Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want my personal financial affairs to be pored over by randoms?

437 replies

MxGrinch · 13/11/2022 22:33

i am looking into getting DC into a private school as he is way too clever for his state school.

I knew of one in the next county and discovered they had academic scholarships for Yr9 entry. Had to register with them (non returnable £100 fee! we are a low income family) and arrange for DC to take the entrance test and scholarship assessments which he’ll be doing next month.

I’m obviously nowhere near as clever as DS as I thought a scholarship meant the fees would be paid! It seems they are only 10-20% paid so we will need to apply for a bursary.

I was sent the application form last week and need to return it tomorrow.

They want so much personal information such as 3 months bank statements, full income and expenditures, children’s income and expenditure. debts, car reg and value etc.it’s really flipping complicated and will take ages.

I know they need to assess whether we can afford the fees but seeing as there is no guarantee DC will even pass the entrance test, this is not information I want to share at this point as it may not go any further.

Theg have said if we don’t return it by tomorrow DC may not get a bursary at all.

AIBU to not want to give loads of private info until DS is actually offered a place?

OP posts:
MawSandra · 14/11/2022 16:19

What makes you think children are brighter at fee paying schools than at state ones?

KatyCustard · 14/11/2022 16:13

It is a well known fact; once children get too clever they can’t stay in a state school.
I just don’t think there’s a state school in the land with a single clever child in it.
IF we do stumble across one we run away screaming.

TheaBrandt · 14/11/2022 16:09

vbac queen wow well done to your Dd!

We have pretty good state schools so we haven’t bothered. Both ours are thriving and dd1 got mostly 9s some 8s and both have really nice friends. The advantages of private as I see it is better customer care for parents and child and undeniably better sports. On balance we felt that wasn’t worth the outlay for us. Everyone’s situation is different though. The end result where we are is basically interchangeable! The teens all socialise together anyway once they get to 6th form.

thisisme2468 · 14/11/2022 16:02

He could study iGCSEs independently from school if he needs more challenges.

Fireflybaby · 14/11/2022 15:59

MxGrinch · 13/11/2022 22:44

DC is too clever and very bored. They say why bother to go to school as they’re not learning anything they don’t already know. School said they’d move them into GCSE classes but then backtracked as it wasn’t possible as they’d be 2 years ahead of their peers.

And where's the issue? He either is ahead of his peers or he isn't? Which one is it?
Affording private education is not going to help. Anyone who has money can send their child (even the not so clever ones) into private education. 🙄

RoseAdagio · 14/11/2022 15:58

If you want something for free that would otherwise cost tens of thousands of pounds, yes you have to let some complete strangers scrutinise your finances to check that you are financially eligible. That's how it works, not sure why you are chafing about it tbh?

Beachloveramy · 14/11/2022 15:57

YABVU. It’s free money.

I have to give that level of detail and more every 2.5 years and pay thousands each time for my husband to remain in the country paying taxes.

You sound extremely entitled.

Fireflybaby · 14/11/2022 15:56

Yeah, no. Yes you are unreasonable. I can't see how private education would fulfill your child's cleverness level as private school would only give them better conditions but same knowledge as any other school.

Have you tried grammar schools?
Private tuition?

Let him take GCSC or A-levels early and then let him move on to university.

If he's a child prodigy then he should be OK... he doesn't need private education.

ToInfinityAgain · 14/11/2022 15:56

Abra1t · 14/11/2022 15:47

Unless you're applying to an ancient foundation with deep pockets, the people funding your child's bursary are ultimately other families. Who may only just be able to afford it, by the skin of their teeth.

Finding out about bursaries put me off the private route a bit.

It’s one thing to pay £30,000 per year to get £30,000 worth of education and facilities for my child but quite another to pay that much for £20,000 value and also to pay another £10,000 per year to pay for someone else’s child to go, someone else whose child is likely no more “deserving” if the place than mine, and whose parents were no less privileged than me.

No thanks; I’d not pay 50% extra at the Ferrari showroom to subsidize a poor buyer who also wanted one so why do it at school?

TheWitchOfShields · 14/11/2022 15:55

Way too clever for state school? 🤣🤣🤣 whatever!

Abra1t · 14/11/2022 15:53

Yup, and no need to declare the private tutor on the UCAS form, so less obviously a privilege.

vbacqueen1 · 14/11/2022 15:52

My DD went to a very rough underperforming state school. Seven level 9’s and two level 8’s at GCSE.
Smashed her A levels.
Is now at Oxford doing a double degree.
Neither her father or I went to university. We live in a very ordinary town and are not loaded. We chose to send her to the same school as her siblings.
If they’re clever enough and have the ambition they’ll do well wherever they go to school.
If you’re so set on private school I’m afraid you need to suck it up and answer the questions.

MrsDarcy1989x · 14/11/2022 15:51

Another private school attendee here, once watched another student eat his sock for £5. Save all that effort and get him a private tutor to cover all these subjects that ‘state school’ is holding him back on :)

Justthisonce12 · 14/11/2022 15:51

Bigpantygirl21 · 14/11/2022 15:44

Is it not the same curriculum whether you’re in a private or state school? My privately educated nephews are of similar intelligence to my dd, and she got far better exam results than both of them, at a state school.
That aside, I personally would make the effort to fill in the forms and get all the information together. They have every right to request this information from you, in return for a free place for your child.

But you will never know what your DD might of achieved in private school it may have been better it may have been worse I’ve had people say to me that my daughter didn’t go to university so what a waste her private education was. But I look at her beautiful handwriting and her ability to conversed on numerous subjects the fact that she speaks beautifully knows how to hold a self on how to present all of which will be beneficial to her in the future.

Abra1t · 14/11/2022 15:47

Unless you're applying to an ancient foundation with deep pockets, the people funding your child's bursary are ultimately other families. Who may only just be able to afford it, by the skin of their teeth.

CecilyP · 14/11/2022 15:47

They want so much personal information such as 3 months bank statements, full income and expenditures, children’s income and expenditure. debts, car reg and value etc.it’s really flipping complicated and will take ages.

It won’t take nearly as long as it would take to earn the money to pay for fees you want waived. I do feel some sympathy that they are asking for this information so early in the application process. But if that’s what they do, there will be plenty of others who will comply with their request.

Bigpantygirl21 · 14/11/2022 15:44

Is it not the same curriculum whether you’re in a private or state school? My privately educated nephews are of similar intelligence to my dd, and she got far better exam results than both of them, at a state school.
That aside, I personally would make the effort to fill in the forms and get all the information together. They have every right to request this information from you, in return for a free place for your child.

Welshmonster · 14/11/2022 15:41

Have you looked into grammar schools near you as they are free but you do need to pass an entrance test.

they may accept mid year applications as pupils who started in y7 may have now left so if there isn’t anyone on waiting list able to take up place it may be an option.

the current school should be challenging him with appropriate work and if not then speak to the SENCO as they are for all children not just children of lower ability.

Itloggedmeoutagain · 14/11/2022 15:34

RosesAndHellebores · 14/11/2022 15:17

I agree with @Dontaskdontget. The reason mine went to indeoende t schools was because from an early age they received specialist Maths, English, French, Science, History and Geography teaching. Even from year 7 on dc won't necessarily have specialist Maths and Science teaching. It certainly doesn't exist in the UK before 11.

One advantage my dc have is that ehir written English is excellent and grammatically correct. I have many staff, state educated who write I myself and can't use was and were correctly. It's rather shocking.

You may like to check your spellings.

RosesAndHellebores · 14/11/2022 15:32

They aren't the same teachers TolfinityAgain (trying to work out why your user name says you don't exist when I use the @) I agree, badly written post. Fat fingers on phone and tapping away.

Itloggedmeoutagain · 14/11/2022 15:31

On the one hand you say he may not pass
On the other hand he's getting grade 9s in gcse
Surely if he can get a 9 he can pass the entrance exam
Just fill the forms in

2greenroses · 14/11/2022 15:29

Private school teachers can be treated worse than state school teachers, in many instances. And can be worked harder sometimes - private schools are profit making enterprises, not for anything else.

And a no teacher should be rough or mean to children, but their basic personality isn't going to change between one job and another.
"They know where their salaries come from" - cuts both ways

WindyHedges · 14/11/2022 15:28

Way too clever for state school

?????

I’m a leading researcher in my field. I went to a big standard comprehensive.

My parents decided I didn’t need the extra help of a bought education and it would be better in all sorts of ways not to be hot housed although they had the finances to pay for it. They invested in other aspects of our education.

YABU. And you can’t afford a private school. It’s not just fees. Spend the money on books and extra- curricular activities.

2greenroses · 14/11/2022 15:27

Dontaskdontget · 14/11/2022 15:09

This is total nonsense, what a ridiculous post. I’ve had children at state school and at private, in the same town, and the teaching at private is infinitely higher standard. The state school teachers were overworked and this made them sarcastic and impatient (sometimes even physically rough with 4 year olds ☹️) and their attention is split in 32 different directions. Plus several of the teachers could not spell basic words.

The private school teachers are relaxed and have time to think about each child, and they are also playful, for example the teacher may randomly come to work in fancy dress when they feel like doing a special lesson. And they are never sarcastic/rough with the children because they know where their salary comes from.

It. is. the. same. teachers.

Teachers move around between local schools, for promotions, or to go part time, or to specialise, etc. Some teachers may choose to spend their whole career in either state, or private, but many don't. I've moved between state and private, and so have many colleagues.

Class sizes are both far bigger and far smaller in private schools. In the same school, even. The basic class may be smaller, but there seem to be no ratios imposed at all. I've had over 100 children in my charge alone at one time in private, which would never happen in state, and I've also, as a visitor to one of the most expensive and prestigious schools in the country come across a situation where a large number of children where left without any adult supervision what so ever, for hours. These things dont happen in state, we close down year groups first, and send children home

And that is just a silly thing to say about teacher's spelling. How do you know you have spelt a word correctly? Because it's the way you have seen it written. How do teachers see word written? Wrongly, multiple times, year after year after year for decades. Hesitancy over spelling is a well recognised sign of a long term experienced teacher, and they are few and far between

ToInfinityAgain · 14/11/2022 15:22

RosesAndHellebores · 14/11/2022 15:17

I agree with @Dontaskdontget. The reason mine went to indeoende t schools was because from an early age they received specialist Maths, English, French, Science, History and Geography teaching. Even from year 7 on dc won't necessarily have specialist Maths and Science teaching. It certainly doesn't exist in the UK before 11.

One advantage my dc have is that ehir written English is excellent and grammatically correct. I have many staff, state educated who write I myself and can't use was and were correctly. It's rather shocking.

A parody post, or just amusingly poorly written?