Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Role of grandparents in a family

186 replies

Stickmansmum · 13/11/2022 16:53

There’s a few dynamics at play here that requires respect and control of entitlement on both sides. BUT (having come from and married into) a loving and supportive family I never understand the double standard of ‘you decided to have kids so need to not be anyway entitled about help with them from their grandparents’ vs what I believe to be a lifelong commitment to help and love and support your children. Your grandchildren are maybe not your responsibility but by default they are. You decided to have children and that doesn’t end when they are 18. I think it’s ok to expect your mum and dad to still be supportive.

Of course as the adult child of someone you also have a responsibility to not make your parents unwell or take so much from them that it damages their quality of life. And to also support them with help and love and consideration.

I guess some people don’t make the jump to grandparent who still feels love and responsibility for their grown up child, and grown up child who doesn’t realise they now have a responsibility to care for their parents.

But my AIBU is, if you have a child I think you are taking on the responsibility of being both a parent and a grandparent (probably) as part of that. And don’t get to just wash your hands of the role any more than you get to wash your hands of being a parent. (Assuming you haven’t raised entitled dickheads for children).

OP posts:
Babdoc · 13/11/2022 17:48

Crikey, I certainly will not be providing full time childcare!
I worked my guts out as a hospital doctor (72 - 120 hours a week, as a junior) and brought my two children up alone while working, without any support from grandparents, as I was widowed when both DDs were still in nappies and the GPs were 240 miles away.
I was permanently exhausted.
Then I retired, and got long Covid, so am now struggling with fatigue in what is finally meant to be “me time”. My DDs are 50 miles away - there is no way I could do a daily 100 mile round trip, let alone find the energy to childmind.

Ted27 · 13/11/2022 17:47

Part of this is about generational and societal change.
I'm 57, when I was growing, where I lived, most people still lived close to family, fewer women worked outside the home or worked part time.
I grew up between my family home and my nan's, she lived two streets away and was a very young grandmother, only in her 40s when I was primary age. My mum always worked, as a dinner lady, washing up in kitchens.
I moved away, adopted my son on my late 40s, my mum in her late 60s. My mum and stepdad are fantastic grandparents- they think my son is the bees knees, he adores them. Bit there is just no way it could ever be the same as when I was growing up.

I think many families are like this now.

JustKeepSlimming · 13/11/2022 17:47

DripDripDripSugar · 13/11/2022 17:30

There are a lot of people who think that being a good grandparent automatically equates to unlimited free childcare. It doesn’t.

Absolutely. My parents are brilliant with our kids, but they were absolutely clear from the start that they would not be providing full-time childcare (nor did we expect them to). They very kindly do 1 day per week, because they like to see the kids, and they'll drop everything to help in an emergency, but there is no way I (or my sister) would expect them to give up their lives for it. Yes, I'd be disappointed if they didn't want to spend time with their grandchildren, but they have no responsibility to be involved if they didn't want to be.

I want my parents to enjoy their retirement, which is precisely what they're doing. They both go to classes in the local community centre and have met lots of friends through those; they go on holiday when they want etc.

I remember taking DC to toddler groups and there'd be grandparents there (usually just Granny; occasionally Granda as well) who looked exhausted because every day they'd go to the son/daughter's house at 7 so they could leave for work, drop the older child to school for 9, entertain the toddler for an hour until toddler group started, sit there and enjoy a bit of a rest for an hour, then home to do lunch, pick the older child up, sort their homework, dinner for both, and then the kids would be collected at 6pm. It was absolutely obvious to anyone else that they were beyond exhausted, and not really capable of properly supervising a rampaging toddler, but their own children seemed to be oblivious.

RedWingBoots · 13/11/2022 17:46

Stickstickstickstickstick · 13/11/2022 17:40

Literally no-one on this thread has said that??? It’s just people complaining about theoretical people and situations.

You've missed the threads that have been on MN in the last few days.

ApplePieFry · 13/11/2022 17:45

SkeetyLola · 13/11/2022 17:40

@ApplePieFry

What if that time is when your 50 and still have your own career? Will you be quitting to be full time child minder?

And why does “if you care about your child you generally want to help them” not extended to being as selfless as you expect grandma to be and giving up your career to help your own child?

Well mum is 52 and was still in her career, but dropped down and moved to support her child. And will be fully retiring if/when my siblings have kids.

And yes I will do the same if mine have families of their own.

Why should I have to give up my career?

Mums had a good run career wise, which was only enabled due to having support from her mother and MIL.

RedWingBoots · 13/11/2022 17:44

SkeetyLola · 13/11/2022 17:31

@thelobsterquadrille

Im betting “the responsibility of being a grandparent” means a shitload of childcare while Mum works. Doesn’t it always?

Weird how for some looking after the kids is grannies job (and it is granny)and she’s expected to be self sacrificing but somehow the same is not expected by Mum of herself.

Yep.

My parents refused to look after their grandchildren because they had younger children at home and were working. However my siblings had child free younger adults around - siblings, cousins and family friends - who were a safer bet in terms of providing regular - as in a few hours a week - or emergency childcare.

Other grandparents I know who refuse to do childcare are simply exhausted. They have later shown they are not well enough to look after a small child for more than an hour randomly. Then there are those who don't agree with how their adult child parents so know to avoid conflict that they should not offer help.

ApplePieFry · 13/11/2022 17:43

Ted27 · 13/11/2022 17:38

@ApplePieFry

So your mum went part time to look after your children and then moved to provide child care - so enabling you to carry on working and/or saving you lot of money

What was the impact of that on her income, her pension, her standard of living and financial security- or was that not considered?

Yes

Just like her mother and MIL did the same to help her, it’s called paying it forward. She had a great career from that support, and is doing the same for me.

My father is due to return to the UK next year so will be picking up the other 2 days a week childcare too which will be great.

Its had very little impact on her financial security, they’ve paid the mortgage off her pension is very good (worked for a bank all her life who paid in 15% since she was 18 and she has paid in a lot since turning 40)

Also, tbh even if it did impact her financially she wouldn’t have cared, she loves her kids enough to put them first, thankfully both she and my father are of the opinion your kids are your kids until you die. Not until they hit 18.

alittlequinnie · 13/11/2022 17:41

I’m a Grandma -2 boys 4 and 8.

I work full time but condense my hours so that I work a 9 day fortnight.

I dedicate that one day a fortnight to helping my DD.

I take boys to and from school on that day change beds, housework and pick boys up.

I also use all my annual leave to spend my time with DD and DGC.

I don’t do it out of a sense of duty or because I feel obliged I do it because I really love them all and want to do it. I can’t think of anything I would rather do in my spare time than spend it with them.

I never felt my daughter was a burden when I had her either or looked to get free time etc – I just fell head over heels in love with her and cherished all the time we had together.

So as not to drip feed DD is disabled so needs the help and I need my wages so can’t give up work to care for her full time but we worked this out.

My DH is also as keen to spend time together with her and boys – we just love being together.

SkeetyLola · 13/11/2022 17:40

ApplePieFry · 13/11/2022 17:37

If you care about your child you generally want to help them.

I will be glad to do the same for my kids when they’re old enough to start their own families.

@ApplePieFry

What if that time is when your 50 and still have your own career? Will you be quitting to be full time child minder?

And why does “if you care about your child you generally want to help them” not extended to being as selfless as you expect grandma to be and giving up your career to help your own child?

Stickstickstickstickstick · 13/11/2022 17:40

SkeetyLola · 13/11/2022 17:34

@DripDripDripSugar

yeah that’s the sense I’m getting from this thread.
Its strange how grandma is expected to give up her free time and retirement (or working time) to look after grandchildren yet the suggestion that her daughter the childrens mother give up some of her career to look after her own children is abhorrent (at least to said mother of children)

Literally no-one on this thread has said that??? It’s just people complaining about theoretical people and situations.

TheMatlockMangle · 13/11/2022 17:40

In reality you're talking about grandmothers. Grandfathers never receive any flack for not providing childcare for their grand children, grandmothers do. Those same grandmothers who are often also expected to care for elderly parents, while their male siblings are far too busy and important. Add to which, most women now work until state pension age. So she has a job, is caring for elderly parents (even her inlaws) and is then expected to provide support and free childcare for grandchildren who she had no say in planning for. All the while coping with the symptoms of menopause.

OP, given your views that GPs are duty bound to grandchildren, do you think grandparents should have a legal right to access to their grandchildren?

PS - I provide regular baby sitting, had my daughter and baby granddaughter living with me for 5 months due to my daughter needing surgery and extensive rehab so I was caring for my daughter and granddaughter 24/7, so any accusations of me being uncaring couldn't be further from the truth.

breadandmillk · 13/11/2022 17:39

My grandchildren are not my responsibility. My adult children are no longer my responsibility either. They are adults, just like me.

My adult children are not responsible for me either because...I am an adult.

An adult is 'a person who is fully grown and developed'. I am so proud of the thoughtful; hardworking and sensible adults my children have become.

We could not love each other more and of course we help each other out if we can. But, there is no sense of entitlement or feeling responsible either way. I don't agree that adults are responsible for other adults.

My children respect my boundaries when it comes to babysitting and being on tap to help out. They want me to enjoy my old age with some respite from carrying the weight of everybody’s needs and expectations.

The deep love we have for each other - and the bond we share - is not dependent on a quid pro quo of how much babysitting I can offer, or what they can do for me.

SkeetyLola · 13/11/2022 17:38

BritWifeInUSA · 13/11/2022 17:05

It depends what you mean by “support them”. If you mean maintain a positive and loving relationship, communicate regularly, show interest in what the grandchildren are doing in terms of sports, music, activities outside of school, etc, spend time together without acting like it’s a duty then you are not being unreasonable.

But on here we see a lot of posters assuming that their parents will provide free childcare for their children and not just on an occasional evening so that they can go to the cinema, but full-time so that they can go back to work. I’ve seen posters on here where you can sense the steam coming from their ears because they are so angry that their parents have said “no” to looking after babies and toddlers for 5 full days a week. I usually hope that the same thing happens to them when they reach their later years and are ready to slow down and their child is a parent themselves and asks them to provide full-time childcare. And I’ve also seen that argument used: ”my mum chose to have children so you must have known she would be a grandmother one day so she chose this”. That’s the unreasonable part.

@BritWifeInUSA

It is weird. Especially as their own mother who they now want to look after grandkids full time probably worked less to look after her own kids.

Its like the idea that Grandma should sacrifice what she wants to do to look after her grandkids is a given to them, yet it never occurs to them to sacrifice their own career for the kids. No, that was grannies job, both for them and their kids.

I doubt the women who think like this will actually keep that morality when they’re grandparents somehow.

Personally I’m always thinking of unempathetic and selfish they are when I see the attitude of “why isn’t my mum looking after my kids 4 days a week”😡

Ted27 · 13/11/2022 17:38

@ApplePieFry

So your mum went part time to look after your children and then moved to provide child care - so enabling you to carry on working and/or saving you lot of money

What was the impact of that on her income, her pension, her standard of living and financial security- or was that not considered?

ApplePieFry · 13/11/2022 17:37

SkeetyLola · 13/11/2022 17:29

@ApplePieFry

Done their time usually doesn’t refer to not seeing or caring about their grandkids but rather being used as daily childcare by their daughter as she goes back to work. Something which some Mums get quite bitter about their mum not providing and try to act as though grandma providing free childcare for working Mums is some kind of old tradition when it’s anything but.

If you care about your child you generally want to help them.

I will be glad to do the same for my kids when they’re old enough to start their own families.

Stickstickstickstickstick · 13/11/2022 17:37

SkeetyLola · 13/11/2022 17:27

Many people here seem to think that being a grandparent (usually grandma) involves providing childcare while Mum works full time and that is talked about as though it’s some old traditional thing of the village raising your child.
No, what is traditional is that granny was around at the same time as Mum who also didn’t work - and was a second pair of hands to help out sometimes.

It’s certainly not normal or healthy to expect your Mum to do lifelong free childcare. And realistically if you want Mum to do free childcare while you work full time then by the time your children have kids you won’t be able to do that - as you will likely still be working.

This generation of women expecting their mothers who may have worked less when young to do childcare so they can work full time will surely be singing a different tune when they are grandparents about what can be “expected” of them.

There’s no need to take swipes at whole swathes of people just because you’re annoyed at a post on mumsnet. Also, the OP doesn’t mention childcare in their post.

I sympathise with the OP. I wish my dad would just take an interest, rather than washing his hands of me like he’s never met me, but there we are. I don’t expect childcare, but just to see him often enough that my dd doesn’t scream every time she sees him because he’s basically a stranger.

SkeetyLola · 13/11/2022 17:34

DripDripDripSugar · 13/11/2022 17:30

There are a lot of people who think that being a good grandparent automatically equates to unlimited free childcare. It doesn’t.

@DripDripDripSugar

yeah that’s the sense I’m getting from this thread.
Its strange how grandma is expected to give up her free time and retirement (or working time) to look after grandchildren yet the suggestion that her daughter the childrens mother give up some of her career to look after her own children is abhorrent (at least to said mother of children)

SkeetyLola · 13/11/2022 17:31

thelobsterquadrille · 13/11/2022 17:19

What does "taking on the responsibility of being grandparent" mean, though?

Full-time childcare?
Regular childcare?
Regular visits and family meals/days out?
Helping out on special occasions or in emergencies only?

What happens if you become a grandparent while still being a parent to underage children?
What about if you're working full-time or have caring responsibilities for elderly parents or other family members?
What if the grandchildren are severely disabled and you're not physically capable of providing help? What if you're disabled or frail yourself?

There are too many different scenarios for their to be one way of doing things.

@thelobsterquadrille

Im betting “the responsibility of being a grandparent” means a shitload of childcare while Mum works. Doesn’t it always?

Weird how for some looking after the kids is grannies job (and it is granny)and she’s expected to be self sacrificing but somehow the same is not expected by Mum of herself.

DripDripDripSugar · 13/11/2022 17:30

There are a lot of people who think that being a good grandparent automatically equates to unlimited free childcare. It doesn’t.

FinnysTail · 13/11/2022 17:30

When I was growing up my GM lived about 4 hours away. We visited about 3 times a year. On very rare occasions me and brother, as teenagers, travelled by train and stayed over for 2 nights. That happened about 4 times. GM came to stay with us on occasion but not often. Maybe once every 4/5 years.

DM and GM chatted on the phone about twice a month. My brother and I don’t feel we missed out by not having our GM around constantly. She was our GM. We had a good relationship with her. It was what it was.

I have my GC twice a week for my DS and DIL to work, and occasionally to sleep over if their parents are going out. I help out with birthday parties and Christmas activities. Sometimes I’m invited to theirs for Sunday dinner. Sometimes they all come to me.

I work two days/evenings a week and have 3 days to myself (my youngest are teenagers so apart from doing dinner and cleaning up, like most mothers they are fairly self sufficient).

We all know where we stand in terms of childcare and spending time with the GC and it works great for us.

Many GP’s still work full time and see their GC when they can - or not if they have no desire to. Every family is different.

There’s no hard and fast rule about how much time a GP must spend with their GC.

SkeetyLola · 13/11/2022 17:29

ApplePieFry · 13/11/2022 17:25

YANBU

im always sad to read the really bitter posts on here from those who’ve ‘done their time’

Im glad this isn’t something I or anyone I know deals with, my parents are very active in their DGCs lives (my dad lives the other side of the world but calls 2-3 times a week for FaceTime, and regularly flies back for their birthdays etc.)

Mum dropped down to part time the week after my first was born so she could support physically and emotionally. She also moved closer to look after them 2-3 days a week

@ApplePieFry

Done their time usually doesn’t refer to not seeing or caring about their grandkids but rather being used as daily childcare by their daughter as she goes back to work. Something which some Mums get quite bitter about their mum not providing and try to act as though grandma providing free childcare for working Mums is some kind of old tradition when it’s anything but.

Goatsanddogs · 13/11/2022 17:29

I am a grandmother and my daughter has a medical problem that means she gets tired easily, forgetful and constant headaches. I look after my GD 4 days a week while DD works, help out evenings and weekends as well. I love my daughter and GD so it is a pleasure.

SkeetyLola · 13/11/2022 17:27

Many people here seem to think that being a grandparent (usually grandma) involves providing childcare while Mum works full time and that is talked about as though it’s some old traditional thing of the village raising your child.
No, what is traditional is that granny was around at the same time as Mum who also didn’t work - and was a second pair of hands to help out sometimes.

It’s certainly not normal or healthy to expect your Mum to do lifelong free childcare. And realistically if you want Mum to do free childcare while you work full time then by the time your children have kids you won’t be able to do that - as you will likely still be working.

This generation of women expecting their mothers who may have worked less when young to do childcare so they can work full time will surely be singing a different tune when they are grandparents about what can be “expected” of them.

ApplePieFry · 13/11/2022 17:25

YANBU

im always sad to read the really bitter posts on here from those who’ve ‘done their time’

Im glad this isn’t something I or anyone I know deals with, my parents are very active in their DGCs lives (my dad lives the other side of the world but calls 2-3 times a week for FaceTime, and regularly flies back for their birthdays etc.)

Mum dropped down to part time the week after my first was born so she could support physically and emotionally. She also moved closer to look after them 2-3 days a week

Onlyforcake · 13/11/2022 17:25

Good grandparents probably were good parents. Unfortunately a very high number of parents never wanted to be/ suck at it/ move on to other interests once the kids leave.

Plus grandparents are often past their prime in terms of full on caring for children. They probably want an hour or two, maybe a meal then everyone to bugger off and leave them in peace. The idea of grandparents taking toddlers to the park or daily childcare fills me with concern. Bored kids act up. My parents generation are hardly about loving understanding, it was all about slaps to keep you 'in line', so I literally wouldn't trust them to be alone with my children.

Swipe left for the next trending thread