Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want my personal financial affairs to be pored over by randoms?

437 replies

MxGrinch · 13/11/2022 22:33

i am looking into getting DC into a private school as he is way too clever for his state school.

I knew of one in the next county and discovered they had academic scholarships for Yr9 entry. Had to register with them (non returnable £100 fee! we are a low income family) and arrange for DC to take the entrance test and scholarship assessments which he’ll be doing next month.

I’m obviously nowhere near as clever as DS as I thought a scholarship meant the fees would be paid! It seems they are only 10-20% paid so we will need to apply for a bursary.

I was sent the application form last week and need to return it tomorrow.

They want so much personal information such as 3 months bank statements, full income and expenditures, children’s income and expenditure. debts, car reg and value etc.it’s really flipping complicated and will take ages.

I know they need to assess whether we can afford the fees but seeing as there is no guarantee DC will even pass the entrance test, this is not information I want to share at this point as it may not go any further.

Theg have said if we don’t return it by tomorrow DC may not get a bursary at all.

AIBU to not want to give loads of private info until DS is actually offered a place?

OP posts:
tadaaaa · 14/11/2022 07:26

I work in a private school. I'll ignore the controversial stuff and tell you a bit about the process.

First off, the £100 absolutely won't have covered the full cost of running the admissions process for your child. That's particularly true of a bursary applicant. The bursary process is complicated and time consuming, whether a school does it in-house or outsources it. But we obviously don't want to charge more for those applicants, because they're the least likely to be able to afford it.

On the main question, the reason we need to have the info first is because of the timings. It takes a good couple of months to complete all the bursary assessments. When we offer places, our candidates are often holding offers from multiple schools. They need to decide within a couple of weeks whether to accept each offer, and then pay a deposit. When an applicant either turns down our offer, or turns us down later post-deposit, then we have to offer to another student to fill that gap (all schools over-offer, but you can't do it by that much). If we were assessing bursaries post offer, then we'd have lots of those families turning down our offers a couple of months later once we'd given them a bursary decision (because we can't give them all as much discount as they want/need). We would then have to fill those places - but other families would already have accepted offers elsewhere. Now, we're a very sought-after school, but we've still got lots of competition, and although there are plenty of parents who will forfeit their deposit to accept a late offer from us, there are plenty of others who won't.

There's also the impact on the pupil. Lots of our bursary applicants withdraw when they get their bursary decision (because we've only got so much money to offer), so that their child doesn't have the stress of sitting the exams and the false hope of a place, if there's no prospect of their parents being able to afford it. If we assessed post-exam, then there would be lots more disappointed children.

And yes, we get lots of either ridiculously over-optimistic or downright fraudulent bursary applications, so I'm afraid we do need all that detail.

Hope that helps explain things.

arethereanyleftatall · 14/11/2022 07:25

Op, I'm not sure you've understood completely what private schools are.

Private schools are for RICH children. No difference in their intellect.

You need a selective school. Who select on academic ability. Some will be private. In the state sector, these are available - they're called Grammar Schools.

Through my job, I know hundreds of teachers - the teachers are not better at private schools, often the opposite, but the resources are, generally, and class sizes smaller.

Lozzybear · 14/11/2022 07:24

@TheaBrandt utter crap. Scholarships reflect ability and are given to the most talented students disregarding their financial circumstances. That’s why they generally only give a very small fee remission and sometimes are “honorary” with no fee remission whatsoever.

badbaduncle · 14/11/2022 07:19

😂😂😂

TheaBrandt · 14/11/2022 07:19

At a family members private school the scholarship/ bursary pupils are known as “the chavs” 🙄. so watch out….

howshouldibehave · 14/11/2022 07:14

he is way too clever for his state school

Riiight.

passport123 · 14/11/2022 07:11

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 13/11/2022 23:32

Eh? So you found a private school, gave them £100 (which, especially if you're a low income family, is a lot of money) to enroll him in the exam without doing any research into how you'd afford the fees? Just assuming someone else would foot the bill?

I mean, I'm also in a low income family but how bloody entitled are you?

Ultimately, you've gotten his hopes up but because you can't be arsed to do the research or complete the paperwork, he's going to be left disappointed.

Greeeaaattt parenting right there.

Why the fuck did you pay the £100?

This!

HelloagainLilibet · 14/11/2022 07:11

Way too clever for state school? Nice.

chwaer · 14/11/2022 07:09

4onway · 14/11/2022 06:57

State school teacher. 50% of gcse students in my subject got grade 7+ in my subject last year. About 20 in year (20%) grade 9s. One girl a few years ago was one of only a handful in the country to get grade 9s across the board. The private schools poach our students for sixth form and give them bursaries as they boost their results! We are none selective comprehensive. No such thing as too smart for state school. You know the teachers go to the same universities and are trained in the same places don’t you? Just different employers.

Yes, this is true if you're looking at the bigger picture.

But if you're looking at the experience for the individual, then being in a school with other high achievers, high expectations and excellent resources can easily be a better learning environment for that individual.

FWIW I don't believe in private education in a political sense. I think we should close the private schools. If the rich people had to send their DC to state school, you can bet the government would suddenly find the money to properly resource them.

But, do DC in the private school have to read photocopies of extracts because they can't afford to give each DC a book like in my DC's school? (Actually they probably get parents to buy them, but every child has a book).

Are they constantly short of supplies and asking the parents to donate things like glue sticks? No.

Three schools in this town have swimming pools: two are private, one is state. On paper, equal, right? But the reality is the private schools have Olympic sized pools, the state school has a 10m pool that's constantly closed as they can't afford the repairs. Not equal.

My DC's state schools are wonderful and their teachers brilliant, on the whole, and doing an amazing job under difficult circumstances. That doesn't mean they might not get more opportunities in private schools though.

pinkfondu · 14/11/2022 07:07

Testina · 13/11/2022 22:39

“it’s really flipping complicated and will take ages.”

Get the too clever for state school son to do it faster?

Or at least get him to do a basic pounds per minute calculation of what your time will “earn”, potentially. You might feel better about doing it then?

Grin
Noodlehen · 14/11/2022 07:03

Let’s hope they don’t fail the exam now!

babyyodaxmas · 14/11/2022 07:00

I think he sounds like he could get to Oxbridge DS was similar and has just gone this last October. But he did it from a SS state school.

Tubs11 · 14/11/2022 07:00

If he's too clever for state school could he teach at said school. Shortage of teachers and all that? YABVU to think he is too clever for state school

4onway · 14/11/2022 06:58

Also the last year a level results were published our schools were the highest for both state and private schools in the county. This from a non selective sixth form that doesn’t only let those with super high grades in

chwaer · 14/11/2022 06:58

OP, if you want your DS to have a chance if getting in, you have to do the form, it's as simple as that.

You might well be right, it's unreasonable for them to ask for so much info before your Ds has passed the test.

But it's their money, their rules can be as unreasonable as they like.

Just do the form.

If he doesn't get in, do you have a backup plan? His school obviously aren't meeting his needs. Are there any better schools anywhere near you? Could you move?

Dogsitter1 · 14/11/2022 06:57

OP- maybe they look at both results in exams and finances at the same time, taking both into consideration when making offers?
They may also need to know you can afford the remaining fees.

4onway · 14/11/2022 06:57

State school teacher. 50% of gcse students in my subject got grade 7+ in my subject last year. About 20 in year (20%) grade 9s. One girl a few years ago was one of only a handful in the country to get grade 9s across the board. The private schools poach our students for sixth form and give them bursaries as they boost their results! We are none selective comprehensive. No such thing as too smart for state school. You know the teachers go to the same universities and are trained in the same places don’t you? Just different employers.

chwaer · 14/11/2022 06:53

Tigofigo · 13/11/2022 23:50

The teaching may be the "same" but the experience probably is not.

In one private school I know of, gifted children are put into a special class designed to stretch them, with more subjects at more challenging levels, different and additional extra curricular topics. Working at least 1 year ahead in all subjects. At the local state schools, the gifted kids are bored and not stretched.

In another, class sizes as small as 8 sometimes with two teachers at a time meant much more personalised teaching. Also some A level subjects had multiple teachers for different modules to play to their strengths. Native speakers for languages and so on.

Behaviour generally excellent throughout both schools too.

Not true.

I went to private and state school and the education, expectations and opportunities in the private school were much, much better than the state school.

There were other things I preferred about the state school but not worth going into here.

FWIW, my DC go to state school, I'm happy with their schools.

Not all private schools are better than all state schools. But on the whole, they are better resourced and have a very different ethos, which will suit some kids better (and some worse. Look at the entitled shits Eton is creating and how we're suffering as a nation due to it. Only half joking).

LumpOfCoalAndASatsuma · 14/11/2022 06:50

What a stupid thing to say about being too clever for state school.

Did he inherit your DP's brains?

WonderingWanda · 14/11/2022 06:43

They can't offer him a free place until they know if he is eligible for a free place. I assume of you had £15 spare you could get a paid place tomorrow op but instead you are asking a private business to provide a service for free. To do this they need to means test you. If you don't like it don't do it but they don't owe you a place.

For info, children are not 'too clever' for state school. What is it you think the private school will be doing differently?

Pipsquiggle · 14/11/2022 06:29

Hi OP

I am sure you have done your research, but just check that the private school you're looking at is actually academic. Many private schools are more about 'ability to pay' rather than 'ability of the child'

My local private school is academically very, very average (lower grades than local state schools) but is strong in sports.

Bursary applications do have to be thoroughly checked - many top boarding schools have bursary support for household incomes up to £100k - this was a few years ago so could have gone up.

Jaybird43 · 14/11/2022 06:28

Don’t forget that private school trips abroad may be a heck of a lot more than state school trips. My niece is in a very well known private school and the trips are very expensive. Also don’t forget uniform costs and other ad hoc fees that may be incurred. Personally, if you can’t afford it (without putting your family in jeopardy with being unable to afford bills / the basics) then I wouldn’t do it. What about hiring a private tutor and trying to get him into a grammar school?

RosesAndHellebores · 14/11/2022 06:25

Then pay in full for something you can afford.

2greenroses · 14/11/2022 06:16

MxGrinch · 14/11/2022 01:38

Where I did say he doesn’t engage or ask for more things to do? I’ve already said he did GCSE papers at home, got grade 9s on them and took them in to show his teachers.

He built his own gaming PC from scratch a few weeks ago, in two hours, totally on his own. DS1 who is away at Uni was going to come home to help him but DS3 couldn’t wait. He told me what bits to order and just got me to hold some wires. Even DS1 was shocked that he did it and it worked perfectly as he needed his mates to help him build his and he was about 18.

He’s also taught himself about nuclear fusion/fission at age 9/10. genetics, and loads of other science stuff and writes a lot of code where stuff pops up, animation etc for fun. Recently diagnosed Type 1 diabetic as well and took over management from the start. Doesn’t want me fussing! Took it in his stride and is very matter of fact about it. One of the other reasons I’d like to get him in a private school is for the pastoral care.

Done the form now!

I sincerely wish your son luck. He certainly sounds bright, but not particularly noteworthily so. I would expect a couple of kids in every year 9 class to be able to do this, at least. Not trying to burst your bubble, just want you to be a bit more realistic. Most year 9s can get grade 8/9 in any favourite subject at GCSE, which is why universities and employers ignore any GCSE taken at this age - the real test is can they do it when taking 10-12 GCSEs in one sitting, including the subjects they have less of an affinity with. This is why students are only assessed on the GCSEs they take in year 11. If your child started taking GCSEs now, they would most likely be disregarded for his university application anyway. Likewise, the ambition to Oxbridge is a bit of a worry, as you have mentioned the institution, rather than the subject. Oxbridge has a good reputation for some subjects, such as English, and a very poor reputation for others, so I worry about how realistic this "ambition" is, as it isn't necessarily "ambitious". If he is happy in the school, but not learning, ( and I find that difficult to believe tbh) then address that. If he has to take the GCSE paper in to show the teacher his grades, he is clearly not getting the same grades in the classroom - and this is typical - kids do score a grade or two higher at home than they do in class, right from reception upwards.

Well, lets hope he gets this place, and the scholarship and the bursary, and goes on to be happy, or stays where he is and is happy, and either way does well in education and is happy as an adult too 💐

babyyodaxmas · 14/11/2022 06:10

www.theaccessproject.org.uk/schools

Like this