Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think some people come on Mumsnet solely to be the utter bitches they can't get away with being in real life.

287 replies

SynchOrSwim · 13/11/2022 18:44

I just see so many posts where people seem to do everything they can to make others feel as small and stupid as possible.

I know there will be disagreement and debate on here but some people are so unnecessarily nasty they're like panto villains!

OP posts:
Headabovetheparakeet · 14/11/2022 14:44

I agree. There's a huge amount of nastiness from some posters.

I also find the poster who responds to loads of threads with just 'Confused' very annoying. Normally they're in the first handful of replies. It's like they constantly refresh the active threads page looking for opportunities to do it.

samyeagar · 14/11/2022 14:41

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn at the user's request.

And the grownups keep taking the bait over and over and over and over

OoooohMatron · 14/11/2022 14:37

Apologies, just seen your update.

ilovesooty · 14/11/2022 14:35

OoooohMatron · 14/11/2022 14:28

I think this is the sort of comment OP meant. Condescending and superior.

Could I ask you if you've read my subsequent posts? I think you might have seen that comment and responded without looking at how the thread developed.

OoooohMatron · 14/11/2022 14:28

ilovesooty · 13/11/2022 18:49

So I take it you've challenged such posters on the relevant threads and reported personal attacks?

I think this is the sort of comment OP meant. Condescending and superior.

PoundShopPrincess · 14/11/2022 14:18

Quite a few of the examples that are being given are actually posters trying to protect others from trolls. If there are suddenly a spate of threads on a subject that is emotive or causes arguments then yy posters will point it out. It's flagging to others that it may be an OP being deliberately contentious or is actually a TAAT because the OP didn't like the replies the first time round. There's also a trend from MRAs/TRAs to deliberately start nasty threads and post abusive comments so they can screenshot them and pretend they show what MN is like.
I don't think MN is for everyone. That's ok.
I do wonder how often posters who complain about MN go on Twitter, for example, and tweet to all the men posting death and rape threats, and tell them off for being abusive. Or go on Tattle, and start a thread saying stop being so mean to women whose only crime is using the internet to earn an income. Or go on the army forum and call posters keyboard warriors. Or pistonheads and call for kindness.
There are many more helpful posters on here than there are abusive ones. Even now with the attacks from MRAs, TRAs and incels - women being helpful are still in the majority. It's also a little hilarious that the MRAs/TRAs/incels think they can't be spotted.

GoldenCupidon · 14/11/2022 12:35

encantorerun · 14/11/2022 12:02

Slightly off topic but similar - something that does grate on me is that someone starts a thread and they get some shitty responses but then they are people who have really considered the issue. I often go away and make a coffee and really think about something and I might spend ages drafting what I hope is a thoughtful reply.

But then the OP just gets caught in the web of arguing with the vipers who probably took less than 3 seconds to write 'I couldn't get upset by this'. Rather than focusing on the people who wrote several paragraphs trying to empathise, but also provides solutions, alternative ways of thinking and provided a balanced view.

Sometimes it is a case of 'cut off the air supply to the toxic people' - stop giving them air time and they'll get bored and move on.

that is a really good point

encantorerun · 14/11/2022 12:02

Slightly off topic but similar - something that does grate on me is that someone starts a thread and they get some shitty responses but then they are people who have really considered the issue. I often go away and make a coffee and really think about something and I might spend ages drafting what I hope is a thoughtful reply.

But then the OP just gets caught in the web of arguing with the vipers who probably took less than 3 seconds to write 'I couldn't get upset by this'. Rather than focusing on the people who wrote several paragraphs trying to empathise, but also provides solutions, alternative ways of thinking and provided a balanced view.

Sometimes it is a case of 'cut off the air supply to the toxic people' - stop giving them air time and they'll get bored and move on.

ImustLearn2Cook · 14/11/2022 11:59

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 14/11/2022 11:26

I agree completely. And I also suspect that a great many of the nastier responses, particularly when it comes to threads about women facing domestic and sexual abuse, are emanating from precisely that direction.

Yes, some people do behave badly. But on the whole, I see the good - and there's a great deal of it - that still exists on this site.

I agree too. Sometimes I get the distinct impression that there are people who are deliberately trying to sabotage the good and the support that Mumsnet provides. Derailing threads, bullying the Op, bullying pp who have been supportive or have given good advice or a helpful perspective, being goady, etc.

GoldenCupidon · 14/11/2022 11:39

I think another underlying thing is that some people spend a LOT more time on here than others. I tend to come and go a bit for example, at times I’ve been here every day for hours, other times not for months or longer. But some very frequent posters can forget that this is a “drop in” for others, and everyone hasn’t seen every thread they’ve seen. I got absolutely roasted for starting a thread in a particular section and was accused of being a troll, a man, some kind of agent etc when I was actually a lapsed user who hadn’t realised I was raising a topic often raised at that time. Tbh I didn’t mind as I could see it from their point of view but I don’t feel comfortable posting there any more in case I inadvertently put my foot in it again.

sooo many of the meaner toned threads follow this pattern I think - “have you posted this before OP?” “This is the 3rd thread about this I’ve read in the last fortnight” etc - well yes lots of people have the same thoughts and problems.

CulturePigeon · 14/11/2022 11:36

Ethelfromnumber73 · Today 11:10
AnApparitionQuipped · Yesterday 18:47
Undoubtedly some posters are the proverbial keyboard warriors. Others fall victim to goading. Some might overreact if a thread touches a particular nerve. Sometimes when you post something, it reads more harshly than you intended.
Absolutely this

Sure - but take time to read back the post and count or 10 or something. Be aware that you don't have tone of voice, intonation or facial expression or body language to soften what may come over in words as rude, harsh, sarcastic or spiteful.

()ff topic a bit, but I remember hearing someone say that the reason social media can be so harmful is the rapidity and ease of communication - as well as the impossibility of calling something back if you have second thoughts. In the past someone wanting to post a poison-pen letter (same types we get on here occasionally) would have to find a pen, paper, stamp, and envelope, write their horrible spite out and then walk to the post box to send it. All this would give time for consideration and second thoughts.

Now - you can hurt someone, wreck their self-esteem or just spoil their day very successfully while sitting on your backside in the back bedroom.)

mamabear715 · 14/11/2022 11:27

I didn't go on the 'engagement' thread because I could guess how it would turn out.. seems like it did..
I DO sometimes add 'xx' because the person looking for advice can't see me.. it's my way of saying I'm with you, I understand, I'm sending virtual hugs..

I've kind of beat myself up this weekend after getting a bit too invested in some threads & trying to help & be gentle & understanding, in the midst of nasty replies.. then the OP never responds & I fear the nasties will come after me.. :-0
Oh well, I'm trying to be the best person I can, but must stand back a little..

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 14/11/2022 11:26

PoundShopPrincess · 14/11/2022 11:19

There are also lots of brilliant posters on here. Intelligent, wise, funny. Experienced professionals who share their field specific knowledge. It is still the best place on the internet for women looking for female-centred support, advice or just a chat.

I think another reason the MRAs hate it is because it proves how often women lift up other women. It illustrates every day how capable women are. And it shines a light on the real issues that matter to women. There are some absolutely amazing women on here who are working hard in RL to make other women's lives better every single day.

I agree completely. And I also suspect that a great many of the nastier responses, particularly when it comes to threads about women facing domestic and sexual abuse, are emanating from precisely that direction.

Yes, some people do behave badly. But on the whole, I see the good - and there's a great deal of it - that still exists on this site.

CulturePigeon · 14/11/2022 11:21

I agree.

They always defend their position by claiming to be robust, tell it like it is etc etc.

There is a difference between a discussion/disagreeing with a poster and a slanging match. Yes, bitchery is not too strong a word. I imagine some bitter, miserable, angry, frustrated person sitting there like a trap-door spider, just waiting for an unsuspecting OP to come along and - wham - they pounce with usually one of the following pearls of wisdom:

  • Why do you care?
  • You sound vile/snobbish
  • It's none of your business

Very 'primary school playground'.

I think they must be really inarticulate and terrible at English comprehension. An OP raises a point for discussion and immediately gets asked why they care when they've usually explained in their OP why they care.

PoundShopPrincess · 14/11/2022 11:19

There are also lots of brilliant posters on here. Intelligent, wise, funny. Experienced professionals who share their field specific knowledge. It is still the best place on the internet for women looking for female-centred support, advice or just a chat.

I think another reason the MRAs hate it is because it proves how often women lift up other women. It illustrates every day how capable women are. And it shines a light on the real issues that matter to women. There are some absolutely amazing women on here who are working hard in RL to make other women's lives better every single day.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 14/11/2022 11:17

WinterWitchy · 13/11/2022 19:06

There was a thread earlier where the OP was saying she may be getting engaged at Christmas, some of the replies were awful to what was clearly a lighthearted thread.

Some people must live pretty shit lives that they feel the need to come on a forum to try and belittle others, it’s quite sad and pathetic tbh. MN has always been a ‘say it like it is’ forum, however, I do think people just come on to be nasty bitches a lot of time.

I was on that thread. I challenge that behaviour where I see it happening.

But I have to say don't think starting threads referring to other women using misogynistic pejoratives like 'bitches' is doing much to improve the ambience of the site.

Ethelfromnumber73 · 14/11/2022 11:10

AnApparitionQuipped · 13/11/2022 18:47

Undoubtedly some posters are the proverbial keyboard warriors. Others fall victim to goading. Some might overreact if a thread touches a particular nerve. Sometimes when you post something, it reads more harshly than you intended.

Absolutely this

Cuppasoupmonster · 14/11/2022 11:09

I also think a lot of posters use it as a proxy to take out their anger at someone in real life where they feel unable to do so, like ‘other women’ or people whose kids bite other kids etc.

username8888 · 14/11/2022 11:07

Absolutely. Some love to kick someone when they are already feeling anxious and down.

Wheatandchaff · 14/11/2022 09:29

chakra1 · 14/11/2022 07:04

There are a lot of people very jealous about SAHMs on MN, but there is one particular poster who comes in every SAHM thread and they are so utterly inane, it drives everyone else off the thread. I've seen it about ten times now - no point even commenting on those threads I feel like going on and warning people not to get sucked into this poster's game..It is bizarre to watch and you wonder what has happened to this person in real life that they are so bitter and twisted.

Yes! I wonder if we’re thinking about the same person! They have been called out by posters before because every time there is a SAHM thread they go on and make unrelating comments about how they can’t stand SAHP and would never allow it and derail the thread until it’s working parents vs SAHP.

JanetSally · 14/11/2022 09:15

You get difficult/angry/ mentally ill people on every forum unfortunately. The worst and most unkind bullying I ever received was from a bunch of regular posters on gransnet of all places!!

Morestrangethings · 14/11/2022 09:09

Discovereads · 14/11/2022 08:38

Don’t disagree, this is a parenting site so there will be angry women and angry men on here. But all I ask is please don’t try and guess sex & accuse a poster of being a man on a thread. I’ve been accused of being a man on MN at least a few dozen times and it’s really upsetting.

No, I’ve not questioned them because, of course, I could be wrong. I’ve learned not to respond because they’ll just come back nastier. I just stay away from them.

Im sorry that’s happened to you.

Nor will I accuse people of being sock puppets just because 2 or 3 people have the same controversial thought. I’ve seen the sock puppet accusation on quite a few occasions.

The third thing I’ve seen is a group gang up on someone -make vague jokes about them and use a lot of the laughing emojis in each post as though amused at their own cleverness. Can’t really explain it, it’s a weird sort of passive aggression.

Other than that mn is pretty cool. Lots of topics for discussion and I read heaps of interesting things. It’s members are also really good value in regards to information sharing.

Wiccan · 14/11/2022 08:44

I am staying well away from anything SAHM from now on , I've never seen anything like it .

Discovereads · 14/11/2022 08:38

Morestrangethings · 14/11/2022 04:24

I agree. I’ve run into a few of those. The nature of their replies indicate they are male.

Don’t disagree, this is a parenting site so there will be angry women and angry men on here. But all I ask is please don’t try and guess sex & accuse a poster of being a man on a thread. I’ve been accused of being a man on MN at least a few dozen times and it’s really upsetting.

chakra1 · 14/11/2022 07:04

There are a lot of people very jealous about SAHMs on MN, but there is one particular poster who comes in every SAHM thread and they are so utterly inane, it drives everyone else off the thread. I've seen it about ten times now - no point even commenting on those threads I feel like going on and warning people not to get sucked into this poster's game..It is bizarre to watch and you wonder what has happened to this person in real life that they are so bitter and twisted.