer than now.

Well I don't think anyones thinking of exterminating them, just stripping them of powers. And they absolutely wouldn't be richer than they are now, of the sovereign grant, Duchies and royal estates were taken away from them.

Hollyhead · 14/11/2022 07:29

People always cite tourism as the main source of income, it’s the massive property estate that does and most of that money goes straight to the government who then give about 20% of it back to fund them. If it was all sold off, the amount of money we’d get from new private owners would be 40% max as it would be subject to normal taxation rules.

Poopoolittlerabbit · 14/11/2022 07:28

‘The Royals are not going anywhere. Sorry and all that @Poopoolittlerabbit 😢 Don't cry too much now.’

Did I say they were? Unfortunate Prince Andrew, the weird, non-sweating paedophile, is here to stay as are most of the other free loaders… but there’s many steps between having a figure head and having an unelected., toff wielding the kind of political power Charlie boy does.

OP posts:
Lisbeth50 · 14/11/2022 07:26

The monarchy and the Royal Family are not the same thing. If we abolished the monarchy, the Royal Family would still exist, probably richer than now. Germany hasn't had a monarchy for over 100 years but there are still people going around calling themselves Prince so and so.

Abolishing the monarchy would require an agreed system in its place. Just voting for a republic would be as ridiculous as voting for Brexit with no plan in place was. Republics and presidency exist in lots of forms.

Presidents still cost money.

Young people may not support the monarchy as much as older people but will probably change as they age. All views matter not just those of people under 35.

Monarchy is not a relic of empire. It's an ancient system, not just here but worldwide.

I wouldn't invent a monarchy if I was starting from scratch but it's here, it works and atm imo we would be much worse off without it.

Mixednuts574 · 14/11/2022 07:26

ElmoNeedsThePotty · 14/11/2022 06:56

But we are allowed to demonstrate publicly whether we want a monarchy or not, last time I checked we are not living in China.

Nothing stopping you and fellow republicans lobbying for change.

Have you actually done anything about it rather than comment on here?

Yes I have. I wrote to my MP shortly after the late Queen’s death when all of the proclamations were taking place. I didn’t receive a reply.

I considered joining a republican organisation but some of their views are quite extreme and I need to do more research in to which organisation is the right fit for me. Unfortunately I have a busy life so haven’t made a decision yet.

And yes we are allowed to demonstrate but my point is that there should be less drastic and more reliable methods of registering our opinions on this matter, than standing in the street waving a banner, which isn’t practical or possible for the vast majority of people.

If the monarchy is so popular, then the establishment doesn’t need to be wary of allowing the general public a vote on the matter.

Poopoolittlerabbit · 14/11/2022 07:25

The sooner we move to a Scandinavian model for the monarchy the better, starting with getting rid of the power to sign Acts and laws.
the idea that someone is ‘born to rule’ belongs back in the medieval times.

OP posts:
ElmoNeedsThePotty · 14/11/2022 07:18

@Theunamedcat Eh? Were you quoting me?

If you were, I think you need to re-read my post as you have obviously missed that I am not in favour of tha abolition of the monarchy.

I wa making the point to those who do should get on with doing something about it, rather than having a moan online.

They obviously don't care that much or else they would be out on the streets, lobbying, etc, etc. Just as other countries have done successfully.

Florenz · 14/11/2022 07:17

I'd rather have a King than a politician as head of state.

I don't see the monarchy going away any time soon.

If there was a referendum I think keeping the monarchy would win in a landslide.

Softplayhooray · 14/11/2022 07:15

PurpleButterflyWings · 14/11/2022 00:26

The Royals are not going anywhere. Sorry and all that @Poopoolittlerabbit 😢 Don't cry too much now.

Why the spite? Of course the Royals aren't going anywhere but that's because their vast wealth and power means that endless acolytes and opportunists will defend them until the end of time because it means they can benefit from some of that money and power, too.

That means endless wealth passed off to one family that could have been used on schools, hospitals, free school meals for kids, etc, alongside constant ongoing expensive press calls and PR campaigns to keep the public thinking that people actually want them. There's nothing wrong in calling that out as being a reply unpleasant and irrational practice.

MyLovelyPen · 14/11/2022 07:13

@reluctantbrit if the royals are our moral head we’re a bit fucked aren’t we? Charles being best friends with the Saudis for starters. His delightful brother. When he was alive, his bully of a dad. And so on.

Theyre certainly not someone I’d look to for moral leadership.

Mycatsgoldtooth · 14/11/2022 07:10

It’s good to have a national figurehead that isn’t a politician. Had dinner yesterday with Pils who are not English born, both saying when they went home after the queens funeral to visit their parents, there was lots of talk about their country regretting getting rid of their monarchy. I sang the national anthem yesterday at the end of the remembrance service and it was moving that we had something unifying us in that moment as a group of people belonging to a nation. I can not imagine a political party unifying people.

MyLovelyPen · 14/11/2022 07:08

”Dont knock what you don’t understand” said on the same post as “oh it’ll be President Blair shows that YOU don’t understand 🙄. What a nonsense thing to say.

And can we please stop with the bullshit about Charles’ environmental credentials - he hardly practices what he preaches does he?

TheBitchNextDoor · 14/11/2022 07:08

lfYouLikePInaColadas · 14/11/2022 00:11

No it isn’t. Majority of the young don’t want them.

And the country isn't run by the young, and the young will be older one day and many will have changed their minds when experience makes them wiser.

Mixednuts574 · 14/11/2022 07:06

Fufumcgoo · 14/11/2022 06:46

All I know is, at remembrance Sunday yesterday not one person sang the national anthem. The only voice ringing out what that of the vicar at the microphone on the square. Sad really, but not unexpected.

Yes exactly. Inviting people to sing “God save the King” when many believe in neither!

I do practice a faith as it happens but the whole notion of the national anthem is difficult for me. I would happily sing to God to protect the sick and the most vulnerable in society but to save our King? Well, perhaps to guide him to make the right decisions and to help him as a person on a human level, but do we need the “send him victorious, happy and glorious, long to reign over us”? I don’t think we do!

Pipsquiggle · 14/11/2022 07:04

I am all for changing the monarchy. Less deference. Slimming it down a lot. But not totally getting rid of it

What would you have in its place?
I quite like how we can deploy the royal family to events around the world, give a showing of UK Plc and our politicians can get on with running the country (something the current lot has to focus on!)

Theunamedcat · 14/11/2022 07:03

ElmoNeedsThePotty · 14/11/2022 06:56

But we are allowed to demonstrate publicly whether we want a monarchy or not, last time I checked we are not living in China.

Nothing stopping you and fellow republicans lobbying for change.

Have you actually done anything about it rather than comment on here?

With so much bad things going on in the UK right now why are people fixated on the royal family? Getting rid of them won't change the effects of brexit or the war in the Ukraine it won't bring down food and fuel prices it will just be another thing to watch the government fuck up "we are selling the palace's to help support the economy" and promptly give themselves another fucking pay raise they are short sighted egotistical individuals and I don't trust them to run around the block let alone our country but they were voted for

Snnowflake · 14/11/2022 06:58

Our lives are heavily ruled by what eg Elon Musk is saying/ doing , Mark Zuckerberg, bloggers , influencers. Winners of IACGMOOH.
Take away tradition and that’s chiefly what would remain.

ElmoNeedsThePotty · 14/11/2022 06:56

Mixednuts574 · 14/11/2022 06:50

Just repeating the words “they are here to stay” doesn’t actually make it so you know!

And the point about ‘how do people think this is going to come about?’ is pertinent precisely because the way our establishment is set up makes it very difficult to abolish the monarchy.

Imho, there should be ways in which the public can vote for them to stay or go. It’s rather arrogant to assume we all feel the same way after a seventy year reign isn’t it? Like it or not, the monarchy needs public approval in order to continue, so we should be allowed to demonstrate our support formally, or not.

”But this isn’t the way a constitutional monarchy works” everyone will say…. well yes, exactly … we need to change the system so that they are more directly accountable to the public’s wishes.

Finally, the inherent problem with Charles being hailed as a defender of the environment is that he has at least eight houses! I don’t doubt that he is genuine in his beliefs and his staff may all compost and use the bath water to water the flowers but there is inherent hypocrisy in his overall level of consumption. His credibility is shot if he doesn’t shed a few of the estates!

But we are allowed to demonstrate publicly whether we want a monarchy or not, last time I checked we are not living in China.

Nothing stopping you and fellow republicans lobbying for change.

Have you actually done anything about it rather than comment on here?

ThatshallotBaby · 14/11/2022 06:54

YANBU. But most people are afraid of change. I also think the Royal family would be more palatable if run on the Scandinavian model. That might happen.

BadLad · 14/11/2022 06:51

BitOutOfPractice · 14/11/2022 06:17

In the latest poll only a third of 18-24 year old supported the monarchy. Source

Eh? From your link:

Although the British monarchy is supported by a plurality of people across most age groups in Great Britain, it is among over 65 year-old's where the level is support is highest at 77 percent. Younger age groups are progressively more likely to oppose the monarchy, with 31 percent of 18-24 year old's opting instead for an elected head of state.

Of course, most of it is behind a paywall, including the graph - if you can see it, perhaps you could let the rest of us know what it says. Maybe there's a third of that group who support the monarchy (as you said), 31% in favour of an elected head of state and just over a third who have no preference.

Mixednuts574 · 14/11/2022 06:50

Just repeating the words “they are here to stay” doesn’t actually make it so you know!

And the point about ‘how do people think this is going to come about?’ is pertinent precisely because the way our establishment is set up makes it very difficult to abolish the monarchy.

Imho, there should be ways in which the public can vote for them to stay or go. It’s rather arrogant to assume we all feel the same way after a seventy year reign isn’t it? Like it or not, the monarchy needs public approval in order to continue, so we should be allowed to demonstrate our support formally, or not.

”But this isn’t the way a constitutional monarchy works” everyone will say…. well yes, exactly … we need to change the system so that they are more directly accountable to the public’s wishes.

Finally, the inherent problem with Charles being hailed as a defender of the environment is that he has at least eight houses! I don’t doubt that he is genuine in his beliefs and his staff may all compost and use the bath water to water the flowers but there is inherent hypocrisy in his overall level of consumption. His credibility is shot if he doesn’t shed a few of the estates!

Swipe left for the next trending thread