Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want my personal financial affairs to be pored over by randoms?

437 replies

MxGrinch · 13/11/2022 22:33

i am looking into getting DC into a private school as he is way too clever for his state school.

I knew of one in the next county and discovered they had academic scholarships for Yr9 entry. Had to register with them (non returnable £100 fee! we are a low income family) and arrange for DC to take the entrance test and scholarship assessments which he’ll be doing next month.

I’m obviously nowhere near as clever as DS as I thought a scholarship meant the fees would be paid! It seems they are only 10-20% paid so we will need to apply for a bursary.

I was sent the application form last week and need to return it tomorrow.

They want so much personal information such as 3 months bank statements, full income and expenditures, children’s income and expenditure. debts, car reg and value etc.it’s really flipping complicated and will take ages.

I know they need to assess whether we can afford the fees but seeing as there is no guarantee DC will even pass the entrance test, this is not information I want to share at this point as it may not go any further.

Theg have said if we don’t return it by tomorrow DC may not get a bursary at all.

AIBU to not want to give loads of private info until DS is actually offered a place?

OP posts:
tadaaaa · 15/11/2022 07:07

Some people are missing a key part of the jigsaw here, which is that quite a few schools offer their bursaries before the entrance tests. It sounds like the OP's school might be one of these. Of course the bursary is then dependent on the child getting in, but the bursary amount is not conditional upon the entry tests (so you don't need to be extra clever to get a generous bursary). In fact the richest schools are increasingly seeking to be 'means-blind' - ie they want to offer their places irrespective of how much parents can pay. (I don't think any have fully achieved this yet.)

In that context, it's perfectly proportionate to ask for this level of detail now, because the school can't make that assessment without it.

Andypandy799 · 15/11/2022 03:10

@MxGrinch please let us know if your gifted child passes the test 😂😂😂😂

Goldenbear · 14/11/2022 22:50

But what you are describing is proportionate to the service you are using. The OP's situation would not be considered 'fair' it would be considered 'excessive' under data protection laws. There are principles in the law that 'all' organisations in the UK have to follow, it is irrelevant whether the private school thinks they 'should' be allowed this information, the law if applied correctly to this scenario would highlight they are 'not' entitled to it at this stage.

Rikalaily · 14/11/2022 22:36

We are paying our debts off with a debt management plan. Our annual financial reassessment call was at 9.45am this morning. They require the same info as what you have been asked for. I got a pen and piece of paper, logged into our online banking and wrote down our income and outgoings from there. I started at 9.10am and was done by 9.30am and had rime to make a cuppa before the call.

You know your income and outgoings, you can check your outgoings through bank statements or even paper bills if you recieve them, it doesn't take long at all. Even when we first set up the plan and had to send the actual evidence of bills and payslips, it only took a few hours to collate, photograph and email it all in.

If you want tens of thousands of pounds of free school fees paid then get it done. Or don't and have your son miss out. The financial side has to be sorted before a place is offered, or it may be too late for another family to take that place after the exam results are in.

You are being massively unreasonable.

Goldenbear · 14/11/2022 22:32

I agree with you OP, private schools have to comply with data protection laws and arguably this is 'excessive' processing if the OP's child hasn't even passed the entrance exam. You can't process personal data just because it 'might' be needed in the future!

Lemonella · 14/11/2022 22:21

HydrangeaRose · 14/11/2022 21:35

Bear in mind if successful a bursary may not help towards very expensive uniform requirements and as they progress into senior years , eye watering school trips that all of their friends go on and are deemed beneficial .

This is the regular tripe trotted out by the anti-private school mob. Not all kids in private schools are loaded, a lot use the second hand uniform stores in the schools, and trips are very much not compulsory. Loads of kids don’t go on the trips. Also, bursaries can include uniforms. You don’t have to spend huge additional sums, it’s a myth perpetuated on here by the clueless.

Whalesong · 14/11/2022 22:19

Yes, academic scholarships at private schools are 10% if you're lucky. To be honest, in the superselective ones (which you're presumably looking at since you say that your child is "too clever for state school" - not sure what that's supposed to mean) every single successful applicant will be at the very top, so why would yours get a full scholarship above anyone else?
Mine did attend one of these superselectives and it was extremely good for him to be near the top but not at the very top (which he was at his primary, which was considered very academic). There were always others who were even brighter, and that was very healthy. He went on to get an academic scholarship at university (now that one DOES pay out a significant amount).
And the ones who had gained scholarships weren't always the ones who ended up in the top sets (much to their parents' annoyance) - and shock, horror, they didn't all get offers to Oxbridge either, when others did.
Seriously, anyone who gets into one of the superselectives could qualify for a scholarship depending on the day - hence why they mean very little beyond a token monetary amount.
Yes, if you can prove financial hardship you MAY qualify for a bursary. Assuming your child aces the entrance exams. But you will have to get your head around sharing your financial information to be in the running.

surreygirl1987 · 14/11/2022 22:14

Depends entirely on the private school. It obviously makes a huge difference whether it's boarding or day! I make significantly more money in the private sector than I would working in a state school (and have longer holidays too) - I'll never go back. I don't work anything like 70 hours a week... not even remotely close.

pollyglot · 14/11/2022 22:09

Show me a private school with a lesser workload! I've spent 23 years in the independent system and despite the smaller classes, never worked less than a 70 hour week. That's because the long teaching day (8.30-6 pm, generally) is just the start. There's compulsory evening duties until 10 pm, Saturday morning classes, followed by games until at least 4 pm, Sunday Chapel...Ok, an exeat every so often, but I always used to say, at my first school, that we worked a 6-week week...6 weeks of 61/2 day weeks, then an exeat. Not for the fainthearted.

cardibach · 14/11/2022 21:35

justgettingthroughtheday · 13/11/2022 23:31

This is just not true. Private schools pay more and attract the best of the best teaching wise. Smaller class sizes means lessons are more tailored to the individual kids.
Subject specific teachers teaching much younger classes. So Maths teachers teaching maths at primary level rather than a single class teacher covering all subjects.
The teaching is superior - that's why people pay for it.

I guess I need to get onto the private schools I’ve worked for to ask for the extra pay they should have given me then. In both I warned less than for the equivalent job in state. Private schools can attract teachers due to the smaller classes which result in reduced workload. (And the freedom from the political interference in state).

HydrangeaRose · 14/11/2022 21:35

Bear in mind if successful a bursary may not help towards very expensive uniform requirements and as they progress into senior years , eye watering school trips that all of their friends go on and are deemed beneficial .

entropynow · 14/11/2022 21:20

AnneLovesGilbert · 13/11/2022 22:38

Do you think it’s rude of mortgage companies to ask financial info too? That’s a long, not even free money.

If your son is as bright as you say he’ll thrive with your support wherever he is.

The idea that " bright children thrive wherever" is a) false b) responsible for an awful lot of suffering. But hey, they're clever kids and everyone hates them, so who cares, right? 🙄

GeorgeorRuth · 14/11/2022 21:16

NumberTheory · 14/11/2022 20:59

This might apply on the macro level, but at the individual level you’re looking at particular children and particular schools and some schools are better than others. Being able to choose away from a poorly performing school (or one that performs poorly for your child) is an advantage. Well off parents do this in many ways, moving house, paying for private schooling, or hot housing for the 11 plus in areas with a grammar system.

In OP’s case she probably can’t afford those options but she can try and improve her choices by applying for bursaries at private schools in her area that are better than the school her son is allocated by the state system.

It’s privileged to be able to assume that your child’s state school is going to be good enough. There are many that do a bad job with at least some of the children they serve. And the ones that do the best job tend to be hard for people who aren’t well off to get into - it’s not just academics that make schools selective - leaving them without the likelihood of their children getting a place that will help them reach their potential.

Yes, to all this. State schools vary. Some DC will be motivated if with other motivated DC but unmotivated if with less good influences. See the thread about behaviour in schools running at the moment! Those at the bottom of the social/ financial scale will not have the same expectations made of them. Accessing the same opportunities is difficult. Enrichment requires resources not always available to low income families. We were lucky there was a charity that paid for 1 extra curricular activity each.. We applied for scholarships and bursaries for all 3 DCs at varying ages. All were given 95-100%. Yes, the forms are intrusive but the price to pay.
Good luck OP, but do you have a plan b in case you don't get the funds?

Itaintwhatyoudoitsthewaythatyoudoit · 14/11/2022 21:07

NumberTheory · 14/11/2022 20:59

This might apply on the macro level, but at the individual level you’re looking at particular children and particular schools and some schools are better than others. Being able to choose away from a poorly performing school (or one that performs poorly for your child) is an advantage. Well off parents do this in many ways, moving house, paying for private schooling, or hot housing for the 11 plus in areas with a grammar system.

In OP’s case she probably can’t afford those options but she can try and improve her choices by applying for bursaries at private schools in her area that are better than the school her son is allocated by the state system.

It’s privileged to be able to assume that your child’s state school is going to be good enough. There are many that do a bad job with at least some of the children they serve. And the ones that do the best job tend to be hard for people who aren’t well off to get into - it’s not just academics that make schools selective - leaving them without the likelihood of their children getting a place that will help them reach their potential.

I am so relieved to read this post which is the most balanced argument on the entire thread. Thank you.

RoseAdagio · 14/11/2022 21:00

MxGrinch · 14/11/2022 01:38

Where I did say he doesn’t engage or ask for more things to do? I’ve already said he did GCSE papers at home, got grade 9s on them and took them in to show his teachers.

He built his own gaming PC from scratch a few weeks ago, in two hours, totally on his own. DS1 who is away at Uni was going to come home to help him but DS3 couldn’t wait. He told me what bits to order and just got me to hold some wires. Even DS1 was shocked that he did it and it worked perfectly as he needed his mates to help him build his and he was about 18.

He’s also taught himself about nuclear fusion/fission at age 9/10. genetics, and loads of other science stuff and writes a lot of code where stuff pops up, animation etc for fun. Recently diagnosed Type 1 diabetic as well and took over management from the start. Doesn’t want me fussing! Took it in his stride and is very matter of fact about it. One of the other reasons I’d like to get him in a private school is for the pastoral care.

Done the form now!

I've figured it our guys; OP's son is in fact Chuck Norris.

NumberTheory · 14/11/2022 20:59

Redebs · 14/11/2022 20:32

Yes, private schools get better results because they are selective. There's no advantage to the individual pupil, apart from the status and networking associated with privileged families.

This might apply on the macro level, but at the individual level you’re looking at particular children and particular schools and some schools are better than others. Being able to choose away from a poorly performing school (or one that performs poorly for your child) is an advantage. Well off parents do this in many ways, moving house, paying for private schooling, or hot housing for the 11 plus in areas with a grammar system.

In OP’s case she probably can’t afford those options but she can try and improve her choices by applying for bursaries at private schools in her area that are better than the school her son is allocated by the state system.

It’s privileged to be able to assume that your child’s state school is going to be good enough. There are many that do a bad job with at least some of the children they serve. And the ones that do the best job tend to be hard for people who aren’t well off to get into - it’s not just academics that make schools selective - leaving them without the likelihood of their children getting a place that will help them reach their potential.

RobertNotBob · 14/11/2022 20:56

YABU If you want the privilege and advantage that go with private education, you'll have to jump through the hoops.

Tillow4ever · 14/11/2022 20:42

Guessing the form wasn't that complicated in the end, OP, as it only took you about 20 mins from saying you would fill it in to saying you'd completed it. Hardly the onerous task you were making it out to be. Sounds more like this post was simply to tell us all just how clever your son is...

Plmoknijb123 · 14/11/2022 20:38

Just disclose your info for gods sake. What a whinge.

Redebs · 14/11/2022 20:32

4onway · 14/11/2022 06:57

State school teacher. 50% of gcse students in my subject got grade 7+ in my subject last year. About 20 in year (20%) grade 9s. One girl a few years ago was one of only a handful in the country to get grade 9s across the board. The private schools poach our students for sixth form and give them bursaries as they boost their results! We are none selective comprehensive. No such thing as too smart for state school. You know the teachers go to the same universities and are trained in the same places don’t you? Just different employers.

Yes, private schools get better results because they are selective. There's no advantage to the individual pupil, apart from the status and networking associated with privileged families.

CrochetIsCool · 14/11/2022 19:45

2greenroses · 13/11/2022 22:36

How is it possible to be "too clever" for state school? That doesn't happen

This!

LynetteScavo · 14/11/2022 19:34

They're not going to bother picking through your finances unless they're seriously thinking of offering him a place. Will you even qualify for a Bursury? I'm asking because you weren't aware how much the scholarship is worth. You need to submit the paperwork to show commitment and to get things in motion. You're basically asking them to give you charity of tens of thousands of pounds. It's a vast amount, so you need to play the game.

If your DC is so able they'll ace the entrance tests and that's when you'll have to worry about the school bursar noticing your payments to Love Honey

Boredom isn't a sign of intelligence, btw - it's usually the complete opposite.

Lemon80 · 14/11/2022 19:13
Biscuit
Ffariee · 14/11/2022 18:44

My 11 year old has been coding and developing games since about age 8 and I was told by juniors he is gifted and talented, my 13 year old got top marks for all his year 7 tests out of 150+ students. However I trust in the state school they go to to help them both meet their potential. It worked with my 18 year old who got fantastic results and is doing the course he wanted at a great university. It even helped with my eldest (22) who has learning disabilities and is finding his own success in the world of work - we are lucky enough to be near good state schools, sounds like OP may not be so lucky where she lives.
However…
OP - your comments have sounded boasting and have obviously rubbed everyone up the wrong way- we’d all like to send our kids to the awesome private school for free so please understand how lucky you are to have the chance you have been offered.
with regards to the ‘invasive’ form, you have no idea!! I bet I have filled forms in that are so much worse - I’m talking PIP forms and help with debt (stories for another time!).
If, after the exam, your son doesn’t get the place at the school, they have to remove this personal data legally from their records within a given time and you also have the ‘right to be forgotten’ where you request they remove all the personal data they hold about you.
There! - no harm done! except for your precious time lost filling out the oh so hard form from records you should already have to hand.
I hope for your son’s sake he gets the education he needs to be successful and happy and that he can grow up to be a decent caring person

WrongWayApricot · 14/11/2022 18:36

BloodAndFire · 14/11/2022 09:52

Very high IQs in young children almost always drop as they get older because they are measured against age. It is far more common to score significantly higher than the average for your age when you are very young ('child prodigies'). In the vast majority of cases, iq scores level out as children get older.

The fact that she screwed up her A-levels is a separate issue, not the school's fault, and also not uncommon with children who start off very bright.

How do we know that those bright kids wouldn't have done better if they had been stretched or whatever you want to call it. Wasn't there a study that showed if you told teachers children had a higher iq the children did better at school because they were treated like they could do better?