Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think some people come on Mumsnet solely to be the utter bitches they can't get away with being in real life.

287 replies

SynchOrSwim · 13/11/2022 18:44

I just see so many posts where people seem to do everything they can to make others feel as small and stupid as possible.

I know there will be disagreement and debate on here but some people are so unnecessarily nasty they're like panto villains!

OP posts:
WinkOnlyCellophane · 13/11/2022 22:33

ilovesooty · 13/11/2022 19:01

I take your point. I reacted to the irritation of these threads appearing several times a week but I could have made my point differently.

How lovely to see this response. Hurrah for civility all around.

(not intended to be patronising)

OneFrenchEgg · 13/11/2022 22:31

My experience of MN would be so much better if I could hide or block posters. When I've hidden a thread because it's got unpleasant and still get the bloody @ so people can tell me how wrong I am - it's horrible. I don't remove the function because sometimes people are relying kindly on other threads with advice about uni or something.
There's several posters that I see and just exit a thread because of their style.

nomoreflyingducks · 13/11/2022 22:29

I think there are a fair few TRAs and probably some seriously pissed off men who walk the boards. Also the tone of a thread is often set by the first couple of replies to the OP. If these are unpleasant then whoosh the thread becomes a pile on. I've been on here for many years, but I've noticed over the last year the relationships board has become really quite unpleasant (AIBU has always been akin to circus maximus!) but relationships was generally a safe place.
I have a very varied work life, and a do some volunteer work with vulnerable young people, the thread which really got to me was the poster asking if it was weird that a stranger, on the bus, asked her for coffee. People gave the Op a right bashing and told her she was a bitch for being unfriendly etc so unnecessarily unpleasant, but what posters don't realise is the people I work with, would read this and think it would be okay to go for coffee with a stranger because that's what lots of people do to make friends. It puts my client group at a greater risk because they don't have the skills needed to determine if that would be 'safe' or 'risk', when they are already struggling to navigate the complexities of social interaction.

PituitaryPippa · 13/11/2022 22:26

Back in the day the phrase "Don't Feed the Troll" was used frequently on forums as the people who deliberately posted shitty or deliberately provocative responses were classed as trolls. Unfortunately the definition seems to have adapted to mean someone who posts a fake thread.

The problem is with these trolls is that they do it for attention-to get a rise out of people. They will be delighted when they engage someone or even better, several people, in an argument!

I have posted in AIBU and started a couple of threads (under another username) and had the inevitable trolls responding and I just ignore and refuse to engage. I really wish everyone would do the same. If they don't get the attention they crave hopefully they'll crawl back under the stones they came from!

TiptoeThroughTheToadstools · 13/11/2022 22:26

YANBU some of the vitriol that comes out is incredible. It puts me off posting about things tbh, and I only comment on things every so often because the vile things that people say here.

ilovesooty · 13/11/2022 22:25

Thedogscollar · 13/11/2022 22:20

@ilovesooty
Thankyou I really appreciate that. I think I just remembered how I felt a few years ago when I first posted on here having big problems with my then teenage son. I was literally sobbing with some of the replies they were just so cruel and unnecessary.
It was another poster who DM'd me she was a police officer who helped me through that time and I will never forget her kindness as it really helped me cope. That is why I have stayed on MN as I find it informative, funny and at times a great source of comfort in the advice given.

I'd hate to be the cause of someone feeling like that. I really am sorry - and sorry you went through that.

Wiccan · 13/11/2022 22:23

The 99% sure getting engaged thread was mentioned thought I take a quick scan of it . OMG it is brutal . The OP is deleting her account .Some terrible comments !

PurpleBananaSmoothie · 13/11/2022 22:23

I think most people have probably been guilty of saying a twatish comment at some time. The reasons for this are:

  • this poster has asked the same things in a lot of different posts and they are looking for a different answer. When advice is given in good faith and the poster doesn’t listen, it’s infuriating.
  • tone doesn’t convey in a post
  • some people would say these things in person but the tone would be decipherable or you would know that person is usually quite blunt
  • people carry grievances from one post to another post - as seen on here
  • some people just enjoy being mean
  • I think the big thing is that MN is an echo chamber. Whatever the prevailing view can generate a hive mind and it can lead to a chorus of nasty post because they all feel they are within the realms of reasonableness because it is the view of the site. In reality, the view of the site isn’t something that is shared by most in real life E.g. toilet brushes

Sometimes I find MN too much and I need to leave for a while. I try to stay around because if I’m in a good space, I will comment on threads where OP is being dragged over the coals for something unfairly or having horrible comments made about them.

I think sometimes it’s best to just leave things. I’ve had a number of posters respond to me with shitty comments and sometimes you feel the need to defend yourself but sometimes you just need to walk away. In real life, if someone was outright aggressive to you for some grievance only they can work out, you would distance yourself from them, you wouldn’t respond to them or if you had to you would say whatever you needed to leave there without it getting violent.

Thedogscollar · 13/11/2022 22:20

@ilovesooty
Thankyou I really appreciate that. I think I just remembered how I felt a few years ago when I first posted on here having big problems with my then teenage son. I was literally sobbing with some of the replies they were just so cruel and unnecessary.
It was another poster who DM'd me she was a police officer who helped me through that time and I will never forget her kindness as it really helped me cope. That is why I have stayed on MN as I find it informative, funny and at times a great source of comfort in the advice given.

JuliaGooliaaa · 13/11/2022 22:11

That’s lovely @lightaa that will help to shift the balance the right way

ilovesooty · 13/11/2022 22:02

Thedogscollar · 13/11/2022 21:52

@Roussette and @ilovesooty
Apologies if I have offended anyone as this thread is about the opposite of this.
I was perhaps upset at receiving an 🙄yesterday in reply to my post.

I apologise for that. It was snarky.

lightaa · 13/11/2022 21:59

This was the reason I have deleted mumsnet twice already. I have just rejoined for a third time.

People are so mean and I now go out my way to try and make people feel good.

I think if enough of us are the opposites of trolls it will bring people up.

Mumtobabyhavoc · 13/11/2022 21:58

EarringsandLipstick · 13/11/2022 21:27

4 pages of posts atm? Shocking some aren't studying it before posting

It wasn't 4 pages at the start of the repeated posts targeting Sooty

And yeah, if people are going to comment negatively, it's worth a quick scroll to the end to see if the thread's moved on.

People don't though... it's the internet. 🤷‍♀️
i do get your point, though. 😊

Squiblet · 13/11/2022 21:54

I'm not keen on that idea - it's too much of a target for trolls and sock puppets and also risks turning Mumsnet into a popularity contest. You can imagine, e.g. MRA trolls downvoting FWR posts to oblivion

True, that would be super frustrating. I guess it only works when you have a large enough population of readers, so that any special interest group gets drowned out in the chorus. Maybe MN is not big enough for this.

Shame, as it would be so satisfying to downvote the spiteful posters, without having to engage with them directly...

Thedogscollar · 13/11/2022 21:52

@Roussette and @ilovesooty
Apologies if I have offended anyone as this thread is about the opposite of this.
I was perhaps upset at receiving an 🙄yesterday in reply to my post.

LittlePearl · 13/11/2022 21:49

I completely agree OP, in fact I was thinking the same earlier today. I was doing some research of a topic the other day that took me to a number of old threads and the tone seemed much less vitriolic and more friendly.

I find some of the threads really depressing these days, just because the unpleasantness is quite disturbing. I know people like to say, well get off the site if you don't like it, but I enjoy being a mumsnetter and I don't want to leave. I just want posters to be a bit more civil to one another.

I'm not an avid 'Be Kind'-er, and I love a robust debate but there are ways to make your argument without sarcasm and insults. And to the posters who like to say 'Why are you bothered what a bunch of randoms say? It's not real life', if it's possible to offer genuine care, compassion and support online it's equally possible to be hurtful, rude and obnoxious. Criticising people who are offended by your bad behaviour heaps insult on top of insult.

ilovesooty · 13/11/2022 21:44

Thanks @Roussette .

Cuppasoupmonster · 13/11/2022 21:42

I get the feeling 99% of the posters aren’t anywhere near as ‘straight talking’/LTB in real life as they are on here.

Roussette · 13/11/2022 21:39

Thedogscollar · 13/11/2022 21:36

Hi sooty
Nice to hear that this thread has made you reflect on the tone of your reply.

Your post sums up the title of this thread.

Sooty immediately and politely corrected her post, yet people are still doing what I call a pile on.

I wonder if you would ever correct anything you posted? Doubtful.

Thedogscollar · 13/11/2022 21:36

ilovesooty · 13/11/2022 21:12

Since you mean me you might as well say so.

I'm not "trying to backtrack". I acknowledged that my tone in my first post could have been different when I was politely challenged: I felt the poster who challenged me had made a fair point.

Hi sooty
Nice to hear that this thread has made you reflect on the tone of your reply.

mrsg2019 · 13/11/2022 21:35

Bahaha op - so true!! Some of the things people put on here Shock I always think to myself - is this how people really think/behave?!

AnApparitionQuipped · 13/11/2022 21:32

Squiblet · 13/11/2022 21:16

What I wish they had here is "upvote" and "downvote" arrows like they do on Reddit.

You can like or dislike each post. The most-liked ones rise to the top and the least-liked ones sink or almost disappear.

Generally, the wisdom of crowds ensures that good advice gets upvoted (and the wittiest posts!) and the mean, wrong or rude ones get downvoted to oblivion.

I'm not keen on that idea - it's too much of a target for trolls and sock puppets and also risks turning Mumsnet into a popularity contest. You can imagine, e.g. MRA trolls downvoting FWR posts to oblivion.

EarringsandLipstick · 13/11/2022 21:27

4 pages of posts atm? Shocking some aren't studying it before posting

It wasn't 4 pages at the start of the repeated posts targeting Sooty

And yeah, if people are going to comment negatively, it's worth a quick scroll to the end to see if the thread's moved on.

Ramble0n · 13/11/2022 21:27

I think a lot of the really nasty posters that seem to have appeared recently are just trolling the site.Much like the Bison/M & S weirdo.

Redwineandroses · 13/11/2022 21:20

DorritLittle · 13/11/2022 21:06

I remember this sort of thing too. I didn't really post for years.

Agree with the OP though.

I think with the norm of name changing, people are more anonymous nowadays on here (because they want to be) and you don't get cliques happening. It was quite tedious at times, especially as some would wittle on about being an original member etc as though they had some sort of superior status because of this.

Some of them were so rude and said things where if someone outside of the cliques had said it, they'd get a flaming. They'd also ignore other posters on some threads and talk to eachother. I took a long break, as in some years away because it was so tedious, then when I came back it had changed.