Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Goodbye Monarchy, as is

458 replies

Poopoolittlerabbit · 14/11/2022 00:00

that’s it really. I’m not fussed about the ‘king’ -
happy to downgrade the entire system.
the jewels, the palaces, the changing of the guard belong to the country, and/or people … if Charles buggers off we keep all the tourist attractions, and all that people say makes the royal family worth while ££
now the Queen has gone, the ‘firm’ needs to go
done with them. AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
vera99 · 14/11/2022 09:16

Yes, the Irish famine where 1 million died and 1 million fled the country reducing the population by 25% whilst the British establishment looked on and did nothing 1845 -1849 - no wonder that the Union Jack is called the butcher's apron and not a single apology ....

'The genocide of the Great Famine is distinct in the fact that the British created the conditions of dire hopelessness, and desperate dependence on the potato crop through a series of sadistic, debasing, premeditated and barbarous Penal Laws, which deliberately and systematically stripped the Irish of even the least semblance of basic human freedom.' When blight struck the Irish were 'totally vulnerable'. This was a 'nuanced genocide', he continues, one that manipulated fate 'by pushing a people to the brink of annihilation and turning away so not to hear the wailing

Poopoolittlerabbit · 14/11/2022 09:13

‘She opted for Monty Don, which I thought was a lovely idea.’ ha!
I’d opt for Monty Don’s favourite spider plant over the current monarch.

OP posts:
LakieLady · 14/11/2022 09:11

I think they should be abolished and have a president. And before anyone starts: it won't be like the US where PM and Head of State are the same person. It would (could, should) be more like France or Germany where the roles are divided.
And it needn't be an ex-politician. My current favourite pick for president would be Doreen Lawrence (slightly political because she sits in the HoL)

My MIL absolutely adores the RF, but a while ago we were having a (light-hearted) conversation about who would make a good president. She opted for Monty Don, which I thought was a lovely idea.

Doreen Lawrence would be good, and it would enrage the racists.

I'd go for David Olusoga or Mary Beard though.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 14/11/2022 09:10

Poopoolittlerabbit · 14/11/2022 09:05

It’s baffling that there are still so many people who seem to think that British Colonialism and the ‘empire’ was good somehow, or something to be proud of.
I blame the English history curriculum, it still does little to educate children to the real harms of invading someone else’s country, stealing their resources and subjugating their people.

Do you expect other countries to apologise for their empires or just the British?

Poopoolittlerabbit · 14/11/2022 09:10

‘It’s essentially ceremonial anyway. Charles signing laws into being/having a chat with the PM is politically meaningless. He can’t realistically refuse to sign something or tell the PM what to do as the concept of monarchy by consent would instantly end.’

So why bother?

you’re seriously underestimating the power and influence of the monarch.
the Queen was from a different world, a different era. She’s gone and so should most of the ‘traditions’ that allowed her to become the most famous woman in the world.

OP posts:
Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime · 14/11/2022 09:07

carefulcalculator · 14/11/2022 08:54

You seem to be mistaking 'presidency' for 'dictatorship'.

There are many presidential models, in the UK it would be the PM with the current powers and an elected head of state instead of an unelected head of state.

UK current system is referred to as an 'elective dictatorship' for good reason - due to our unelected hereditary head of state the PM has gathered more power than in other systems because you can't justify letting the King/Queen intervene in politics.

The public would have more control with an elected head of state.

I’m not mistaking anything.
I honestly couldn’t care less either way. It would have zero impact on me and my life if we got rid of them or if they stay.
Some people are very happy with the current set up where we vote for our MP, the party who get the most MP’s choose a Prime Minister and the Monarch oversees it all.
I don’t think they’re stupid or mistaken. I think they just have a different opinion to you. That’s all.

Ivyonafence · 14/11/2022 09:06

@vera99 oh my goodness I hadn't seen those before 😂

MangosteenSoda · 14/11/2022 09:05

I’m much less bothered about the monarchy than I used to be. It’s essentially ceremonial anyway. Charles signing laws into being/having a chat with the PM is politically meaningless. He can’t realistically refuse to sign something or tell the PM what to do as the concept of monarchy by consent would instantly end.

After the shitshow of Brexit, I would absolutely want to know what the alternative looks like and what the process would be to get there before voting for it. I’m not keen on the American or French versions of presidency and am not sure whether the, say, Irish or German versions would be worth the effort. On the basis of the last 10 years or so, I also don’t trust my fellow citizens to vote with any modicum of sense. Sometimes the status quo is the least bad option.

Poopoolittlerabbit · 14/11/2022 09:05

It’s baffling that there are still so many people who seem to think that British Colonialism and the ‘empire’ was good somehow, or something to be proud of.
I blame the English history curriculum, it still does little to educate children to the real harms of invading someone else’s country, stealing their resources and subjugating their people.

OP posts:
vera99 · 14/11/2022 09:01

Poopoolittlerabbit · 14/11/2022 08:59

‘Nobody alive today is responsible for the atrocities of the colonial era and just because something is a 'throwback to empire' doesn't mean it has to be eradicated.’

you should Google what the British did to the Kenyans- pretty sure there are people still alive responsible for that. And the Paratroopers who murdered civilians on Bloody Sunday are certainly still with us.

vera99 · 14/11/2022 08:59

Ivyonafence · 14/11/2022 08:47

Lol!

Unless you're Irish, or aboriginal, or Native American, or Indian, or from many African countries...

Colonisation has not exactly been the 'well being' elixir you seem to think it is.

For many First Nations people the royal family represent genocide. They can wear all the stupid hats and wave as much as they like, they enriched themselves through stealing and dispossession. Charlie didn't do it himself but he's not exactly handing it back and apologising is he?

Oh, I don't know the younger generation has their ear to the ground ....

Goodbye Monarchy, as is
Poopoolittlerabbit · 14/11/2022 08:59

‘Nobody alive today is responsible for the atrocities of the colonial era and just because something is a 'throwback to empire' doesn't mean it has to be eradicated.’

you should Google what the British did to the Kenyans- pretty sure there are people still alive responsible for that. And the Paratroopers who murdered civilians on Bloody Sunday are certainly still with us.

OP posts:
Quveas · 14/11/2022 08:57

Chocolatehamper · 14/11/2022 00:06

You didn't give the option to vote but yes. YABU. If you don't like the monarchy, that's your entitlement but it's here to stay.

I don't agree. It's dying on its feet now. The new King visited our city last week. I fell over laughing at the caption on one of the photo's in the local paper. "Hundreds turned out to welcome him". Had it been the queen it would have been many thousands. Regradless of what the monarchy meant to them individually, the Queen was respected as a product of her time and class. The "time and class" are now long gone, and most people I speak to think the same of the monarchy. Spending £millions of taxpayers money on an outmoded and outdated institution when people are facing freezing over winter and no food on the table is tone deaf. And as for the King giving his staff a £600 cost of living bonus "out of his own money" (in other words, money made off the backs of the poor in the first place), if the staff were paid better then they wouldn't need it.

Brefugee · 14/11/2022 08:56

Flanjango - the monarchy in the UK is nothing to do with the Empire, it's been around a lot longer than that.

piffle. It is entirely connected with the empire. The greed of a monarchy wanting to own ever more and more stuff (places, people, the means of production) is the entire point of having an empire.

Added to which how many of the gongs they hand out all the time have the word "empire" in them?

carefulcalculator · 14/11/2022 08:54

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime · 14/11/2022 08:48

I think it’s a perfectly reasonable argument to not have one person in sole control of the country with no one else having any authority to intervene.

You seem to be mistaking 'presidency' for 'dictatorship'.

There are many presidential models, in the UK it would be the PM with the current powers and an elected head of state instead of an unelected head of state.

UK current system is referred to as an 'elective dictatorship' for good reason - due to our unelected hereditary head of state the PM has gathered more power than in other systems because you can't justify letting the King/Queen intervene in politics.

The public would have more control with an elected head of state.

Poopoolittlerabbit · 14/11/2022 08:54

The idea that suggesting that the Powers of the Monarch should be abolished somehow means an attack in the U.K. is bizarre.
you can be British and still look at Prince Charles and think, you shouldn’t have the influence you do on our politics.

I wonder if he’s every done a DNA test? The idea that he’s somehow linked back to Royals from 1000 years ago is bizarre. He’s just a likely to have some servant or minor Lord as a great great great whatever than a king or queen…

OP posts:
Pr1mr0se · 14/11/2022 08:52

Flanjango - the monarchy in the UK is nothing to do with the Empire, it's been around a lot longer than that.

fernfen · 14/11/2022 08:52

Oh look the OP a nobody wants to make a change to British life and our traditions, suddenly decided for the entire country that we need to now abolish the royal family.

And the world shug's it's shoulders rolls their eyes and carries on we have a nother crazy in town 🤣

TheKeatingFive · 14/11/2022 08:51

I think it’s a perfectly reasonable argument to not have one person in sole control of the country with no one else having any authority to intervene.

But a presidential model wouldn't have to be like that at all. Google Ireland's model. The HOS role is very similar to the UK's except that it's elected

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime · 14/11/2022 08:48

carefulcalculator · 14/11/2022 08:33

He wouldn't get voted in now anyway, so why the endless obsession with Blair anyway?

The discussion about a president vs. monarchy is one of principle. If all you have to defend the Monarchy is you don't want person X, that is extremely weak.

I think it’s a perfectly reasonable argument to not have one person in sole control of the country with no one else having any authority to intervene.

Ivyonafence · 14/11/2022 08:47

Olios · 14/11/2022 00:34

YABU. The royal family is part of national identity and culture which contributes to people's well-being and sense of belonging. I actually think the constant attack on identity and culture is partially responsible for deteriorating mental health in general as it's exhausting and depressing to hear. Nobody alive today is responsible for the atrocities of the colonial era and just because something is a 'throwback to empire' doesn't mean it has to be eradicated. The royal family have modern roles and the king is also an advocate for the environment on a platform where frankly we need as many voices as possible for the benefit of young people.

Lol!

Unless you're Irish, or aboriginal, or Native American, or Indian, or from many African countries...

Colonisation has not exactly been the 'well being' elixir you seem to think it is.

For many First Nations people the royal family represent genocide. They can wear all the stupid hats and wave as much as they like, they enriched themselves through stealing and dispossession. Charlie didn't do it himself but he's not exactly handing it back and apologising is he?

Brefugee · 14/11/2022 08:47

The discussion about a president vs. monarchy is one of principle. If all you have to defend the Monarchy is you don't want person X, that is extremely weak.

That isn't the whole thing is it though? It is "I don't want X who is randomly born out of Y and therefore gets to be head of state"

I think they should be abolished and have a president. And before anyone starts: it won't be like the US where PM and Head of State are the same person. It would (could, should) be more like France or Germany where the roles are divided.

And it needn't be an ex-politician. My current favourite pick for president would be Doreen Lawrence (slightly political because she sits in the HoL)

Poopoolittlerabbit · 14/11/2022 08:47

‘YANBU. In this day and age, I don't understand how anyone can look at their nine year old child and think, yes that's what we want for him, a life of duty and public scrutiny.’

every time I see that poor child wearing a suit and tie like a tiny accountant I do feel sorry for him.

OP posts:
Poopoolittlerabbit · 14/11/2022 08:46

Funny, when we talk about elected heads of states or 2nd chambers people always rush straight to poor examples or start screaming about Tony Blair being a war criminal-

what we could do is look around a democracies that have successful, power-less Monarchies like the Dutch, or countries that have elected heads of state like the Republic of Ireland that work really well.

OP posts:
Ivyonafence · 14/11/2022 08:43

MightyAtlantic · 14/11/2022 00:15

YANBU. In this day and age, I don't understand how anyone can look at their nine year old child and think, yes that's what we want for him, a life of duty and public scrutiny.

Completely agree. Seems like state sanctioned child abuse.

Good on Harry for getting his wife and children away from it all.