Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Goodbye Monarchy, as is

458 replies

Poopoolittlerabbit · 14/11/2022 00:00

that’s it really. I’m not fussed about the ‘king’ -
happy to downgrade the entire system.
the jewels, the palaces, the changing of the guard belong to the country, and/or people … if Charles buggers off we keep all the tourist attractions, and all that people say makes the royal family worth while ££
now the Queen has gone, the ‘firm’ needs to go
done with them. AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
FacebookPhotos · 14/11/2022 10:37

It's probably about 200 million if you take into account the SG, all the Duchies and the direct tax payer money used for security. That's not even taking into consideration money that could be realised from all the royal estates, the artwork, antiques and the 7 billion quid jewellery collection. Or the tax on private money they don't pay.

Tax payers would still have to pay for security if we abolished the monarchy, though the amount would dwindle over time as they became less relevant. £200 million (though I'd argue you are also biased so I why should I trust your sources) is less than £3 per person. Still not significant imo.

As for the money "realised" from royal estates, I presume you mean sold? I definitely wouldn't want that! Our cultural heritage in the hands of private owners isn't something I could get behind. I much prefer to keep them where they are and use the revenue from tourists as an ongoing source of income for the country, regardless whether the monarch or the state were the official owner.

I agree with taxing their private wealth, though.

mamabear715 · 14/11/2022 10:33

Yabu

TheKeatingFive · 14/11/2022 10:32

I think the issue with recent polls is that people voting in them aren't necessarily distinguishing between 'being in favour of monarchy' and 'having Elizabeth Windsor as head of state'. Then there's obviously a bounce immediately after her death.

It will be more clear how many are genuinely monarchists in the next 3-5 years. I'll be interested to see what comes out then

Poopoolittlerabbit · 14/11/2022 10:29

‘Don't knock what you don't understand!’

I do though, maybe that’s the problem. We’d be doing that little boy a favour by making sure the ‘king’ is nothing more than a ceremonial figurehead by the time his turn comes around.

OP posts:
Poopoolittlerabbit · 14/11/2022 10:20

‘Currently, according to polls over the last few years, about 60% are in favour of keeping it 20% opposed and 20% unsure.’

who’s running these polls? The royal PR team? And what does ‘keeping it’ mean?
if they want to stay relevant- they need to get their noses out of our democracy.

how about polls that asked questions about whether or not a man born into extreme privilege should have any right to influence U.K. politics just because of who his mum
was?

OP posts:
MattDillonsEyebrows · 14/11/2022 10:06

theworldhas · 14/11/2022 09:46

Currently, according to polls over the last few years, about 60% are in favour of keeping it 20% opposed and 20% unsure. Though of course it’s not a fair question, in much the same way it’s not fair to ask citizens of China if they oppose or support the communist party - British citizens have been told by the legacy media and establishment institutions since their birth that the British monarchy is a Very Good Thing. Indeed there were calls in some quarters for Queen Elizabeth to receive a sainthood for … being monarch for a very long time.

So in the context of a generally fawning media and a cultural landscape which glorifies the concept of monarchy (which of course is not always the same as glorifying specific individuals - see Harry, Andrew, etc) 40% not actively in favour of retaining the monarchy is actually pretty high. Of course the status quo will always have a huge advantage. And in modern Britain there is very little that unites the place anymore apart from the idea that our country used to be great and very important and lead the world (symbolised by the Queen/King).

But it doesn’t look like you’ve been brainwashed by ‘a fawning media and the glorified concept of a monarchy’ @theworldhas so why would anyone else be?

Do tell us what made you so enlightened that has passed the 60% by?

Notes:
i will hazard a guess that here you’ll say something along the lines of:

not believing every thing you read in the media
doing your own research
daily mail blah blah blah
a wide range of resources

TheKeatingFive · 14/11/2022 10:06

I think Instagram covers a lot of the Royals utility. If you want to see people leading much more luxurious lives than your own, titting about in designer clothes, struggling to be both aspirational and relatable at the same time, playing the gallery for 'likes'.

It's a much better platform.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 14/11/2022 10:02

Gosh, those who are in favour of the monarchy are being very rude on this thread.

”It’s here to stay”, “don’t cry too much now”, “you opinion doesn’t count”. And that’s just the first page. What ever happened to respectful discussion?

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 14/11/2022 10:01

Then I saw how much joy they bring to some people and who am I to say that should be eradicated?

If people derive joy from an entertaining soap opera focusing on extreme privilege and heredity, they could simply find a retro channel and watch a re-run of Dynasty. It's a sight cheaper (cost, incidentally, is the least of my objections to our current anachronistic, unfit-for-purpose system). It's a sight more democratic (that's a lot more important).

Best of all, they don't get to foist their choice of banal entertainment on the rest of the country.

Poopoolittlerabbit · 14/11/2022 09:59

‘However, I think the usual arguments are silly. Firstly, the "cost" thing. 17p per person in the UK is negligible.’

sorry, what now? Have you actually sat down and done the suns or are you regurgitating some twaddle from the Monarchy marketing department?

TBH, even if it was 17p I begrudge giving multi millionaires a single penny.

and the cost isn’t why we need to get their paws off our politics anyway. What modern, democratic ( or so we claim) country should have an UNELECTED hereditary man as head of state?

OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 14/11/2022 09:56

is that supposed to be an argument for or against these leeches??

😂

TheKeatingFive · 14/11/2022 09:55

However, I think the usual arguments are silly. Firstly, the "cost" thing. 17p per person in the UK is negligible.

You're only saying this because the PR people have trained you to think of it in these terms, which I'm sure you don't apply to anything else that requires public money. Well done to the PR guys, they are good at their job.

It's probably about 200 million if you take into account the SG, all the Duchies and the direct tax payer money used for security. That's not even taking into consideration money that could be realised from all the royal estates, the artwork, antiques and the 7 billion quid jewellery collection. Or the tax on private money they don't pay.

Its very far from negligible, at least try to make the PR's job challenging for them.

Areyouactuallyserious · 14/11/2022 09:52

YANBU

Poopoolittlerabbit · 14/11/2022 09:51

‘Doesn't anyone do history anymore? The church of England was formed by an adulterous man who happened to be king’

is that supposed to be an argument for or against these leeches??

OP posts:
Holly60 · 14/11/2022 09:49

Poopoolittlerabbit · 14/11/2022 00:00

that’s it really. I’m not fussed about the ‘king’ -
happy to downgrade the entire system.
the jewels, the palaces, the changing of the guard belong to the country, and/or people … if Charles buggers off we keep all the tourist attractions, and all that people say makes the royal family worth while ££
now the Queen has gone, the ‘firm’ needs to go
done with them. AIBU?

You know that there have been people saying that the monarchy is finished for literally HUNDREDS of years.

You aren't saying anything that hasn't been said before.

At one point we actually got rid of the monarchy. And then brought it back.

I don't think it's going anywhere soon, despite your own personal views op.

FacebookPhotos · 14/11/2022 09:49

I'm not sure about having a monarchy tbh. On the one hand, it really helps to keep the class system in place and that is very bad. On the other hand, I like the soft power they exert - having someone free from political winds can be helpful in that sense, and I like the sense of history which comes with keeping them.

However, I think the usual arguments are silly. Firstly, the "cost" thing. 17p per person in the UK is negligible. Not worth kicking up a fuss imo. And the weekly meeting with the PM - the monarch is the only person in the world that the PM can be 100% sure won't discuss the conversation with the media. I can see how that is hugely beneficial to the PM, and I imagine they ignore the monarch's opinions on political matters.

Overall, a slimmed down monarchy would probably be a good balance for now. Fewer people in receipt of state support and fewer engagements.

theworldhas · 14/11/2022 09:46

Currently, according to polls over the last few years, about 60% are in favour of keeping it 20% opposed and 20% unsure. Though of course it’s not a fair question, in much the same way it’s not fair to ask citizens of China if they oppose or support the communist party - British citizens have been told by the legacy media and establishment institutions since their birth that the British monarchy is a Very Good Thing. Indeed there were calls in some quarters for Queen Elizabeth to receive a sainthood for … being monarch for a very long time.

So in the context of a generally fawning media and a cultural landscape which glorifies the concept of monarchy (which of course is not always the same as glorifying specific individuals - see Harry, Andrew, etc) 40% not actively in favour of retaining the monarchy is actually pretty high. Of course the status quo will always have a huge advantage. And in modern Britain there is very little that unites the place anymore apart from the idea that our country used to be great and very important and lead the world (symbolised by the Queen/King).

Theunamedcat · 14/11/2022 09:42

Poopoolittlerabbit · 14/11/2022 09:35

‘I think it's hilarious that a 74 year old man who committed adultery whilst in waiting to be King is now Head of the Church of England and has a job for the first time in his life.’

well, yes there is that.

Doesn't anyone do history anymore? The church of England was formed by an adulterous man who happened to be king

Poopoolittlerabbit · 14/11/2022 09:35

@AutumnCrow if I’ve made even one person smile today, then it’s already a good day! You’re welcome.

OP posts:
MarieIVanArkleStinks · 14/11/2022 09:35

After the shitshow of Brexit, I would absolutely want to know what the alternative looks like and what the process would be to get there before voting for it.

This is absolutely crucial, yes. But it's a conversation which, following the death of Elizabeth II, was inevitable. In reality it had started many years before, and the questions surrounding the future of the hereditary constitution were already growing louder and more persistent.

Poopoolittlerabbit · 14/11/2022 09:35

‘I think it's hilarious that a 74 year old man who committed adultery whilst in waiting to be King is now Head of the Church of England and has a job for the first time in his life.’

well, yes there is that.

OP posts:
AutumnCrow · 14/11/2022 09:25

Interesting discussion, @Poopoolittlerabbit.

On a personal note, I woke up a #miserablebastard and yet you put a smile on my face with 'a Ham Christian Andersen story book'. Thank you.

greenhousegal · 14/11/2022 09:24

I think it's hilarious that a 74 year old man who committed adultery whilst in waiting to be King is now Head of the Church of England and has a job for the first time in his life.

I don't think he is all that bright either, and has the personality of a plank. But that's subjective, my first sentence is fact.

Poopoolittlerabbit · 14/11/2022 09:21

@vera99 its almost pointless trying to get the English in particular to understand anything about the Famine.
they gloss over it very glibly in their history text books… and any talk of it on MN usually has people frothing at the mouth claiming the British either weren’t responsible or are they supposed to apologise for EVERYTHING now??

OP posts:
Poopoolittlerabbit · 14/11/2022 09:18

‘Doreen Lawrence would be good’

I’d happily vote for the immigrant Briton who was awarded an OBE for services to community relations and has dedicated her life to campaigning for justice for victims of racist crime.
Put Doreen along side of Charles and tell me who’s the more worthy leader? Who’s more likely to understand what it is to live in modern Britain. Who’s the better role model to young people? Who’s more relatable?

OP posts: