Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Goodbye Monarchy, as is

458 replies

Poopoolittlerabbit · 14/11/2022 00:00

that’s it really. I’m not fussed about the ‘king’ -
happy to downgrade the entire system.
the jewels, the palaces, the changing of the guard belong to the country, and/or people … if Charles buggers off we keep all the tourist attractions, and all that people say makes the royal family worth while ££
now the Queen has gone, the ‘firm’ needs to go
done with them. AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Figgygal · 14/11/2022 08:39

You're entitled to your opinion I suppose

carefulcalculator · 14/11/2022 08:38

TheKeatingFive · 14/11/2022 08:19

Isn't there some research that shows young people never want the monarchy

Ive never seen it. Have you a link?

One example: yougov.co.uk/topics/politics/articles-reports/2021/05/21/young-britons-are-turning-their-backs-monarchy

There was a marked change 2019-21. I disagree with the phrase young people never want the monarchy - it varies, but the polling is generally populations becoming less supportive of an unelected hereditary head of state.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 14/11/2022 08:38

The discussion about a president vs. monarchy is one of principle. If all you have to defend the Monarchy is you don't want person X, that is extremely weak.

On the contrary it's a strong argument - FOR abolition.

If you don't want Person X, tough. You're getting them anyway if they happen to emerge into the line of succession first in a particular order.

King Charles could just as easily have been King Andrew. UK citizens could not have done a thing about it, because we don't receive the courtesy of a vote for our own head of state. Then imagine Andrew had become King and was later found to be abusing his position by taking money from all manner of dubious sources, and his dealings with Epstein came out at a later stage. UK citizens would not have an opportunity of voting him out, because we are stuck with these unremarkable, not very bright (and that's the most benign thing you can say about some of them) for life.

vera99 · 14/11/2022 08:37

Even the loathsome TaxPayers Alliance have got the boot in .....

This is patently not acceptable at a time of national economic calamity. The bailout by HM Treasury means that money that would have been spent on public services has now been diverted to the royals. This is expected to give the monarch a grant of £86.3 million for the year 2020-2021. Despite the Act guaranteeing the royals will never make a loss, the Sovereign Grant has ballooned in size, giving them year on year increases for the past decade above levels of inflation. In 2016-17 the grant was worth £42.8 million, which steeply jumped to £76.1 million in 2017-18 and continued to rise handsomely until this year. The royal family have a rising income under this system, but now they must ride the bad times like the rest of us. They should not forget the significant public sympathy which was generated when the Queen’s own wedding dress was rationed with clothing coupons in the midst of postwar austerity.

By budgeting the costs of royal engagements, taxpayers can better assess value for money, funding a small but effectively resourced royal family which is less wasteful and more in tune with the public. This way, the monarchy will no longer be immune to economic hardship and share in the struggles of its subjects. This does not mean they will become a budget monarchy. But value for money applies to everyone - prince or pauper.

www.taxpayersalliance.com/the_sovereign_grant_needs_a_reality_check

Brefugee · 14/11/2022 08:36

John Oliver has this covered.

MyLovelyPen · 14/11/2022 08:35

@Dreamingcats i don’t know how old you are but I lived through much of the history depicted in the Crown and it absolutely is true. Of course there’s some dramatisation but TamponGate and the poll turning on the Queen are matters of historical record, to name just a couple of examples. The royals desperately want you to believe it’s all fiction - don’t be fooled.

Fleurdaisy · 14/11/2022 08:35

lfYouLikePInaColadas · 14/11/2022 00:11

No it isn’t. Majority of the young don’t want them.

Good. A lot of us oldies don’t want them either.
Their “ chosen by a god, we’re far superior to anyone else” crap is way outdated.
Wouldn’t go as far as the 18c French but Sue Townsend wasn’t far off. Sooner they all go, the better.

Byfleet · 14/11/2022 08:35

@Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime

Yes Tony Blair is a war criminal. I agree.

But why would we end up with him as a president if we abolished the RF? I don’t get it. I don’t get why the argument for keeping the RF is that we might end up with Tony Blair as president. It’s such a weird defence of the system of monarchy. It is hugely more likely that we might end up with a maniac as our monarch because we have no choice about it. We would be voting for a president.

Sarahcoggles · 14/11/2022 08:35

People have been talking about the end of the monarchy for as long as I remember. My Mum - a staunch anti royalist - would tell me with absolute certainty that when I was an adult it would all be over. And yet there is no sign of it.

And maybe "the youth" do want to get rid of the monarchy, but they're too busy gazing at their phones to do anything about it. They might sign an online petition but they're not going to go to the trouble of actually protesting.

MarshaBradyo · 14/11/2022 08:34

bloodyplanes · 14/11/2022 08:02

OP you are living on another planet if you think the Monarchy are going anywhere! The vast majority of the uk love them and everything they bring to this island ( as evidenced by the large crowds during the mourning of QE in all of the countries that make up the UK). Look what the " elected elite" have done to this country and then tell us we should be a republic, it's laughable!

Crowds were big but also support went up afterwards. I’m not surprised each part was well done and showed tradition

carefulcalculator · 14/11/2022 08:33

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime · 14/11/2022 08:28

He’s a war criminal

He wouldn't get voted in now anyway, so why the endless obsession with Blair anyway?

The discussion about a president vs. monarchy is one of principle. If all you have to defend the Monarchy is you don't want person X, that is extremely weak.

Spinninggyro · 14/11/2022 08:32

Fufumcgoo · 14/11/2022 06:46

All I know is, at remembrance Sunday yesterday not one person sang the national anthem. The only voice ringing out what that of the vicar at the microphone on the square. Sad really, but not unexpected.

If you Google national anthem cenataph you can watch on you tube and hear and see that many people are singing

prh47bridge · 14/11/2022 08:30

lfYouLikePInaColadas · 14/11/2022 00:11

No it isn’t. Majority of the young don’t want them.

Various opinion polls have shown that support for the monarchy is lower amongst younger age groups, but that is mainly due to a large number of don't knows (over one third of those polled). If you factor out don't knows, supporters still outnumber those who favour ending the monarchy.

Also, assuming that young people will stick to their views as they get older is wrong. For decades, some on the left have been saying that the huge lead for left wing parties amongst the young means the Conservatives will be wiped out in a few years. It hasn't happened yet. The reality is that people's views change. The evidence available suggests this applies as much to the monarchy as it does to other matters.

I'm not saying the monarchy will last forever. We simply don't know.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 14/11/2022 08:30

Bring it on.

Byfleet · 14/11/2022 08:29

What do you replace them with?

@Dogtooth

I am not necessarily in favour of replacing the RF but the argument that it’s impossible to think of an alternative is so weird. Most countries in the world have presidents. It’s quite a simple idea. We vote for a president.

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime · 14/11/2022 08:28

Byfleet · 14/11/2022 08:26

@Canthave2manycats

Every single thread on this topic (and I have been on here for about 15years) without fail, always asks if there were no more RF could anybody possibly imagine the absurdity of a President Blair. What? Why?

First of all, just why would Tony Blair become president? There are so, so, so many more other statesman/women to choose from. And we would be voting. It wouldn’t be imposed on us. Secondly, although I was no fan of Tony Blair at all and wouldn’t vote for him in the incredibly unlikely event he were a candidate for president, why exactly would it be absurd if he were president? Why is the idea of Tony Blair as president a killer argument for not abolishing the RF? I don’t get it.

He’s a war criminal

vera99 · 14/11/2022 08:28

Voted the wrong way by mistake of course they should go - off with their heads.... I hope Jeremy Hunt in his "difficult tax choices" has said sorry your Maj but that Sovereign Grant for one of the richest families in the country is on a downward journey to zero. If they want to go on strike so be it....

Dogtooth · 14/11/2022 08:26

MattDillonsEyebrows · 14/11/2022 08:16

Why was the Brexit referendum an example of how not to do things? How would you do things differently for a monarchy referendum?

Unfortunately with a proper informed discussion you have to allow all voices & opinions, not just the ones you like or even the most rational ones.
I personally knew exactly what I was voting for in the Brexit referendum. I listened to both sides, was swayed by some of the arguments for Brexit eg the fishermen’s discussion of the ridiculous catch limits and wastefulness there but ultimately decided I didn’t want Brexit so voted remain.

Other people had their own reason for voting the way they did. Some will be fully informed, some will have just read the headlines of a bus, some will just want their gap years to be easier, some won’t give a shit either way but want to take part in a part of history, but you have to take in all the votes and just because someone else voted differently and it didn’t go the way I wanted, why would I assume they weren’t informed or they were thick, uneducated or racist?

@MattDillonsEyebrows Brexit was an example of how not to do things because it was poorly run. Most referenda on major issues in other countries require a two thirds majority not a simple majority exactly to avoid a situation where the country is split down the middle.

It was also characterised by really poor levels of knowledge in both the public and politicians about what the EU does and is for, which meant every grievance under the sun could be laid at the door of the EU rather than domestic politicians. So it wasn't really decided on a rational basis about what the EU does, it was a referendum on 'should things change' not the actual membership.

Byfleet · 14/11/2022 08:26

@Canthave2manycats

Every single thread on this topic (and I have been on here for about 15years) without fail, always asks if there were no more RF could anybody possibly imagine the absurdity of a President Blair. What? Why?

First of all, just why would Tony Blair become president? There are so, so, so many more other statesman/women to choose from. And we would be voting. It wouldn’t be imposed on us. Secondly, although I was no fan of Tony Blair at all and wouldn’t vote for him in the incredibly unlikely event he were a candidate for president, why exactly would it be absurd if he were president? Why is the idea of Tony Blair as president a killer argument for not abolishing the RF? I don’t get it.

Dogtooth · 14/11/2022 08:21

What do you replace them with? I don't have much time for the monarchy but they're just there to keep their mouths shut and be figureheads. Since Brexit I have no faith in this country to elect a sensible president.

TheKeatingFive · 14/11/2022 08:19

Isn't there some research that shows young people never want the monarchy

Ive never seen it. Have you a link?

anexcellentwoman · 14/11/2022 08:18

Isn't there some research that shows young people never want the monarchy. Many mysteriously change their views as they age and perhaps consider the alternatives

BellePeppa · 14/11/2022 08:17

There are far more things to worry about than the Monarchy. You may not like them but millions of people are still very very interested in it, hence the massive crowds whenever there’s a big event. Not having a monarchy will make zero difference to your pocket or your everyday life. I quite like having them because of the big events etc but I don’t give it’s existence a thought day to day.

cakeorwine · 14/11/2022 08:17

Why do people 'love' the Royal Family?

What is it about Charles and his immediate family that you love?

MattDillonsEyebrows · 14/11/2022 08:16

Mixednuts574 · 14/11/2022 07:55

Speaking as a republican, I think this is a very important point. Sadly, people do have a tendency to vote to destroy things just for the sake of it and because they can.

And yes the Brexit referendum was an example of how NOT to do things but it must be possible, in this day and age, with the technology available to us, to facilitate proper, informed discussion and come to a conclusion through a series of debates, perhaps like the UN form a resolution?

Why was the Brexit referendum an example of how not to do things? How would you do things differently for a monarchy referendum?

Unfortunately with a proper informed discussion you have to allow all voices & opinions, not just the ones you like or even the most rational ones.
I personally knew exactly what I was voting for in the Brexit referendum. I listened to both sides, was swayed by some of the arguments for Brexit eg the fishermen’s discussion of the ridiculous catch limits and wastefulness there but ultimately decided I didn’t want Brexit so voted remain.

Other people had their own reason for voting the way they did. Some will be fully informed, some will have just read the headlines of a bus, some will just want their gap years to be easier, some won’t give a shit either way but want to take part in a part of history, but you have to take in all the votes and just because someone else voted differently and it didn’t go the way I wanted, why would I assume they weren’t informed or they were thick, uneducated or racist?