Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want my personal financial affairs to be pored over by randoms?

437 replies

MxGrinch · 13/11/2022 22:33

i am looking into getting DC into a private school as he is way too clever for his state school.

I knew of one in the next county and discovered they had academic scholarships for Yr9 entry. Had to register with them (non returnable £100 fee! we are a low income family) and arrange for DC to take the entrance test and scholarship assessments which he’ll be doing next month.

I’m obviously nowhere near as clever as DS as I thought a scholarship meant the fees would be paid! It seems they are only 10-20% paid so we will need to apply for a bursary.

I was sent the application form last week and need to return it tomorrow.

They want so much personal information such as 3 months bank statements, full income and expenditures, children’s income and expenditure. debts, car reg and value etc.it’s really flipping complicated and will take ages.

I know they need to assess whether we can afford the fees but seeing as there is no guarantee DC will even pass the entrance test, this is not information I want to share at this point as it may not go any further.

Theg have said if we don’t return it by tomorrow DC may not get a bursary at all.

AIBU to not want to give loads of private info until DS is actually offered a place?

OP posts:
ToInfinityAgain · 14/11/2022 15:21

Dontaskdontget · 14/11/2022 15:09

This is total nonsense, what a ridiculous post. I’ve had children at state school and at private, in the same town, and the teaching at private is infinitely higher standard. The state school teachers were overworked and this made them sarcastic and impatient (sometimes even physically rough with 4 year olds ☹️) and their attention is split in 32 different directions. Plus several of the teachers could not spell basic words.

The private school teachers are relaxed and have time to think about each child, and they are also playful, for example the teacher may randomly come to work in fancy dress when they feel like doing a special lesson. And they are never sarcastic/rough with the children because they know where their salary comes from.

Maybe one if your better-educated children could explain to you why we have different words for anecdote and data.

RosesAndHellebores · 14/11/2022 15:17

I agree with @Dontaskdontget. The reason mine went to indeoende t schools was because from an early age they received specialist Maths, English, French, Science, History and Geography teaching. Even from year 7 on dc won't necessarily have specialist Maths and Science teaching. It certainly doesn't exist in the UK before 11.

One advantage my dc have is that ehir written English is excellent and grammatically correct. I have many staff, state educated who write I myself and can't use was and were correctly. It's rather shocking.

Dontaskdontget · 14/11/2022 15:09

2greenroses · 13/11/2022 22:54

I don't know why anyone thinks the teaching at private schools is any different. Its the same staff. Teacher's move around between private and state in their career. If its a local private school, they are likely to be seeing some of the teachers moving between the two schools.

Private schools may have better facilities, and smaller classes, but no difference in teaching. There is the advantage of being able to get rid of poorly behaved students much more easily. There are more networking opportunities.

Many advantages to private schools, but teaching is likely to be exactly the same - it isn't really the clever children that benefit the most. It is children who get lost and cant keep up in big classes, or who have SEND and need more input, etc

This is total nonsense, what a ridiculous post. I’ve had children at state school and at private, in the same town, and the teaching at private is infinitely higher standard. The state school teachers were overworked and this made them sarcastic and impatient (sometimes even physically rough with 4 year olds ☹️) and their attention is split in 32 different directions. Plus several of the teachers could not spell basic words.

The private school teachers are relaxed and have time to think about each child, and they are also playful, for example the teacher may randomly come to work in fancy dress when they feel like doing a special lesson. And they are never sarcastic/rough with the children because they know where their salary comes from.

Dontaskdontget · 14/11/2022 15:00

You’re asking for other people to pay for your child to get a top quality private education, of course they need to check that you genuinely can’t afford it yourself.

I’m spending £20k a year on school fees and I would bloody love it if instead I could just show my bank statements and get a free place.

Maybe show a little gratitude?! The world is full of super-bright children and also full of low income families. You’re being offered a very rare opportunity and you’re moaning about it already, wow.

ToInfinityAgain · 14/11/2022 14:45

RosesAndHellebores · 14/11/2022 14:42

TolnfinityAgain how ghastly. I'm sure none of DS's peers would have done that. Well there was one who did but all the other boys really ripped it out of him. I honestly don't think DS or his friends could have cared less. Neither could dd's bf who went to the same school and got bullied for being a nerd.

We were in the middle. Fortunately in London so nobody had a pony.

It was the tipping point for me. I’d been agonizing over the decision, I’d paid the £4,000 non-refundable deposit to secure the space, but suddenly didn’t want my child going there.

If he doesn’t thrive in the school we chose instead then I’ll be happy to revisit the decision in later years.

RosesAndHellebores · 14/11/2022 14:42

TolnfinityAgain how ghastly. I'm sure none of DS's peers would have done that. Well there was one who did but all the other boys really ripped it out of him. I honestly don't think DS or his friends could have cared less. Neither could dd's bf who went to the same school and got bullied for being a nerd.

We were in the middle. Fortunately in London so nobody had a pony.

TheaBrandt · 14/11/2022 14:41

Weirdly my friend who has just moved her kids to private has started talking about money a lot and categorising people in conversation as to how wealthy they are. She never did that before.

That said I spent years being called “posh” at my state comp so you can’t win! Though to be fair it wasn’t malicious. Think I would rather be called “posh” by my peers than looked down on!

Itaintwhatyoudoitsthewaythatyoudoit · 14/11/2022 14:41

I have to say that I’m surprised so many on this thread can’t afford private school as MN posters usually love to brag how they are in the top 1% of high earners.
Maybe that is complete horseshit as I’ve always suspected.

Pipsquiggle · 14/11/2022 14:41

"There is an outstanding school in our area with higher GCSE grades but our disabled DC attended there and he was treated disgracefully, discriminated against and my relationship with the school completely broke down before I had no choice but to remove him. The Head was blatantly trying to bully me to get rid of him so there’s no way I would send DS there! It is also well known for bullying amongst students not being dealt with and older DS suffered that as well."

@MxGrinch
Although 1 of your DC didn't have a good experience at this school, might this be the perfect solution for your 'bright' son?

I loved the school I went to, my older sister hated it and left due to unresolved issues. My parents also fell out with the head because of it. Thankfully they let me stay and I thrived.

It might be time to swallow your pride - particularly if they have a 'gifted' scheme at this school - as most comps do.

Itaintwhatyoudoitsthewaythatyoudoit · 14/11/2022 14:38

That’s why it is important to choose private schools carefully. There are plenty of rich schools and there are plenty that will attract families who are trying hard to give their children the best education their money can buy, - many of them from different cultures who are by no means holidaying four times a year.

ToInfinityAgain · 14/11/2022 14:36

On the “will they know” point the little darling showing me around the local prep school was telling me about his dad’s McLaren and Rolexes. That’s me, the adult, who he’d met fifteen minutes earlier.

The idea that children won’t know who’s from a wealthy family and who isn’t really tenable.

Whether it matters or not is another question.

BoredZelda · 14/11/2022 14:34

Are you kidding me. My niece had an IQ of 154 at age 7 and that dropped to 110 by age 16. She was very advanced (learned to read by age 4, for example) and the school did not set an appropriate program for her although she was accelerated two times. She was bored, lost interest in school and just scraped through A levels.

IQ can change with so many variables, not least which IQ test you set a person, but the most volatility is in childhood to adolescence.

There is no such thing as "an IQ" it's simply how a person performed on one test in one day.

PurpleWisteria1 · 14/11/2022 14:17

The vast majority will be wealthy.
It’s no good saying ‘oh they won’t know’ Yes in secondary they will know by week 2 that you are not wealthy, even if you choose not to say. Just by life experiences and pretty much everything you say. There will be some kinder kids sure but many will be sneering / scoffing behind the child’s back and even if they are not, that can be something the child is paranoid about. As I said upthread, feeling like the poor one who can’t do the same as your peers is miserable.

Rainn21 · 14/11/2022 13:52

Range Rover thing was a generalisation. People will know your child isn’t paying to be there.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 14/11/2022 13:38

My kids are in private school, both are of average intelligence and one is getting bullied. I could have had this anywhere else and saved bloody money.

gogohmm · 14/11/2022 13:28

Sorry he's too clever for state, no he's not! You want to try to get a private education for free so yes there's hurdles. Scholarships are usually small as they are not means tested , do check the max bursary before you complete the forms. Yes they are intrusive but that's to stop a person with loads of assets applying

ilovemotorways · 14/11/2022 13:23

Yabu for saying your son is too clever for his state school. Ridiculous statement.

Not all people at private school are 'clever'. If he's clever he should do well anywhere.

Yabu also for your original question. You're asking for a free place. Obviously they need these details. Did you wait till you had a mortgage offer before submitting your finances too?

TheOrigRights · 14/11/2022 13:19

RosesAndHellebores · 14/11/2022 13:14

@Rainn21 not all private school dc are dropped off in range rovers. There are many scruffy cars at the gates. Mine was included.

I had a very, very old Nissan Micra (a long story, it served a need). People probably thought it was reverse snobbery!

TheOrigRights · 14/11/2022 13:18

Compare to a mother who worked as an FE teacher, never able to get a fraction higher than 4 days a week. Too much to get any benefits and again in LA accommodation. No chance of a bursary for her equally clever daughter and that mother was cream crackered.

The school must have had a pretty high bar to award bursaries.

I was surprised my son received so much. I am a lone parent with (at the time) 2 dependent children, a pretty reasonable salary, mortgage, but no other significant debts/loans, no major assets. I think we're pretty comfortable, or at least secure, but when we received the award I was reminded of how some people get annual bonuses probably of the same value as my annual salary, have multiple properties or what have you.

RosesAndHellebores · 14/11/2022 13:14

@Rainn21 not all private school dc are dropped off in range rovers. There are many scruffy cars at the gates. Mine was included.

TheOrigRights · 14/11/2022 13:13

ToInfinityAgain · 14/11/2022 13:05

Everyone’s going to know as soon as anyone sees the houses that people live in though aren’t they?

Not if they "We sacrificed everything, including the shirt on our back" crowd are anything to go by.

Anyway, my son was privately educated for 6th form only. Maybe the novelty of making the students in receipt of a bursary feel like shit had worn off by then, or maybe some of the students learnt by then that using someone's (parents') wealth as a benchmark for friendship or worth was not a good measure.

NellesVilla · 14/11/2022 13:12

Haven’t read entire thread but too clever for state school?

OP, get your head out of your arse. I went to a private school and failed to get into Cambridge (got into a good uni but not that one!) whilst my 3 x cousins all got in (and they were state educated).

RosesAndHellebores · 14/11/2022 13:11

@ShiningStarQueen some would say all barristers are criminal. Did you mean you are at the criminal barWink.

@MxGrinch just to take the thread back a few pages, I think the school is quite right to carry out due diligence prior to the examination. There is no point raising a child's hopes whose family don't meet the bursary bar. It's entirely realistic.

Also, these schemes sadly get "played" and the "players" need weeding out. The places are funded from full fee payers and trusts and bequests usually left by former pupils. It is very important schools take care to award bursaries to those genuinely in need.

DD had a friend who got a full bursary. Child of a single parent, LA accommodation, in a very nice block. The mother was Eastern European, had perfect English, they lived quite well. The mother had never done a days work in the UK. I'd have had no objection to anything at all had she done a hands turn.

Compare to a mother who worked as an FE teacher, never able to get a fraction higher than 4 days a week. Too much to get any benefits and again in LA accommodation. No chance of a bursary for her equally clever daughter and that mother was cream crackered.

ToInfinityAgain · 14/11/2022 13:05

TheOrigRights · 14/11/2022 13:03

I hope that is not the norm.
I was reassured that none of the teachers knew who the 'bursary students' were, and the opinion I got from my son was that his friends and peers only knew that he got a bursary if he chose to tell them.
Not that we had any shame in receiving a bursary, but because we are aware that some people have the views you state.

Everyone’s going to know as soon as anyone sees the houses that people live in though aren’t they?

ShiningStarQueen · 14/11/2022 13:04

Surely he’s definitely going to pass the entrance test if he’s too clever for state school 🙄