Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want my personal financial affairs to be pored over by randoms?

437 replies

MxGrinch · 13/11/2022 22:33

i am looking into getting DC into a private school as he is way too clever for his state school.

I knew of one in the next county and discovered they had academic scholarships for Yr9 entry. Had to register with them (non returnable £100 fee! we are a low income family) and arrange for DC to take the entrance test and scholarship assessments which he’ll be doing next month.

I’m obviously nowhere near as clever as DS as I thought a scholarship meant the fees would be paid! It seems they are only 10-20% paid so we will need to apply for a bursary.

I was sent the application form last week and need to return it tomorrow.

They want so much personal information such as 3 months bank statements, full income and expenditures, children’s income and expenditure. debts, car reg and value etc.it’s really flipping complicated and will take ages.

I know they need to assess whether we can afford the fees but seeing as there is no guarantee DC will even pass the entrance test, this is not information I want to share at this point as it may not go any further.

Theg have said if we don’t return it by tomorrow DC may not get a bursary at all.

AIBU to not want to give loads of private info until DS is actually offered a place?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
RoseAdagio · 16/11/2022 15:41

PicaNewName · 16/11/2022 13:37

@RoseAdagio In year 8, he probably knows how to use the internet pretty well.

I hope you find the right education for your son, OP!

I don't doubt that but there aren't enough hours in the day to teach himself the amount of stuff he would need to learn outside of school hours in order to be getting grade 9s without having covered any of the syllabus at school yet!

PicaNewName · 16/11/2022 13:37

@RoseAdagio In year 8, he probably knows how to use the internet pretty well.

I hope you find the right education for your son, OP!

JudgeJ · 16/11/2022 13:29

PurpleButterflyWings · 13/11/2022 22:37

I am looking into getting DC into a private school as he is way too clever for his state school.

You lost me at THAT sentence there. As you were. Nothing to see here.

If he is so very clever then maybe he can fill the forms in for the OP!

So many people fiddle applications for financial support, my brother got thousands of pounds of bonuses paid in cash so he paid ne school fees, school are registered as charities, rightly or wrongly, and have to account strictly for their funds.

RoseAdagio · 16/11/2022 12:46

FYI for anyone genuinely in the position OP claims her son is in - very high ability state school pupil with Oxbridge ambitions - I would think twice about private school right now, especially super selective ones where ALL the pupils will get very strong GCSE results. They now use an assessment tool that adjusts for the school your child went to, in order to try to level the playing field for disadvantaged pupils. They won't just look at the fact your child has a mix of grades 7-9 at GCSE, they will look at what percentile they fall in for GCSE results for their school. Bad news if you are at a highly selective private or state school (Tiffin etc) where getting 8s and 9s across the board is par for the course, rather than exceptional!

Of course if you accept that Oxbridge isn't the be all and end all of exceptional university education in this country, ignore this completely and go wherever you think your kids will do best. Plenty of other excellent universities in this country....

RoseAdagio · 16/11/2022 12:40

SlippingIntoTheTwilightZone · 15/11/2022 17:58

Sorry but I am absolutely calling bullshit on this one. Your child won't even have been taught the syllabus yet…

You sound like the school headmaster who insisted that my gifted nephew (age 4) wasn't reading even after he demonstrated that skill to the headmaster using a book chosen at random from the school library. "He can't possibly be reading. He's not old enough!". My brother said, "Well if that's not reading what the hell do do you want to call what he's doing?" Nephew went to a different school and graduated from university last year, aged 20.

Well no, not really, because a 4 year old very likely will have had access to normal, age appropriate books and thus may well have learned to read, whereas a year 8 pupil won't have had access to an entire GCSE syllabus-worth of material to teach themselves up to grade 9 standard already. The amount of material required for a 4 year old to learn to read vs a 12/13 year old to already be up to the highest grade ability of a GCSE syllabus he hasn't yet been taught isn't really comparable.

Lifelessordinary1 · 16/11/2022 09:00

Anyone who needs to claim benefits has to do this - no one likes it - but you have to do it if you want to benefit.

LulooLemon · 16/11/2022 08:34

Good luck to your son OP. Hope he gets in.

SlippingIntoTheTwilightZone · 16/11/2022 00:09

FarFromTheStart · 15/11/2022 18:01

From Oxford, with a first in Physics and Philosophy of course?

It’d be horribly disappointing if your nephew who you feel is so gifted ended up doing Economics at Bournemouth.

And yet it is OP who is being accused of snobbery on this thread!

SlippingIntoTheTwilightZone · 16/11/2022 00:00

NumberTheory · 15/11/2022 23:28

Compare and contrasts OP’s actual words ”his state school” with your straw man ”state schools en mass”.

Then, if you have decency, you could apologize to her.

I take it Lime Twists is not an English teacher! 😆

NumberTheory · 15/11/2022 23:28

LimeTwists · 15/11/2022 22:38

i am looking into getting DC into a private school as he is way too clever for his state school.

As a teacher with many years of experience in both elite private and inner-city state schools, the idea that a child can be too clever for a state school is the most unreasonable part of your post. Absolute snobbery.

Too clever for an Ofsted-graded ‘inadequate’ school which doesn’t stretch or challenge its pupils, sure. But state schools en masse? Wow. Do you actually mean that?

Compare and contrasts OP’s actual words ”his state school” with your straw man ”state schools en mass”.

Then, if you have decency, you could apologize to her.

LimeTwists · 15/11/2022 22:38

i am looking into getting DC into a private school as he is way too clever for his state school.

As a teacher with many years of experience in both elite private and inner-city state schools, the idea that a child can be too clever for a state school is the most unreasonable part of your post. Absolute snobbery.

Too clever for an Ofsted-graded ‘inadequate’ school which doesn’t stretch or challenge its pupils, sure. But state schools en masse? Wow. Do you actually mean that?

pollyglot · 15/11/2022 21:11

FarFromTheStart · Today 18:45
PhotoDad · Today 18:32
Small world (and tiny course; I probably had the same lecturers as your DH unless we're very different ages). Yes, I don't think my drive to study that subject came from my school? But it might have done. Now I'm a teacher; success or failure? But at least I do get to teach both subjects.
Show quote history
If you take pleasure from it, then you are definitely a success. Even if you don’t you’ll have made one hell of a difference to many lives.
It’s a shame that so few with “elite” degrees nowadays make their way into teaching.

How I agree with you! One superb teacher can make such a difference to so many, and it has a cascade effect through the generations. I was fortunate to have the Queen of Teachers back in the 60s - a woman from a pit village who achieved a place in a top university in the 40s. Her erudition, her encyclopaedic knowledge of Shakespeare, her ability to identify "something" in every child inspired so many - in her wake, she has left cabinet ministers, barristers, surgeons, educated mothers, but most of all, teachers who took on her mantle - now into the 3rd generation. What a legacy to leave of one's life.

FarFromTheStart · 15/11/2022 18:45

PhotoDad · 15/11/2022 18:32

Small world (and tiny course; I probably had the same lecturers as your DH unless we're very different ages). Yes, I don't think my drive to study that subject came from my school? But it might have done. Now I'm a teacher; success or failure? But at least I do get to teach both subjects.

If you take pleasure from it, then you are definitely a success. Even if you don’t you’ll have made one hell of a difference to many lives.

It’s a shame that so few with “elite” degrees nowadays make their way into teaching.

PhotoDad · 15/11/2022 18:32

FarFromTheStart · 15/11/2022 18:28

DH attended a state comp in an ex-pit village, and he too did P&P, at Oxford, which is why I picked it.

He went on to theoretical and then particle physics, helped find the Higgs and then became a trader in the city.

So, possibly you’d have done the same at the state school. Hard to say of course.

Small world (and tiny course; I probably had the same lecturers as your DH unless we're very different ages). Yes, I don't think my drive to study that subject came from my school? But it might have done. Now I'm a teacher; success or failure? But at least I do get to teach both subjects.

FarFromTheStart · 15/11/2022 18:28

PhotoDad · 15/11/2022 18:22

Nothing to add here, but that was my course, so I'm rather pleased to see it being held up as a pinnacle of academic achievement! Didn't get a First, though.

I was on a 100% scholarship to an independent school. First from either side of my family to go to either private school or university. I've picked up a few more degrees since then. Genuinely no idea how my life would have turned out at the local state school; probably just as well?

DH attended a state comp in an ex-pit village, and he too did P&P, at Oxford, which is why I picked it.

He went on to theoretical and then particle physics, helped find the Higgs and then became a trader in the city.

So, possibly you’d have done the same at the state school. Hard to say of course.

PhotoDad · 15/11/2022 18:22

FarFromTheStart · 15/11/2022 18:01

From Oxford, with a first in Physics and Philosophy of course?

It’d be horribly disappointing if your nephew who you feel is so gifted ended up doing Economics at Bournemouth.

Nothing to add here, but that was my course, so I'm rather pleased to see it being held up as a pinnacle of academic achievement! Didn't get a First, though.

I was on a 100% scholarship to an independent school. First from either side of my family to go to either private school or university. I've picked up a few more degrees since then. Genuinely no idea how my life would have turned out at the local state school; probably just as well?

FarFromTheStart · 15/11/2022 18:01

SlippingIntoTheTwilightZone · 15/11/2022 17:58

Sorry but I am absolutely calling bullshit on this one. Your child won't even have been taught the syllabus yet…

You sound like the school headmaster who insisted that my gifted nephew (age 4) wasn't reading even after he demonstrated that skill to the headmaster using a book chosen at random from the school library. "He can't possibly be reading. He's not old enough!". My brother said, "Well if that's not reading what the hell do do you want to call what he's doing?" Nephew went to a different school and graduated from university last year, aged 20.

From Oxford, with a first in Physics and Philosophy of course?

It’d be horribly disappointing if your nephew who you feel is so gifted ended up doing Economics at Bournemouth.

SlippingIntoTheTwilightZone · 15/11/2022 17:58

Sorry but I am absolutely calling bullshit on this one. Your child won't even have been taught the syllabus yet…

You sound like the school headmaster who insisted that my gifted nephew (age 4) wasn't reading even after he demonstrated that skill to the headmaster using a book chosen at random from the school library. "He can't possibly be reading. He's not old enough!". My brother said, "Well if that's not reading what the hell do do you want to call what he's doing?" Nephew went to a different school and graduated from university last year, aged 20.

Pearls1234 · 15/11/2022 17:05

:biscuit:

chakra1 · 15/11/2022 11:05

I agree that the GCSE curriculum doesn't start until Year 10 (possibly Year 9) and it's very specific. So even if a very gifted child has niche interests, they still would still need to cover the curriculum.

OP, the school probably want to be sure about whether you qualify for a part / full bursary before they make any decisions. This is because, in borderline cases, they may still offer a fee-paying place. Or perhaps they are weighing up whether to offer 10% or 100% of the fees? This is very common.

Also, a word of caution regarding your expectations of an independent school. Two of mine are in some of the most selective independents in the U.K. - but they are still doing the same GCSEs to everyone else! Certainly nobody is asking to do GCSEs in Year 8. No school is going to let him jump the curriculum.

Also, if it's a very selective independent, it's probably best to not go in talking about Oxbridge in Year 8. Be very careful about being 'that parent' with 'that child' going in. Some of the "prodigy types" (or parent-declared prodigy-types) in Year 7 / 8 do not continue on this trajectory, while others come into their own higher up the school. It may even be that the best degree course for him is not offered at Cambridge. Nothing wrong with aspirations and good luck to him because he sounds like a bright boy. But just encourage him not to be too fixated. Good luck to him in the entrance exams.

RoseAdagio · 15/11/2022 10:05

MxGrinch · 13/11/2022 23:04

Not in DSs school @2greenroses. He gets top marks for everything with ease. Has taken in the various GCSE papers he’s sat at home for fun to show his teachers, asked himself for higher level work and nothing has been done. Not a boast just fact. He’s also very conscientious, well behaved and mannered.

I would expect a student awarded an academic scholarship in a private school to be worked hard and a lot expected of them. That is what DS needs. He loves learning.

Sorry but I am absolutely calling bullshit on this one.

Your child won't even have been taught the syllabus yet for GCSE material. It starts at year 9 or year 10 usually. There's no way he can already be getting top marks in material he has not yet been taught, and there is no way even the brightest year 8 kid in the country is going to have already taught themselves trigonometry, quadratic equations, atomic structure, bonding, organic chemistry etc (to pick just a few areas at random) and to have self taught this to such an extent that they are already getting 9s....the highest mark available for even the brightest year 11 students in the country.

And frankly, if your year 8 son is already self teaching to that level, then they are such a child prodigy that a) you don't need to worry which school they go to and b) you don't need to worry about whether they will pass the entry exams for the private school and thus the entire concept of this thread (why fill in long forms full of personal information if there is a risk he won't get in anyway?!) is otiose.

No way is thus correct. OP is either a fantasist or a journalist fishing for a Mumsnet troll story.

RosesAndHellebores · 15/11/2022 09:02

The uniform and trips argument is repetitively irrelevant. As I said up thread when we had both children at independents the total fees were £37k from net (taxed) income in 2013. The facts that the initial uniform outlay was £500 and the sports tours were £2,500 were neither here nor there. A drop in the ocean compared to the overall outlay.

If people can't afford the uniform and the odd trip, they can't afford the fees. Those things need to be regarded as part of the overall outlay. The perce take annual increases were often far higher than a new blazer or a trip to Bologna.

HydrangeaRose · 15/11/2022 08:15

Thanks Lemonella .
Both my children are in a private school and have been for the last 10 /8 years . I am speaking from personal experience . Next year one child is going to Indonesia at £4.5 k and same child has now been asked to go to America in the same year .
The uniform is more expensive in my experience , that’s all I was sharing .

tadaaaa · 15/11/2022 08:08

I think it's just that there's a lot of variation between schools. Some have great second hand shops (that not just the poorer families use). Some bursaries include uniform. Some have lots of clubs etc as extras, others have them all included. Yes, there are expensive trips, but then our local state secondaries also have geography trips to Iceland, cricket tours to Barbados etc. Perhaps fewer kids go on them, but there are often still plenty who don't go on many trips at private schools. By all means the OP should do her homework, on the particular school, but it's certainly not a given that the extras make private school unaffordable, as some posters suggest.

sheepdogdelight · 15/11/2022 07:50

Lemonella · 14/11/2022 22:21

This is the regular tripe trotted out by the anti-private school mob. Not all kids in private schools are loaded, a lot use the second hand uniform stores in the schools, and trips are very much not compulsory. Loads of kids don’t go on the trips. Also, bursaries can include uniforms. You don’t have to spend huge additional sums, it’s a myth perpetuated on here by the clueless.

Why is pointing out that private school uniform is (generally) more expensive than state school uniform (some state school uniform is eye watering as well) and that private schools tend to have more expensive trips (a reason some people like them!) anti-private school? It's simply advising the OP to check what the fees/bursary include. Most of the people posting this advice actually have children in private schools or know people who do. (And the downside of second hand uniform shops is that they may not have anything in your child's size and then you are forced to buy full price.

SIL (private school children) and myself (state school children) ended up in a conversation about uniform costs once. Even with her using the 2nd hand shop as much as she could, her uniform cost were significantly (think double or more) than mine.

Swipe left for the next trending thread