Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Role of grandparents in a family

186 replies

Stickmansmum · 13/11/2022 16:53

There’s a few dynamics at play here that requires respect and control of entitlement on both sides. BUT (having come from and married into) a loving and supportive family I never understand the double standard of ‘you decided to have kids so need to not be anyway entitled about help with them from their grandparents’ vs what I believe to be a lifelong commitment to help and love and support your children. Your grandchildren are maybe not your responsibility but by default they are. You decided to have children and that doesn’t end when they are 18. I think it’s ok to expect your mum and dad to still be supportive.

Of course as the adult child of someone you also have a responsibility to not make your parents unwell or take so much from them that it damages their quality of life. And to also support them with help and love and consideration.

I guess some people don’t make the jump to grandparent who still feels love and responsibility for their grown up child, and grown up child who doesn’t realise they now have a responsibility to care for their parents.

But my AIBU is, if you have a child I think you are taking on the responsibility of being both a parent and a grandparent (probably) as part of that. And don’t get to just wash your hands of the role any more than you get to wash your hands of being a parent. (Assuming you haven’t raised entitled dickheads for children).

OP posts:
SkeetyLola · 13/11/2022 18:21

Roomytrouser · 13/11/2022 18:19

My friend used to complain a lot about her DM not helping her. Her DH used to encourage this and together they would talk about how unreasonable she was. We used to go on holiday with friend and her DH but we stopped after a few years because her DH is a complete tool who expected my DH and I (plus my DF) to all the childcare while he arsed around doing “important” work and talking about the work trips he was not in order to be there with us whilst doing fuck all with his own children. If one of my DCs has a partner like that then the support they’ll be getting from me is help with getting their DP to wise up or for them to leave.

By the time I’m retirement age, DC1 will be the age I was when they were born. I’ll have to work full time until then and I’m hoping I have some years of health where I can have a bit of freedom. This thread is making me think that I might need to ask the DCs if they’d like to look after me in old age. That’s what always used it happen, isn’t it?

@Roomytrouser

Oh yeah, the DC’s can “help you out” by working overtime and foregoing those holidays so they can afford to build you that semi attached grannyfl flat with spa bath.
After all you don’t stop being someone’s parent when you turn 70

SkeetyLola · 13/11/2022 18:19

@bigfamilygrowingupfast

Does help of support equate to near full time childcare so that mum can work?
Because that isn’t support, it’s being used by an entitled parent.

Support is babysitting casually without expectations, it’s family dinners and taking the grandkids so the parents can go on short holidays. It’s not facilitating your adult daughters career by taking he children 5 days a week

bigfamilygrowingupfast · 13/11/2022 18:19

Just to add as well, there is of course a line. Some people completely take the piss imho with taking advantage of grandparents! But if I was in a position where I could, I'd like to think I'd support my adult children as much as possible

Roomytrouser · 13/11/2022 18:19

My friend used to complain a lot about her DM not helping her. Her DH used to encourage this and together they would talk about how unreasonable she was. We used to go on holiday with friend and her DH but we stopped after a few years because her DH is a complete tool who expected my DH and I (plus my DF) to all the childcare while he arsed around doing “important” work and talking about the work trips he was not in order to be there with us whilst doing fuck all with his own children. If one of my DCs has a partner like that then the support they’ll be getting from me is help with getting their DP to wise up or for them to leave.

By the time I’m retirement age, DC1 will be the age I was when they were born. I’ll have to work full time until then and I’m hoping I have some years of health where I can have a bit of freedom. This thread is making me think that I might need to ask the DCs if they’d like to look after me in old age. That’s what always used it happen, isn’t it?

SkeetyLola · 13/11/2022 18:17

@ApplePieFry

Actually most people do see it like that. Very few women in their mid 50’s want to stop work to provide full time daily care for grandchildren.

It’s strange that you think it’s the grandmothers job to stop work in her 50’s to do childcare for her daughter full time as though that has ever been a thing. I also highly doubt you will continue the “tradition”

bigfamilygrowingupfast · 13/11/2022 18:16

I completely agree. I don't understand this notion that once your kids get to 18 or marry or whatever that you don't have to help them or support them. There's just no way I could enjoy myself if I knew my kids were struggling, whether they were 9, 29 or 59!

SkeetyLola · 13/11/2022 18:14

ApplePieFry · 13/11/2022 18:06

You seem to really struggle reading this evening

I never expected anything, she wants to support her children the same way she was supported, next year dad will also shoulder a fair amount of the childcare too when he moves back to the UK.

Most want to support their kids, it’s odd you can’t understand that

@ApplePieFry

Most don’t want to “support” their kids by doing full time childcare at all. It’s odd you can’t understand that.

The simple reality is that you had an expectation that grandparents would “help” by doing childcare and that was fine that your mother lost her career because “she’d had a good run career wise anyway”

Yours is the odd attitude, it’s entirely strange that you think that grandparents helping and being kind is full time childcare which they sacrifice their careers for - and yet you are puzzled at the suggestion you sacrifice your career to look after your kids despite the fact your parents will do the same to look after your kids.

TrentCrimm · 13/11/2022 18:14

Handing out Werther's.

Anything above is a bonus.

ApplePieFry · 13/11/2022 18:11

SkeetyLola · 13/11/2022 18:09

@ApplePieFry
Ok, so they want to sacrifice their career for your children and you don’t want to sacrifice your career for your children, glad we’ve established that.

The point is most people would find it unreasonable to just give up their career or life to look after grandchildren when the childrens own mother hasn’t the slightest intention or feeling of responsibility that she should do the same - yet does have expectations of it being a grandparents role.

Thankfully most people don’t see it like this, many grand parents offer child care.

Mum isn’t sacrificing her career, she has had her career and wants the same for me. Do you not understand the difference between someone in their mid 30’s having a career enabled vs someone mid 50’s (or nearly mid 50s)

SkeetyLola · 13/11/2022 18:09

ApplePieFry · 13/11/2022 18:04

Why would I sacrifice my career when I don’t have to?

I don’t expect them to do it, they want to do it, there is a difference

@ApplePieFry
Ok, so they want to sacrifice their career for your children and you don’t want to sacrifice your career for your children, glad we’ve established that.

The point is most people would find it unreasonable to just give up their career or life to look after grandchildren when the childrens own mother hasn’t the slightest intention or feeling of responsibility that she should do the same - yet does have expectations of it being a grandparents role.

Venetiaparties · 13/11/2022 18:06

Good loving parents tend to grow into good loving grandparents, health issues allowing. They will enjoy helping their adult children, nurture their grandchildren and welcome the joy of new children in the family. Keen to help and bond with their young GC, they will contribute and help as much as possible, and be much loved in return.

Those that didn't want children/had too many/struggled in some or many ways tend to think their job is done and dusted at the first opportunity, often at very young ages such as 15/16/17/18 and are not interested in doing anything else child related - including interest or support of grandchildren. Their job is 'done' mentality. They are the same bunch that seem to then expect to be 'paid back' for their exceptionally average parenting efforts. There is a transactional element to parenting.

In a perfect world we would have loving gps and families that help and support each other. In reality it is not a given.

ApplePieFry · 13/11/2022 18:06

RedWingBoots · 13/11/2022 18:05

Other grandparents don't want to do it.

Good for them?

ApplePieFry · 13/11/2022 18:06

SkeetyLola · 13/11/2022 17:51

@ApplePieFry

You expected your mum to give up her career at 52 to look after your kids because “she’s had a good run career wise” yet it’s beyond the pale that you should give up your career to look after our kids?

Thats pretty rich.

You seem to really struggle reading this evening

I never expected anything, she wants to support her children the same way she was supported, next year dad will also shoulder a fair amount of the childcare too when he moves back to the UK.

Most want to support their kids, it’s odd you can’t understand that

RedWingBoots · 13/11/2022 18:05

ApplePieFry · 13/11/2022 18:04

Why would I sacrifice my career when I don’t have to?

I don’t expect them to do it, they want to do it, there is a difference

Other grandparents don't want to do it.

ApplePieFry · 13/11/2022 18:04

SkeetyLola · 13/11/2022 17:49

@ApplePieFry

You seem to have a lot of thoughts about parents looking after their grown up kids by doing childcare for them because your kids are your kids till they die - why don’t you be as self sacrificing as you expect your parents to be for you and look after your own children now instead of expecting them to do it while you further your career?

Why would I sacrifice my career when I don’t have to?

I don’t expect them to do it, they want to do it, there is a difference

HeraldicBlazoning · 13/11/2022 18:00

FuzzyPuffling · 13/11/2022 16:55

Every situation, every parent/child/grandparent different.

Exactly this. I grew up 90 minutes from both sets of grandparents, and out of the three surviving grandparents only one drove. We saw our grandparents occasionally, at holidays or on a Sunday. They never picked us up from school or cared for us on a regular basis. Similarly, I am further than that from parents and inlaws and never expected it either.

SkeetyLola · 13/11/2022 17:59

@Kabalagala

The issue is what does “support” mean? Does support mean family dinner, flog one calls, babysitting sometimes and dropping by to see the grandkids or having them over - or does “support” mean free childcare while mum works full time?

Because often I get the impression on here grandparents keeping a distance actually have a good read on their kids and realise that if they give a hand then a arm will be expected and their daughters will want full time childcare and get stroppy if it doesn’t happy how and when they want it.

Someone said that good parents made good grandparents - well it could also be said that selfish daughters grow into selfish mothers who expect grandparents to do their job.

WeWereInParis · 13/11/2022 17:57

I agree to an extent but it's more complicated. For example, you (generally) decide when you are ready to have children, but (obviously) have no say over grandchildren so it may not be possible for a grandparent to help out but they would have been able to if the grandchildren had been born at a more convenient time to them.

ZeroFuchsGiven · 13/11/2022 17:57

This is just a TAAT.

SkeetyLola · 13/11/2022 17:55

Seems for a lot of people “spending time with their grandkids” seems to equate to “doing childcare so I can continue my career full time”. They really aren’t talking about the odd babysit or friendly family dinner or lunch or taking the kids so mum and dad can have a short holiday.

They’re talking about a commitment from grandparents (specifically grandma) to do something to benifet them, not because it fosters a closer relationship with their grandkids and makes both grandkid and parent happy - but because it makes Mums life easier. Little else is considered but that last point despite the pretence otherwise.

Kabalagala · 13/11/2022 17:54

Imo unsupportive gps are a symptom of a wider issue. My parents have never emotionally supported me so I don't expect them to be supportive grandparents. Very much "I've done my bit, now you're independent its my time" No babysitting, no chats on the phone, no sympathetic texts, nothing but the occasional imposed visit.
My MIL is the total opposite, and I adore her.
Families should WANT to support each other and it's so sad that some don't.

SkeetyLola · 13/11/2022 17:51

ApplePieFry · 13/11/2022 17:45

Well mum is 52 and was still in her career, but dropped down and moved to support her child. And will be fully retiring if/when my siblings have kids.

And yes I will do the same if mine have families of their own.

Why should I have to give up my career?

Mums had a good run career wise, which was only enabled due to having support from her mother and MIL.

@ApplePieFry

You expected your mum to give up her career at 52 to look after your kids because “she’s had a good run career wise” yet it’s beyond the pale that you should give up your career to look after our kids?

Thats pretty rich.

IncessantNameChanger · 13/11/2022 17:49

I think the poster said if you was a shitty parent then your going to be a shitty GP.

My kids don't have GP figure month to month I their life. Mil lives abroad so see her for a few days every few years, my mum.is abusive so see her a few times a year when she might also be rude to us all or not mood dependent. Fil remarried when dh was 10 so step mil can't handle the family side and the kids haven't seen him for five years.

So I don't want childcare, but I'd have liked to have them go to concerts, or invite us around for Sunday lunch or come to sports day. All too late now even they wanted to. That door has closed and there's no bond between the generations.

Basically because we the kids of the GP aren't valued. I don't think they love us at all really.

Proamble · 13/11/2022 17:49

I don’t understand what you mean OP? Could you explain what you think the duties of a grandparent are?

SkeetyLola · 13/11/2022 17:49

ApplePieFry · 13/11/2022 17:43

Yes

Just like her mother and MIL did the same to help her, it’s called paying it forward. She had a great career from that support, and is doing the same for me.

My father is due to return to the UK next year so will be picking up the other 2 days a week childcare too which will be great.

Its had very little impact on her financial security, they’ve paid the mortgage off her pension is very good (worked for a bank all her life who paid in 15% since she was 18 and she has paid in a lot since turning 40)

Also, tbh even if it did impact her financially she wouldn’t have cared, she loves her kids enough to put them first, thankfully both she and my father are of the opinion your kids are your kids until you die. Not until they hit 18.

@ApplePieFry

You seem to have a lot of thoughts about parents looking after their grown up kids by doing childcare for them because your kids are your kids till they die - why don’t you be as self sacrificing as you expect your parents to be for you and look after your own children now instead of expecting them to do it while you further your career?